Skip to main content
Court Order

Interim Order 4

CNR DLET02002362202417 Apr 2025
Karkardooma, CMM Court
delhi · Delhi (DL)
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Interim Order 4 · 17 Apr 2025 · CNR DLET020023622024

Order Details: COPY OF ORDER
Pdf Text: 24 CT Cases 205/2024 ANKIT JAIN Vs. NEHA JAIN /0 ()
17-04-2025
Present : Ld. Counsel Sh. Pradeep Kumar for complainant (through VC).
The matter is listed for orders.
Vide this order, I shall dispose of the application under Section 156 (3)
Cr.P.C.filed on behalf of the complainant.
Arguments on application under Section 156 (3) Cr.P.C. have been heard.
Briefly stated facts of the case is that the marriage was solemnized on
20.04.2022 between the complainant and accused no.1 according to Hindu Rites and customs at
White Rose Banquet, Sector-18, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad, U.P. – 201012 and no child was born
out of said wed-lock of the parties. The above said marriage of the accused No.1 with the
complainant is the second marriage and accused no.1 had a love marriage with Mr. Ankit Jain
S/o Mr. Arvesh Kumar Jain on 22.01.2018 with the consent of the family members. It is stated
that accused no.1 had lived with her first husband only for about 6-7 months and after that the
accused persons lodged a false and frivolous FIR bearing No.55/2019 u/s 498/406/34 IPC in PS
Krishna Nagar against her previous husband and his family members. It is further stated that the
dispute between the accused no.1 and her previous husband has been settled and the first
husband of accused no.1 took divorce from the accused and paid huge settlement amount of
Rs.5,50,000/- to the accused. It is further stated that accused no.2 and 3 solemnized the second
marriage of accused no.1 with the complainant after about 02 years i.e. on 20.04.2022 but from
the first day of marriage, the behavior of accused no.1 was not good towards the complainant,
his mother Smt. Poonam and his sisters. The complainant being a gentle and devoted husband
always discharge his duty without any complaint and always fulfilled all the desires of accused
no.1 as per his capacity and capability. Also, the complainant tried several times to understand
accused no.1 and the complainant told to accused no.2 and 3 about her behavior but instead of
understanding her daughter, they started abusing and threatening the complainant and said that
"NEHA JO KEHTI HAI USKA KABHI VIROD MAT KARNA VO KHULE VICHARO
WALI LADKI HAI, TUM BHI USKE KISI BHI KAAM ME DAKHAL ANDAJI NAHI
KARTE" and thereafter, accused no.1 started making false complaint of complainant to accused
no.2 and 3, due to which, accused no.2 and 3 came to the complainant's house and started
fighting with the complainant without any rhyme and reasons. It is further stated that accused
no.1 became habitual to leave the matrimonial house without the consent and permission of the
complainant or his family members and accused no.1 stayed in her parents’ house for most of
the days in every month and she returned to her own accord. Further, accused no.1 was
-- 1 of 6 --
undergoing treatment for the depression, even before marriage but accused persons did not tell
anything about it at the time of marriage and fraudulently accused no.2 and 3 got their daughter
married to the complainant.
It is worth to mentioning here that due to depression, accused no.1 in collusion and
connivance of accused persons harassed and leveled false and frivolous allegations against her
first husband namely and his family members and finally accused no.1 took divorce by extorting
huge money from her said first husband. The medical records of accused no.1 is annexed
herewith for kind perusal of this Hon'ble Court. It is further stated that when the complainant
came to know about the said illness of accused no.1, the complainant asked the accused persons
that "you married Neha to me by lying because you could have told about Neha's illness earlier
also" then the accused no.2 and 3 said that "HAME TO TERE JAISE BEVKOOF LADKE SE
HI NEHA KI SHADI KARNI THI, PEHLE BHI HUMNE TERE NAAM KE LADKE KE
SATH HI NEHA KI SHADI KI THI, USKE PARIWAR SE BHI HUMNE NEHA SE
CHUTKARA PANE KE LIYE SAMJHOTA RAKAM 5,50,000/- OR LAGBHAG 4-5 LAKH
KI JEWELARY HUMNE LI THI, TAB NEHA KA TALAQ 22.10.2020 KO KARWAYA
THA. Accused no.2 and 3 further threatened the complainant by saying that "AGAR TUJHE
BHI NEHA SE CHHUTKARA PANA HAI TO HAME KAM SE KAM 20 LAKH RUPEE DE
NAHI TO HUM TUJHE VAT ERE PARIWAR WALO KO DAHEJ TATHA MARPITAI KE
JHOOTE CASE ME PANSVA DENGE" and accused no.l was taken home by accused no.2 and
3 in the month of October 2022. The complainant tried a lot to stop accused no.2 and 3 but they
said that "if you want to keep the Neha with you, then give us Rs.20 lakh and only after that
Neha will stay with you". The complainant tried to bring accused no.1 to his home several times
but every time the accused persons refused for the same.
It is mentioned that in the month of December 2022, the complainant along with his
family relatives went to the parental house of accused no.1 and after explaining a lot to the
accused persons, accused no.1 was sent along with the complainant on the same day. Thereafter,
accused no.1 lived peacefully for about 1-2 months and after that accused no.1 used to pick up
quarrels with accused no.1 and his mother even on petty matters without any reason and for
which accused no.2 to 5 had a full backing. On 17.05.2023, accused no.1 left her matrimonial
home along with her parental family members at her own's free will, without any logical reason.
Thereafter, on 27.05.2023, accused no.1's call came on the complainant's phone and accused
no.1 said that "I am coming home to collect the things as it is the namekaran ceremony of my
uncle's grandson. If I do not find anyone at home, I will break the lock of the house and
forcefully enter the house". The complainant said to accused no.1 that he is out of the house
-- 2 of 6 --
right now and it will take about 1 hour for him to reach home. Thereafter, the complainant
reached his house at around 09:00 o'clock and accused no.1 along with accused no.4 and 5 came
home and started carrying money, jewellery and clothes from the safe kept in the house in 3-4
suitcases and when the complainant said that this is not a good thing of you and your family, if
you want to take something then you can come alone and take it as this house is yours. Do not
spoil your house by following the advice of your parents. The mother of complainant also asked
accused no.1 that what would you do with so many clothes, don't you want to come back home?
Hearing this, the accused no.1 started shouting loudly at her mother-in-law Smt.Poonam Jain
and the complainant tried to understand the accused no.1 but all in vain and she left her
matrimonial house. The accused no.1 has taken all her jewellery and belongings along with
herself at the time of leaving the matrimonial home. The abovesaid incident was recorded by the
complainant in his mobile phone. Further, seeing the dispute between the parties, on
12.06.2023, the respectable persons of the society held a meeting to unite the two families, in
which it was decided that the accused no.1 will have a separate kitchen with her husband. She
will do all the work and will not do any work for the complainant's family members and the
complainant's mother Smt. Poonam Jain will keep her food and drink separate. Accused no.1
will not have anything to do with the complainant's mother. So the complainant told of accused
no.2 and 3 that he is only son of his mother and his father has also passed away. If he leave his
mother alone, then who will take care of his mother? The complainant further said to accused
no.2 and 3 that you too, Rishabh Jain is the only son and how will you feel if your son leaves
you and stays with his wife? Finally, the complainant said that he cannot leave his mother alone.
The complainant also requested that if accused no.1 wants to live with him then she can live
happily with him and his mother and sisters but the parents of accused no.1 clearly refused to
send accused no.1 with the complainant. Thereafter, the complainant, on the request of his
mother, went to accused no.1 parental house on 20.07.2023 to take his wife i.e. accused no.1,
but the money-greedy accused no.2 to 4 clearly refused to send accused no.1 and they said that
"HUM NEHA KO TERE SATH JAB BHEJENGE JAB TU HAME 20 LAKH RUPEE OR
MAKAAN DEGA TO TERI MAA POONAM JAIN KE NAAM HAI, VAH BUDIYA
MAKAAN ME REHKAR KYA KAREGI, AAJ YA KAL TO USSE MARNA HI HAI,
HAMARI MANGO KO POORI KARO NAHI TO HUM TUJHE OR TERE PARIWAR
WALO KE KHILAF DAHEJ VA MARPEET KA JHOOTA CASE LAGWA DENGE". In this
regard, the complainant gave information to the police station Krishna Nagar, Delhi on
10.08.2023. Thereafter, on 08.09.2023 at around 07:00 pm, the accused persons suddenly came
to the complainant's house and started banging the door of the house loudly, the sound of the
-- 3 of 6 --
gate ringing loudly and hearing this, the complainant and his mother came and the people of the
nearby neighborhood also gathered. The accused no.1 started abusing loudly in filthy language
and started shouting to give her remaining jewelery and other items and started saying that
"BUDIYA MERI JEWELLARY OR SAMAN DE DE NAHI TO MAI POLICE WALO KO
BULAKAR TUM DONO MAA-BETE KO JAIL ME BUND KARWA DUNGI" then the
complainant said to the accused no.1 that "You have already taken the things, what is yours
here?". The accused no.1 pushed mother of complainant and made her fall on the ground. The
accused persons forcefully entered in the house of accused no.1 and started searching the house.
Seeing the act and behavior of the accused persons, the complainant called the police PCR van
by dialing 112 and informed about the said act and behavior of the accused persons. Seeing the
said act and behavior of the accused persons, the PCR van police officials pacified the accused
persons by threatening them. The complainant told the accused persons in front of the police
officials that whatever items accused no.1 will take away, the complainant will give it in writing
or in front of the police officer because earlier also the accused no.1 had taken jewelery and
clothes from the house without informing. So, the complainant took a photo of the Baleno car
keys, luggage and remaining jewellery in front of the police and gave the goods to the accused
no.1 and her said family members and the complainant further clear that now the complainant
do not have accused no.1's jewellery, car and clothes as the accused no.1 is taking everything,
then the parents of accused no.1 started threatening the complainant and said that "HUM TERA
PEECHA NAHI CHHODEGE". The accused persons are greedy persons for money and they
are repeatedly demanding money from the complainant. The abovesaid incident was recorded
by the complainant in his mobile phone. It is further mentioned that accused persons had earlier
also asked for money arbitrarily from first husband of accused no.1 and now they are harassing
the complainant and his family members mentally and physically as accused no.1 and her said
family members demanding Rs.20 lakh by threatening to implicate the complainant and his
family members in false case of demand of dowry and assault.
It was submitted on behalf of the complainant that since the complaint of the
complainant was disclosing commission of cognizable offence by the accused persons, in view
of various authoritative pronouncement of Hon'ble Supreme Court in this regard, it was
bounded duty of the police to register an FIR and investigate the matter.
I have carefully perused the application u/s 156 (3) Cr.P.C. as well as the other
material on record. As per the status report filed by the IO, the complainant did not mention in
his statement that any action would be taken on his complaint, nor did he give any other
statement or complaint in this regard later.
-- 4 of 6 --
In this regard, it becomes imperative to keep in consideration the circumstances,
when an application or prayer under section 156(3) Cr.P.C. should be entertained by the Court.
It is settled proposition of law that the power of Magistrate to give directions under section
156(3) Cr.P.C. is discretionary and the same has to be exercised only when there is requirement
of investigation / custodial interrogation by the police agency. If the evidence is within the
reach of the complainant, usually the directions under section 156(3) Cr.P.C. are not given. The
word used in the section 156(3) is “may” whereas the word used in section 154 Cr.P.C. is
“shall”. The wording of this section clearly implies that the police is bound to register an FIR
when information regarding the cognizable offence is given to the police whereas the Magistrate
is not bound to give direction under section 156(3) Cr.P.C. even though, the complaint discloses
the commission of cognizable offence as a Magistrate has to see whether the investigation by
the police is required or not.
In M/s. Skipper Beverages Pvt. Ltd. Vs State, Cited as 2001 IV AD (Delhi) 625,
the circumstances when the power of Magistrate under section 156(3) Cr.P.C. should be
exercised has been explained.
“7. It is true that Section 156(3) of the Code empowers a Magistrate to
direct the police to register a case and initiate investigations but this
power has to be exercised judiciously on proper grounds and not in a
mechanical manner. In those cases where the allegations are not very
serious and the complainant himself is in possession of evidence to prove
his allegations there should be no need to pass orders under Section
156(3) of the Code. The discretion ought to be exercised after proper
application of mind and only in those cases where the Magistrate is of the
view that the nature of the allegations is such that the complainant himself
may not be in a position to collect and produce evidence before the Court
and interests of justice demand that the police should step in to held the
complainant. The police assistance can be taken by a Magistrate even
Under Section 202(1) of the Code after taking cognizance and proceeding
with the complaint under Chapter XV of the Code as held by Apex Court
in 2001 (1) Supreme Page 129 titled " Suresh Chand Jain Vs. State of
Madhya Pradesh & Ors."
After going through the complaint and hearing the arguments, it is seen that the
entire facts is known to the complainant or the complainant can get the evidence summoned
through the process of this court and nothing new is to be collected for which the assistance of
the police is required. Even the identity of the proposed accused persons is known to the
complainant and has been mentioned in the complaint. Besides, if after examination of the
complainant, any police assistance is required, the court is within its power to direct
investigation under section 202 Cr.P.C.
Considering the facts and circumstances, there is no ground for this court to
-- 5 of 6 --
exercise jurisdiction under Section 156 (3) Cr.P.C. Accordingly, the application under Section
156 (3) Cr.P.C. is hereby dismissed.
Before parting with the order, cognizance on the complaint under section 190(1)
(a) Cr.P.C. is hereby taken.
To come up for pre summoning evidence under Section 200 Cr.P.C. on 21-07-
2025.
(P. Bhargav Rao)
JMFC-05(East)/KKD Court
Delhi 17-04-2025
-- 6 of 6 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.