Full Order Text
Final Order 8 · 03 Oct 2024 · CNR DLET030018592023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: Suit No 991/23 Pg 1 of 5 IN THE COURT OF AYUSH SHARMA: CIVIL JUDGE, EAST DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI Date of Institution of Suit: December 18th, 2023 Reserved on: September 25th, 2024 Pronounced on: October 3rd, 2024 SUIT NO: 991/23 IN THE MATTER OF: - RAJNI GUPTA W/O LATE SHRI ASHOK KUMAR GUPTA R/O A-8, FIRST FLOOR, OLD GOVIDPURA, DELHI-110051 ...PLAINTIFF Through: Sh. Vinod Kumar Goyal, Advocate. VERSUS SANJEEV KUMAR SINHA S/O NARESH SINHA R/O H. NO. 563, MALIWARA, GHAZIABAD, UTTAR PRADESH 201001 ...DEFENDANT Through: None. SUIT UNDER ORDER XXXVII CPC FOR RECOVERY OF RS. 70,000/- ALONGWITH INTEREST JUDGMENT UNDER ORDER XXXVII RULE 2 (3) CPC 1. The present suit has been instituted under Order XXXVII of Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (‘CPC’) for recovery of amount of Rs. 70,000/- with interest @ 18 % per annum and cost. -- 1 of 5 -- Suit No 991/23 Pg 2 of 5 2. Briefly stated, the case of the plaintiff, as outlined in the plaint, is: 2.1 The late husband of the plaintiff was engaged in the business of leasing commercial crockery to banquet halls, marriage halls, farmhouses, and outdoor catering services across Delhi and the NCR region. Following his death in 2021, the plaintiff decided to wind up the business. As part of the process, she began selling the crockery and other related items. In November 2021, the defendant approached the plaintiff, mentioning that he had a good relationship with her late husband since he was in the same line of work. He expressed interest in purchasing the crockery and other articles. 2.2 After some negotiations, the plaintiff agreed to sell the crockery and other items to the defendant for a total consideration of Rs. 1,60,000/-. The defendant requested to pay the amount in two installments and promised to clear the entire sum by 15.12.2021, to which the plaintiff agreed. 2.3 On 24.11.2021, following the plaintiff’s instructions, her son-in-law handed over all the commercial crockery to the defendant after receiving a token amount of Rs. 5,000/- via UPI. The defendant agreed to pay Rs. 25,000 within the next two days and also issued two post-dated cheques: cheque no. 622820 dated 15.12.2021 and cheque no. 622821, both drawn on PNB Bank, Nehru Nagar branch, Ghaziabad, for amounts of Rs. 70,000/- and Rs. 60,000/- respectively. 2.4 Despite multiple reminders from the plaintiff, the defendant failed to pay the agreed Rs. 25,000 and did not clear the cheque amount by February 2022. On 24.02.2022, a heated argument ensued between the plaintiff and the defendant, after which the defendant deposited Rs. 25,000 into the plaintiff’s account and informed her that cheque no. 622821 amounting to Rs. 60,000 could be deposited the following day, i.e., on 26.02.2022. -- 2 of 5 -- Suit No 991/23 Pg 3 of 5 2.5 The plaintiff deposited the cheque at her bank, ESAF Small Finance Bank in Mayur Vihar, Delhi, but was shocked when the cheque was returned unpaid. Upon approaching the defendant, he apologized and requested two more days, promising to transfer the amount directly into the plaintiff’s bank account. He also took the cheque back. Despite repeated reminders, the defendant failed to make the payment. 2.6 On 15.04.2022, the plaintiff approached the defendant once more, requesting him to settle the outstanding amount of Rs. 1,30,000/-. However, the defendant cited financial difficulties and asked for six months to make the payment. On 29.07.2023, when the plaintiff again requested the payment, the defendant outrightly refused to pay the amount. The plaintiff further states that the defendant had approached the plaintiff to purchase the articles at her residence, which is located within the jurisdiction of this court, and that all dealings and negotiations were finalized at that location. As a result, the present suit has been filed to recover the sum of Rs. 70,000 based on cheque no. 622820. 3. Summons of the suit were issued vide order dated 18.12.2023 by Ld. Predecessor, which returned as served on 03.07.2024 upon the defendant. The plaintiff has filed affidavit of service along with whatsapp chat with the defendant. As per the office report, no appearance under Order XXXVII, has been filed by the defendant. The statutory period for filing the appearance under order XXXVII CPC has already expired. 4. Sh. Goyal, Ld. Counsel for plaintiff, prayed that the suit be decreed in terms of order XXXVII Rule 2 (3) CPC on account of non-appearance. 5. I have heard the submissions and perused the material on record. 6. The plaintiff in support of her case has placed reliance upon copy of Original cheque bearing no. 622820 drawn on Punjab National Bank, Nehru Nagar Branch, Ghaziabad, legal notice dated 11.09.2023, voter Id of -- 3 of 5 -- Suit No 991/23 Pg 4 of 5 plaintiff and death certificate of plaintiff’s husband. 7. In M/s S.S. Steel Industry Vs M/s Shree Guru Hargobind Steels CR.P. No.42/19, the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi held: “10. Learned counsel further relies on the judgment of the Division of this Court in Comba Telecom Ltd. Vs. S. Tel Private Ltd. 2016 (228) DLT 713 to which I was also a party. 11. The Division Bench in the said judgment has held that in a Suit under summary procedure under Order XXXVII, where summons are duly served and the defendant has not entered appearance, the defendant could not defend the Suit, all allegations made in the plaint are deemed to be admitted and the consequences are that the plaintiff would be entitled to a decree as indicated under Order XXXVII Rule 2 Sub Rule 3 CPC. 12. Order XXXVII Rule 2 Sub Rule 3 CPC specifically lays down that defendant shall not defend the Suit unless he enters appearance and in default of his entering appearance the allegations made in the plaint shall be deemed to be admitted and plaintiff would be entitled to a decree for the sum not exceeding the sum mentioned in the summons. 13. The learned Trial Court, though noticed the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in Comba Telecom Ltd. (Supra), has held that the same is not applicable on the ground that the Suit is not maintainable under Order XXXVII CPC. 14. The Trial Court has clearly committed an error. In view of the specific provisions of Order XXXVII Rule 2 Sub Rule 3 CPC, it is not within the powers of the Trial Court at that stage, to assess as to whether the Suit satisfies the requirement of Order XXXVII CPC or not. Once summons in the prescribed form have been directed to be issued and duly served, the defendant is obliged to enter appearance within the statutory period, and on failure of the defendant to enter appearance within the statutory period, the averments in the plaint are deemed to be admitted and the plaintiff is entitled to a decree forthwith.” -- 4 of 5 -- Suit No 991/23 Pg 5 of 5 8. Despite service, the defendant has failed to put up an appearance within the stipulated period. Accordingly, the facts as averred in the plaint, in view of Order XXXVII Rule 2 (3) CPC, are deemed to have been admitted by the defendants, and the plaintiff is held entitled to a decree in terms of the said provisions. The suit is accordingly decreed under Order XXXVII Rule 2(3) CPC against the defendants and in favour of the Plaintiff for the sum of Rs. 70,000/- along-with interest @ 6% per annum from the date of filing of the suit till the date of decree. Costs are also awarded in favour of plaintiff. Decree sheet be prepared. File be consigned to Record Room as per rules. Pronounced in open court On 3rd October 2024 (AYUSH SHARMA) CJ/EAST/KARKARDOOMA DELHI/03.10.2024 This judgment contains 5 pages and each page has been signed by me. -- 5 of 5 --
