Full Order Text
Interim Order 6 · 26 Apr 2025 · CNR DLND010079502024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MR. SATYABRATA PANDA, DJ-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI CS No.4218-24 Sanjay Aggarwal Vs. Muthuswamy 26.04.2025 Present: Sh. Aditya Singh, Ld. counsel for plaintiff. Sh. Rohit Panwar and Sh. Hirak Anand, Ld. counsel for defendant. ORDER (ORAL) 1. Ld. counsel for the plaintiff has filed application u/o 6 Rule 17 CPC seeking amendment of the plaint along with the proposed amended plaint. Advance copy was already supplied. 2. Ld. counsel for the defendant has filed reply to the application u/o 6 Rule 17 CPC. Copy supplied. 3. Ld. Counsel for the defendant has submitted that the application u/o 6 Rule 17 CPC is faulty since after the paragraph 2, the plaintiff has straight away mentioned paragraph no.4. 4. Upon this, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff has submitted that this is merely a typographical mistake in the numbering of the paragraphs and nothing more. 5. The objection regarding the paragraph numbers is clearly frivolous in view of the submission of the Ld. Counsel for CS No.4218-24 Sanjay Aggarwal Vs. Muthuswamy Page 1 of 7 -- 1 of 7 -- the plaintiff that there is only a typographical error in the numbering of the paragraphs. 6. At this stage, Ld. Counsel for the defendant has submitted that he was also not given a legible copy of the application by the ld. Counsel for the plaintiff. 7. Upon enquiry, Ld. Counsel for the defendant has handed over for perusal the copy which he was supplied. 8. A perusal of the copy shows that the same is clearly legible. Furthermore, the Ld. Counsel for the defendant has already filed reply to the application u/o 6 Rule 17 CPC. 9. Ld. counsel for the plaintiff has submitted that by way of the application u/o. 6 rule 17 CPC, the plaintiff is only seeking to add one sentence in paragraph no.3 of the plaint to the following effect: “On 05.03.2022, the plaintiff transferred an amount of Rs.10,00,000/- in the account of the defendant vide RTGS No.349201500031”. Ld. counsel submits that the plaintiff has clearly stated in paragraph 3 of the plaint that as on 07.04.2022, the plaintiff had transferred a total amount of Rs.35,00,000/- to the defendant. It is submitted that however, the transactions which are mentioned in the paragraph 3 amount to only Rs.25,00,000/- and inadvertently, the transfer of amount of Rs.10,00,000/- on 05.03.2022 was not stated. It is submitted that along with the application u/o 6 Rule 17 CPC, the plaintiff is also filing copy of the bank statement CS No.4218-24 Sanjay Aggarwal Vs. Muthuswamy Page 2 of 7 -- 2 of 7 -- of the plaintiff showing the transfer of amount of Rs.10,00,000/- to the defendant on 05.03.2022. It is submitted that the plaintiff inadvertently did not mention the same in the paragraph 3, and that the plaintiff may now be permitted to amend the plaint to incorporate this transaction. It is submitted that the matter is still at the pre- trial stage and that no prejudice would be caused to the defendant. 10. On the other hand, Ld. Counsel for the defendant has submitted that the application may not be allowed as the plaintiff is only trying to incorporate a new cause of action in the suit. 11. I have considered the submissions of the Ld. Counsels for the parties and I have perused the record. 12. In paragraph 3 of the plaint as originally filed, the plaintiff has stated as follows: “3. That as per the said undertaking given by the defendant to the plaintiff, on 04.03.2022, the plaintiff has transferred an amount of Rs. 10 lacs in the bank account of the defendant in ICICI Bank. R.K. Puram branch being no. 349201500031. On 06.04.2022, the plaintiff has again transferred an amount of Rs. 13 lacs in the bank account of the defendant and on 07.04.2022 the plaintiff has again transferred an amount of Rs. 2 lacs in the said bank account of the CS No.4218-24 Sanjay Aggarwal Vs. Muthuswamy Page 3 of 7 -- 3 of 7 -- defendant. It is submitted that on 07.04.2022, the plaintiff has transferred a total amount of Rs. 35 lacs and thereby the plaintiff duly complied the said terms of the understanding made by the defendant in favour of the plaintiff.” 13. During the course of hearing on 08.04.2025, the Ld. Counsel for the defendant had pointed out that although in paragraph 3 of the plaint, the plaintiff had claimed that as on 07.04.2022, the plaintiff had transferred a total amount of Rs.35,00,000/- to the defendant, however, the transfer amounts mentioned came to only a total of Rs.25,00,000/-, and upon this, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff had submitted that there was another transfer of amount of Rs.10,00,000/- on 05.03.2022, which was missed out. The order dated 08.04.2025 is extracted hereunder: “08.04.2025 Present: Mr. Aditya Singh, Ld. Counsel for plaintiff and plaintiff in person. Mr. Rohit Panwar, Ld. Counsel for defendant along with defendant in person. The plaintiff has already filed replication to the written statement. Copy has been supplied. CS No.4218-24 Sanjay Aggarwal Vs. Muthuswamy Page 4 of 7 -- 4 of 7 -- Ld. counsel for the defendant has filed reply to the application under Order XII Rule 6 CPC. Copy has been supplied. During the course of submissions on the aforesaid application, Id. counsel for the defendant has submitted that although in paragraph 3 of the plaint, the plaintiff has claimed that as on 07.04.2022, the plaintiff had transferred a total amount of Rs.35 Lacs to the defendant, however, in the said paragraph the plaintiff has stated that amounts of Rs.10 Lacs, Rs. 13 Lacs and Rs. 2 Lacs were transferred on 04.03.2022, 06.04.2022 and 07.04.2022, respectively, amounting to total of only Rs. 25 Lacs and not Rs.35 Lacs. Upon this, Ld. counsel for the plaintiff submits on instructions that the plaintiff had also transferred an amount of Rs.10 Lacs on 05.03.2022 into the bank account of the defendant, however, inadvertently, this fact was missed out in paragraph 3 of the plaint. Ld. counsel for the plaintiff submits that the plaintiff would be moving an application to amend the paragraph 3 of the plaint so as to give the details of the amount of Rs. 10 Lacs which is stated to have been transferred on 05.03.2022 into the bank account of the defendant and that the CS No.4218-24 Sanjay Aggarwal Vs. Muthuswamy Page 5 of 7 -- 5 of 7 -- plaintiff would also be filing his bank statement with regard to the transfers within 3 days. Let an advance copy of any such application be provided to the Id. counsel for the defendant. The defendant shall file reply to the application within 1 week thereafter with advance copy to the other side. Re-list for further proceedings on 26.04.2025.” 14. The suit is still at the pre-trial stage and as such, the court would be liberal in considering the application u/o 6 Rule 17 CPC. The plaintiff has also filed copy of his bank statement in support. It would be in the interest of justice to allow the amendment. 15. Accordingly, the application u/o 6 Rule 17 CPC is allowed. The amended plaint is taken on record. 16. Let the amended written statement be filed within one week with advance copy to the other side. 17. Let the amended replication be filed within three days thereafter with advance copy to the other side. 18. Ld. counsel for the plaintiff has also filed an application u/s 379 BNSS as well as an application u/o 38 Rule 5 CPC for furnishing security. Copy supplied. CS No.4218-24 Sanjay Aggarwal Vs. Muthuswamy Page 6 of 7 -- 6 of 7 -- 19. Let reply to the applications be filed within 15 days with advance copy to the other side. 20. Relist for consideration on the pending applications on 27.05.2025. (SATYABRATA PANDA) District Judge-04 Judge Code- DL01057 PHC/New Delhi/26.04.2025 CS No.4218-24 Sanjay Aggarwal Vs. Muthuswamy Page 7 of 7 -- 7 of 7 --
