Full Order Text
Final Order 28 · 06 Aug 2022 · CNR DLND010001642021
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MR. DHARMESH SHARMA
PRINCIPAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE : NEW DELHI
PATIALA HOUSE COURTS : NEW DELHI
In Re:
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021
CNR No. DLND010001692021
Smt. Pooja Singh & Ors. v. The State & Ors.
AND
Criminal Revision No. 16/2021
CNR No. DLND010001712021
Ashok Kumar Bedi v. The State & Ors.
AND
Criminal Revision No. 17/2021
CNR No. DLND010001742021
Jagdeep Shokeen v. The State & Ors.
AND
Criminal Revision No. 18/2021
CNR No. DLND010001752021
Karan Juneja v. The State & Ors.
AND
Criminal Revision No. 19/2021
CNR No. DLND010001732021
Amit Jain v. The State & Ors.
AND
Criminal Revision No. 20/2021
CNR No. DLND010001662021
Sanjay Soni v. The State & Ors.
AND
Criminal Revision No. 21/2021
CNR No. DLND010001672021
Sushil Chandra Baluni v. The State & Ors.
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 1 of 22
-- 1 of 22 --
AND
Criminal Revision No. 22/2021
CNR No. DLND010001682021
Rawat S. Yadav v. The State & Ors.
AND
Criminal Revision No. 23/2021
CNR No. DLND010001632021
Smt. Shipra Madan v. The State & Ors.
AND
Criminal Revision No. 24/2021
CNR No. DLND010001652021
Naresh Garg v. The State & Ors.
AND
Criminal Revision No. 25/2021
CNR No. DLND010001642021
Vishal Kapoor v. The State & Ors.
AND
Criminal Revision No. 26/2021
CNR No. DLND010001872021
Tarun Nangia v. The State & Ors.
Date of Institution : 08.01.2021
Date of hearing arguments : 23.07.2022
Date of order : 06.08.2022
Appearances:
Ms. Jaya Goyal and Ms. Manpreet Kaur, Advocates for the petitioner
revisionist.
Sh. Ravinder Khandelwal, Addl. PP for the State/R1.
Sh. Manish Sharma, Sh. Ninad Dogra, Ms. Jigyasa Sharma and Sh.
Rahul Dhaiya, Advocates for the respondentBPTP.
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 2 of 22
-- 2 of 22 --
ORDER:
1. This common order shall decide above noted 12 Criminal
Revisions filed under Section 379 read with Section 399 of Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973, which are assailing impugned order dated
23.02.2022 passed by Ms. Pragati, Ld. MM01, New Delhi District,
Patiala House Courts, New Delhi, whereby the applications filed by the
petitionersrevisionists under Section 156 (3) Cr.P.C. were dismissed.
This common order is being passed since these bunch of criminal
revisions raise common questions of facts and law and can be
conveniently disposed of together. The criminal revision No.16/2021
titled “Ashok Kumar Bedi v. State (NCT Delhi)” shall be the lead case
and this order shall apply mutatis mutandi to the remaining aforesaid
eleven criminal revisions.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND:
2. Petitionerrevisionist Ashok Kumar Bedi in Criminal
Revision No.16/2021 filed a complaint in terms of Section 200 Cr.P.C.
on 06.10.2016 and stated that he is a retired personnel from BHEL, and
suffice to state that he purchased a residential plot bearing No. C337,
measuring 225 square yards from the original allottee in a Housing
Scheme named “AMSTORIA” a project situated in Sector102,
Gurugram and floated by accused No.4 M/s. BPTP Pvt. Ltd. alongwith
the accused No.5 M/s. Countrywide Promoters Pvt. Ltd. and that the
complainant got the booking transferred in his name after the payment of
35% of the total value of the land allegedly after a delay of almost one
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 3 of 22
-- 3 of 22 --
year. It is stated that the accused persons executed a plotbuyer’s
agreement dated 02.09.2011 at the time of transfer of nomination in May
2011 and the accused persons promised to deliver the possession of the
aforesaid plot to the complainant within 24 months from the date of
signing of the contract. However, in complete contradiction to the
aforesaid promise, the accused persons rather took a new stand that the
possession would be delivered in a period of 24 months from the date of
sanction of the service plan/plotbuyer’s agreement, whichever is later.
The grievance of the complainant was that the service plan, which should
have ideally been sanctioned in the year 2011, was sanctioned as late as
in June2014, and consequently the period of 24 months was to be
reckoned from June2014 to his detriment resulting in inordinate delay of
4 years in acquiring possession of the agreed plot of land.
3. It was further the grievance of the complainant that on
reaching the site to inquire about the status of possession, he was
shocked to find that the development work had not been commenced
despite the fact that the complainant had made timely payments as per
the agreement/payment plan to the tune of Rs.92,70,861/, which made
up for about 95% of the total payment uptill May2012, that included
External and Infrastructural Development Charges viz., EDC and IDC,
which were not paid despite receiving timely payments form the
complainant and other similarly placed buyers so much so that the
proposed accused persons had not even placed their purchase order for
supply of most of the equipments pertaining to set up Substations and
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 4 of 22
-- 4 of 22 --
distribution lines of electricity and had also failed to make the requisite
payments towards various charges to the concerned department as a
result of which their licenses from the Director of Town and Country
Planning Haryana, Chandigarh, had lapsed.
4. It is further grievance of the complainant that although the
accused persons had promised to make provision for back lane/ service
lane for each plot in the lay out of the master plan of the society but the
same was altered without any intimation to the complainant thereby
removing the provision for back lane/service lane; and that the
complainant also came to know that the accused persons had taken a
bank loan with a lien on the site for the project “AMSTORIA”; and that
accused No.2, who is the Chairman and Managing Director of accused
No.4 company and accused No.1 Kabul Chawla had undertaken to get
the registry done on the basis of this loan but the same remained unpaid
till the date of filing of the complaint. It was alleged by the complainant
that the accused persons had not obtained any “NOC” from the
concerned bank and there was a clear intention on the part of the accused
persons to cheat and fraud the innocent buyers and instead the accused
persons in order to wriggle out of the conundrum, sent a communication
dated 04.09.2015 informing that it would take another three years to
provide infrastructural facilities and the possession would be delayed by
further 3 years. The complainant thereafter sought registration of FIR
and criminal prosecution against the accused persons under Sections
406, 415, 418,420, 467, 468, 471, 120B r/w 34 IPC.
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 5 of 22
-- 5 of 22 --
5. It is pertinent to mention here that prior to the impugned
order dated 23.10.2020, the application under Section 156 (3) Cr.P.C.
had earlier been dismissed by the same Ld. MM01, New Delhi vide
order dated 26.02.2020 and the complainants, who were then 15 in
numbers filed different complaints assailing the impugned order in
Criminal Revision Nos.273/20, 274/20, 275/20, 276/20, 277/20, 278/20,
279/20, 280/20, 281/20, 282/20, 283/20, 284/20, 285/20, 286/20 and
287/20, which were decided by the Ld. Predecessor of this Court vide
order dated 05.10.2020 and the criminal revision petitions were allowed
making the following observations, which are reproduced in toto as
under:
“The record of the Ld. MM, which I have discussed
hereinabove, present a sorry state of affairs. It is beyond
comprehension that how the Ld. MM kept the matter pending
for around two years only for passing the order under Section
156 (3) Cr.PC and finally, when the order was passed, the Ld.
MM did not even write a line about the facts of the case.
Though, the Ld. MM wrote the law correctly, but did not
write at all the facts of the case. The Ld. MM did not refer to
any judgments cited by the complainant. The reasoning in a
judicial order are its lifeline. If the law confers a discretion
upon the court, the discretion has to be exercised judicially
and not mechanically. The courts are bound to give the
reasons not only for the satisfaction of the litigant before
them, but also for the Appellate Court to understand the
thought process of the court. The Trial Courts are bound to
pass a reasoned and speaking order. Any order devoid of
reasoning basically cannot be termed as a judicial order. I
considered that the impugned order in the present form is not
sustainable at all. Hence, without going into the merits of the
case, the aforesaid revision petitions are disposed of with a
direction that matter be placed before the Ld. MM concerned
on 08.10.2020 and the Ld. MM shall fix a date within 10 days
for affording the opportunity to the complainant to advance
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 6 of 22
-- 6 of 22 --
their arguments and thereafter shall pass a reasoned order in
accordance with law without any further delay.
It is pertinent to mention here that the abovesaid order has
been passed without considering the merits of the case and
the Ld. MM shall decide the application under Section 156(3)
Cr.PC on the merits of the case without being influenced by
the order passed by this court. The Ld. MM shall also sent a
report to this court informing tbaout the disposal of the
application under Section 156 (3) Cr.PC within three weeks.”
6. So after remand, the Ld. MM vide impugned order dated
23.10.2020 considered the ‘status report’ filed by the SHO PS Connaught
Place and observed that in terms of clause 5.7 of the agreement, there
was a stipulation for extension of time for completion of development of
the colony and the delivery of the possession of plot was kept reserved
and the same was binding on the complainant. The license of the accused
persons qua the project was never cancelled and the total amount of
EDC/ IDC paid by the company against licenses No.50/10 and 45/11
pertaining to the project “AMSTORIA” as on 30.03.2016 was
Rs.74,09,11,649/ whereas the total payment received from the accused
persons from the complainant(s) was Rs.45,89,81,199/ (including
service tax) and it was thus reported by SHO PS: Connaught Place that
the company has paid excess amount of Rs.28,19,30,450/, and that as
per the accused persons, vide order dated 13.09.2013, DTCP had
unilaterally, without affording any opportunity to the alleged company to
clarify its stand, withdrew the approval of demarcationcumlayout with
respect to license No. 58/10 on the ground that the said approval was
granted based on the undertaking furnished by alleged company on
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 7 of 22
-- 7 of 22 --
30.06.2011 that it shall deposit the balance EDC within 3 months from
the date of approval of demarcation/zoning plan. However, subsequently,
upon the representations made by the accused company (s), the said order
dated 13.09.2013 was withdrawn by DTCP vide memo dated
17.10.2013; and the ‘ATR’ reflected that the complainant had
deliberately not mentioned a word in his complaint regarding the said
withdrawal order of DTCP. It was further found during enquiry that the
alleged company had raised the demands as per the agreed and accepted
payment plan mentioned under the plotbuyer’s agreement and it had all
requisite approvals and licenses before the launch of the project; and that
the grievances raised by the complainant are covered under the terms
and conditions of the plotbuyer’s agreement and can be adjudicated by
the Court of civil law; and thus it was concluded that as no cognizable
offence was made out, therefore, no FIR was registered by the police.
7. Suffice to say that Ld. MM vide order dated 23.10.2020
observed that all the facts and circumstances of the matter were within
the personal knowledge of the complainant and there was no imperative
or requirement for holding field investigation and the case in hand was
raising a dispute of “civil nature: and no cognizable offence had been
made out. Ld. MM distinguished the decision of Arun Saxena v. Today
Homes & Infrastructure P. Ltd. & Others, W.P. (CRL) No.1645/2013,
decided by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi and instead relied on
decision in Subhkaran Luharuka Vs. State (Government of NCT of
Delhi), 2010(170) DLT 516 and it was held that the complainant could
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 8 of 22
-- 8 of 22 --
produce or summon the documents in support of his allegations and no
assistance of police was required and the application under Section 156
(3) Cr.PC was dismissed. However, cognizance of the offence under
Section 200 Cr.P.C. was taken and the complainant was called upon to
lead presummoning evidence.
Criminal Revision No.14/2021
8. The petitionerrevisionist No.1 is the widow whereas
petitionerrevisionist Nos. 2 and 3 are the son and daughter of the the
deceased Manoj Kumar Singh, who filed the complaint in terms of
Section 200 Cr.P.C. against the same set of the proposed accused
persons/respondents on 04.10.2016. Briefly stated, it was the case of the
deceased complainant Manoj Kumar Singh that on 12.12.2012 he
purchased a residential plot bearing D59 measuring 250 Sq. Yards from
the original allottee in the same housing scheme named ‘AMSTORIA, a
project to be executed in Section 102, Gurugram and a plotbuyer’s
agreement dated 30.01.2012, which was endorsed on 11.02.2013 and the
case of the complainant is ditto with regard to delayed execution of the
project reiterating that as per clause 5.1 of the plotbuyer’s agreement
dated 30.01.2012, the possession was stipulated to be handed over to the
complainant with amenities such as Gym, Swimming Pool, SPA,
canopied trees, wide roads etc. within 24 months of the date of execution
plotbuyer’s agreement but to his shock when he visited the spot, no
development work had been undertaken by the respondents. It was
claimed that the complainant had made timely payment of various
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 9 of 22
-- 9 of 22 --
installments and had paid total amount of Rs. 1,22,90,397/. It is
reiterated that the accusedcompany and its accusedDirectors have
already charged 95% of the basic cost plus 100% charges towards Club
Membership, firefighting equipments besides EDC and IDC for
construction of plot Club House, Lake, 24 hours power backup, security
with electronic surveillance etc. but they were unable even to construct
33/11 KV Switchyard and could not ensure the connectivity of HT power
from Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam. It was further alleged that on
enquiries conducted by him, it came to the light that charges towards
EDC + IDC had not been deposited with the Directorate of Town and
Planning and instead the amount collected from him and other buyers
had been misappropriated by the respondent Nos. 2 to 7.
Criminal Revision No.17/2021
9. The petitionerrevisionist in this case filed his complaint on
04.10.2016 and stated that he had booked a residential plot bearing No.
C55 measuring 303 Sq. Yards from the original allottee in the same
housing scheme and to cut the long story short, he has claimed that he
had made payment of Rs. 1,53,70,289/ towards 95% of the basic cost
and likewise 100% charges towards club membership, firefighting
equipments and 100% charges towards external charges and
infrastructural charges and he has also lamented that they promised Club
House, Lake, power backup, security with electronic surveillance etc.,
which were a complete nonstarter and the money contributed by him for
the purchase of the plot had been siphoned off and misappropriated by
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 10 of 22
-- 10 of 22 --
the proposed accused persons.
Criminal Revision No.18/2021
10. The petitionerrevisionist filed this complaint also on
04.10.2016 and claimed that he had booked a residential plot bearing No.
C377, measuring 225 Sq. Yards in the same project and his grievance
was again on the same grounds, having made timely payment of Rs.
95,85,962/ towards 95% of the basic cost plus 100% charges towards
other amenities including EDC and IDC but no work was undertaken by
the respondents/proposed accused persons, and thereby, he claimed that
he has been cheated and deprived of his hard earned money by the
proposed accused persons.
Criminal Revision No.19/2021
11. This complaint was also filed on 04.10.2016 and in a
nutshell the petitionerrevisionist claimed that in November2011 he
booked residential plot bearing No. C82 measuring 303 Sq. Yards in the
same housing scheme and despited making timely payment of total
amount of Rs. 1,15,74,944/, the promised plot of land with all amenities
had not been delivered.
Criminal Revision No.20/2021
12. The petitionerrevisionist in the present case likewise
claimed that on 30.10.2010 he had booked a residential plot bearing No.
C354, measuring 225 Sq. Yards in the same housing scheme and had
made timely payment of total amount of Rs.94,62,418/ against the 95%
of the basic cost of the land plus 100% charges towards other amenities;
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 11 of 22
-- 11 of 22 --
and that he has not only been cheated but whole amount had been
misappropriated by the accused persons.
Criminal Revision No.21/2021
13. This complaint was also filed on 04.10.2016 and the
petitionerrevisionist stated that he had purchased a residential plot
bearing No. C137, measuring 250 Sq. Yards on 29.10.2010 on the
assurances given by the respondents/accused persons in the same housing
scheme i.e. ‘AMSTORIA’ to be broughtup in Section 102, Gurugram
and he made timely payment of the installments totalling RS.
1,09,92,564/ towards 95% of the basic cost of the land plus 100%
towards amenities etc.; and that he was not given promised land with
amenities and has been not only cheated but deprived of his hard earned
money by the accused persons.
Criminal Revision No.22/2021
14. The petitionerrevisionist, who is a senior citizen, filed the
complaint on 04.10.2016 and likewise claimed that he he had purchased
a residential plot bearing No. C217, measuring 225 Sq. Yards from the
original allottee in the same housing scheme viz. ‘AMSTORIA’ and had
made timely payment of Rs. 95,15,938/; and that the promised plot of
land was never delivered given with all the promised amenities; and that
he was also cheated and the whole amount has been misappropriated by
the accused persons. In Criminal Revision No.23/2021, the complaint
was filed on 04.10.2016 as well and the petitionerrevisionist claimed
that in the year 2010 she had booked a residential plot bearing No. C177
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 12 of 22
-- 12 of 22 --
measuring 250 Sq. Yards from the original allottee in the same housing
scheme and over the years made timely payments of total amount of Rs.
1,31,09,665/. In Criminal Revision No.24/2021, the complaint was also
filed on the same day i.e. 04.10.2016 and the plaintiff claimed that on
01.02.2012 he had purchased a residential plot bearing No.D053
measuring 250 Sq. Yards from the original allottee in the same housing
scheme and over the years made timely payment of total amount of Rs.
1,10,31,596/. Similarly, in Criminal Revision No.25/2021 the
complaint filed on 04.10.2016 likewise brought out the claim of the
petitionerrevisionist that in the year 2011 he purchased a residential plot
bearing No. D54, measuring 208 Sq. yards from the original allottee in
the same housing scheme and made timely payment of installments
totalling Rs. 99,46,400/. In Criminal Revision No.26/2021 the
complaint was also filed on 04.10.2016 by the petitionerrevisionist, who
is a senior citizen and claimed that on 03.12.2012 he purchased
residential plot bearing No. C340 measuring 225 Sq. Yards from the
original allottee in the same housing scheme and as is the case of other
complainants, he claimed that he had made timely payment of the
installments totaling Rs. 1,01,30,425.75/ Paisa. Needless to state that the
aforesaid petitionersrevisionists also claimed that the promised plot of
land with promised amenities was not delivered so much so that no
developmental work was carried out and they have been cheated and
deprived of their legitimate hard earned money by the accused persons.
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 13 of 22
-- 13 of 22 --
GROUNDS OF REVISION:
15. In each of the Criminal Revisions, the impugned order dated
23.10.2020 passed by the Ld. MM is assailed almost on the identical /
ditto grounds and to cut the long story short, the impugned order (s) is
assailed on the grounds that it has been passed in a very arbitrary,
whimsical and mechanical manner, applying the wrong notions of law
and misreading the ratio of the cited judgment in the impugned order, in
particular wrongly decidendi distinguishing the case of Arun Saxena v.
Today Homes & Infrastructure P. Ltd. & Others, W.P. (CRL)
No.1645/2013, where the factual narrative was the same.
PROCEEDINGS ON FILING OF THE CRIMINAL REVISIONS:
16. On filing of the aforesaid Criminal Revisions, notice was
issued to the respondents, who jointly filed a reply in each of the
Criminal Revisions. Incidentally, there were given several opportunities
to the parties to negotiate for an amicable settlement but it failed.
17. The main plank of the arguments canvassed by Ms. Jaya
Goyal, Ld. Counsel for the petitionersrevisionists is that the petitioners
revisionists have clearly demonstrated that each one of them had made
timely payment of installments running into lacs/crores and the
respondents/ proposed accused persons not only failed to deliver the
promised pieces of land that were booked/allotted, but also undertook no
work at the site and failed in complying with various legal formalities,
resulting into not only delayed projects but also depriving the petitioners
revisionists of enjoying their right to residence in a peaceful manner. It
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 14 of 22
-- 14 of 22 --
was vehemently urged that the impugned order dated 23.10.2020 has
been passed on complete misreading of law on the subject under Section
156(3) Cr.P.C., which has been reiterated time and again, and compiled
in the case of Arun Saxena v. Today Homes & Infrastructure P. Ltd.
& Others (supra).
18. Per contra Sh. Manish Sharma, Ld. Counsel for the
respondents pointed out that in the present Criminal Revisions, each of
the petitionersrevisionists has claimed refund of the amount paid by
them and the complaints are nothing but to apply coercive measures upon
the respondents so as to enable the petitionersrevisionists to wriggle out
from their responsibilities and obligations under the respective plot
buyer’s agreement. It was vehemently urged that the learned Counsel for
the petitionersrevisionists has failed to show as to how the impugned
order is unfair and/or contrary to the law; and that the allegations levelled
by each of the complainants are wrong and motivated since the accused
company(s) had rather deposited excess amount of EDC/IDC and their
licenses were never cancelled and reference was invited to various
documents and orders passed by DTCP qua licenses, occupation and
completion certificates including EDC and IDC. Sh. Manish Sharma, Ld.
Counsel for the respondents placed reliance on decisions in Lalita
Kumari v. State of UP, (2014) 2 SCC 1; Shri Subhkaran Luharuka v.
State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi), 2010 (170) DLT 516; M/s. Skipper
Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v. State, 2011 (59) DRJ 129; Minu Kumar & Ors.
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 15 of 22
-- 15 of 22 --
v. The State of Bihar, (2006) 4 SCC 359; and Meenakshi Anand
Sootha v. State & Ors., Crl. R.P. No. 501 of 2007 (Delhi High Court).
DECISION:
19. I have given my thoughtful consideration to the detailed
submissions advanced by the respective parties at the Bar. I have also
perused the trial Court record as also the record in the present revision
petitions. I have meticulously gone through the case law cited at the Bar.
20. At the outset, I am unable to persuade myself to sustain the
impugned order dated 23.10.2020 passed by the Ld. MM, which prima
facie appears to have been passed in a mechanical manner relying upon
on a meaningless and not so impartial inquiry conducted by the police.
First thing first, what the Ld. Trial Court has completely missed out is
that each of the complainants have specifically alleged that while they
were making timely payments of installments dutifully in terms of the
agreed payment plan to the respondent accused companies, the whole
project was a nonstarter since it is prima facie brought that no
development work had been commenced or initiated worth its salt at the
project site; and it has been alleged that the respondents/proposed
accused companies as well as respondent/proposed directors suo moto
reviewed the terms and conditions of allotment and delivery of the
promised/agreed plots of land and there were levelled allegations by the
complainant(s) that timely payments of EDC and IDC were not made by
the proposed accused persons.; and that electronic surveillance system
was not created, the Electric Substation and distribution lines for supply
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 16 of 22
-- 16 of 22 --
of electricity were not set up and huge loans had already been taken on
the land, which were not even repaid; and last but not the least, various
amenities in the nature of Club House, Lake, 24 hours power backup,
security with electronic surveillance etc. were never created besides
deviating from the plan of having service or back lanes etc.
21. The whole scenario leads to a prima facie inference that the
respondent/proposed accused persons, while on the one hand were
collecting installments from the complainant and other similarly placed
persons, on the other hand there was no intention in their mind from the
very beginning to commence and execute their part of the obligations and
by all human probabilities, the amount paid by each of the complainant
and also similarly placed persons/buyers were siphoned off and
misappropriated. Secondly, and more importantly, the decision by
Hon’ble Single Judge in Shri Subhkaran Luharuka v. State (Govt. of
NCT of Delhi) (supra) is per incurium since it failed to consider the
decision in Ramesh Kumari v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2006) 2 SCC
677, as was observed by their lordship in the case of Arun Saxena &
Anr. v. Today Homes & Structure Pvt. Ltd. To my mind, the Ld. MM
has completely misread the proposition of law laid down in the case titled
Arun Saxena & Anr. v. Today Homes & Structure Pvt. Ltd., 2018
SCC OnLine Del 10752, wherein after detailed academic discourse, it
was observed that:
“Thus, in view of the law laid down in State of Haryana vs.
Bhajan Lal & Ors. 1992 AIR 604, which was followed
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 17 of 22
-- 17 of 22 --
in Ramesh Kumari (supra) upon receipt of information
disclosing commission of a cognizable offence, the police
officer concerned is mandated to register a case and
investigate the same. The police officer cannot embark on an
enquiry as to whether the information laid by the informant is
reliable and genuine, or not. He cannot refuse to register a
case on the ground that the information is not reliable or
credible. He is statutorily obliged to register the case and
then to proceed with the investigation, if he has reason to
suspect the commission of a cognizable offence. The police
cannot tell the complainant that even though his complaint
discloses commission of a cognizable offence, he must prefer
a complaint under Section 200 Cr PC since, according to the
police, the complainant is possessed of all the information
necessary to prosecute the accused and that police has no role
in the matter of conduct of investigation.”
22. Reverting to the instant matter, the Ld. MM missed the
aspect of the enormity of the alleged criminal acts and omissions
committed by the respondents/proposed accused persons, failing to
appreciate that the complainants were not possessed of all the
documentary evidence and investigation envisaged approaching different
government departments including Banks who were involved or should
have been involved for timely completion of the project. It is but obvious
that the police with its resources and reach is better suited to conduct an
investigation and find out how and in what manner funds have not been
applied for the commencement of the project or whether siphoned of and
misappropriated by the proposed accused persons. Reference can again
be made to the decision in the cited case of Arun Saxena & Anr. v.
Today Homes & Structure Pvt. Ltd, (supra), wherein it was observed:
“In the light of the aforesaid discussion, in my view, serious
miscarriage of justice has taken place by denying to the
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 18 of 22
-- 18 of 22 --
petitioners/complainants their prayer for direction to the
police to register a case on their complaint. The
petitioners/complainants have been left high and dry and with
no satisfactory remedy. They have been left to fend for
themselves, when they are not possessed of the machinery
and authority of the State. As lay persons, they are not in no
position to carry out the necessary investigation to bring
home their allegations. Their complaints disclose commission
of serious cognizable offences under Section 406/420/468
read with Section 120B IPC. Investigation by the police of the
said offences is not only conducive to justice, and would not
only save the time of the Court from being wasted, it is
absolutely imperativeif the offenders absolutely have to be
brought to justice. Paragraph {86}
The reluctance shown by the police in registering the FIR's on
the complaints of the petitioners/complainants, despite the
same disclosing commission of serious cognizable offences,
as also their opposition to the applications of the
petitioners/complainants under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. before
the ld. MM; thereafter before the Ld. ASJ; and thereafter
before this Court shakes the confidence of this Court and
raises doubts as to whether the police is truly interested in
performing its statutory obligations. The possibility of the
accusedwho are builders are having deep pockets,
influencing the machinery, cannot be ruled out.
Paragraph {88}”
23. Incidentally, Ld. MM also failed to appreciate that on
somewhat similar complaints lodged by some of the other buyers and
almost on ditto grounds/allegations three FIRs bearing Nos. 544/16,
545/16 & 546/16, have been ordered to be registered at PS Rajendra
Park, Gurgaon, Haryana, against the respondent/proposed accused
persons, the copies of which were placed during the course of inquiry
before the Ld. MM. It is quite baffling as to how the Ld. MM from the
decision in Lallan Chaudhary and Ors. vs. State of Bihar & Ors.
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 19 of 22
-- 19 of 22 --
2006(3) ACR 3161 (SC) came to the conclusion that the allegations
disclosed in the present complaints were only of “civil nature” and no
cognizable offence has been made out. Likewise, the case of State vs.
Khimji Bai Jadeja, Crl. Ref. No. 01/2014, decided on 08.07.2019 by the
Hon'ble High Court of Delhi, was altogether on a different issue with
regard to amalgamation of several complaints in case of inducement,
allurement and cheating of large number of investors/ depositors as it
was held that each deposit by an investor constitutes a separate and new
transaction.
24. At the cost of repetition, the factual narrative on a bare
reading of the allegations in each of the complaints raise a strong
inference that the respondent/proposed accused persons made huge
promises and tall claims to allure gullible investors and thereby inducing
them to invest in their project in question and despite getting timely
payments from each of them, there was no work undertaken at the site
leaving the complainants high and dry and without any effective and
timely legal remedy. The acts and omissions on the part of the
respondent/accused persons prima facie amounts to an offence of
cheating within the meaning of Section 415 IPC as the complainants
were dishonestly induced to make payment towards purchase of the plots
of the land in the project in question without any intention to fulfill their
part of the contractual obligations and to that end commencement of the
development work at the project site was not undertaken and it prima
facie appears that the amount collected from each of the complainant and
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 20 of 22
-- 20 of 22 --
similarly placed buyers were siphoned off and misappropriated.
25. It manifestly appears that the Ld. MM while passing the
impugned order completely misdirected herself on facts and law and
passed the order purely based on the ATR, which report was almost
based on a sham or “no inquiry” by the police. In fact, it appeared to be a
case of no will or desire on the part of the Police to inquire or investigate
into the offences. The Ld. MM simply went by the version in the ATR
that DTCP had unilaterally withdraw the approval of demarcation/layout
license no. 58/10, based probably on the version of the
respondent/accused persons while there was certainly more to the story
than to meet the eyes.
26. In view of the foregoing discussions, the present criminal
revision petitions are allowed and the impugned orders dated 23.10.2020
passed by the Ld. Trial Court are set aside and the SHO, PS Connaught
Place, New Delhi, is directed to register an FIR in the present matter on
the complaint of each of the revisionists as separate FIRs within 48 hours
as per the relevant provision of law, and thereafter, conduct investigation
as per law. Copies of this order and in the remaining aforesaid twelve
criminal revisions be sent to the SHO PS Connaught Place for immediate
compliance. A compliance report be filed by the SHO on Monday 8th
August, 2022. Nothing contained herein shall tantamount to an
expression of opinion on the merits of the case and the police
investigation except for registering of the FIR within the time stipulated,
shall be conducted in the ordinary course of their public duties as per the
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 21 of 22
-- 21 of 22 --
law. The aforesaid criminal revision petitions are disposed of
accordingly.
27. Original copy of the order be placed in the file bearing
Criminal Revision16/2021 titled ‘Ashok Kumar Bedi v. The State &
Ors.’ and signed copy of this order be placed in each of the remaining
criminal revision petitions.
28. Trial Court record in each of the files alongwith copy of
this order be sent back forthwith. Files of all the revision petitions be
consigned to Record Room.
Announced in the open Court (DHARMESH SHARMA)
on 06th August, 2022 Principal District & Sessions Judge (NDD)
Patiala House Courts, New Delhi
Criminal Revision No. 14/2021 and 16/2021 to 26/2021 Page 22 of 22
-- 22 of 22 --