Full Order Text
Final Order 4 · 24 Jul 2025 · CNR DLND010050582025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. PULASTYA PRAMACHALA, DISTRICT JUDGE (COMMERCIAL COURT)-01, PATIALA HOUSE COURT, NEW DELHI CS (COMM) 512/2025 Mr. Vishwinder Nath Gupta & Anr. Vs. Ansal CH-1 Flat Owners Association & Ors. Date of pronouncement of the order : 24.07.2025 ORDER 1) This suit has been filed by plaintiffs making following prayers: i. Pass a decree of Declaration in favour of Plaintiffs/Owners against Defendants, their officials, agents, successors, assigns or anyone claiming through or under them that as on 30.09.2023, Plaintiffs/Owners lawfully cleared all applicable dues of Defendant Nos. 1 & 2 or anyone claiming through or under them for the period prior to 30.09.2023 in respect of all dues under the Agreement dt. 02.07.1990 in respect of the Suit Property; ii. Pass a decree of Declaration in favour of Plaintiffs/Owners against Defendants, their officials, agents, successors, assigns or anyone claiming through or under them that as on 30.09.2023, neither Alleged Arrears of Rs. 23,71,182/- pursuant to fraudulent invoice dt. 07.12.2023 nor any further/ incidental amounts nor any other amount pertaining to the period till 30.09.2023 are payable by Plaintiffs/Owners or can be claimed by Defendants, their officials, agents, successors, assigns, or anyone claiming through or under them from Plaintiffs/Owners or anyone claiming through or (Pulastya Pramachala) Page 1 of 10 District Judge (Commercial Court)-01, Patiala House Court, New Delhi -- 1 of 10 -- under them in respect of the Suit Property; iii. Pass a Decree of Permanent Injunction in favour of Plaintiffs/Owners and against Defendants, their officials, agents, successors, assigns or anyone claiming through or under them restraining Defendants from claiming the Alleged Arrears of Rs. 23,71,182/- or any interest/incidental amounts arising therefrom or in connection therewith from Plaintiffs/ Owners or anyone claiming through or under them. iv. Pass a Decree for Permanent Injunction in favour of Plaintiffs/Owners thereby restraining Defendants, their officials, agents, successors, assigns thereby restraining from causing any delay, prejudice, hinderance, obstruction, nuisance, disruption in any manner whatsoever in the use, enjoyment or disposal of the Suit Property by Plaintiffs/Owners, including by sale, lease, licencing, etc. pursuant to the fraudulent invoice dt. 07.12.2023 or any interest/ incidental amounts arising therefrom or in connection therewith. v. Pass a Decree in favour of Plaintiffs/Owners and against Defendants thereby directing Defendants to, jointly and severally, pay Plaintiffs/Owners an amount of Rs. 6,32,742/- i.e., interest @ 18% p.a. on sale consideration of Rs.65,13,000/- from 14.11.2024 till 30.05.2025 payment on account of loss of profits/income arising out of the inconclusive sale between Plaintiffs/Owners and the Buyer; vi. Pass a Decree in favour of Plaintiffs/Owners and against Defendants thereby directing Defendants to pay Plaintiffs/Owners pendente lite and future interest @ 18% p.a. on Rs. 65, 13,000/- till complete payment thereof; vii.Pass a Decree in favour of Plaintiffs/Owners and against Defendants thereby directing Defendants to pay Plaintiffs/Owners an amount of Rs.5,00,000/- for compensation/penalty paid to the Buyer arising out of the Cancellation Deed 14.1l.2024; viii. Pass a Decree in favour of Plaintiffs/Owners and against Defendants thereby directing Defendants (Pulastya Pramachala) Page 2 of 10 District Judge (Commercial Court)-01, Patiala House Court, New Delhi -- 2 of 10 -- to jointly and severally pay Plaintiffs/Owners an amount of Rs. 48,575/-, i.e., interest @ 18% p.a. on compensation/penalty paid of Rs.5,00,000/- from 14.11.2024 till 30.05.2025 payment on account of loss of profits/ income on the inconclusive sale between Plaintiffs/ Owners and the Buyer; ix. Pass a Decree in favour of Plaintiffs/Owners and against Defendants thereby directing Defendants to pay Plaintiffs/Owners pendente lite and future interest@ 18% p.a.; x. Pass a Decree in favour of Plaintiffs thereby directing Defendants to jointly and severally pay to Plaintiffs Damages of Rs. 10,00,000/- towards mental harassment and torture, inconvenience, etc. arising out of the mala fides acts and conduct of Defendants; xi. Pass a Decree for payment of Costs of this lis in favour of Plaintiffs and against defendants; xii. pass such other Decree and/or Order or grant such other reliefs as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the matter in favour of Plaintiffs and against Defendants. 2) Along with the suit, plaintiff has also filed application under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC making following prayers: i. Pass ex-parte ad-interim directions thereby restraining Defendants from causing any hindrance, prejudice, etc. to the rights and claims of Plaintiffs/Owners, including by non-issuance of No Objection Certificates/No Dues Certificates relating to any intending sale/transfer by Plaintiff(s)/Owner(s), on the basis of the Alleged Arrears and/or any interest thereon and/or any incidental amounts during the pendency of this Suit and subject to outcome thereof; and ii. Pass ex-parte ad-interim directions thereby retraining Defendant(s) from claiming the Alleged Arrears and/or any interest thereon and/or (Pulastya Pramachala) Page 3 of 10 District Judge (Commercial Court)-01, Patiala House Court, New Delhi -- 3 of 10 -- iii. Pass ex-parte ad-interim directions thereby retraining Defendant(s) from claiming the Alleged Arrears and/or any interest thereon and/or any incidental amounts from Plaintiffs/Owners during the pendency of the captioned Suit; and iv. Exempt Plaintiffs from complying with the provisions of Section 12A, Commercial Courts Act, 2015 qua Pre-Institution Mediation in this matter; and v. Pass any other order(s) as this Hon'ble Court deems fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the present suit in favour of Plaintiffs/Owners. 3) The suit has been filed without compliance of provisions under Section 12A of Commercial Courts Act and in the plaint, exemption has been claimed from the compliance of Section 12A of Commercial Courts Act on the grounds of seeking urgent relief. 4) Briefly stated the relevant factual matrix presented by the plaintiffs are that plaintiffs are owner of the suit property i.e. Commercial shop No. R-9, LGF, Ansal Chamber no.1, 3 Bhikaji Cama Place, New Delhi. Defendant no.2 is the agency related to maintenance and defendant no.3 is the promoter of this project. Defendant no.1 is the RWA/society which collects the quarterly maintenance charges. Plaintiffs wanted to sell the suit property. For the purposes of sale, plaintiffs entered into talk with proposed purchasers and also executed an agreement to sell. For the purposes of sale of the suit property, no dues certificate/clearance certificate were required from defendant no.1 and 2. According to plaintiffs, they had cleared all the dues. However, vide invoice dated 07.12.2023, defendants raised demand of arrears in the sum of Rs.23,71,182/- against the plaintiffs. According to (Pulastya Pramachala) Page 4 of 10 District Judge (Commercial Court)-01, Patiala House Court, New Delhi -- 4 of 10 -- plaintiffs, such arrears were malafidely and illegally raised and for such reasons, no dues certificates were not given to the plaintiffs, resulting into cancellation of agreement to sell between plaintiffs and prospective purchasers. 5) Submissions were invited in respect of present form of the suit as well as nature of relief sought and exemption from compliance of provisions under Section 12A CC Act. 6) Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff submitted that the demand made by the defendants is illegal. Plaintiffs are not liable to pay that amount. Plaintiffs had already paid full and final amount of dues till September 2023. Defendants raised the subsequent demand malafidely, when they were requested time and again to issue NOC. Ld. Counsel submitted that there is need of urgent relief so that defendants do not stop the plaintiff from selling the suit property as well as from participating in the activities of the society including election process. 7) I have given due considerations to the contentions made by ld. Counsel for the plaintiff and to the materials placed on the record. Compliance of Section 12A of Commercial Courts Act, 2015. 8) As far as nature of relief claimed in this suit, is concerned, it has to be seen if there was actually any urgency to bye- pass the provisions under Section 12A of Commercial Courts Act or an urgency has been shown mere for the sake of claiming an urgent relief and to bye- pass the legal requirements. In Yamini Manohar v. T K D Keerthi, 2023 SCC Online 1382, it was held that “ when a plaint is filed under the CC Act, with a prayer for an urgent interim relief, the commercial court should examine the nature and (Pulastya Pramachala) Page 5 of 10 District Judge (Commercial Court)-01, Patiala House Court, New Delhi -- 5 of 10 -- the subject matter of the suit, the cause of action, and the prayer for interim relief. The prayer for urgent interim relief should not be a disguise or mask to wriggle out of and get over Section 12-A of the CC Act. The facts and circumstances of the case have to be considered holistically from the standpoint of the plaintiff.” 9) In the case of M/s Dhanbad Fuels Private Limited Vs. Union Of India & Anr. 2025 INSC 696, Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under: “In light of the aforesaid discussion, we summarise our findings as under: a. The decision of this Court in Patil Automation (supra) lays down the correct position of law as regards Section 12A of the 2015 Act by holding it to be mandatory in nature. b. As held in paragraph 104 of the decision in Patil Automation (supra), the declaration of the mandatory nature of Section 12A of the 2015 Act relates back to the date of the Amending Act. c. As held in paragraph 113.1 of the decision in Patil Automation (supra), any suit which is instituted under the 2015 Act without complying with Section 12A is liable to be rejected under Order VII Rule 11. However, this declaration applies prospectively to suits instituted on or after 20.08.2022. d. A suit which contemplates an urgent interim relief may be filed under the 2015 Act without first resorting to mediation as prescribed under Section 12A of the 2015 Act. e. Unlike Section 80(2) of the CPC, leave of the court is not required to be obtained before filing a suit without complying with Section 12A of the 2015 Act. f. The test for “urgent interim relief” is if on an examination of the nature and the subject-matter of the suit and the cause of action, the prayer of urgent interim (Pulastya Pramachala) Page 6 of 10 District Judge (Commercial Court)-01, Patiala House Court, New Delhi -- 6 of 10 -- relief by the plaintiff could be said to be contemplable when the matter is seen from the standpoint of the plaintiff. g. Courts must also be wary of the fact that the urgent interim relief must not be merely an unfounded excuse by the plaintiff to bypass the mandatory requirement of Section 12A of the 2015 Act. h. Even if the urgent interim relief ultimately comes to be denied, the suit of the plaintiff may be proceeded with without compliance with Section 12A if the test for “urgent interim relief” is satisfied notwithstanding the actual outcome on merits. i. Suits instituted without complying with Section 12A of the 2015 Act prior to 20.08.2022 cannot be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 on the ground of non- compliance with Section 12A unless they fall within the exceptions stipulated in paragraph 113.2 and 113.3 of the decision in Patil Automation (supra). j. In suits instituted without complying with Section 12A of the 2015 Act prior to 20.08.2022 which are pending adjudication before the trial court, the court shall keep the suit in abeyance and refer the parties to time-bound mediation in accordance with Section 12A of the 2015 Act if an objection is raised by the defendant by filing an application under Order VII Rule 11, or in cases where any of the parties expresses an intent to resolve the dispute by mediation.” 10) The dispute between the parties as appearing from the plaint, relates to demand of arrears of Rs.23,71,182/- raised by defendants vide invoice dated 07.12.2023. Naturally, defendants would not be issuing NOC without compliance of aforesaid demand of arrears. 11) I have already reproduced the prayers made by the plaintiffs in the plaint and in the application seeking urgent relief. The prayer made in application under Order XXXIX (Pulastya Pramachala) Page 7 of 10 District Judge (Commercial Court)-01, Patiala House Court, New Delhi -- 7 of 10 -- Rules 1 and 2 CPC cannot be treated as urgent relief. Rather such prayer cannot be maintained because acceding to such prayer would tantamount to decide this case at this stage itself in favor of plaintiffs. Hence, I do find that without having any cause for some actual urgent relief to be claimed, plaintiffs did not comply with the provisions under Section 12A of Commercial Courts Act under the garb of aforesaid application. For this reason, suit is bad in the eyes of law. Valuation And Court Fees 12) In the present case, the plaintiffs valued the suit for first two reliefs of declarations and first relief of injunction thereby, seeking to avoid payment of arrears of Rs.23,71,182/-, at Rs.200/- each. In the case of Rampur Distillery and Chemicals Co. Ltd. v. Union of India 1995 (57) DLT 642, the plaintiff had valued the suit for declaration and for injunction at fixed sum. High Court of Delhi noted that the plaintiff was seeking to avoid payment of Rs.5,24,790/- to the defendant and, therefore, the plaintiff was liable to pay the Court fees on Rs.5,24,790/-. Relevant portion of the said judgment is reproduced hereunder: - 1) “The Court in deciding the question of Court fee should look into the allegations in the plaint to see what is the substantive relief that is asked for; mere astuteness in drafting the plaint will not be allowed to stand in the way of the Court looking at the substance of the relief asked for -observed their Lordship in Shamsher Singh v. Rajinder Prashad & Ors., AIR 1973 SC 2384. So is the view taken by Full Bench of Delhi High Court in Mahant Purushottam Dass & Ors. v. Har Narain & Ors., AIR 1978 Delhi 114. 2) xxx xxx xxx 3) The facts stated in the plaint show the plaintiff having (Pulastya Pramachala) Page 8 of 10 District Judge (Commercial Court)-01, Patiala House Court, New Delhi -- 8 of 10 -- entered into a contract with the Union of India for supplying certain commodity. The contract has failed. The defendant has exercised its right under the risk purchase clause, consequent to which a recovery in an amount of Rs. 5,24,790/- is outstanding against the plaintiff. By filing of the suit, the plaintiff seeks to get rid of the contract and also avoid payment of Rs. 5,24,790/- to the defendant. Ad valorem court fee has not been paid by the plaintiff. 7. The suit filed by the plaintiff is governed by Sections 7(iv)(c) of the Court Fees Act, 1870. In such suits, the amount of court fee payable has to be concluded on the amount at which the relief sought is valued in the plaint or memorandum of appeal. The plaintiff has to state the amount at which he values the relief sought. 4) The injunction sought for by the plaintiff seeks avoidance of a specified money liability to the tune of Rs.5,24,790/-. The plaintiff is liable to pay ad valorem court fee on this amount.” 13) The aforesaid judgment was relied upon by Delhi High Court in the Case of NDMC Vs. M/s Prominent Hotels Ltd., (RFA no. 78/2014 decided on 11.09.2015). In that case also, Hon'ble High Court of Delhi reiterated the same law. Thus, in view of the aforesaid law, plaintiffs are liable to value this suit for the purpose of above-mentioned reliefs for declarations and permanent injunction and pay ad valorem Court fee, on the amount of Rs.23,71,182/-. Suit in its present form 14) By way of seeking relief of declaration and first relief of permanent injunction, plaintiffs have challenged their liability to make payment of such demand raised by the defendants. However, interestingly plaintiffs have not sought any declaration regarding the invoice dated 07.12.2023, vide which aforesaid demand was raised by the defendants. The prayer clause is not happily worded. (Pulastya Pramachala) Page 9 of 10 District Judge (Commercial Court)-01, Patiala House Court, New Delhi -- 9 of 10 -- Plaintiffs have not sought any declaration to the effect that aforesaid invoice is null or void or non-est and is liable to be cancelled accordingly. They have sought to deny liability of Rs.23,71,182/-. It will be subject matter of trial to be looked into the merits of that claim. However, without aforesaid invoice getting declared null and void, the relief of permanent injunction (relief no.3) as sought by plaintiff cannot be maintainable qua such liability. 15) In respect of valuation of the suit and present form of the suit, plaintiff could have been given opportunity to amend the plaint. However, in view of law explained by Supreme Court in aforesaid case as well as in M/s Patil Automation Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. Vs. Rakheja Engineers Pvt. Ltd., 2022 LiveLaw (SC) 678, this plaint on account of non- compliance of provision under Section 12 A of Commercial Courts Act, 2015 is liable to be rejected. In M/s Patil Automation (supra), Supreme Court further held that the Court is to discharge its duty of rejecting the plaint and for that purpose, no application is required. Court can do so suo-moto. 16) Accordingly, this plaint is rejected on account of non-compliance of Section 12 A of Commercial Courts Act, 2015. 17) File be consigned to record room. Pronounced in the (PULASTYA PRAMACHALA) Open Court on this District Judge (Commercial Court)-01, 24th Day of July, 2025 Patiala House Court, New Delhi (Pulastya Pramachala) Page 10 of 10 District Judge (Commercial Court)-01, Patiala House Court, New Delhi -- 10 of 10 --
