Full Order Text
Final Order 4 · 29 May 2025 · CNR DLND010014622025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: 1 CR REV 120/2025 BPTP LTD. AND ORS. VS. STATE NCT OF DELHI 29.05.2025 Present: Sh. Subhash Gulati and Pankaj Yadav, Ld. Counsels for the petitioners. Sh. Himanshu Garg, Ld. Substitute Addl. PP for the State / R-1. Sh. Shivek Trehan and Ms. Riya Nair, Ld. Counsels for R-2 and R-3. TCR received. Heard detailed arguments on behalf of stakeholders. Put up for orders. ORDER 1. The present revision is against the order dated 01.03.2025 passed by Ld JMFC-01 in CC No. 59018/2024. Vide said order, Ld JMFC has allowed the application of the respondent no. 2 and 3 u/s 175 (3) BNSS and directed the BPTP LTD. AND ORS. Vs. STATE NCT OF DELHI Page No. 1 of 10 -- 1 of 10 -- 2 concerned SHO to lodge FIR against the petitioners u/s 316 (2)/318 (4) and 61 (2) of BNS. 2. It is submitted by Ld counsel for petitioners that the Ld JMFC has passed the order dated 01.03.2025 without appreciation of the facts and that the dispute is pertaining to the property which is purely civil in nature. It is submitted that the matter seeking refund of invested amount along with interest is already subjudice before Hon’ble NCDRC. It is submitted that R2 and R3 filed parallel proceedings before NCDRC, Haryana RERA and NCLT seeking refund of the amount which they had paid towards the booking of flat in question. They had never demanded possession of the flat in question. Vide order dated 15.03.2023 passed by NCDRC, the petitioners gave the proposal that the refund shall be made in terms of batch matters as per judgment in Virender Kumar Kataria Vs M/s BPTP Ltd & Anr. Pursuant to the said proposal, R2 and R3 got issued one notice dated 24.03.2024 seeking refund of the amount with interest. On 11.04.2023, the counsel for petitioners handed over the cheques to the counsel for R2 and R3 which were consequently found to have been handed over to the wrong counsel. Thereafter on BPTP LTD. AND ORS. Vs. STATE NCT OF DELHI Page No. 2 of 10 -- 2 of 10 -- 3 20.04.2023, the petitioners again issued fresh cheques/DDs to R2 and R3, which they deliberately did not present as there was dispute regarding the rate and nature of interest. It is submitted that R2 and R3 always insisted on refund of the amount and never endeavored to take possession of the flat in question. It is submitted that it is only when R2 and R3 agreed for refund of the amount and wrote e-mail to this effect, the petitioners sold the flat in question to third party in view of clause 7 of the agreement executed between the parties. It is submitted that there was and is a dispute regarding the quantum of interest to be paid on the refund amount,which is civil in nature, however, R2 and R3 had filed the complaint case giving it the colour of criminal case. The flat in question was sold only after R2 and R3 agreed for refund. It is submitted that Ld JMFC failed to appreciate that dispute is purely civil in nature. It is prayed that order dated 01.03.2025 be set aside. 3. Per contra, it is submitted by Ld. Counsel for the respondent there is no infirmity in the order dated 01.03.2025. It is submitted that R2 and R3 had booked the flat in question with the petitioners in 2012. After payment of certain amount, they BPTP LTD. AND ORS. Vs. STATE NCT OF DELHI Page No. 3 of 10 -- 3 of 10 -- 4 entered into tripartite agreement with the petitioners and HDFC bank and took loan on the flat in question. Out of the total sale consideration amount, 95% of the amount has already been paid to the petitioners. The delivery of the flat was to be made in 2017 but when the flat was not delivered on time, R2 and R3 were constrained to approach NCDRC and other forums. It is submitted that R2 and R3 sought refund of the amount alongwith interest, however, the said matter is still subjudice before NCDRC. Though the petitioners had proposed for some settlement, however, the matter could not be settled. It is submitted that as per order dated 10.05.2023 passed by NCDRC, it is specifically noted that the matter could not be settled. It is submitted that the petitioners had already entered into agreement to sell with the third party on 09.05.2023, but, they did not disclose the same before NCDRC on 10.05.2023. They entered into the said agreement without informing the bank and R2 and R3. They executed the sale deed on 14.06.2023 without the information and consent of R2 and R3 and never disclosed about the said sale deed to them. It is only when R2 and R3 visited the flat in question on 08.07.2024, they came to know that the same has been sold to some third party. It is submitted that as per BPTP LTD. AND ORS. Vs. STATE NCT OF DELHI Page No. 4 of 10 -- 4 of 10 -- 5 clause 7 of the agreement, the petitioners had to first terminate the contract and intimate about the termination and then only they can sell the flat. It is prayed that the present revision petition be dismissed. 4. Heard all the stakeholders. Perused the revision file, the documents relied upon by the counsels for R2 and R3 and Trial Court Record. 5. Brief facts of the case are that R-2 and R-3 had entered into a flat buyer agreement dated 17.01.2013 for the purchase of a flat bearing no. T-25/303 in a residential project of BPTP Ltd/petitioner no. 1 company in Sector -37D, Gurugram, Haryana. The agreement was followed by an addendum agreement on 10.07.2013. The total sale consideration for the purchase of the flat was fixed at Rs 13416121. The complainant/R-2 and R-3 paid initial booking amount of Rs 7 lacs on 30.07.2012 and additional amount of Rs 1709057/- on 01.11.2012 and also availed loan for payment of the balance amount. The entire loan amount was transferred directly to the builder/petitioner no. 1 as per the tripartite agreement dated BPTP LTD. AND ORS. Vs. STATE NCT OF DELHI Page No. 5 of 10 -- 5 of 10 -- 6 17.02.2013. When the builder/Petitioner no. 1 failed to deliver timely possession, R-2 and R3 approached various forums for amicable resolution by way of refund of the consideration amount with interest, however, the matter could not be settled or resolved. It is alleged that on 08.07.2024 when R2 and R3 visited the project site, they found that the flat which was alloted to them has been sold to a third person without their knowledge and consent. Hence, they lodged the complaint with the police and consequently complaint case before Ld JMFC along with the application for registration of FIR. Ld JMFC vide order dated 01.03.2025 allowed the application of R2 and R3 u/s 175 (3) BNSS and gave the directions to concerned SHO for registration of FIR against the petitioners, hence the present revision petition. 6. In the present case, there is no dispute to the fact that the parties are litigating for refund of the amount of the flat in question before various forums. Their had been offers and counter offers about the amount of interest to be paid on the refund amount. From the order dated 15.03.2023 of NCDRC, it is evident that petitioners had proposed for refund of amount along with interest in terms of order dated 04.01.2023 passed in BPTP LTD. AND ORS. Vs. STATE NCT OF DELHI Page No. 6 of 10 -- 6 of 10 -- 7 CC/3023/2017 Virender Kumar Kataria Vs M/s BPTP Ltd & Anr and other connected matters within the same period. Pursuant to the said order, counsel for R2 and R3 had issued the notice dated 24.03.2023 claiming the refund of amount with interest. There is no dispute to the fact that the petitioners had got prepared the cheques/DDs for refund of the amount, however, the dispute regarding rate of interest remained pending between the parties. Admittedly, in the claim filed by R2 and R3 before NCDRC, they have sought refund of the amount with interest. There is no prayer for handing over the possession of the flat in question. 7. Ld counsel for petitioners had rightly pointed out that since R2 and R3 had always filed petitions/claims for refund of the amount and consequent to the proposal exchanged between them, they got prepared the demand drafts and handed over the demand drafts; it is only pursuant to the talks of settlement that since R2 and R3 wanted termination of the contract, they sold the flat in question in terms of clause 7 of agreement entered between the parties. It is submitted that the petitioners are still ready to refund the amount, however, it is R2 and R3 who are not BPTP LTD. AND ORS. Vs. STATE NCT OF DELHI Page No. 7 of 10 -- 7 of 10 -- 8 willing to take the refund and have converted the civil dispute into criminal proceedings. 8. In Hridaya Ranjan Prasad Verma & Ors. v. State of Bihar & Anr. AIR 2000 SC 2341, the Supreme Court outlined the distinction between breach of contract and the offence of cheating in the following terms:- "15... That the distinction between mere breach of contract and the offence of cheating is a fine one. It depends upon the intention of the accused at the time to inducement which may be judged by his subsequent conduct but for this subsequent conduct is not the sole test. Mere breach of contract cannot give rise to criminal prosecution for cheating unless fraudulent or dishonest intention is shown right at the beginning of the transaction, that is the time when the offence is said to have been committed. Therefore it is the intention which is the gist of the offence. To hold a person guilty of cheating it is necessary to show that he had fraudulent or dishonest intention at the time of making the promise. From his mere failure to keep up promise subsequently such a culpable intention right at the beginning, that is, when he made the promise cannot be presumed.” BPTP LTD. AND ORS. Vs. STATE NCT OF DELHI Page No. 8 of 10 -- 8 of 10 -- 9 9. In Sarabjit Kaur v. State of Punjab & Anr, Criminal Appeal No. 581 of 2023 the Supreme Court has again emphasized that a breach of contract does not give rise to criminal prosecution for cheating, unless fraudulent or dishonest intention can be shown to have existed right at the beginning of the transaction. Mere allegation of failure to keep the promise will not be enough to initiate criminal proceedings. It was further observed that criminal proceedings are not meant to be used for settling scores or to pressurize parties to settle civil disputes. In the said case, observing that the FIR came to be registered three years after the last date fixed for execution of the sale deed, the proceedings were quashed terming the same as an abuse of process of the Court. 10. To a similar extent are the observations of the Supreme Court in Usha Chakraborty & Anr. v. State of West Bengal & Anr. 2023 INSC 86 and Naresh Kumar & Anr. v. State of Karnataka & Anr. 2024 INSC 196. 11. From the contents of the complaint and in view of the above discussion, it is evident that the dispute between the BPTP LTD. AND ORS. Vs. STATE NCT OF DELHI Page No. 9 of 10 -- 9 of 10 -- 10 parties had been for refund of the amount and about the rate of interest, which is purely civil in nature. It is well settled law that the courts should refrain from ordering registration of FIR for disputes that are purely civil in nature. Criminal law should not be used as a tool to settle civil disputes. In view of above discussion, the order of Ld JMFC dated 01.03.2025 is set aside. Present revision is allowed. TCR be sent back to concerned court along with the copy of this order. Revision file be consigned to Record room. (KIRAN GUPTA) Addl. Sessions Judge-04 Patiala House Court New Delhi/29.05.2025 BPTP LTD. AND ORS. Vs. STATE NCT OF DELHI Page No. 10 of 10 -- 10 of 10 --
