Full Order Text
Final Order 8 · 04 Nov 2023 · CNR DLND010090292021
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. ANURAG SAIN, DISTRICT JUDGE, (COMMERCIAL COURT)-01, PATIALA HOUSE COURT, NEW DELHI CS (COMM)608/2022 In the matter of: Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. Having its Registered office at: 27 BKC, C 27, G Block Bandra Kurla Complex Bandra (E), Mumbai-400051 Branch Office at: Through its authorized representative Mr. Amar Maini …. Plaintiff Versus 1. Dinesh Singh S/o Sh.Bhagwan Singh R/o H.No.116, Village- Garhi Madde, Police Station-Barhan, Tehsil-Etmadpupr, Distt-Agra Uttar Pradesh-283201 Mobile : 9675171824 ….Defendant no.1 2. Ved Prakash, S/o Sh.Bhagwan Singh, R/o H.No.116, Village- Garhi Madde, Police Station-Barhan, Tehsil-Etmadpupr, Distt-Agra Uttar Pradesh-283201 Mobile : 9639054884 ...Defendant no.2 CS (COMM).608/2022 Page 1 of 10 -- 1 of 10 -- Date of institution of the case : 15.12.2021 Date on which judgment was reserved : 04.11.2023 Date of pronouncement of the judgment : 04.11.2023 Appearance: Sh.Parma Nand, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff. None for defendants. (defendants are ex-parte). JUDGMENT 1. This suit was filed by the earlier plaintiff De Lage Landen Financial Services India Pvt. Ltd. for recovery of Rs.3,34,329/- (Rupees Three Lakh Thirty Four Thousand Three Hundred Twenty Nine) with interest @ 30% per annum from the date of the suit till the date of realization and costs. Earlier Ms. Surabhi Gupta, Authorized Representatives of the plaintiff company, who was stated to be conversant with the facts of the case and was authorized to institute the suit on behalf of the plaintiff. 2. During the course of proceedings by virtue of assignment agreement dated 07.07.2022, the loan in question has been assigned by the earlier plaintiff De Lage Landen Financial Services India Pvt. Ltd. in favour of present plaintiff Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited, consequently, devolution of interest has occasioned in favour of plaintiff Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited with respect to claim in this suit. Thus, vide order dated 27.10.2022, Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited was permitted to be substituted as plaintiff. CS (COMM).608/2022 Page 2 of 10 -- 2 of 10 -- 3. Thereafter, the present plaintiff Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited sought permission to substitute Sh. Amar Maini as Authorized Representative of Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited and also vide the same order Sh.Amar Maini, Deputy Manager of plaintiff bank was permitted to be its Authorized Representative. 4. The brief facts as averred in the plaint are as under: 4.1. Plaintiff sanctioned a loan to the defendants on the request of defendants vide Loan cum Hypothecation Agreement dated 27.11.2016 for an amount of Rs.3,50,000/- (Rupees Three Lakhs Fifty Thousand only) vide loan account no.100-0001443-001. Defendants obtained the loan for purchasing a Tractor of Escorts, Model FT-45 F10 – Classic, with Engine No. E-2381817 and Chassis No. T05- 2376319GE (Equipment) and the said equipment was hypothecated in favour of the plaintiff. 4.2. Defendants also executed a Demand Promissory Note and Continuity Letter dated 27.11.2016 in favour of the plaintiff. As per case of the plaintiff, on conjoint reading of the agreement and repayment schedule, it is noticeable that the defendants are required to repay the loan comprising of principal amount and interest @21% per annum along with default interest @30% per annum on default in payment of any outstanding loan installment to the plaintiff. The defendants have failed to adhere to the financial discipline and neglected to pay the outstanding debts. CS (COMM).608/2022 Page 3 of 10 -- 3 of 10 -- 4.3. It is further submitted that the said equipment is the security against the loan amount. Defendants failed to abide by the repayment schedule and have defaulted in payment of several installments despite repeated requests. Thereafter, plaintiff served upon the defendants a Facility Cancellation / Acceleration notice dated 25.11.2020. 4.4. It was alleged that as per Clause 5 of the Agreement, the defendants were required to repay the loan along with interest and other charges but they defaulted in repayment of the installments. The plaintiff in terms of Clause 18.1 and 18.2 of the Agreement canceled the loan facility and demanded immediate payment of the outstanding dues and other charges including interest by issuing a notice. The plaintiff then issued a facility Cancellation/Acceleration (loan recall notice) recalling the entire facility. The notice was duly served on the defendants but the defendants did not make the payment. It was alleged that the defendants are jointly and severally liable to pay the aforesaid sum along with interest. 4.5. It is stated that as per Clause 28.2, the parties to the agreement had unequivocally agreed to grant liberty to the plaintiff to initiate legal proceedings against the borrower in any court of competent jurisdiction. It is stated that the agreement was executed at Delhi, the entire documentation was also made in Delhi office of the plaintiff and as such, the courts at Delhi has the jurisdiction. CS (COMM).608/2022 Page 4 of 10 -- 4 of 10 -- 4.6. It is claimed that suit is well within the limitation. 5. Before filing of the suit, plaintiff approached New Delhi DLSA for Pre-Litigation Mediation on 30.01.2021, but the defendants did not appear despite notice. Non-starter report dated 24.03.2021 has been filed by plaintiff along with the plaint. 6. Proceedings and service to the defendants: 6.1. Defendant no.1 was duly served through whatsapp on 09.06.2022, whereas the defendant no.2 was duly served through speed post on 19.12.2022. As neither the defendants appeared nor filed any written statement, hence, they were proceeded exparte vide orders dated 22.07.2022 and 15.07.2023 respectively. 7. Thereafter, plaintiff again requested for substitution of its authorized representative and thus, on request of the plaintiff, vide order dated 11.10.2023, Sh.Ravinder Tomar was substituted as new AR of the plaintiff. 8. Plaintiff's Evidence: 8.1. In plaintiff's evidence, Sh.Ravinder Tomar, was examined as PW1 who filed his affidavit Ex.PW1/A. 8.2. Sh.Ravinder Tomar i.e. PW-1 tendered his evidence by way of affidavit before the Court and he proved the following documents :- CS (COMM).608/2022 Page 5 of 10 -- 5 of 10 -- S. NO Documents Exhibit 1 Copy of Board Resolution dated 02.05.2023 Ex.PW1/1 2 Loan and Hypothecation Agreement dated 27.11.2016. Ex.PW1/2. 3. Demand Promissory Note and Continuity Letter datd 27.11.2016 Ex.PW1/3. 4. Welcome letter and repayment schedule dated 27.11.2016 along with postal receipts Ex.PW1/4 (Colly). 5. Office Copy of Facility Cancellation/Acceleration notice dated 25.11.2020 and its postal receipts Ex.PW1/5 (colly) 6. Statement of Account Ex.PW1/6. 7. Certificate under Section 65 (B) of Indian Evidence Act Ex.PW1/7 8. The copies of deed of assignment confirming the assignment of debts recoverable from defendants Mark PW1/1A. 8.3. PW-1 was examined and discharged. Thereafter, plaintiff's evidence was closed vide separate statement of the Authorized Representative of the plaintiff. CS (COMM).608/2022 Page 6 of 10 -- 6 of 10 -- 9. I have heard the learned counsel for the plaintiff and carefully gone through the record. During the course of arguments, ld. Counsel for plaintiff has submitted that the equipment has not been repossessed in the present matter. 10. The cause of action in the present matter was arose when the defendants defaulted in the repayment of the installment amount, the last payment of Rs.25,000/- was made by the defendants on 20.08.2019 and the suit filed on 15.12.2021. Hence, the suit is well within the period of limitation. 11. Detail discussion: 11.1. I have perused the documents placed on record by the PW-1 and have also perused the unchallanged testimony of the plaintiff’s witness. 11.2. In his unrebutted testimony PW-1 has clearly proved from the documents that he is authorized by the plaintiff by way of Ex. PW1/1. It is proved by way of oral testimony of witness PW-1 and the documentary evidence that defendants have applied for the loan from the plaintiff for purchase of equipment, which was sanctioned vide loan sanction letter/welcome letter dated 27.11.2016 Ex.PW-1/4. It is proved that on 27.11.2016 defendants signed and executed the documents i.e. Loan-cum-Hypothecation Agreement Ex.PW-1/2 and Demand Promissory note Ex.PW-1/3. CS (COMM).608/2022 Page 7 of 10 -- 7 of 10 -- 11.3. It is established that equipment loan of Rs.3,50,000/- was sanctioned to the defendants. Failure of the defendants to repay the loan amount to the plaintiff is proved by the deposition of PW-1 corroborated by various documents viz. Legal notice Ex.PW-1/5; repayment schedule (part of Ex.PW-1/4); and statement of loan account (Ex.PW-1/6) filed along with certificate under Section 65 B of the Indian Evidence Act Ex. PW-1/7. 11.4. Considering the unchallanged testimony of Plaintiff’s witness and the documents proved on record, in my view, plaintiff has proved its case in balance of probabilities. I do not find any reason to disbelief the unrebutted testimony of PW-1 and the documents proved on record. In my opinion, plaintiff has successfully proved its case in respect of the due amount i.e. Rs.3,34,329/- (Rupees Three Lakh Thirty Four Thousand Three Hundred Twenty Nine). 12. Interest: 12.1. Plaintiff has claimed default interest @ 30% per annum from the date of institution of the suit till the realization of the decreetal amount. Order VII rule 2A of Code of Civil Procedure (hereinafter referred as CPC) was brought in by way of amendment in respect of the requirements of pleadings where interest has been claimed by the plaintiff but the perusal of the plaint reveals that no case has been set up by the plaintiff in accordance with order VII rule 2A of CPC. 12.2. Under section 34 of CPC it is provided that where the CS (COMM).608/2022 Page 8 of 10 -- 8 of 10 -- liability in relation to the sum so adjudged had arisen out of commercial transaction, the rate of such further interest may exceed 6% per annum but shall not exceed the contractual rate of interest or where there in no contractual rate, the rate at which money is lent or advanced by nationalized banks in relation to the commercial transactions. 12.3. Keeping in view the above discussion, in my opinion, plaintiff has not justified its claim of default interest @ 30% per annum claimed in the plaint and no pleadings has been set up to justify the interest at such an exorbitant rate of interest. 12.4. It has been established that it has been commercial transaction, so in my opinion, keeping in view the prevalent rate of interest in nationalized banks in such transactions, interest of justice will be served if plaintiff is allowed pendant-lite and future interest @9% per annum. 13. Cost: 13.1. Plaintiff has also claimed the cost of the suit, keeping in view section 35 and 35A of CPC, it has been established that defendants failed to pay the amount despite service of legal notice; then failed to appear in pre-institution mediation and did not appear before the court despite service of summons. Therefore, defendants themselves are responsible for the litigation and is liable to bear the cost to the extent of court fee and lawyers fee etc. as per rules. In my view plaintiff is entitled for the cost of litigation against defendants. CS (COMM).608/2022 Page 9 of 10 -- 9 of 10 -- 14. Relief: 14.1. In view of the above discussions, suit for recovery is decreed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants for Rs.3,34,329/- (Rupees Three Lakh Thirty Four Thousand Three Hundred Twenty Nine) due and payable along with interest @9.00% per annum from the date of filing of the suit till the date of decree; and (on the decreetal amount) from the date of decree till the realization of the decreetal amount. Defendants are liable to pay jointly and severally. 14.2. Cost is also awarded in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants to the extent of court fee and advocate’s fee as per rules. 14.3. Advocate's fee certificate be filed by plaintiff within seven days failing which notional fee of Rs.10,000/- be allowed in the decree sheet. 14.4. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. 14.5. File be consigned to the record room. Pronounced in the open Court (Anurag Sain) on this 4th Day of November, 2023 District Judge (Commercial Courts)-01 New Delhi District, Patiala House Courts New Delhi CS (COMM).608/2022 Page 10 of 10 -- 10 of 10 --
