Full Order Text
Order 16 · 10 Feb 2025 · CNR DLND010093382022
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. VIDYA PRAKASH DISTRICT JUDGE (COMMERCIAL COURT)-02 NEW DELHI DISTRICT, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS NEW DELHI CS (COMM.): 870/2022 CNR NO.: DLND010093382022 IN THE MATTER OF:- RISHABH MOTORS PVT LTD & ANR. ......PLAINTIFFS VERSUS M/S GARGA INTERNATIONAL PVT LTD & ANR. ......DEFENDANTS ORDER 1. Vide this order, I shall decide the application under Order I Rule 10 r/w Section 151 CPC dated 28.09.2023, moved by defendant no. 2 seeking its deletion from the array of the parties. 2. Arguments on the aforesaid application have already been heard on behalf of both the sides during pre-lunch session. I have also gone through the material available on record. 3. Shorn of unnecessary details, the plaintiff has filed the present suit for recovery of Rs. 1,58,74,174/- alongwith costs, pendent lite and future interest against the defendants, including the applicant/defendant no. 2 herein, on the averments that the plaintiff no. 1 was in the business of providing logistical support and transportation services to various automobile CS (COMM.): 870/2022 Page 1 of 9 -- 1 of 9 -- manufacturers including the applicant/defendant no. 2 herein. In the year 2010, the plaintiff no. 1 was awarded contract to provide logistical support and transportation services to defendant no. 2. However, plaintiff no. 1 faced liquidity crunch from the year 2012 onward and which continued till 2014, due to which, the plaintiff no. 1 company started looking for a partner to do logistic business with them. The defendant no. 1 company through its Director namely Mr. Krishan Kumar Gupta, had approached the said plaintiff and conveyed their intention to purchase the contracts including the contract with defendant no. 2, owned by plaintiff no. 1 and consequently, a meeting took place on 29.07.2015 which was attended by said Mr. Krishan Kumar Gupta, Mr. Rakesh, Mr. Mukesh Jain, the then Director of plaintiff no. 1 and plaintiff no. 2, followed by other meetings held on 09.08.2015 and 18.08.2015. After finalization of the terms and conditions, MOU dated 31.08.2015 was entered into between plaintiff no. 1 and defendant no. 1, as per which, the Maruti Contract between plaintiff no. 1 and defendant no. 2, was also agreed to be transferred in favour of defendant no. 1 company on certain terms and conditions including that defendant no. 1 shall pay Rs. 1.90 Crores to the plaintiff no. 1 and the plaintiff no. 1 shall cooperate in getting the said Maruti Contract assigned in favour of the defendant no. 1. Accordingly, the contract was signed between the defendant no. 1 and the defendant no. 2, however, the defendant no. 1 made part payment of Rs. 91 Lacs only, thereby leaving CS (COMM.): 870/2022 Page 2 of 9 -- 2 of 9 -- balance amount of Rs. 99 Lacs still due and payable by defendant no. 1 to plaintiff no. 1. The plaintiff no. 1 diligently fulfilled all the obligations on its part and Business Transfer Agreement dated 09.10.2015 was executed between the plaintiff no. 1 and the defendant no. 1. It is stated that the plaintiff no. 2 who was erstwhile Director of plaintiff no. 1, was inducted on the Board of Directors of defendant no. 1 on 26.09.2015 and by virtue of Business Transfer Agreement dated 09.10.2015, it was agreed that 5% share holding of defendant no. 1 would be transferred to plaintiff no. 2 namely Mr. Mohit Jain. It is alleged that defendant no. 1 illegally removed said Mr. Mohit Jain from directorship of defendant no. 1 on 26.03.2016 in violation of Section 169 of Companies Act. On the basis of these averments, the plaintiffs have sought a decree of Rs. 1,58,74,174/- alongwith pendente lite and future interest and costs, besides decree of mandatory injunction as against defendant no. 1. 4. Now, reverting back to the application under consideration. It is stated in the application that the defendant no. 2 was neither privy to the Business Transfer Agreement, nor received any consideration for the same. It is further stated that there is no allegation whatsoever against the defendant no. 2 and no relief whatsoever has been claimed against defendant no. 2. Therefore, the suit is bad for misjoinder of defendant no. 2 herein. 5. In their reply to the present application, the plaintiffs CS (COMM.): 870/2022 Page 3 of 9 -- 3 of 9 -- have claimed that one meeting was held between plaintiff no. 1’s representative, plaintiff no. 2 and defendant no. 1 at the factory premises of defendant no. 2 situated at Gurugram to discuss the default on payments as made by defendant no. 1 as per MOU and thus, the presence of defendant no. 2 is necessary for adjudication of the subject matter involved in the present suit. 6. After referring to the pleadings of the parties, more particularly the averments made in the plaint, Ld. Counsel of applicant/defendant no. 2 reiterated the grounds raised in the instant application, in order to bring home his point that the defendant no. 2 is neither necessary, nor proper party for the just adjudication of the issues involved in the present suit. He therefore urged that the application may be allowed and the said defendant may be deleted from the array of the defendants. 7. Per contra, Ld. Counsel of plaintiffs opposed this application on the ground that one meeting was held on 04.02.2016 at the factory premises of defendant no. 2, however, the defendant no. 2 has denied about the said fact in their written statement. He also submitted that defendant no. 2 has admitted in the written statement that an e-mail dated 05.09.2015 was issued on behalf of plaintiff no. 1 requesting therein that the business/contract which was being done by plaintiff no. 2 for defendant no. 2, may be transferred to defendant no. 1. However, their written statement is silent about the execution of contract between defendant no. 1 and CS (COMM.): 870/2022 Page 4 of 9 -- 4 of 9 -- defendant no. 2 and thus, the applicant/defendant no. 2 is a necessary and proper party to the present suit. He therefore urged that the application may be dismissed. Analysis and Conclusion 8. Before dealing with the rival submissions made on behalf of both the sides, it would be apposite to discuss the legal provisions and the legal position governing the issue in hand. 9. Order I of Civil Procedure Code deals with the necessity of bringing parties to the suit for proper and effectual adjudication of the matter in dispute. Order 1 Rule 10 C.P.C. empowers the Court to add any person as party at any stage of the proceedings, if the person whose presence before the Court is necessary in order to enable the Court to effectively and completely adjudicate upon and settle all the questions involved in the suit. Avoidance of multiplicity of proceedings is also one of the objects of the said provision. 10. It is well settled principle of law that basically, it is for the plaintiff in a suit to identify the parties against whom he has any grievance and to implead them as defendants in the suit filed for necessary relief. He cannot be compelled to face litigation with the persons against whom he has no grievance. Where, however, any third party is likely to suffer any grievance, on account of the outcome of the suit, he shall be entitled to get himself impleaded. 11. The principles governing the power of the Court under Order 1, Rule 10 of C.P.C, are that the Court should not, CS (COMM.): 870/2022 Page 5 of 9 -- 5 of 9 -- as a rule, add any person as a defendant in a suit when the plaintiff is opposed to such addition. The reason is that the plaintiff is the “ dominus litus”. Thus, he cannot be compelled to fight against a person against whom he does not wish to fight and against whom he does not claim any relief. 12. There are two types of persons who may be added as party to the suit. (1) Person who is a necessary party i.e., in the absence of whom relief claimed in the suit cannot be granted; and (2) The second class of persons consists of those who are proper parties i.e., whose presence may be necessary with a view to fully adjudicate upon the matters involved in the suit. 13. In “Kasturi vs., Uyyamperumal and others” reported in (2005) 6 SCC 733, Hon’ble Apex Court has observed as under:- “it is now clear that two tests are to be satisfied for determining the question who is a necessary party. Tests are - (1) there must be a right to some relief against such party in respect of the controversies involved in the proceedings (2) no effective decree can be passed in the absence of such party.” 14. What makes a person a necessary party is not merely that he has relevant evidence to give on some of the questions involved, for the simple reason that same would only make him a necessary witness. The only reason which makes it necessary to make a person a party to an action is so that he should be bound by the result of the action. Therefore, the question to be settled must be a question in the action, which cannot be effectually and completely CS (COMM.): 870/2022 Page 6 of 9 -- 6 of 9 -- settled unless he is a party. It is necessary that the person must be directly or legally interested in the action is the answer i.e., he can say that the litigation may lead to a result, which will affect him legally, that is, by curtailing his legal right. 15. In “Mahadeva Rice & Oil Mills Vs. Chennimalai Gounder”, reported as AIR 1968 Mad. 287, Hon’ble Madras High Court has explained shortly but vividly the basic object of the provision contained in Order 1 Rule 10 C.P.C. and has laid down the following principles:- (i). If, for the adjudication of the "real controversy" between the parties on record, the presence of a third party is necessary, then he can be impleaded. (ii). It is imperative to note that by such impleading of the proposed party, all controversies arising in the suit and all issues arising thereunder may be finally determined and set at rest, thereby avoiding multiplicity of suits over a subject-matter which could still have been decided in the pending suit itself; (iii). The proposed party has a defined, subsisting, direct and substantive interests in the litigation, which interest is either legal or equitable and which right is cognisable in law; (iv). Meticulous care should be taken to avoid the adding of a party if it is intended merely as a ruse to ventilate certain other grievances of one or the other of the parties on record which is neither necessary or expedient to be considered by the Court in the pending litigation; and (v). It should always be remembered that considerable prejudice would be caused to the opposite party when irrelevant matters are allowed to be considered by Courts by adding a new party whose interest has no nexus to the subject-matter of the suit. 16. Now coming back to the application under consideration. The question which arises for consideration of the Court CS (COMM.): 870/2022 Page 7 of 9 -- 7 of 9 -- is as to whether or not the plaint discloses any valid cause of action against the applicant/defendant no. 2 so as to make the said defendant either necessary and/or proper party in this suit. The answer to said question, in the opinion of this Court, has to be in negative for the reasons to be noted hereinafter. 17. Ld. Counsel of the non-applicant/plaintiff has heavily relied upon the averments made in relevant paras of the plaint, to bring home his point that although, the plaintiffs are not claiming any relief against defendant no. 2, which is a proforma party, however, the presence of said defendant is required for just and effective adjudication of the controversy involved in the present suit. However, it may be noted that Para no. 17 of the plaint expressly recites that Business Transfer Agreement dated 09.10.2015 was executed between the plaintiff no. 1 and the defendant no. 1. The entire plaint revolves around the said alleged Business Transfer Agreement purportedly executed between plaintiff no. 1 and defendant no. 1, without disclosing any cause of action whatsoever as against the applicant/defendant no. 2. In fact, the plaintiffs have expressly averred in para no. 40 of the plaint that no relief is being sought against applicant/defendant no. 2, which is described to be a proforma party. Indisputably, no relief whatsoever has been sought against defendant no. 2.That being so, there is no iota of doubt that the defendant no. 2 is not at all a necessary party to the adjudication of the present suit. It is no where explained on behalf of plaintiffs either in the CS (COMM.): 870/2022 Page 8 of 9 -- 8 of 9 -- plaint or even in their reply to the present application as to how the defendant no. 2 is even a proper party to the present suit. There is nothing on record to suggest that the presence of defendant no. 2 is required for effective or proper adjudication of the subject matter of the present suit. 18. In view of above discussion, this Court finds considerable force in the submissions made on behalf of applicant/defendant no. 2 that for want of any valid cause of action and in the absence of any specific averments mentioned in the plaint, it cannot be said that the said defendant is either necessary and/or proper party in this suit. Accordingly, the application in hand is hereby allowed and consequently, the applicant/defendant no. 2 is hereby deleted from the array of the defendants. The application stands disposed off in the aforesaid terms. Announced in the open Court On 10th Day of February, 2025. (VIDYA PRAKASH) DISTRICT JUDGE (COMMERCIAL COURT)-02 PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI CS (COMM.): 870/2022 Page 9 of 9 -- 9 of 9 --
