Full Order Text
Final Order 2 · 22 Mar 2024 · CNR DLND010013992024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. PAWAN KUMAR, LD. ASJ/SPL/FTC/PHC/NEW DELHI REVISION PETITION NO. 125/2024 CNR No. DLND01- IN THE MATTER OF: Vijay Vaid Proprietor of M/s. Vijay Vaid & Associates A-75, First Floor, Ramprastha, Ghaziabad, U.P.- 201010. ..…..Revisionists Versus M/s Surya Roshini Ltd. Corporate Office At: Padma Tower-I, Rajendra Place, New Delhi-110008. ……..Respondent Instituted on : 23.02.2024 Pronounced on : 22.03.2023 JUDGMENT 1. Vide this judgment, I shall dispose of the present petiion filed by the revisionist/accused Vijay Vaid assailing the order dated 02.11.2023, whereby Ld Metropolitan Magistrate-05 (NI Act), New Delhi, has dismissed the application of the revisionist under Sectino 91 Cr.P.C., in case bearing CC No. 36731/16 titled as Surya Roshini Ltd. v. Vijay Vaid, filed under section 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act (hereinafter Crl Rev. No. 125/2024 Vijay Vaid v. Surya Roshini Ltd Page No. 1 of 7 -- 1 of 7 -- referred to as 'NI Act'). 2. Brief facts may be taken note of : A complaint alleging commission of offence under section 138 NI Act was filed by the respondent against the revisionist on 15.10.2015 and the matter is pending before the Ld. Trial Court at the stage of clarification/order. During the trial, the Ld. Trial Court dismissed an application under Section 315 Cr.P.C. for summoning of certain documents vide order dated 07.05.2022. Vide impugned order, the Ld. Trial Court dismissed the application of the revisionist seeking summoning of similar documents under Section 91 Cr.P.C. 3. Vide impugned order dated 02.11.2023, Ld Trial Court dismissed the application of the revisionist moved under Section 91 Cr.P.C. The relevant observation of said order of Ld Trial Court is reproduced below :- “Vide present order, the undersigned is disposing the application of accused under Section 91 Cr.P.C. It is suffice to note that earlier the application of accused under Section 315 Cr.P.C. seeking similar such documents was already dismissed on 07.05.2022 as being devoid of merits. It is clear that the accused somehow wants to delay the present matter by filing the present application as the accused seeks to engage in a roving and fishing inquiry into the case of the complainant when the cross examination of complainant has already been completed. The DE of accused has already been closed on 04.08.2022 vide separate statement of accused in this regard. Accordingly, there is no merit in the present application and same is hereby dismissed. Put up for final arguments on 04.12.2023 at 2:15 pm.” Crl Rev. No. 125/2024 Vijay Vaid v. Surya Roshini Ltd Page No. 2 of 7 -- 2 of 7 -- 4. The revisionist is aggrieved with the said order and has assailed the impugned order on various grounds which can be summarized as under:- (i) That the Ld. Trial Court has not applied its judicial mind and dismissed the application of the revisionist without appreciating the facts merely on the ground that the similar application under Section 315 Cr.P.C. has already been dismissed vide order dated 07.05.2022 (ii) That the Ld Trial Court has failed to appreciate the fact that application under Section 91 Cr.P.C. was moved in consequent upon the dismissal of his application under Section 315 Cr.P.C.; (iii) That Ld Trial Court has passed a cryptic and mechanical order without application of mind; (iv) That Ld Trial Court failed to appreciate the fact that the documents sought by the revisionist in his application under Section 91 Cr.P.C. are of utmost importance for the just and proper adjudication of this case; 5. At the outset, Ld counsel for revisionist was requested to satisfy about the maintainability of present petition. The Ld. Counsel for the respondent raised question as to the maintainability of the present revision petition being the impugned order interlocatory one. It was forcefully argued by Ld counsel for revisionist that the impugned order is not 'interlocutory' in nature and therefore, petition is very much maintainable Crl Rev. No. 125/2024 Vijay Vaid v. Surya Roshini Ltd Page No. 3 of 7 -- 3 of 7 -- in the eyes of law. It is argued that the term 'interlocutory' should be interpretated in the liberal manner. 6. I have heard contentions and perused the record. 7. The first question to be decided by this Court is whether the present revision petition is maintainable in view of the bar created by provisions of Section 397(2) CrPC. Here, it will be relevant to reproduce relevant portion of Section 397 CrPC which is as under:- “Sec.397- Calling for records to exercise powers of revision.- (I) The High Court or any Sessions Judge may call for and examine the record of any proceeding before any inferior Criminal Court situate within its or his local jurisdiction for the purpose of satisfying itself or himself as to the correctness, legality or propriety of any finding, sentence or order, recorded or passed, and as to the regularity of any proceedings of such inferior court, and may, when calling for such record, direct that the execution of any sentence or order be suspended, and if the accused is in confinement, that he be released on bail or on his own bond pending the examination of the record. Explanation ................ (2) The powers of revision conferred by sub- section (1) shall not be exercised in relation to any interlocutory order passed in any appeal, inquiry, trial or other proceeding. (3) ..............” 8. In the judgment Amar Nath & Ors. V. State of Haryana & Another, (1977) 4 Supreme Court Cases 137, the Hon'ble Supreme Court while interpreting “Interlocutory order” has observed:- “It seems to us that the term “interlocutory order” in Section 397(2) of the 1973 Code has been used in a restricted sense and not in any broad or artistic sense. It merely denotes orders of a purely interim or temporary nature which do not decide or touch the important rights or the liabilities of the Crl Rev. No. 125/2024 Vijay Vaid v. Surya Roshini Ltd Page No. 4 of 7 -- 4 of 7 -- parties. Any order which substantially affects the right of the accused, or decided certain rights of the parties cannot be said to be an interlocutory order so as to bar a revision to the High Court against that order, because that would be against the very object which formed the basis for insertion of this particular provision in Section 397 of the 1973 Code. Thus, for instance, orders summoning witnesses, adjourning cases, passing orders for bail, calling for reports and such other steps in aid of the pending proceeding, may no doubt amount to interlocutory orders against which no revision would lie under Section 397(2) of the 1973 Code.” 09. In the judgment of Neelam Mahajan & another Vs. The State & Ors. dated 08.04.2016, Hon'ble Delhi High Court has observed as under:- “Applying these tests to the impugned order, this Court finds that the order permitting the re-examination of the petitioners is purely an interlocutory order as it does not terminate the proceedings but the trial goes on until it culminates in acquittal or conviction. Furthermore, it is impossible to spell out the concept of an interlocutory order unless it is understood in contradistinction to or in contrast with a final order.” 10. Further, in the judgment of Varun Aggarwal Vs. State of NCT of Delhi & Anr., Crl.M.C. No. 2424/2017, Hon'ble Delhi High Court after referring the judgment passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court in “Amar Nath & Ors. V. State of Haryana & Another” observed that the order passed by Ld. MM closing the right of complainant to examine Forensic Expert was held to be interlocutory order and consequently revision was held to be not maintainable. 11. Similarly, in the judgment of Sethuraman Vs. Raja Manickam, (2009) 5 SCC 153, the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that the order Crl Rev. No. 125/2024 Vijay Vaid v. Surya Roshini Ltd Page No. 5 of 7 -- 5 of 7 -- refusing to call the documents and rejecting application U/S 311 CrPC are interlocutory orders and as such, revision against these orders are clearly barred U/s 397(2) CrPC. The relevant observations of the Apex Court in this case are as follows: “ Secondly, what was not realized was that the order passed by the Trial Court refusing to call the documents and rejecting the application under Section 311 Cr.P.C., were interlocutory orders and as such, the revision against those orders was clearly barred under Section 397(2) Cr.P.C. The Trial Court, in its common order, had clearly mentioned that the cheque was admittedly signed by the respondent/accused and the only defence that was raised, was that his signed cheques were lost and that the appellant/complainant had falsely used one such cheque. The Trial Court also recorded a finding that the documents were not necessary. This order did not, in any manner, decide anything finally. Therefore, both the orders, i.e., one on the application under Section 91 Cr.P.C. for production of documents and other on the application under Section 311 Cr.P.C. for recalling the witness, were the orders of interlocutory nature, in which case, under Section 397(2), revision was clearly not maintainable. Under such circumstances, the learned Judge could not have interfered in his revisional jurisdiction. The impugned judgment is clearly incorrect in law and would have to be set aside. It is accordingly set aside. The appeals are allowed. ’ 12. Now turning to the facts of the present case: Ld. Trial Court vide impugned order, dismissed the application of the revisionist moved under Section 91 Cr.P.C. It is pertinent to note that the Ld. Trial Court had already dismissed one application of the revisionist seeking similar prayer vide order dated 07.05.2022. The impugned order does not terminate the proceedings. It is clear that impugned order closed the opportunity to seek production of certain documents after the closure the defence evidence. In Crl Rev. No. 125/2024 Vijay Vaid v. Surya Roshini Ltd Page No. 6 of 7 -- 6 of 7 -- the impugned order, it is mentioned that DE of the accused has already been closed vide separate statement of the accused on 04.08.2022. The impugned order is merely a procedural order and therefore, is an interlocutory order and hence, the present revision petition is not maintainable and is liable to be dismissed in view of bar created by Section 397 (2) CrPC. Accordingly, the present revision petition is liable to be dismissed being non-maintainable. 13. Even on merit, it is evident from record that despite dismissing the application of the revisionist seeking similar prayer, he filed another application seeking the production of similar documents under separate provision of law. The Ld. Trial Court has rightly dismissed the application as the same was already dismissed. I found no patent illegality or irregularity in the impugned order. 14. With these observations, present revision petition stands dismissed. 15. TCR be sent back to the Ld. Trial court along with copy of this judgment. 16. Revision file be consigned to Record Room after due compliance. Announced in Open Court, On 22nd March, 2024. (Pawan Kumar) ASJ /Spl. FTC / PHC / NDD New Delhi/22.03.2024 Crl Rev. No. 125/2024 Vijay Vaid v. Surya Roshini Ltd Page No. 7 of 7 -- 7 of 7 --
