Interim Order 3

Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS
Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS Comm no.369 of 2019
Nike International Ltd. Vs. m/s Subhash Foot Wear.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. S.K.Bansal, counsel for the plaintiff through VC.
Proxy counsel for the defendant physically present.
It is informed by proxy counsel that copy of contempt application
has not been supplied to the defendant by plaintiff.
Let plaintiff to supply the same within 07 days.
Both the counsels submit that the matter may be sent to mediation
cell for exploring possibility of settlement.
In view of the submissions and request, let the matter be sent to
the Incharge, Mediation Cell, PHC, ND with a request to explore possibility of
settlement. Parties are directed to appear before Mediation Cell on 20.10.2021
and to report back on 14.02.2022. Ahmad is directed to send the file to
Mediation Cell for the date fixed.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 1 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS Comm no. 376 of 2019
M/s L’oreal Vs. Fringes Curls Salon.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. S.K.Bansal, counsel for the plaintiff through VC.
Sh. Vivek Singh, counsel for th defendant through VC.
Counse for plaintiffl states that plaintiff is ready to settle subject to
defendant giving an undertaking that defendants shall not use plaintiff's trade
mark unauthorisedly and shall also withdraw the FIR/police complaint , if any
filed by defendant against plaintiff or its employees and further subject to
defendant paying Rs 50,000/- towards litigation charges. Counsel for
defendant states that defendant is ready to give the undertaking as proposed
above and shall also make payment of Rs. 50,000/- towards the litigation
charges through demand draft on or before the next date of hearing.
Counsel has given an undertaking on behalf of defendant today in the
court. Same is recorded seperately.
At request case is adjourned for payment of Rs 50,000/- and
withdrawal for 06.10.2021.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 2 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS Comm no. 376 of 2019
M/s L’oreal Vs. Fringes Curls Salon.
18.09.2021
Statement of Sh. Vivek Singh , counsel for defendant Enroll. no. D-864 /2002
At Bar.
I am counsel for the defendant in the present suit. Under the
instructions and on behalf of defendant, I state that the defendant is ready to
make payment of Rs. 50,000/- (Rs. Fifty Thousand only) to the counsel for
plaintiff towards the litigation charges through demand draft on or before the
next date of hearing.
I undertake that defendant will not use plaintiff’s trademark
‘L’OREAL’ unauthorizedly in any manner. I further undertake that the defendant
will withdraw the complaint, if any filed by it against the plaintiff or its
employees.
RO&AC
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 3 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no.266 of 2017
Ajay Kumar Bhargava Vs. M/s Kundan Care Products ltd.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. Umesh Mishra, counsel for the plaintiff physically present.
None for defendant. Only court clerk of counsel is present.
Counsel for plaintiff submits that only last witness of the defendant
is left to be cross-examined by them before the LC and sought short
adjournment in the matter.
Considering the submission and request, case is adjourned for
report of LC regarding conclusion of the evidence in the matter/ further
proceedings on 09.12.2021.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 4 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
Counter Claim no. 29 of 2017
M/s Kundan Care Products ltd. Vs. Ajay Kumar Bhargava.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : None for plaintiff Only court clerk of counsel is present.
Sh. Umesh Mishra, counsel for the defendant physically present.
Put up with connected matter on 09.12.2021.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 5 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no.243 of 2019
M/s Venture Tour and Packaging Pvt. Ltd Vs. Sukhbir Singh Choudhary
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Ms. Rita Kumar, counsel for the plaintiff through VC.
Ms. Singdha Sharma, counsel for the D-4 and D-5 through VC.
Counsel for plaintiff request for short adjournment saying that
main counsel is not available today on account of some personal difficulty.
Counsel for defendant no. 4 and 5 says that as per instructions
received from her client there is no settlement arrived at between the parties
till date.
Let reply be filed to the application under section 10 CPC 15 days
prior to next date of hearing with advance copy to opposite side. In view of
these facts and circumstances, case is adjourned for arguments on said
application on 14.02.2022.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 6 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no. 436 of 2020
Ajay Sharma and etc. Vs. Om Prakash Sehrawat.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Ms. Charu Tyagi, counsel for the plaintiff through VC.
Sh. Naveen Arya, counsel for defendant physically present.
WS alongwith application under Order 7 rule 11 CPC has already
come on record on behalf of defendant.
Counsel for the plaintiff submits that she has been recently
engaged in the matter and she will file her vakalatnama during the course of
the day. She also requests for supply of copy of WS and said application on
her e-mail (shared in the chat box of VC).
Counsel for defendant assures to supply the same.
Let reply to the application under Order 7 rule 11 CPC be filed 15
day prior to next date of hearing with advance copy to the opposite side.
Put up for arguments on said application on 14.02.2022.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 7 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no. 437 of 2020
Ajay Sharma and etc. Vs. Jaideep Singh.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Ms. Charu Tyagi, counsel for the plaintiff through VC.
Sh. Vipul Jain, proxy counsel for Sh. Bhupender Lakra, counsel for
defendant through VC.
Proxy counsel for defendant says that he has filed memo of
appearance through official email of the court. Let hard copy of the same be
filed on record within 07 days.
Proxy counsel requests for supply of copy of plaint and its
annexures. Let the same be supplied by counsel for plaintiff to counsel for
defendant today itself through e-mode within a week.
WS be filed within 30 days of receipt of copy of plaint and its
annexures with advance copy to opposite party. At request, case is adjourned
for 14.02.2022.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 8 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
TM no. 16 of 2021
Tenax Pidilite India pvt Ltd. Vs. Nadeem Faiyaz Shaikh.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. Rishi Bansal, counsel for the plaintiff through VC.
At request, case is adjourned for arguments on ad-interim ex-parte
injunction application on 11.10.2021.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 9 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no. 323 of 2021
Kartar Singh Vs. Anju Vohra and ors.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Plaintiff in person physically present.
Plaintiff requests for adjournment as main counsel is not available
today.
Present suit is filed under Order 37 CPC however, from perusal of
the plaint and documents filed with the suit, some clarifications are required
with regard to the maintainability of suit under Order 37 CPC.
Considering the request, adjourned for clarification on 16.10.2021.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 10 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no.351 of 2021.
Neelam Mishra Vs. Dharmender Rajput.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. Avdesh Kumar, counsel for the plaintiff physically present.
Original documents alongwith list of documents filed on record.
File perused. Issue summons of appearance on filing of PF /RC as
well as through e-mode for 14.02.2022.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 11 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
Arbi no. 1385 of 2021
Gaadi Web Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Maa Sherawali Auto Deal.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. Ashok Kumar, counsel for the petitioner physically present.
At request, put up for consideration on 23.09.2021.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 12 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
Arbi no. 956 of 2021
Ankur Tarde Links pvt. Ltd. Vs. Khurshid Aalam.
Arbi no. 957 of 2021
Perfect Fin. Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Dharmender Kumar.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : None for petitioner.
Since none is present for petitioner, put up for consideration on
25.09.2021.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 13 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no. 55670 of 2016
Anil Kumar Vs. Jugal Kishore.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Plaintiff is physically present in the court.
Son of D-1 on behalf of D-1 physically present.
Both request for adjournment saying that their respective main
counsels are not available today.
As per record, case is at the stage of admission-denial of the
documents. Both parties are directed to ensure presence of their respective
lawyer on the next date of hearing to assist the court for settlement of issues.
Relist for admission-denial of documents and settlement of issues
on 14.02.2022. Parties may file proposed issues.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 14 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no. 59323 of 2016
Mukesh Bansal Vs. National Green Tribunal.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. Satprakash Tiwari, counsel for the plaintiff physically present.
Sh. Pankaj Shrivastav, counsel for defendant physically present.
In this case pleadings are complete and affidavits of admission-
denial of documents have already come on record.
In view thereof, I am inclined to frame issues. On the pleadings of
parties and documents on record following issues are framed :
1. Whether the plaintiff had supplied less quantity of stationery items than
the ordered one to the defendant. If so, whether the defendant had already
made payment to the plaintiff in respect of said supply ? OPD.
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recovery of suit amount as claimed
for ? OPP.
3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for interest, if so at what rate and for
which period ? OPP.
4. Relief.
No other issue arises or pressed for.
Parties are directed to file list of witnesses within 15 days. Plaintiff
is directed to file evidentiary affidavit of his witnesses at least 15 days prior to
next date of hearing with advance copy of the same to opposite counsel.
Relist for PE on 14.02.2022.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 15 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no. 59510 of 2016
Vijay Bansal Vs. Hitech Bulk Handling Systems pvt ltd.
PARCHA
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. Sanjay Gupta, counsel for plaintiff physically present.
Counsel for defendant physically present.
As per Ahlmad report file is not traceable.
Counsel for the defendant is ready to make the payment of cost for
D-1 only but counsel for plaintiff submits that he would take the cost after the
file is traced out.
Ahlmad is directed to trace out the file and place it on 26.10.2021.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 16 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no. 55570 of 2016
Naveen Deswal Vs. Gaurav Khattar.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : None for plaintiff.
Defendant in person, physically present.
Case is at the stage of recording of evidence.
As per record, on 18.01.2019, none had appeared on behalf of the
plaintiff but in the interest of justice, court had given plaintiff one last and final
opportunity to lead evidence subject to payment of cost of Rs. 5000/-. Record
further shows that counsel for plaintiff had appeared on 15.12.2020 but on
account of proceedings being conducted through VC, case was adjourned for
evidence.
Evidentiary affidavit of plaintiff is already on record.
Defendant seeks some time to engage a new counsel as his
previous counsel is stated have expired due to Covid.
In view thereof, plaintiff is directed to appear on next date of
hearing for payment of cost and tendering of his evidentiary affidavit and for
his cross examination on 14.02.2022.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 17 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no. 58969 of 2016
Escorts Ltd. Vs. Kaveri Tractors and ors.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Ms. Sonal, counsel for the plaintiff with witness Sh. Gopal Prasad
physically present.
Defendant is ex-parte.
An application under Order 7 rule 14 r/w Section 151 CPC for
placing on record one cheque bearing n. 45684 dated 27.12.2012 draw on
Corporation Bank alongwith it returning memo dated 15.03.2012.
Counsel says that the plaint duly mentions the fact regarding the
issuance of said cheque and its dishonour but inadvertently documents
pertaining it could not be placed on record.
Heard. File perused.
Keeping in view the submissions and fact that defendant in the
present case is ex-parte and no prejudice will be caused if the present
application is allowed, the application is allowed and documents are taken on
record.
Counsel for the plaintiff files additional evidentiary affidavit in
the light of filing of said documents. Heard. Allowed
Witness Sh. Gopal Prasad is partly examined in chief as PW-1, his
further examination is deferred for want of certification under Section 65 B of
Indian Evidence Act.
Relist for further examination of PW-1 on 12.01.2022.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 18 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADJ-04,
PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
Arbi no. 1409; 1410; 1411; 1412 of 2021.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Fresh petition under Section 9 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act
received on assignment. It be checked and registered, as per rules.
Present : Ms. Vanshika, Counsel for petitioner through VC.
Counsel for petitioner is directed to file softcopy of the petition
alongwith annexures through official e-mail of the court before next date of
hearing. Put up for consideration on 25.09.2021.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
PHC/ND/18.09.2021
-- 19 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADJ-04,
PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
Arbi no. 1408; 1413; 1414; 1415 of 2021.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Fresh petition under Section 9 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act
received on assignment. It be checked and registered, as per rules.
Present : Ms. Sonia, Counsel for petitioner through VC.
Counsel for petitioner is directed to file softcopy of the petition
alongwith annexures through official e-mail of the court before next date of
hearing. Put up for consideration on 22.09.2021.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
PHC/ND/18.09.2021
-- 20 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no.09 of 2017
M/s B.G.Creations Pvt. Ltd. Vs. State Bank of Saurashtra.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Ms. Meenakshi, counsel for plaintiff through VC.
None for D-1.
D-2 is ex-parte.
Sh. Tushar Sahu, proxy counsel for D-3 physically present.
As per record, none is appearing for D-1 for the last two dates of
hearing. Today also none is present on behalf of D-1, hence, D-1 is proceeded
ex-parte for today.
Case is at the stage of PE and certain witnesses are required to be
summoned but on account of lock down witness could not be summoned on
the last date of hearing.
Let the witnesses be summoned for next date of hearing. Steps be
taken within 30 days. Put up for PE on 03.01.2022.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 21 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no. 59411 of 2016
Shakuntala Devi Vs. Rajni Champa Devi.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. A.K.Singh, counsel for plaintiff through VC.
Sh. Sachin Narwal, counsel for D-1 to D-5 through VC.
D-6 to D-8 and D-11 to D-18 are ex-parte.
Sh. Debarishi, counsel for D-10 through VC.
Counsels say that evidence before LC was got halted on account of
lockdown and pandemic but they have again resumed the recording of
evidence and same is likely to conclude within 1 or 2 month.
In view thereof, case is adjourned for 11.01.2022 for awaiting the
conclusion of evidence. Let notice be sent to LC for filing report on or before
next date.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 22 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
Counter claim no. 15 of 2016
Shakuntala Devi Vs. Rajni Champa Devi.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. Debasish Bhadra, counsel for counter claimant through VC.
Sh. A.K.Singh, counsel for LRs of deceased non-counter claimant
through VC.
Put up with connected matter on 11.01.2022.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 23 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
Counter claim no. 11 of 2016
Rajni Champa Devi. Vs. Shakuntala Devi
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. Sachin Narwal, counsel for all counter claimant through VC.
Sh. A.K.Singh, counsel for LRs of deceased non-counter claimant
through VC.
Put up with connected matter on 11.01.2022.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 24 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no. 888 of 2018
Infraline Technologies India Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Sharda Ma Enterprises Pvt. Ltd.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. Ishpreet Singh, proxy counsel for plaintiff though VC.
Defendant is ex-parte.
Adjournment is sought for filing plaintiff’s evidentiary affidavit.
At request, case is adjourned for filing the same on 14.12.2012.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 25 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no.1179 of 2018
Singh Corporate Mantra Pvt. Ltd. vs. Protrade Inc. and anr.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. Pankaj Kumar, counsel for plaintiff physically present.
Defendant is ex-parte.
Counsel requests for short adjournment on the ground that AR of
the plaintiff is out of Station.
At request, case is adjourned for PE on 14.12.2012. Let evidentiary
affidavit of PW be filed 15 days prior to next date of hearing.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 26 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no.55582 of 2016
Dr. Morepen Ltd. Vs. M/s Brukem Life Care anr.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. Naman Joshi (through VC) and Sh. Abhishek Arora, proxy
counsel for plaintiff physically present.
Sh. Mohan Vidhani, counsel for the defendant through VC.
Case is listed today for consideration of withdrawal of the suit.
Counsel for plaintiff submits that plaintiff is ready to compensate
the defendant for the litigation charges to the tune of Rs. 50,000/- and subject
to said payment, plaintiff may be allowed to withdraw the present suit.
Counsel for the defendant also agrees to said proposal.
Let payment of Rs.50,000/- be made to the counsel for defendant
on or before next date of hearing. Put up for payment /withdrawal on
28.09.2021.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 27 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no.1083 of 2018
Kirti Vardhan Azad Vs. Pushpesh Kumar.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Counsel for plaintiff physically present.
Counsel for defendant physically present.
Counsel for defendant says that as per instructions from his client
the matter is likely to be settled as parties are negotiating for the same.
However, counsel for plaintiff categorically denies saying that he
has not received any such instruction. Let counsel for plaintiff seeks
instructions in this regard from the client. Put up for settlement if
any/arguments on pending application.
Relist on 30.11.2021. Let the parties to appear in person on the
next date of hearing.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 28 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS Comm no.380 of 2019
PVH Corp. Vs. Samir Khan.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. Rishi Bansal (through VC) and Sh. Somnath De, counsel for
plaintiff physically present.
Ms. Imon Roy, Adv. states that she is appearing for the plaintiff
through VC.
Ms. Roy submits that she has been recently engaged in the matter
by the plaintiff but his client is yet to get the NOC from his erstwhile counsel.
Even counsel for plaintiff states that he also some information in this regard
but he will be in a position to clarify after getting necessary instructions from
his client.
As per record, written submissions have already been filed on
record alongwith the supporting judgment on 08.09.2021.
In view of request, adjourned for arguments on 14.02.2022.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 29 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no.59079 of 2016
Fena Ltd. Vs. J.M.Baxi.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. Praveen Mahajan through VC and Sh. Ankur Gusain, counsel
for plaintiff physically present.
Sh. Gaurav, counsel for defendant through VC.
Written submissions on behalf of parties are already on record.
Case is fixed for verbal arguments on 16.11.2021. Case file is very
old and bulky, therefore, counsel for parties are directed to file convenience
compilation 15 days prior to next hearing.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 30 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no. 213 of 2019
Atul Chawla Vs. Noman Hossain.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Present : Sh. Shashwati Jindal, counsel for plaintiff physically present.
(SHAASHWAT.JINDAL@gmail.com mobile no. 8826908171)
Sh. Suman Kumar with Sh. Avinash, counsel for defendant
physically present.
(AVINASH.JAISWAL79@gmail.com).
Both the counsels say that as per instructions of their clients the
matter is likely to settle very soon.
Counsel for parties say that in order to facilitate the settlement,
matter may be sent to Delhi High Court Mediation Cell.
In view of submissions and request of parties, case is referred to
‘Samadhan’, Delhi High Court Mediation Cell with a request to explore
possibility of settlement.
Parties are directed to appear before ‘Samadhan’, Delhi High Court
Mediation Cell on 23.09.2021 at 3 p.m and to report back on 16.02.2022.
Ahmad is directed to send the file to ‘Samadhan’, Delhi High Court Mediation
Cell for the date fixed.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 31 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
CS no. 362 of 2021
M/s Ahuja Builders Vs. AIMS Gold Town Developers Pvt. Ltd.
18.09.2021
Pursuant to the office order no.569/RG/DHC/2021 dated
19.08.2021 of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and office order no. 6813-
6837/Judl./Prin.D&SJ/NDD/2021 dated 21.08.2021, all the matters are taken
up physically by this court on even dates and through video conferencing on
odd dates.
Fresh suit under Order 37 CPC received on assignment. It be
checked and registered, as per rules.
Present : Sh. Abhay Mahajan, counsel for the plaintiff physically present.
Counsel heard. File perused.
From the nature of the litigation, it appears that dispute in the
present suit is commercial in nature.
Counsel for plaintiff concedes to the said position and requests that
case may be sent to the Ld. District Judge (Commercial).
In view of request of counsel, facts and circumstances of the case,
let file be sent to the court of Ld. Principal District Judge, PHC, New Delhi with
a request to assign the same to Ld. District Judge (Commercial).
Plaintiff is directed to appear before the Ld. Principal District Judge,
PHC, New Delhi on 20.09.2021. Ahlmad is directed to send the file complete in
all respect on or before date fixed.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 32 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
Ex. no. 721 of 2017
K. Natrajan Vs. K.P. Suraliraj.
18.09.2021
Present : Sh.S.Mutukrishnan, counsel for DH physically present.
Sh. Durga Dutt, Adv. earlier representing DH physically present.
Sh. Durga Dutt submits that he was earlier representing DH and he
had handed over the entire file with the Transfer Certificate to the DH.
Sh. S. Mutukrishnan, Counsel for DH submits that the Transfer
Certificate earlier issued in this case was never filed before any court on
account of the fact that either it got misplaced by the DH or his counsel.
Counsel prays for issuance of fresh Transfer Certificate in this case.
Statement of both the counsels recorded separately.
In view of the submissions and statement of counsels, let a fresh
Transfer Certificate be issued to DH. In terms thereof, petition stands disposed
off. File be consigned to record room after due compliance.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 33 of 34 --
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNENA SHARMA, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI
Ex. no. 721 of 2017
K. Natrajan Vs. K.P. Suraliraj.
18.09.2021
Statement of Sh. Durga Dutt, Adv. Enrol. No D136 of 2011, Earlier
representing DH.
At Bar.
639
I state that earlier I was representing DH in the present execution
and I had handed over the entire file with the Transfer Certificate to the DH.
RO&AC.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
Statement of Sh.S.Mutukrishnan, Adv. Enrol. No D-404 of 2006, counsel for
DH.
At Bar.
Under the instructions and on behalf my client I state that the
Transfer Certificate earlier issued in this case was never filed before any court
on account of the fact that either it got misplaced by the DH or his counsel. I
pray for issuance of fresh Transfer Certificate in this case.
RO&AC.
(Sunena Sharma)
Additional District Judge-04
Judge Code DL00222
Patiala House Courts : New Delhi
-- 34 of 34 --