Full Order Text
Order 17 · 10 Feb 2025 · CNR DLND010093382022
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: CS (COMM.)/870/2022 DLND010093382022 RISHABH MOTORS PVT LTD & ANR. Vs. M/S GARGA INTERNATIONAL PVT LTD & ANR. 10.02.2025 Present: Sh. Dharmender Jain, AR of Plaintiff alongwith Sh. Mohit Seth and Sh. Raghav Bakshi, Advocates. Sh. Sandeep Verma, Advocate for Defendant no. 1. Sh. Pawan Kumar, Advocate for Defendant no. 2. Heard. File perused. Matter is fixed for arguments on pending applications i.e. (i) application under Order VII Rule 11 r/w Section 151 CPC moved by defendant no. 2 and (ii) application under Order I Rule 10 r/w Section 151 CPC. With the joint consent of both the parties, arguments on application under Order VII Rule 11 r/w Section 151 CPC moved by defendant no. 2, is partly heard. During the course of submissions, Ld. Counsel of defendant no. 2, on instructions, states at Bar that he wants to withdraw the present application. His statement in this regard is obtained at the first page of the aforesaid application. In view of submissions and statement made by Ld. Counsel of defendant no. 2, aforesaid application of defendant no. 2 is dismissed as withdrawn. Arguments on application under Order I Rule 10 r/w Section 151 CPC seeking deletion of name of defendant no. 2 Contd:- -- 1 of 6 -- -2- i.e., Maruti Suzuki India Limited from the array of defendants, heard. Put up at 04.00 pm for orders on the aforesaid application. Vidya Prakash District Judge (Commercial Court)-02 Patiala House Court, New Delhi. 10.02.2025(V) At 04.05 pm Present: None. Vide separate order of even date, announced in the open Court today, application under Order I Rule 10 r/w Section 151 CPC of defendant no. 2 has been allowed and consequently, the defendant no. 2 has been deleted from the array of defendants. Plaintiffs are directed to file amended Memo of Parties within two weeks from the date of this order, with direction to supply advance copy thereof to the opposite side. Pleadings are complete. From the pleadings of the parties and material available on record, following issues are framed :- ISSUES 1. Whether the suit is barred by limitation ? OPD1. 2. Whether this Court lacks territorial jurisdiction to entertain and try the present suit. If so to what effect ? OPD1. Contd:- -- 2 of 6 -- -3- 3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recover Rs.1,58,74,174/- from the defendant no. 1 ? OPP 4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recover interest from the defendant no. 1? If yes, then at what rate and for which period ? OPP 5. Relief. No other issue arises or is pressed for by the parties. First case management hearing done. Both parties are directed to file their respective list of witnesses within 2 weeks from date of this order with advance copy to each other. The parties shall lead their respective evidence, as per the following schedule : 1. The plaintiffs will file the affidavits of evidence of their witnesses on record on or before 07.03.2025 with advance copy of the same to be supplied to the opposite party at least 2-3 days prior to the said date. 2. The evidence of the plaintiffs’ witness(s) will be now recorded on and from 11.03.2025 onwards and same shall be concluded by 15.04.2025. 3. The defendant no. 1 will file the affidavits of evidence of its witnesses on record on or before 15.04.2025 by supplying copy of the same to the opposite party. 4. The evidence of the defendant no. 1’s witnesses Contd:- -- 3 of 6 -- -4- will be recorded on and from 21.04.2025 onwards and same shall be concluded by 20.05.2025. The parties are directed to adhere to this time-line, failing which adverse consequences will follow in accordance with the provisions of The Commercial Courts Act. It is hereby made clear that in case due to any reason, the purpose for which the matter is fixed, is not concluded, the matter shall be taken up on the next working day. Any unjustified, non-compliance of the aforesaid directions and delay in the above mentioned time lines, may lead to consequences for non-compliance as per Order XVA Rule 8 CPC pursuant to the schedule U/s 16 of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. For recording evidence, the Court exercise the power conferred under Order XV A Rule 6 (o) and (p) CPC by directing that evidence shall be recorded by Local Commissioner, appointed by this court on commission basis. Accordingly, it is directed that plaintiff evidence (PE) and defendant evidence (DE) shall be recorded on commission basis by Sh. Sumit Chauhan, Advocate having mobile No.: 9711900030 & 9599501822. Ld. Local Commissioner shall record the evidence of the witnesses verbatim. In case of any objection raised by any party, same shall be recorded verbatim, which shall be adjudicated by this court. Ld. Local Commissioner on the same day shall supply the copy of the evidence recorded to both the parties on their own cost and also submit typed copy alongwith the relevant proceedings in the Contd:- -- 4 of 6 -- -5- court by next date so fixed. The fee of the Ld. Local Commissioner shall be Rs.5000/- per sitting. The evidence shall be recorded at Judges Library, Patiala House Courts or any other place as per convenience of Ld. LC on date and time agreed by both parties but not later than the date fixed by this court for submitting the report. It is further directed that the plaintiff shall bear the expenses of Ld. Local Commissioner for recording of PE and defendant shall bear the expenses of Ld. Local Commissioner for recording of DE. Further at the time of PE, plaintiff shall arrange typist/ stenographer for recording of evidence, failing which Ld. LC shall arrange for the same and in that eventuality, the plaintiff has to bear Rs.750/- per day which shall be in addition to fee for LC per sitting. Similar direction would apply at the stage of DE as well. Ahlmad/Nazir/Reader shall made himself available with the court file and diet money for the said purpose is fixed Rs.500/-. In case any party seeks adjournment or recording of evidence is adjourned then the party at fault shall pay the expenses of the Commission for the said date. Parties are directed to contact and appear before Ld. Local Commissioner on 11.03.2025 for the purpose of recording of evidence as per the above schedule. In case parties do not contact Ld. Local Commissioner on or after said date, Ld. LC Contd:- -- 5 of 6 -- -6- may file report stating so within 2 weeks from 11.03.2025. Copy of the order be provided to Ld. Local Commissioner by way of Whatsapp/ e-mail for information and necessary action. Put up on [date withheld] for awaiting report of Local Commissioner and further proceedings. Vidya Prakash District Judge (Commercial Court)-02 Patiala House Court, New Delhi. 10.02.2025(V) -- 6 of 6 --
