Full Order Text
Interim Order 7 · 14 May 2025 · CNR DLET030006452024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: Civ Suit 403/24 NITIN DEWAN VS. SHIV NANDAN MISHRA 14.05.2025 Present: Plaintiff in person alongwith Ld. Counsel Mr. Tarun Kumar Sharma and Mr. N K Sharma. Mr. Arnav Chatterjee and Mr. Yash Chandra, Ld. Counsels for all the defendants. On perusal of the case file, it is observed that a cost of Rs. 500/- each was imposed upon all the defendants vide order dated 16.10.2024 for late filing of the WS. With regards the same, an application has been filed seeking its waiver. Copy supplied. It is seen that the WS was filed with a delay of 12 days and the same is fairly conceded. It is averred that the delay was unintentional and the defendants are poor people constrained of means. The delay being not exorbitant, it is prayed that the cost imposed may be waived. Opposed. It is indeed seen that the delay in filing the WS is of mere 12 days as after order passed in that regard on 04.09.2024, WS came to be filed on 16.10.2024. The same is seen to be not excessive. Moreover, it is seen that the plaintiff was directed to file replication on 16.10.2024 which has not been filed till date and repeated adjournments have been sought by the plaintiff for making compliance in that regard, viz. on 28.11.2024, 20.02.2025 and today. As such therefore, conduct of the plaintiff also is seen to be not exactly above board. The Court is therefore inclined to impose a cost of Rs. 1,500/- on the plaintiff in that regard. Since previous cost of Rs. 1,500/- is pending to be paid by the defendants as well, this Court is of the view that such costs be squared up against the one sought to be imposed by the Court on the plaintiff. This is more so since the delay itself in filing the WS is seen to be not excessive / inordinate. In view of the above, application seeking waiver of cost is hereby allowed. At this stage, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff states that no replication is required to be filed and the cost imposed on the defendants may not be waived. Ld. Counsel is apprised of the fact that such casual -1/2- -- 1 of 2 -- stance, with regards filing of replication, seeking time for the same to now stating that it is not required to be filed altogether, after the cost imposed on the defendants is waived, is not proper. The application seeking waiver of cost stands allowed on merits and in fact, the Court has refrained from imposing such cost on the plaintiff for delaying the proceedings by non filing of replication till date. As such therefore, no separate directions other than already passed are required to be given in this regard. Be that as it may, parties submit that there are no documents inter se the parties for the purpose of admission / denial. Pleadings are complete. The following issues emerge from the pleadings: Issue no. 1: Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of recovery of possession of the suit property as prayed for in prayer (i) of the plaint? OPP. Issue no. 2: Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of permanent injunction against the defendants thereby restraining them from transferring / selling / otherwise alienating or disposing off the suit property or creating third party interest therein as prayed for in prayer (ii) of the plaint? OPP. Issue no. 3: Whether the defendants no. 1 and 2 in fact are the lawful owners of the suit property and the same was let out to the plaintiff? OPD. Issue no. 4: Relief. No other issue is made out or pressed upon. Parties are directed to file list of witnesses within 15 days from today. Plaintiff is directed to file affidavit in evidence and supply advance copy of the same to the defendants at least a week prior to NDOH. Re-list for PE on 31.07.2025. (Gaurav Sharma) JSCC-cum-ASCJ-cum-Guardian Judge East/KKD Courts/Delhi 14.05.2025 -2/2- -- 2 of 2 --
