Full Order Text
Order 2 · 26 Mar 2024 · CNR DLND010025662024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: Cr Rev 180/2024 ARAKKAL PANDIKASALAKKAL ABDUL KAREEM & Ors. VS. SARENS HEAVY LIFT INDIA PVT. LTD. 26.03.2024 Present: Sh. Lakshya Dhamija alongwith Sh. Sunav Rastogi, Ld. Counsels for petitioners. The summons sent to the respondent on its Okhla address received back with the report that the concerned company has left the address. It is submitted by the counsel for petitioners that it is the same address given by the respondent / complainant in the complaint case. It is submitted that the matter is listed before the ld. MM on 27.03.2024, he be given liberty to serve the respondent before the concerned MM. The liberty prayed for is granted accordingly. It is submitted by the ld. counsel for petitioners that the summoning order dated 08.12.2023 whereby the ld. MM has summoned all the three petitioners for the offence under S. 138 NI Act be stayed as the complaint perse is defective and not maintainable. It is submitted that on perusal of the complaint, it is evident that the same has been filed against ‘M/S Hajee AP Bava and Company Constructions Pvt. Ltd.’ and its Directors. It is further submitted that in the complaint, the respondent has filed the work order dated 28.05.2022 which has been issued by ...contd. -- 1 of 3 -- --2-- ‘Hajee AP Bava and Co.’ and as per clause 19 of the said work order, the billing address is stated as ‘Hajee AP Bava and Co.’, which is a proprietorship concern of Sh. Abdul Kareem AP. That below the said billing address, GST Number is given, which is also of the proprietorship concern and not of the company. It is submitted that even the Tax Invoices are in the name of ‘Hajee AP Bava and Co.’ and not in the name of ‘M/S Hajee AP Bava and Company Constructions Pvt. Ltd’. It is submitted that despite the fact that the work order was placed by ‘Hajee AP Bava and Co.’, the proprietorship firm, the respondent has made the company (which is some other independent entity) as an accused and its Directors as remaining accused persons. It is submitted that the ld. MM had summoned accused no. 2, 4 and 6 being the Directors and authorized signatory of ‘M/S Hajee AP Bava and Company Constructions Pvt. Ltd’. It is submitted that the complaint itself is defective as the transaction, if any, was between respondent and ‘Hajee AP Bava and Co.’ and not ‘M/S Hajee AP Bava and Company Constructions Pvt. Ltd’. It is submitted that the cheque in question has also been issued by the firm and not the company. It does not bear the signature of ...contd. -- 2 of 3 -- --3-- accused no. 2 / petitioner no.1. As regards the signature of two other persons on the cheque is concerned, they are only signatories to the cheque of the sole proprietorship firm. I have perused the complete revision file and the documents relied upon by the counsel for petitioners i.e. the work order, tax invoices, GST number of the firm and the cheque in question. The work order is on the letter head of ‘Hajee AP Bava and Co.’. Even the Tax Invoices has the customer details as ‘Hajee AP Bava and Co.’ The same is shown to be a proprietorship concern. The present complaint needs deeper analysis. Let the TCR be summoned two days prior to the NDOH. Issue fresh notice of the present petition to the respondent on filing of PF/RC as well as through all the electronic modes for 02.05.2024. Summons be given dasti also. The proceedings before ld. MM are stayed till NDOH. Copy of the order be given dasti as prayed for. (KIRAN GUPTA) Addl. Sessions Judge-04 Patiala House Courts New Delhi/26.03.2024 -- 3 of 3 --
