Full Order Text
Final Order 7 · 20 Aug 2022 · CNR DLND010033432021
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MR. SATYABRATA PANDA, ADJ04, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI CS NO. 204/21 NITIN LALI VS. CHANAKYA IAS ACADEMY Date of Institution :06.04.2021 Final arguments heard : 16.08.2022 Date of judgment : 20.08.2022 Sh. Nitin Lali S/o Sh. D.K. Lali R/o H. No. 8151, Sector D8 Vasant Kunj, New Delhi110070 …..Plaintiff Versus Chanakya IAS Academy One of the branches of Chanakya Academy for Education and Training Pvt. Ltd. Through its Director Sh. Arun Kumar Mishra 124, 2nd floor, Satya Niketan Opp. Sri Venkateshwara College near Durgabai Deshmukh South Campus Metro Station, New Delhi1100021 …..Defendant JUDGEMENT 1. The plaintiff has instituted the present suit against the defendant seeking recovery of sum of 13,97,516/ along with ₹ pendente lite and future interest. Plaint 2. The case of the plaintiff has pleaded in the plaint is as follows: 2.1. The defendant runs a coaching institute which gives coaching to students preparing for the competitive examination of civil services. The plaintiff is a graduate holding a degree of B.Tech. from Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha CS NO. 204/21NITIN LALI VS. CHANAKYA IAS ACADEMY Page No 1 of 8 -- 1 of 8 -- University. The plaintiff worked as a faculty in the said defendant institute and took classes for Civil Services Aptitude Test also known as General Studies Prelims PaperII. The plaintiff took classes in the institute of the defendant in the coaching branch at 124, 2nd Floor, Satya Niketan Opposite Sri Venkateshwara College, New Delhi. 2.2. In the month of January 2017, the plaintiff was contacted by the General Manager of the defendant institute namely Ms. Ela Siwan and offered the plaintiff a job of a faculty for teaching the subject of quantitative aptitude and logical reasoning. The defendant offered initial remuneration at the rate of ₹ 1,000/ per hour which was increased to 1,200/ per hour from 27/08/2019. ₹ The plaintiff received his remuneration amount from the defendant in his bank account in the State Bank of India. 2.3. The plaintiff rendered services to the defendant and took the classes as faculty from January 2017 till 12/03/2020 when coaching institutes were closed due to the national lockdown due to the Covid19 pandemic. 2.4. The plaintiff received the complete remuneration amounts for the period till September 2018. 2.5. Thereafter, in October 2018, the plaintiff only received partpayment, although the defendant deposited TDS on the total remuneration amount payable to the plaintiff. 2.6. From December 2018 till June 2019, the defendant did not make any payment to the plaintiff although the defendant deposited TDS on the total remuneration amount payable to the plaintiff. After June 2019 till March 2020, the defendant neither made any payment to the plaintiff nor deposited the TDS with the income tax authorities. The plaintiff has set out the details of these payments claimed in paragraph 5 of the plaint, which may be tabulated as under: S. MONTH Remuneration TDS Amount Amount paid Balance CS NO. 204/21NITIN LALI VS. CHANAKYA IAS ACADEMY Page No 2 of 8 -- 2 of 8 -- No. On Amount of the plaintiff (in rupees) deducted by the defendant no. 1 institute (in rupees) by the defendant no. 1 institute (in rupees) Amount (in rupees) 1 October, 2018 1,59,000/ 15,900/ 27,800/ 1,15,300/ 2 December, 2018 74,000/ 7400/ NIL 66,600/ 3 January, 2019 92,000/ 9200/ NIL 82,800/ 4 March, 2019 33,000/ 3,300/ NIL 29,700/ 5 April, 2019 1,47,000/ 14,700/ NIL 1,32,300/ 6 May 2019 81,000/ 8,100/ NIL 72,900/ 7 June, 2019 70,000/ 7,000/ NIL 63,000/ 8 JuneJuly 2019 74,400/ NOT PAID NIL 9 August 2019 1,07,340/ NOT PAID NIL 1,07,340/ 10 September 2019 86,880/ 1,08,240/ 54,240/ NOT PAID NIL 2,49,360/ 11 December 2019 83,100/ 51,600/ 48,000/ NOT PAID NIL 1,82,700/ 2.7. In the month of August 2019, the plaintiff had requested the General Manager of the defendant institute, i.e. Ms. Ela Siwan, in regard to his long pending dues which he had not received. On 27/08/2019, Ms. Ela Siwan admitted that the total dues of the plaintiff were Rs. 9,87,000/ as on that date and promised that the defendant would clear the payments. It was promised that the defendant would pay an amount of Rs. 50,000/ per week to the plaintiff to clar the dues. However, the defendants made only payment of 6 instalments of Rs. 50,000/ from August 2019 till November 2019, amounting to total of Rs. 3,00,000/ only. 2.8. In this manner, the plaintiff has claimed that a total remuneration of Rs. 11,76,400/ is due and pending to the plaintiff from the defendant. 2.9. On 21/05/2020, the plaintiff sent email to the General Manager of the CS NO. 204/21NITIN LALI VS. CHANAKYA IAS ACADEMY Page No 3 of 8 -- 3 of 8 -- defendant to clear his dues. On 30/12/2020, the plaintiff again sent another email. Finally, on 04/02/2021, the plaintiff sent another legal notice to the defendant through registered AD and speed post through his lawyer to clear his dues. The defendant received the legal notice on 05/02/2021. In the legal notice, the plaintiff requested the defendant to clear his dues of Rs. 11,76,400/ along with interest at the rate of 12% per annum. On 03/02/2021, the plaintiff had also emailed the scanned copy of the notice to Ms. Ela Siwan, the General Manager of the defendant. Despite service of the legal notice, the defendant failed to make payments of the due amount. 2.10. Hence, the present suit has been filed. Defendant proceeded ex parte 3. The defendant was duly served with the summons through the process server on 09/12/2021. The defendant was also duly served with the summons through Speed Post on 14/10/2021. The Speed Post receipt and tracking report is filed on the record. However, there was no appearance on behalf of the defendant. Accordingly, vide order dated 20/01/2022, the defendant was proceeded ex parte in the suit. Plaintiff’s Evidence 4. In support of his case the plaintiff has examined the following witnesses: 1) PW1, Plaintiff himself, who has tendered his affidavit in evidence Ex.PW 1/A, in which the plaintiff has reiterated on oath his case as stated in the plaint; 2) PW2 (Mr. Bedpal, Senior Associate, SBI R.K Puram) who was summoned by the plaintiff to prove the bank statements Ex. PW2/1 (Colly.); 3) PW3 (Mr. Tarun Kumar Kankhedia, Inspector in Income Tax Department office) who was summoned by the plaintiff to prove the Income Tax records Ex. PW3/1. 5. The following documents have been relied upon on behalf of the plaintiff: CS NO. 204/21NITIN LALI VS. CHANAKYA IAS ACADEMY Page No 4 of 8 -- 4 of 8 -- 1) Affidavit in evidence of PW1 Ex.PW1/A, 2) Certified copy of the Bank statement from the month of January 2017 till the month March 2021 Ex. PW1/1, 3) Copy of TDS certificate issued in favour of deponent Ex.Pw1/2 (colly), 4) Copy of email dated 23.08.2019 Ex.PW1/3, 5) Copy of email dated 10.09.2019, 15.09.2019 and 21.09.2019 Ex.PW1/4 (colly), 6) Copy of email dated 04.12.2019 and 19.12.2019 Ex. PW1/5 (colly) 7) Copy of email dated 21.05.2020 Ex.PW1/6, 8) Copy of email dated 30.12.2020 (date of email wrongly mentioned as 20.12.2020) Ex.PW1/7, 9) Copy of email dated 03.02.2021 Ex.PW1/8, 10)Copy of legal notice dated 04.02.2021 Ex.PW1/9 (colly), 11)Copy of envelope sent to Ms. Ela Siwan Ex. PW1/10, 12)Copy of tracking report Mark A, 13)Copy of whatsapp messages dated 30.03.2021 Ex. PW1/12, 14)Copy of email dated 01.04.2021 Ex.PW1/13, 15)Certificate of 65 B Indian Evidence Act dated 22.03.2022 Ex. PW1/14, and 16)Certificate of 65 B Indian Evidence Act filed on 03.04.2021 Ex.PW115. Discussion 6. I have heard the learned counsel for the plaintiff and I have perused the record. 7. Despite being served with the summons, the defendant has not entered appearance in the suit and has not filed any written statement. As such, the defendant has no defence in the suit. The defendant has been proceeded ex parte. There is no crossexamination by the defendant of the plaintiff’s witnesses. The defendant has also not led any evidence. As such, the plaintiff’s evidence is uncontroverted and unrebutted. 8. In his affidavit in evidence PW1/A, the plaintiff has reiterated on oath his case as pleaded in the plaint. The plaintiff has stated in his affidavit in evidence PW1/A as follows: The plaintiff rendered services to the defendant and took the classes as faculty from January 2017 till 12/03/2020 when coaching institutes were closed due to the national lockdown due to the Covid19 pandemic. The plaintiff has further stated in his affidavit in evidence PW1/A that the plaintiff received the complete remuneration amounts for the period till September 2018. Thereafter, in October CS NO. 204/21NITIN LALI VS. CHANAKYA IAS ACADEMY Page No 5 of 8 -- 5 of 8 -- 2018, the plaintiff only received partpayment, although the defendant deposited TDS on the total remuneration amount payable to the plaintiff. From December 2018 till June 2019, the defendant did not make any payment to the plaintiff although the defendant deposited TDS on the total remuneration amount payable to the plaintiff. After June 2019 till March 2020, the defendant neither made any payment to the plaintiff nor deposited the TDS with the income tax authorities. In the month of August 2019, the plaintiff had requested the General Manager of the defendant institute, i.e. Ms. Ela Siwan, in regard to his long pending dues which he had not received. On 27/08/2019, Ms. Ela Siwan admitted that the total dues of the plaintiff were Rs. 9,87,000/ as on that date and promised that the defendant would clear the payments. It was promised that the defendant would pay an amount of Rs. 50,000/ per week to the plaintiff to clar the dues. However, the defendants made only payment of 6 instalments of Rs. 50,000/ from August 2019 till November 2019, amounting to total of Rs. 3,00,000/ only. In this manner, the plaintiff has claimed that a total remuneration of Rs. 11,76,400/ is due and pending to the plaintiff from the defendant. On 21/05/2020, the plaintiff sent email to the General Manager of the defendant to clear his dues. On 30/12/2020, the plaintiff again sent another email. Finally, on 04/02/2021, the plaintiff sent another legal notice Ex.PW1/9 (colly) to the defendant through registered AD and speed post through his lawyer to clear his dues. The defendant received the legal notice on 05/02/2021. In the legal notice, the plaintiff requested the defendant to clear his dues of Rs. 11,76,400/ along with interest at the rate of 12% per annum. On 03/02/2021, the plaintiff had also emailed the scanned copy of the notice to Ms. Ela Siwan, the General Manager of the defendant. Despite service of the legal notice, the defendant failed to make payments of the due amount. 9. The evidence of the plaintiff through his affidavit in evidence PW1/A is uncontroverted and unrebutted. The Plaintiff has relied upon the Income Tax records Ex.PW3/1, which proves that the TDS has been deducted by the defendant for the period from October 2018 till June 2019. The plaintiff has relied upon his bank statements Ex.PW2/1, which proves that during the period from October 2018 to June 2019, the amount of remuneration received from the CS NO. 204/21NITIN LALI VS. CHANAKYA IAS ACADEMY Page No 6 of 8 -- 6 of 8 -- defendant was deficit as compared to the TDS which had been deducted. Thus, from the bank statements and the Income tax records, the plaintiff has been able to prove that although the TDS was deposited with the income tax authority for the period October 2018 to June 2019, however, the corresponding remuneration was not credited to the bank account of the plaintiff. The plaintiff has also proved through the Emails of September 2019 from the defendant Ex.PW1/4 (Colly) and the Emails of December 2019 from the defendant Ex.PW1/5 (Colly) that the plaintiff was given duties to be performed even post August 2019. 10. It is well settled in a civil case the standard of proof is on a balance of probabilities, as held by the honourable High Court of Delhi in S.C. Parashar v. Union of India 2014 SCC OnLine Del 7691 : (2015) 148 DRJ 125 (DB) : (2015) 217 DLT 283 (DB) as under: “23. It is a settled legal position that preponderance of the evidence, also known as balance of probabilities is the standard of proof required in most civil cases, unlike criminal cases where the prosecution is required to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt. The standard is met if the proposition is more likely to be true than untrue. Effectively, when there is a chance greater than 50 percent for the proposition to be true. (Ref. Lord Denning, in Miller v. Minister of Pensions 1947 (2) All ER 372). … …” 11. Upon consideration of the evidence led by the plaintiff, I hold that, on a balance of probabilities, the plaintiff has been able to prove his case. Thus, I hold that the plaintiff is entitled to decree against the defendant for sum of Rs. 11,76,400/. Further, the plaintiff shall be entitled to interest on the sum of Rs. 11,76,400/ @ 9% p.a. for the period from 04/02/2021 i.e. the date of the legal notice till the date of realisation which includes the pendente lite and future interest. Relief 12. Accordingly, decree is passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant for sum of Rs. 11,76,400/, along with interest @ 9% p.a. for the period from CS NO. 204/21NITIN LALI VS. CHANAKYA IAS ACADEMY Page No 7 of 8 -- 7 of 8 -- 04/02/2021 till the date of realisation which includes the pendente lite and future interest. 13. Costs are decreed in favour of the plaintiff. Decree sheet be drawn up accordingly. File be consigned to record room. (SATYABRATA PANDA) Additional District Judge04 Judge Code DL01057 PHC/New Delhi/20.08.2022 CS NO. 204/21NITIN LALI VS. CHANAKYA IAS ACADEMY Page No 8 of 8 -- 8 of 8 --
