Full Order Text
Order 20 · 18 Aug 2025 · CNR DLND010093382022
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: 15 CS (COMM.)/870/2022 DLND010093382022 RISHABH MOTORS PVT LTD & ANR. Vs. MS GARGA INTERNATIONAL PVT LTD & ANR. 18.08.2025 Present: Sh. Mohit Seth, Advocate for Plaintiffs alongwith AR of Plaintiffs. Sh. Kamal Saini, Proxy Consel for Defendant no. 1. Defendant no. 2 is already deleted from the array of parties vide order dated 10.02.2025. Defendant no. 1 has not filed reply to application under Order XIV Rule 5 CPC of plaintiff. Vide order dated 26.05.2025 four weeks time was given to the defendant no. 1 to file reply to the said application but it is about more thane two months and no such reply has been filed. Hence, opportunity to file reply is hereby closed. Submissions heard on the application. By way of above application, plaintiff seeks to frame the two additional issues regarding the specific prayer made in the plaint. Ld. Counsel of plaintiffs submitted that the Court has omitted to frame the issues in respect of the prayer clause (b) of para no. 49 of the plaint and the additional issues are required to be framed because it is specific case of the plaintiff in para no. 17 of the plaint that pursuant to the business transfer agreement dated 09.10.2015 executed between plaintiff no. 1 and defendant Contd:- -- 1 of 4 -- -2- no. 1, it was agreed that plaintiff no. 2 would be made a Director in the defendant no.1 company and further 5 per cent of the share holding of the defendant no. 1 company would be transferred to plaintiff no. 2. Ld. Counsel of plaintiff submitted that in the written statement, the defendant has made vague denial by stating that the terms and conditions of the agreement were not complied with. Vide order dated 10.02.2025 this court has framed the issue regarding the limitation, territorial jurisdiction, entitlement of the plaintiff to the suit amount and interest. However, no issue has been framed respect in respect of the specific prayer made in the clause (b) of para no. 49 of the plaint. In view of the aforesaid discussions and submissions, it appear that aforesaid two issues have been left out to be framed from the specific prayer made out by the plaintiff in the plaint. Hence, the application is allowed. The following additional issues are framed. (a) Whether the plaintff no. 2 is entitled to a decree of mandatory injunction against defendant no. 1 for inducting the plaintiff no. 2 in the Board of Directors of defendant no. 1 company. OPP (b) Whether plaintiff no. 2 is entitled to 5% share holdilng of defendant no. 1 company ? If the answer is in affirmative, then for which period ? OPP In this case the LC has already been appointed to Contd:- -- 2 of 4 -- -3- record the evidence of the parties. Now the parties shall lead their respective evidence as per the following schedule. 1. The plaintiff will file the affidavits of evidence of their witnesses on record on or before 31.08.2025 with advance copy of the same to be supplied to the opposite party at least 2-3 days prior to the said date. 2. The evidence of the plaintiffs’ witness(s) will be now recorded on and from 08.09.2025 onwards and same shall be concluded by 30.11.2025. 3. The defendant will file the affidavits of evidence of its witnesses on record on or before 10.12.2025 by supplying copy of the same to the opposite party. 4. The evidence of the defendant’s witnesses will be recorded on and from 15.12.2025 onwards and same shall be concluded by 31.01.2026. The parties are directed to adhere to this time-line, failing which adverse consequences will follow in accordance with the provisions of The Commercial Courts Act. The remaining terms and conditions will remain the same as pointed out in order dated 10.02.2025. Parties are directed to contact and appear before Ld. Contd:- -- 3 of 4 -- -4- Court Commissioner for the purpose of recording of evidence as per the above schedule. Copy of the order be provided to Ld. Court Commissioner by way of Whatsapp/ e-mail for information and necessary action. Put up on [date withheld] for awaiting report of Court Commissioner and further proceedings. Balwant Rai Bansal District Judge (Commercial Court)-02 Patiala House Court, New Delhi. 18.08.2025 -- 4 of 4 --
