Full Order Text
Interim Order 6 · 27 Nov 2025 · CNR DLND010013542024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: HTA 2/24, HTA 3/24, HTA 4/24, HTA 5/24, HTA 6/24, HTA 7/24, HTA 8/24, HTA 9/24, HTA 10/24, HTA 11/24, HTA 12/24, HTA 13/24, HTA 14/24, HTA 15/24, HTA 16/24, HTA 17/24, HTA 18/24 Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited Vs. New Delhi Municipal Council 27.11.2025 Present: Sh. Anil Kumar Batra, Ms. Shashi Bala and Sh. Dhruv Kumar, Ld. Counsel for Appellant. Sh. Jasmin Singh Sethi, Sr. Municipal Counsel and Sh. Yougansh Mittal, Ld. Counsel for Respondent. Arguments on the delay condonation application heard. Put up for orders at 04:00 p.m. (Dharmender Rana) District Judge – 01 PHC/New Delhi/27.11.2025 At 04:00 p.m. Present: None. 1. By way of the instant order, I propose to dispose of a delay condonation application moved on behalf of appellant under Section 117 of NDMC Act, 1994, seeking condonation of delay in filing of the instant appeal. 2. The appellant herein has assailed the order dated 22.03.2018 passed by the respondent under Section 72 of NDMC Act, 1994. -- 1 of 5 -- 3. Counsel for the appellant submits that the very foundation of the impugned assessment order was erroneous as premises in question was reflected to be an open plot whereas infact the appellant is running a petrol retail outlet in the premises qua which the assessment order was passed. It is submitted that in order to seek rectification of the said inadvertent error by the respondent, based upon the assurances given by the officials of the respondent, the appellant has approached the respondent under Section 72 (f) of the NDMC Act by filing representation/ objections dated 20.04.2018. It is submitted that instead of rectifying its own mistakes, the respondent continued raising bills on annual basis whereupon successive representations were made by the appellant on 14.07.2018, 11.09.2018, 20.11.2019, 08.02.2021, 10.03.2021, 20.07.2021, 22.11.2021, 27.09.2022, 15.11.2022, 14.06.2023 and 21.11.2023. It is argued that instead of rectifying the mistakes, the respondent evidently issued a Distress Notice on 25.10.2023, pursuant to which the appellant again filed representation dated 21.11.2023. It is submitted that since the respondent failed to take notice of the above-quoted representations, the appellant was constrained to approach the Hon’ble Delhi High Court by filing WP No. 88/2024, which was ultimately disposed of by the Hon’ble Delhi High Court directing the appellant to avail his statutory remedies by instituting an appeal. It is submitted that the delay in the instant matter needs to be condoned for advancement of substantial cause of justice. It is submitted that the appeal could not be filed well within time as appellant was under a bonafide impression that the respondent would rectify its mistakes committed on the administrative side and there would -- 2 of 5 -- not be any requirement for unnecessarily burdening the dockets of the Court. It is further pointed out that neither in the impugned order nor in the Distress Notice dated 25.10.2023, there is any mention of objections dated 30.04.2007 to the notice dated 29.03.2007 filed by the appellant. It is further pointed out that the notices mentioned in the impugned order i.e. dated 31.03.2006 and 31.03.2007 were never served upon the appellant herein. Appellant has placed strong reliance upon the judgment passed by Hon’ble Apex Court passed in the matter of Raheem Shah & Ors Vs. Govind Singh & Ors, MANU/SC/0829/2023. 4. On the contrary, counsel for the respondent has forcefully argued that while disposing of the application for delay condonation, the Courts cannot enter into the merits of the case. It is forcefully argued that it is incumbent upon the appellant to furnish ‘sufficient cause’ explaining the delay. It is submitted that leave aside any sufficient cause, there is no explanation rendered by the appellant, so much so that not even the period which is sought to be condoned, has been specified by the appellant. It is submitted that mere moving of objections shall not rekindle the cause of action and set the clock of limitation back to naught. It is argued that the objections, seeking rectification of any error under Section 72 (f) of NDMC Act, would tantamount to review of the impugned order but that shall not extend the limitation period. It is further argued that appellant herein is a responsible Public Sector Unit with a robust legal team and thus the benefits available to an ordinary naive litigant cannot be claimed by the appellant herein. It is further submitted that except for bare assertions, there is no proof of objections/ -- 3 of 5 -- representations filed by the appellant herein and the appeal is hopelessly time barred and thus deserves to be dismissed. 5. I have heard the rival submissions and carefully perused the record. 6. Section 117 of the NDMC Act empowers the Court to condone the delay in filing of the appeal if the appellant is able to satisfy the Court that he had ‘sufficient cause’ for not filing the appeal within stipulated time period. The word ‘sufficient cause’ is not required to be defined with scientific precision and mathematical exactitude. Sufficient cause is to be liberally construed for advancement of cause of justice. I am fortified in my opinion with the judgment of Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the matter of M/s J.K. Tyre And Industries Ltd. Vs. New Delhi Municipal Council, W.P. (C) 1408/2025, dated 11.02.2025, wherein under identical circumstances, while condoning the delay of about 7 long years, the Hon’ble Delhi High Court has observed here as under:- “17. ….. The question that arises for consideration is whether petitioner is deserving of condonation of delay in filing the appeal so that it is able to avail its statutory remedy against the assessment order passed 16 years after the notice under Section 72 of the NDMC Act. 20. Coming to the present case, it cannot be held that petitioner was not vigilantly prosecuting its cause. Writ petition was filed in 2003 challenging the assessment and demand of property tax which was disposed of on 08.02.2012. Petitioner followed up the matter with NDMC to implement the order and pass a speaking order and to assess the property tax afresh. The assessment order was passed only on 28.09.2017 and the demand notice was issued on 12.10.2023. Petitioner again assailed the assessment order and the demand notice by filing W.P. (C) 489/2024, which is disposed of on 15.01.2024 as an alternate statutory remedy of appeal was available and liberty was granted to the -- 4 of 5 -- petitioner to avail of the same. As noted above, petitioner has challenged the assessment order on two legal issues, which may go to the root of the matter and therefore, there is merit in the contention of the petitioner that having a good case on merit, petitioner should not be thrown as a baby out of the bathwater. As held by the Supreme Court, justice oriented approach must be prioritized over technicalities and the expression ‘sufficient cause’ should be given liberal construction to advance substantive justice, especially when an applicant has a good case on merit, which the petitioner contends it does.” 7. Admittedly, in the instant case the appellant has been consistently pursuing its remedy under Section 72 (f) of NDMC Act. Clause (2) of Section 72 of NDMC Act makes it mandatory for the Chairperson, NDMC to consider the objections made by any person. In the case at hand, the respondent has failed to consider the objections/ representations made by the appellant to the respondent. If the appellant is to be blamed for some lethargy, the respondent is equally guilty of disdainful indolence. In my considered opinion, dismissing the case of the appellant on mere technicalities, shall tantamount to travesty of justice. 8. Considering the totality of circumstances, application for condonation of delay stands allowed. Delay in filing the instant appeal stands condoned. 9. List for arguments on merits in the matter on 10.12.2025. (Dharmender Rana) District Judge – 01 PHC/New Delhi/27.11.2025 -- 5 of 5 --
