Full Order Text
Final Order 6 · 17 Feb 2025 · CNR DLET020077292024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: Lawyers are abstaining from work today. Page No. 1 of 15 47 CT Cases / 514/2024 Waseem Raja Vs. Au Small Finance Bank Limited PS Preet Vihar 17.02.2025 Present: Ld. Counsel for complainant through VC. Order on summoning 1. Arguments already heard on the point of summoning. 2. I have perused the records including the testimony of the witnesses examined under PSE. 3. Briefly stated, the case of the complainant is as follows: that the complainant approached accused bank M/s AU Financiers India Ltd. for a loan of Rs. 14,00,000/- repayable in 120 equated monthly installments (EMIs) of Rs. 21,622/- each. Loan was sanctioned by Accused bank in the first instance and accused bank got signed some printed forms/ documents from complainant and later from his wife Mrs. Ruby Fatima who is a housewife. Accordingly, a cheque no. 340716 for Rs. 10,51,197/- drawn on HDFC Bank, D-54 Siddi Vinayak, Ashok Marg, ‘C’ Scheme, Jaipur, dated 11.07.2017 was issued by accused bank in favour of complainant. Accused Bank paid an amount of Rs. 1,17,000/- to M/s HDB Finance on behalf of -- 1 of 15 -- Lawyers are abstaining from work today. Page No. 2 of 15 complainant to pay off/square up the loan liability of complainant. Accused Bank M/s AU Financiers India Ltd. paid only a total sum of Rs. 11,68,197/- out of total sanctioned loan amount of Rs. 12,00,000/-. Accused bank disbursed the loan amount after deducting a sum of Rs. 31,803/- towards one month interest in advance. The said cheque was handed over to complainant only on 04.08.2017 to get credit in his bank account. Complainant in actual received the loan amount on 05.08.2017, but interest was charged w.e.f. 11.07.2017. On 11.07.2017, accused bank sanctioned another loan of Rs. 2,00,000/- repayable in 120 equated monthly installments (EMIs) of Rs. 3,604/- each, for which the complainant was asked to execute a mortgage deed in favour of accused bank in respect of his property bearing no. H. No. 776, 2nd floor (without roof rights), Sheesh Mahal, Bhadurgarh Road, Azad Market, Delhi-110006 and got the same registered with the office of Sub Registrar, Delhi. However, Accused bank did not join the execution of the said registered mortgage deed, instead unauthorizedly signed the said mortgage deed as mortgagee at the bottom of the document and represented itself as mortgagee before the concerned Sub-Registrar. Thereafter, Accused bank issued a cheque No. 340717 for Rs. 1,92,272/- dated 11.07.2017 drawn on HDFC Bank, D-54, Siddi Vinayak, Ashok Marg, ‘C’ scheme, Jaipur and deducted a sum of Rs. 7,728/- towards one -- 2 of 15 -- Lawyers are abstaining from work today. Page No. 3 of 15 month interest in advance. However, the said cheque was handed to complainant on 17.08.2017 to get credited in his bank account. Accordingly, complainant in actual, received the loan amount on 18.08.2017 but the interest was charged w.e.f 11.07.2017, even on the amount which was not given. Subsequently, the said documents were also got signed by the wife of complainant on the ground that if any mis-happening occurs with complainant, then it would be convenient for complainant’s faimily to get back the property documents. Thereafter, on 22.05.2019 accused bank sanctioned a top up loan of Rs. 5,50,000/-, repayable in 60 equated monthly installments (EMIs) of Rs. 14,267/- each. The said loan amount was disbursed by the accused bank in an account opened by accused bank with it on 22.05.2019 by an amount of Rs. 5,26,397/-, after deducting one month interest of Rs. 23,603/- in advance. Complainant had repaid an amount of Rs. 5,90,632/- (an amount equal to 27 EMIs + Rs. 6,888/-) in loan account no. L9001060713241333 and EMI stood paid up till the month of October, 2019. Complainant had also repaid an amount of Rs. 1,11,724/- (an amount equal to 31 EMIs) in loan account no. L9001060713241503 and EMIs stood paid up till February, 2020. Complainant had also repaid an amount of Rs. 99,869/- (an amount equal to 7 EMIs) in loan account No. L9001060817539835 and EMIs stood paid up till December -- 3 of 15 -- Lawyers are abstaining from work today. Page No. 4 of 15 2019. On 17.01.2020, accused bank issued a notice u/s 13(2) of SARAESI Act calling upon the complainant and his wife to pay Rs. 12,04,207/- due till 16.01.2020, in loan account no. L9001060713241333, Rs. 2,01,063/- due till 16.01.2020, in loan account no. L9001060713241503 and Rs. 5,83,406/- due till 16.01.2020 in loan account no. L9001060817539835. Thereafter, on receiving the said notice, complainant visited the office of accused bank and enquired about the facts and asked for the copies of documents but the same were not provided by the accused bank and allowed the complainant to see the same in its office. On 31.01.2020 complainant went to the office of accused bank and told them that the property owned by the complainant is a dwelling house and the complainant has got no other place where he could go on which the bank officials promised complainant that they would look into the matter if the complainant deposits some amount with the bank. Accordingly, complainant somehow arranged the money and deposited a sum of Rs. 28,510/- in loan account No. L9001060713241333, Rs. 14,420/- in loan account No. L9001060713241503 and Rs. 57,070/- in loan account No. L9001060817539835, as per the guidance of the officials of the accused bank. Accused bank filed an application under section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act before the court wherein the accused bank had got the order dated 28.10.2020, appointing Sh. Saurav Bhasin, Advocate as Receiver -- 4 of 15 -- Lawyers are abstaining from work today. Page No. 5 of 15 to take possession of the property of complainant, by misrepresenting the facts. In compliance of the said order the said Receiver has issued a notice dated 01.12.2020 for taking possession of the said property on 21.12.2020. Thereafter, the complainant alongwith his wife having no other remedy challenged the illegal action of the accused bank by filing a Securitization Application vide SA No.191 of 2020. Accused bank appeared on advance notice of the said SA no.191/2020 and opposed the interim prayer/relief which was declined by the Hon'ble Debt Recovery Tribunal III, Delhi vide order dated 21.12.2020. The Hon'ble Tribunal adjourned the case for 19.05.2021. The said long adjournment was challenged by the complainant before the Hon'ble Delhi High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India which was dismissed vide order dated 25.01.2021 with liberty to exhaust the statutory remedy under section 17(6) of SARFEASI Act before the Hon'ble Debt Recovery Appellate Tribunal. Thereafter the complainant filed the said application under section 17(6) before the Hon'ble Debt Recovery Appellate Tribunal which was also kept pending without any direction to the DRT for disposal of said SA no.191/2020 within statutory period. Taking advantage of undue favour of the Hon'ble Tribunal/Appellate Tribunal, the accused bank put the property of the complainant at auction to take place on 24.03.2021. The complainant filed an application before the -- 5 of 15 -- Lawyers are abstaining from work today. Page No. 6 of 15 Hon'ble Tribunal for stay of the said auction but the same was disposed of as no bid was received for the reserve price of Rs.21,00,000/-. The accused bank put the property of the complainant again for auction to take place on 27.08.2021 reducing the reserve price this time at Rs.14,00,000/-. The stay of the said auction was also sought by filing fresh application under section 17(7) of the SARFEASI Act which was dismissed vide order dated 27.08.2021. This time only one bid was received and the property of the complainant was auctioned to the sole bidder i.e. the accused bank for Rs.14,10,000/-. Thereafter accused bank, having been apprised with the facts that the property of the complainant was mortgaged only for a loan of Rs.2 lac and the maximum liability for the said loan and against the said property could be fetched for Rs.6 Lacs, realising that the things were wrong the bank settled the matter with the complainant as per their right. Accordingly, the complainant cleared the liability of loan account No.L9001060713241503 for loan of Rs.2 lac. The complainant was asked to come again after his call for collecting/receiving of the title documents of the mortgage property as the same were lying with the head office of the accused bank. On 16.02.2022, the complainant went to the office of the accused bank and received the title documents against due acknowledgment and on the same day one bank official came with the complainant at the suit property and -- 6 of 15 -- Lawyers are abstaining from work today. Page No. 7 of 15 opened the seal and handed over the possession. On 22.03.2022, the complainant opened the lock of the property then some unknown persons came at the premises and started quarreling with the complainant and his family. Thereafter the complainant dialed on 112 for police assistance and the matter was reported to the local police station, Bara Hindu Rao, Delhi. On 05.06.2022, complainant received a call from P.S. Laxmi Nagar stating that one complaint has been filed by accused bank against him for cheating, fraud, forgery & impersonation. Then, complainant immediately visited the branch office of the accused bank in Delhi to inquire about the said complaint but the accused bank did not allow the complainant to talk to any official of the bank. Complainant kept trying to contact the accused bank but no official of the bank was paying any heed to the request of the complainant. On 20.01.2024, the complainant filed one RTI application to the SHO Laxmi Nagar, East Delhi to know the status of the false complaint dated 30.05.2022 filed by the accused bank against him. On 20.03.2024, complainant received the reply of his RTI application dated 30.05.2022 from Sh. Avnish Kumar, the public information officer, Addl. DY.Commissioner of Police-, East District and as per the reply the accused bank had stated that one day the complainant came personating him as a buyer and grabbed the property documents and ran away. Complainant had visited the branch office of the -- 7 of 15 -- Lawyers are abstaining from work today. Page No. 8 of 15 accused bank on 16.02.2022 and did his proper KYC and then only the accused bank handed over the original sale deed, original mortgage deed, copy of NOC & copy of LOD. Now one unknown person namely Sh. Abbas Raza is claiming himself to be the owner of the said property on the basis of some illegal sale certificate issued by the accused bank. Complainant filed a complaint to S.H.O. P.S. Laxmi Nagar, Delhi and Commissioner of Police through speed post dated 29.04.2024, but no action was taken. Hence, the present complaint. 4. During PSE, the complainant examined himself as CW-1. 5. The complainant has prayed in the complaint that summons be issued against the accused bank and it be tried for the offences under section 211/420/467/468/471/406/506/120B/34 IPC. 6. Inquiry u/s 202 Cr.PC was directed and a report was filed with respect to the same as per which during the course of inquiry it was found that the matter pertains to a loan amount on mortgage of property. No cognizable offence was made out and the matter was of civil nature. Further, the loans as availed by the complainant to the tune of Rs. 12 lac and Rs. 5.5 lac were active as on date and have not been closed. The complaint referred by the proposed accused bank has been filed as closed as the complainant bank -- 8 of 15 -- Lawyers are abstaining from work today. Page No. 9 of 15 failed to explain the facts. The original title deeds in respect of the flat are in possession of the complainant and the complainant is in the sole and exclusive possession of the property. 7. Arguments heard. Record perused. 8. Before dealing with the allegations in present case, it is appropriate to highlight the settled legal position before summoning of an accused in a criminal complaint. Summoning of a person as an accused in a criminal case is a serious exercise of judicial discretion. There must be credible material before the Court disclosing prima facie commission of an offence for summoning of a person as an accused in a criminal case. It is solemn duty of the court to consider the material on record and apply its judicial mind thereto before summoning any person as an accused in a criminal case. 9. In Pepsi Foods Ltd. & Anr. v. Special Judicial Magistrate and Ors., (1998) 5 SCC 749 Apex Court held as under: "28. Summoning of an accused in a criminal case is a serious matter. Criminal law cannot be set into motion as a matter of course. It is not that the complainant has to bring only two witnesses to support his allegations in the complaint to have the criminal law set into motion. The order of the Magistrate summoning the accused must reflect that he has applied his mind to the facts of the case and the law applicable thereto. He has to examine the nature of allegations made in the -- 9 of 15 -- Lawyers are abstaining from work today. Page No. 10 of 15 complaint and the evidence both oral and documentary in support thereof and would that be sufficient for the complainant to succeed in bringing charge home to the accused. It is not that the Magistrate is a silent spectator at the time of recording of preliminary evidence before summoning of the accused. The Magistrate has to carefully scrutinise the evidence brought on record and may even himself put questions to the complainant and his witnesses to elicit answers to find out the truthfulness of the allegations or otherwise and then examine if any offence is prima facie committed by all or any of the accused." 10.As regards the power of court under section 203 CrPC (corresponding provision is section 226 BNSS) it was held by Apex Court in Jatinder Singh and Others v. Ranjit Kaur (2001) 2 SCC 570 that: " 10. Section 203 of the Code empowers him to dismiss a complaint after holding such inquiry if he is of the opinion that "there is no sufficient ground for proceeding". In that event he has to record the reasons as to why he held that there is not sufficient ground for proceeding, though he need not write an elaborate order " 11. Hence, under Section 203 CrPC / 226 BNSS, the Magistrate can dismiss the complaint if, after taking into consideration the statements of the complainant and his witnesses and the result of the inquiry / investigation, if any, done under Section 202 Cr.P.C/ 225 BNSS, he is of the view that there does not exist sufficient ground for proceeding. On the other hand, Section 204 Cr.P.C./ 227 BNSS provides for issue of process if the Magistrate is -- 10 of 15 -- Lawyers are abstaining from work today. Page No. 11 of 15 satisfied that there is sufficient ground for doing so. The expression "sufficient ground" used in Sections 203, 204 and 209 CrPC (corresponding provisions in section 225,227 and 232 BNSS) means the satisfaction that a prima facie case is made out against the person accused of committing an offence and not sufficient ground for the purpose of conviction. The allegation against the accused no. 1 is that accused no. 1 committed the offence of cheating, breach of trust, forgery and criminal conspiracy against the complainant. 12. Before going further it would be prudent to examine the essentials for constituting an offfence U/s 420 IPC. Section 420 IPC reads as under : “ whoever cheats and thereby dishonestly induces the person deceived to deliver any property to any person, or to make, alter or destroy the whole or any part of a valuable security, or anything which is signed or sealed, and which is capable of being converted into a valuable security, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to 7 years and shall also be liable to fine” 13. In the present case it has been submitted on behalf of the complainant that he had taken loan from the accused bank and that with respect to the same he had mortgaged his property with the -- 11 of 15 -- Lawyers are abstaining from work today. Page No. 12 of 15 bank. Later he paid the entire amount and got released the said property documents from the bank. However the bank then filed a complaint against him alleging that he had impersonated himself and took away the property documents. 14. For constituting an offence U/s 420 IPC it is essential that the accused person must have dishonestly induced the cheated person to deliver the property. In the present case the complainant has not shown as to how and in what manner the accused bank had dishonestly induced him. As per the complainant, he taken a loan from the accused bank and at that time he had given the property documents to the bank. After repaying the entire amount he got released the said papers however the bank later alleged that he took the papers dishonestly and by impersonating himself. Further as per the complainant himself as per the RTI reply obtained by him the said complaint was disposed off as the complainant did not pursue the same. In these facts, the complainant has failed to show as to how he has been cheated by the bank. Mere alleging of cheating cannot attract the offence U/s 420 IPC as has been held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in “ Mariam Fasihuddin and Anr. Vs. State by Adugodi Police Station & Anr” Crml Appeal No. 335/2024. Thus, the ingredients of offence u/s 420 IPC are not satisfied in the facts of the present case. -- 12 of 15 -- Lawyers are abstaining from work today. Page No. 13 of 15 15. The complainant has further alleged that the accused bank committed offence u/s 211/467/468/471/406 IPC. Section 211 IPC talks about False charge of offence made with intent to injure. The complainant has not shown as to what is the false accusation that has been made by the accused bank. Admittedly the complaint which was made by the accused bank has been closed and has already been disposed off. The complainant has further alleged offences under section 467/468/471 IPC which deal with the offence of forgery. The complainant in the present case had given the property documents on mortgage to the accused bank. Later as per the complainant the accused bank returned the same however it filed a complaint against the complainant. The complainant has not shown as to how and in what manner the accused bank has committed any kind of forgery with the property documents. It is settled position that for charges under Sections 467, 468, and 471 IPC to stand, there must be clear evidence of forgery and intent to deceive which is lacking in the facts of the present case. Further, section 406 IPC provides punishment for the offence of criminal breach of trust. To constitute the offence under this section there must be an entrustment of a property which is later dishonestly misappropriated. In the present case the property documents were given to the accused bank and the same as per the complainant himself were returned to him, now in what manner the said documents have been misappropriated has not been shown by the -- 13 of 15 -- Lawyers are abstaining from work today. Page No. 14 of 15 complainant. 16. The complainant has further alleged offence under section 506 IPC. Section 506 IPC read as under: Punishment for Criminal intimidation- “ Whoever commits, the offence of Criminal Intimidation shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both”. If threat be to cause death or grievous hurt etc.- “and if the threat be to cause death or grievous hurt, or to cause the destruction of any property by fire, or to cause an offence punishable with death or (imprisonment for life), or with imprisonment for a terms which may extend to seven years, or to impute, unchastity to a woman, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a terms which may extend to seven years or with fine or with both”. 17. The complainant has not mentioned anywhere in the entire complaint as well as in his deposition as to in what manner the accused bank had criminally intimidated him. The accused has not shown as to what threat if any was given by the accused bank to him. None of the ingredients for constituting the offence of criminal intimidation has been shown by the complainant. 18. Lastly the complainant has alleged that the accused have committed the offence of criminal conspiracy. The complainant has not shown as to with whom the accused bank has conspired and for what purpose. The charge under Section 120-B IPC requires proof -- 14 of 15 -- Lawyers are abstaining from work today. Page No. 15 of 15 of an agreement to commit an illegal act. The complainant has not shown anything in this regard. Further the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Tulsi Ram v State of U.P (1963 AIR 666) has held that if the foundational charges (like forgery) are not established, the conspiracy charge may also fail. 19. The summoning of an accused person in a criminal case is a se- rious exercise. Thus a bare perusal of case record including the averments made in the complaint will clearly show that there is no sufficient ground for proceeding. Accordingly, the present com- plaint is hereby dismissed under section 226 BNSS (corresponding provision under section 203 of Cr.P.C.). Original documents be re- turned to the rightful claimant against due acknowledgment and re- ceipt as per rules. 20. File be consigned to record room after due compliance. (DEEKSHA RAO) Judicial Magistrate First Class-04 East/KKD/Delhi/17.02.2025 -- 15 of 15 --
