Full Order Text
Final Order 21 · 28 Mar 2023 · CNR DLND010049902021
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MR. DHARMESH SHARMA PRINCIPAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE, NEW DELHI PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI RCT No.01/2021 CNR No. DLND010049902021 In re: Subodh Kumar Wadhwa R/o. C1/204 & 202, 2 nd Floor, Naraina Village, Ring Road (Kiran Smarak Sadan), New Delhi110 028 …..…...Appellant Versus 1. Manish Tanwar S/o. Late Sh. Rajbir Singh Flat No.B503, Plot No.30, Sector6, Bhawalpur Appts., Dwarka New Delhi110 077 Also at C/o. Late Sh. Rampat Tanwar, CB96, Naraina Village, Ring Road, New Delhi 110 028 2. The Commissioner of Police Delhi Police (PHQ), IP Estate, New Delhi 110 002 Also at SHO / ACP, Police Station Naraina New Delhi …...…. Respondents Date of Institution : 06.08.2021 Date of addressing arguments : 14.03.2023 Date of Judgment : 28.03.2023 Appearances: Sh. Iqbal Singh, Advocate for the appellant. Sh. C. Prakash, Advocate the respondents. RCT01/2021 Subodh Kumar Wadhwa Vs. Manish Tanwar & Ors. Page 1 of 4 -- 1 of 4 -- JUDGMENT: 1. This Order shall decide an appeal filed under Section 38 of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 as amended up to date, (hereinafter referred as “the DRC Act”), read with Section 151 C.P.C. whereby the appellant/tenant has assailed the order dated 29.06.2021 passed by Ms. Preeti Parewa, the then Ld. ACJcumCCJcumARC, New Delhi District, Patiala House Courts, New Delhi, whereby the relief for resumption of water supply at the residential premises as sought by the appellant by way of interim relief under Section 45 (2) of the DRC Act was declined. FACTUAL BACKGROUND: 2. Briefly stated, it is the case of the appellant that he was inducted as a tenant by respondent No.1 and put in possession of premises bearing No. 202 with attached toilet and WC at Second Floor, C1, Naraina Village (Kiran Smarak Sadan), Ring Road, New Delhi110 028 at a monthly rent of Rs.1400/ per months, including water charges, which is being used for residential purposes since 01.08.2007 till date and; rent @ Rs.1400/ per month has been paid upto September, 2021 by SBI Transfers. It was stated that water supply was attached to the toilet and WC in the tenanted premises since June, 2000, which tenanted premises was earlier being used for commercial usage but was converted to residential usage since August, 2007 to prevent sealing driver by the MCD. It was stated that the amenity of supply of water has been enjoined by him since the very inception of the tenancy sometime in 2000 and the grievance of the appellant/tenant was that the supply of water has since been disconnected by respondent No.1/landlord sometimes in the year 2021. RCT01/2021 Subodh Kumar Wadhwa Vs. Manish Tanwar & Ors. Page 2 of 4 -- 2 of 4 -- 3. Therefore, the appellant filed a petition under Section 45 of the DRC Act and moved an application under Section 45(2) of the DRC Act, seeking restoration of amenity of essential supply of water and access to toilet and bathroom till the disposal of the case. On the moving of the application, notices were issued to respondent No.1 as also respondent No.2 viz. Delhi Police and after the replies were filed, the Ld. Trial Court passed the impugned order, the operative portion of which is as under : “It is the case of the petitioner that the rent of the premises is Rs.1,400/ per month and the domestic connection installed was disconnected in April of this year and accordingly interim relief has been sought for installing/restoring the said water connection. As per the petition, the petitioner is in possession of Room Nos. 202, 204, 205 & 206 (Second Floor) of the building C1, Naraina Village, Ring Road, Delhi. The nonapplicant / respondent No.1 has disputed the fact that the present property falls under the DRC Act. Further, it is disputed that the water connection which was of commercial nature has been removed way back in the year 2021. As per the enquiry report filed by the R2, no water connection to the said rooms of the petitioner is in place since the year 2012 and also there is no separate motor or water tank of the petitioner. The statements of the other tenants namely Mr. Lalit Kumar and Mr. Abhay Verma have also been placed on record. Accordingly, a suit for possession of the premises in question is pending in Civil Court at Tis Hazari Courts where the issue of the quantum of rent is in dispute. Further, during the course of arguments, it is stated that the petitioner is not residing at the said address. Considering the submissions made and the material available on record, a prima facie case is favour of petitioner does not seem to be made out. Hence, at this stage, interim relief as sought by the petitioner is declined. Issues raised can only be proved by way of evidence. Accordingly, the interim application is hereby dismissed. Put up completion of pleadings / further proceedings on 30.09.2021.” 4. Having heard the Ld. Counsel for the parties and on perusal of the record, I am afraid the present appeal is bereft of any merits. First thing RCT01/2021 Subodh Kumar Wadhwa Vs. Manish Tanwar & Ors. Page 3 of 4 -- 3 of 4 -- first, the core issue is whether the petition filed under Section 45 of the DRC Act is maintainable? The said issue between the parties has already been decided by this Court vide order dated 25.03.2023 in RCA No.16/2022, titled as “Manish Tanwar Vs. Subodh Kumar Wadhwa”, whereby it has been held that the tenancy premises has been fetching rent @ Rs.4,200/ per month, and therefore, outside the purview of DRC Act in terms of Section 3 of the Act. The said judgment operates as resjudicata or issue estoppel as to the tenancy falling outside the purview of the DRC Act and is binding upon the parties, whereby although it has been held that there is an existing relationship of landlord and tenant between the parties but the suit premises is not covered by the DRC Act. 5. Be that as it may, the Ld. Trial Court has rightly observed that the suit premises has always been used for commercial purposes and there is no iota of oral and documentary evidence on the record that the appellant has been using the premises for residential purposes or residing thereat. Hence, the appellant has no primafacie case in his favour. 6. In view of the foregoing discussions, the present appeal is dismissed. The Trial Court Record be sent back along with copy of this order. The parties shall appear before the Ld. Trial Court for further proceedings on 01.05.2023. The appeal file be consigned to Record Room. Announced in the open Court (DHARMESH SHARMA) on 28th March, 2023. Principal District & Sessions Judge (NDD) Patiala House Courts, New Delhi RCT01/2021 Subodh Kumar Wadhwa Vs. Manish Tanwar & Ors. Page 4 of 4 -- 4 of 4 --
