Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 06 Aug 2024 · CNR DLND010063712024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. DHEERAJ MOR : Ld. ASJ-06 : NEW DELHI DISTRICT : PATIALA HOUSE COURTS : NEW DELHI Bail Application No. 1161/2024 State Vs. Parvesh Narwal FIR No. 01/2022 PS Crime Branch U/s. 419/420/468/471/120B/34 IPC 06.08.2024 This is an application under Section 483 BNSS for seeking regular bail of the applicant Parvesh Narwal S/o Sh. Surajmal Singh. Present: Sh. S.K. Kain, Ld. Addl. PP for the State. Sh. Sanjay Rathi, Ld. Counsel for the applicant. IO SI Amit Kumar along with case file. 1. Reply to the bail application is filed. Its copy is supplied to the other side. 2. Arguments on the application are heard. Case file, application and its reply are carefully perused. 3. Briefly stated, the present FIR u/s. 419/420/468/ 471/120B/34 IPC was lodged on 04.01.2022 on the complaint of Dy. Secretary (Exam), Delhi Subordinate Services Selection Board (DSSSB), Government of Delhi alleging that the candidates mentioned in the complaint had used malpractices for selection in DSSSB examinations held in 2019. As per allegations, some unknown persons impersonated as the said candidates to appear in the said examinations. 4. During investigation, the IO collected from the complainant, the original documents of the alleged candidates Page No. 1/5 -- 1 of 5 -- including their application forms (along with attached documents), copies of Invigilator and copies of Assistant Observer which contained thumb impressions and hand writing of the alleged candidates. He examined the alleged candidates and with the help of technical means, the applicant was identified. From the said documents, it transpired that his photographs were affixed on the admit cards of three candidates namely Pankaj, Amit and Ankit Khatri. He had impersonated the said three candidates and appeared on their behalf in three different examinations of DSSSB in the year 2019. His father refused to accept notice u/s. 41(A) CrPC and when it was found that he was involved in a similar case in FIR No.396/2020 u/s. 419/420 IPC PS Mourya Enclave, his LOC was initiated. On 27.07.2024, he was apprehended by the Immigration officials at IGI Airport, Terminal-3, Delhi when he was trying to leave the country and he was arrested on the said date. He disclosed that he conspired with Hardeep Malik and Sonu to appear on behalf of three candidates namely Pankaj, Amit and Ankit Khatri in their different DSSSB exams in place of the said three candidates for a consideration of Rs. 4 Lakhs. He further disclosed that he took Rs.4 Lakhs in cash in advance for the said purpose. 5. Ld. Counsel for the applicant submits that he has been falsely implicated in this case. He submits that he is no more required for investigation of this alleged offence which took place more than five years back. He submits that on 26.07.2024, he was going abroad for completion of his M.Sc. in digital marketing in Germany at Berlin School of Business and Innovation. No fruitful purpose would be served by further Page No. 2/5 -- 2 of 5 -- curtailing his liberty. He submits that he has clean antecedents. He further submits that he has deep roots in the society and therefore, his chances of fleeing from justice are non-existent. He submits that co-accused with similar allegations have already been enlarged either on regular bail or anticipatory bail. With these submissions, he has prayed for release of the applicant on bail. 6. On the other hand, Ld. Addl. PP for the State assisted by the IO has opposed the present application. He submits that the applicant has committed a serious offence of cheating by impersonation and forgery thereby depriving the rightful claimants an opportunity for employment. He submits that his LOC had to be opened as he was evading investigation. He was apprehended from the IGI Airport when he tried to escape the country. Therefore, if released on bail, he may run away from justice. He submits that examination centers where he appeared are yet to be identified and co-accused person are yet to be arrested. He submits that he is previously involved in a similar case and in that regard an FIR has been lodged at PS Maurya Enclave. Therefore, there is every likelihood that he may again commit similar offence or tamper the evidence, if released on bail. With these submissions, he has sought dismissal of the present bail application. 7. The investigation qua the applicant has already been concluded and his further incarceration will serve no fruitful purpose. The trial of the present case is likely to take considerable time. He is stated to be a young boy with no previous conviction. His chances of reformation and career Page No. 3/5 -- 3 of 5 -- prospects may suffer a severe blow, if he is kept in the company of hardened criminals in the jail. He is stated to have deep roots in society and his passport is stated to have been seized. Therefore, his flight risk is negligible. Further, stringent conditions can be imposed upon him while granting bail to ensure that he does not run away from justice. In order to afford fair trial to the applicant, he must be given an opportunity to prepare for his defence and that would not be possible while being in custody. The co-accused with similar allegations have already been released on bail. Further, this court is conscious of the settled principle of bail that “Bail is rule and jail is an exception”. The said sacrosanct principle is one of the crucial guiding factor for disposing off bail applications. 8. Therefore, in the above facts & circumstances, in the interest of justice and on the ground of parity, the applicant Parvesh Narwal S/o Sh. Surajmal Singh is admitted to bail on furnishing personal bond in the sum of Rs. 25,000/- (Rupees Twenty Five Thousand only) with one surety in the like amount to the satisfaction of Ld. MM/ Link MM/ Duty MM and subject to the following conditions:- I. He shall regularly appear before the IO as and when directed by him and before the court during the trial; II. He shall not tamper with the evidence; III. He shall not contact the complainant, other witnesses and shall not pressurize them, induce them or extend any kind of threat to them; IV. In case of change of his address, he shall intimate the same to the court; V. His seized passport shall not be released to him without prior permission of the court; and VI. He shall not leave the country without prior permission Page No. 4/5 -- 4 of 5 -- of the court. 9. The observations made while disposing off the present application shall not tantamount to the expressions on the merits of the case. The application is disposed off. 10. A copy of this order be sent to the concerned Jail Superintendent, to inform the applicant. 11. At request, a copy of this order be given dasti to Ld. Counsel for the applicant and the IO. (Dheeraj Mor) Bail Roster Judge ASJ-06/NDD/PHC New Delhi:06.08.2024 Page No. 5/5 -- 5 of 5 --
