Full Order Text
Final Order 15 · 24 Jan 2025 · CNR DLET010119892023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SHRI PITAMBER DUTT:
DISTRICT JUDGE (COMMERCIAL COURT-01)
EAST DISTRICT KARKARDOOMA COURTS : DELHI
CS (Comm) No. 378 / 2023
Punjab & Sind Bank
Having its Corporate Office at:-
Bank House, 4th Floor,
21 Rajendra Place, New Delhi – 110008,
Having its Branch Office at:-
Mayur Vihar, Phase – II,
Delhi – 110091.
Through its Authorizezd Representative
Amit Kumar Bank officer ................Plaintiff
Versus
1. Sh. Amlesh Kumar Srivastava
Proprietor of M/s Krishna Fruits and Vegetables
S/o Sh. Shyam Lal Srivastava,
R/o House o. 2, Village Pradhan Market,
Near Jaganth Mandir, Sec – 101,
District G.B. Nagar, Uttar Pradesh – 201301.
Also at:
101 MSX Complex,
1st Floor, Opposite V-Mart, Dadri Main Road,
Bhangel, Noida, Near Sector – 82,
Uttar Pradesh – 201301.
2. Smt. Neha
W/o Sh. Amlesh Kumar Srivastava
Address – Baba Fauzi Bhawan,
C/o Sh. Sarjeet Singh Rana,
Gali No. 3, Village Chhalera,
Sector – 44, Noida, U.P. – 201303. ................Defendant
Date of institution
: 10.10.2023
Date of reserving judgment : 10.01.2025
Date of judgment
: 24.01.2025
CS (Comm) No. 378/2023
Punjab & Sind Bank Vs Amlesh Kumar Srivastava
Page no. 1 of 7
-- 1 of 7 --
EX- PARTE JU D G M E N T :
1. Vide this judgment, I shall decide the present suit filed by
the plaintiff for seeking recovery of Rs.13,47,765.26P along
with pendente lite and future interest. The brief facts
necessitated in filing of the present suit are given as under:-
2. The plaintiff has averred that defendant is the proprietor of
M/s Krishna Fruits and Vegetables, he approached them in
December 2019 for seeking cash credit facility under Pradhan
Mantri Mudra Yojana. The plaintiff considered his request and
sanctioned cash credit facility of Rs. 10,00,000 on interest @
9% per annum along with penal interest @ 2%, vide sanction
letter dated 27.12.2019, which was disbursed to him vide loan
account no. 08771300007153.
3. The plaintiff has further averred that defendant was also
provided GECL of Rs.1,80,000/- on 19.06.2020 on interest
@7% per annum. Defendant no. 2 stood as a guarantor for the
said loans and both the defendants had executed requisite
documents in favour of the plaintiff bank for securing these
loan facilities.
4. The defendants however, failed to maintain the financial
discipline, due to which their loan accounts were declared as
NPA on 29.05.2022. The plaintiff sent a legal notice dated
24.03.2023 to the defendants but defendants neither responded
to the same nor regularized their loan accounts.
CS (Comm) No. 378/2023
Punjab & Sind Bank Vs Amlesh Kumar Srivastava
Page no. 2 of 7
-- 2 of 7 --
5. The plaintiff also filed an application under Section 12A
of the Commercial Courts Act before Mediation Centre, East
District for initiating pre-institution mediation with the
defendants but they did not participate in those proceedings
and hence, a non-starter report dated 03.02.2023 was issued.
On the basis of these averments, the present suit has been filed
for adjudication.
6. Summons of this suit were sent at the addresses of the
defendants but they could not be served through ordinary
means, consequently, plaintiff was permitted to serve the
defendants through publication in the news papers i.e. Hindi
daily “Veer Arjun” and English daily “The Statesman” and
also through affixation for 27.08.2024.
7. The plaintiff has served the defendants through publication
as well as affixation. However, despite, the service through
publication and affixation, the defendants failed to put their
appearance before this Court, therefore they were proceeded
ex-parte vide order dated 09.09.2024 and matter was posted
for ex-parte plaintiff evidence on 14.10.2024.
8. In order to prove their case, the plaintiff has examined
Sh. Amit Kumar, Bank Officer of plaintiff bank, who
reiterated the averments made in the plaint in his examination
in chief. PW-1 has exhibited photocopy of Power of Attorney
dated 22.02.2023 as Ex.PW1/1 (OSR), loan application dated
12.12.2019 as Ex.PW1/2, sanction letter dated 27.12.2019 as
CS (Comm) No. 378/2023
Punjab & Sind Bank Vs Amlesh Kumar Srivastava
Page no. 3 of 7
-- 3 of 7 --
Ex.PW1/3, cash credit hypothecation and book debt facility
agreement dated 27.12.2019 as Ex.PW1/4, hypothecation of
goods to secure a demand cash credit dated 27.12.2019 as
Ex.PW1/5, deed of hypothecation dated 27.12.2019 as
Ex.PW1/6, letter of guarantee dated 27.12.2019 executed by
defendant no. 2 as Ex.PW1/7, letter of continuity dated
27.12.2019 as Ex.PW1/8, Offer letter and Sanction letter
under GECL Scheme dated 19.06.2020 as Ex.PW1/9,
acceptance letter dated 19.06.2020 as Ex.PW1/10, deed of
hypothecation under GECL Scheme dated 19.06.2020 as
Ex.PW1/11, Undertaking (GECL) dated 19.06.2020 as
Ex.PW1/12, Term Loan agreement dated 19.06.2020 as
Ex.PW1/13, Addendum to the loan agreement dated
30.09.2021 as Ex.PW1/14, NPA letter as Ex.PW1/15, a copy
of statement of account as Ex.PW1/16, demand notice dated
24.03.2023 as Ex.PW1/17, receipts of speed post as
Ex.PW1/18, Certificate under Section 2A(b) of Banker’s Book
Evidence Act in respect of computer generated documents as
Ex.PW1/19, non-starter report as Ex.PW1/20.
9. I have heard Sh. Pradeep Kumar, Ld. Counsel for the
plaintiff and perused the pleadings, evidence and other
materials placed on record. Perusal of the above shows that
plaintiff had sanctioned cash credit facility of Rs. 10,00,000/-
to defendant no.1 on interest @ 9% per annum with penal
interest @ 2% Per Annum, vide loan account no.
08771300007153. The defendant no. 1 was also provided
GECL facility of Rs.1,80,000/-, vide loan account no.
CS (Comm) No. 378/2023
Punjab & Sind Bank Vs Amlesh Kumar Srivastava
Page no. 4 of 7
-- 4 of 7 --
08771200007764 on 19.06.2020, for which defendant no. 1
executed various documents in favour of the plaintiff bank.
The defendant no. 2 stood as a guarantor for the above loans.
10. The defendant no. 1, however failed to adhere to terms
and conditions of said loans, due to which, his loan
accounts were declared as Non-Performing Asset on
29.05.2022.
11. The summons of this suit have been duly served upon
the defendants through publication as well as through
affixation, but they failed to contest the suit and were
proceeded ex-parte vide order dated 09.09.2024.
12. In order to prove its case, plaintiff has examined
Sh. Amit Kumar as PW-1, who reiterated the averments made
in the plaint in his examination in chief. He also exhibited
documents executed by the defendants in favour of the
plaintiff bank.
13. The testimony of PW-1 has remained unrebutted and
uncontroverted as defendants have chosen not to contest the
present suit despite service of the summons, thus, deemed to
have admitted the same.
14. The plaintiff has thus proved on record that it advanced
cash credit facility of Rs. 10,00,000/- on interest @ 9% per
annum with penal interest @ 2% Per Annum, to defendant no.
CS (Comm) No. 378/2023
Punjab & Sind Bank Vs Amlesh Kumar Srivastava
Page no. 5 of 7
-- 5 of 7 --
1 vide loan account no. 08771300007153. Defendant no. 1
was also provided GECL facility of Rs.1,80,000/-, vide loan
account no. 08771200007764 on 19.06.2020. The plaintiff has
also proved that defendant has failed to adhere to terms and
conditions of the said loans, due to which the said loan
accounts were declared as NPA and as per the Statement of
Account Ex.PW-1/16 a total sum of Rs.13,47,765.26P
{Rs.11,24,048/- (towards cash credit facility) + Rs.2,23,717/-
(towards GECL facility)} was due and recoverable against the
defendant as on 31.08.2023, towards both cash credit facility
as well as GECL facility, granted by the plaintiff to the
defendants, which they have failed to pay.
15. The defendant no. 2 stood as a guarantor for the
repayment of the loan advanced to defendant no. 1, vide letter
of guarantee dated 27.12.2019 Ex.PW-1/7. Thus, the liability
of defendant no. 2 to repay the said loans is co-existent with
defendant no. 1 as per Section 128 of the Contract Act,
therefore, he is also liable to pay the said amount along with
defendant no. 1.
16. The plaintiff has also claimed pendente lite and future
interest @ 11.85% Per Annum for the amount of cash credit
facility and @ 7% per annum for GECL facility from the date
of filing of he suit till the realization of entire amount.
However, considering the facts and circumstances, I am of the
considered view that interest of justice would be served, if
plaintiff is awarded interest @ 7% per annum each for both
CS (Comm) No. 378/2023
Punjab & Sind Bank Vs Amlesh Kumar Srivastava
Page no. 6 of 7
-- 6 of 7 --
cash credit facility and GECL facility, from the date of filing
of the suit till the realization of the amount.
17. In view of the above facts and circumstances, the suit
filed by the plaintiff against the defendant is decreed with cost.
A Decree of recovery of Rs. 13,47,765.26P is passed in favour
of the plaintiff and against the defendant along with interest @
7% Per Annum from the date of filing of the suit till the
realization of the amount. A Decree Sheet be prepared
accordingly.
File be consigned to Record Room after due compliance.
Announced in the open Court
on 24th of January, 2025.
(PITAMBER DUTT)
District Judge (Commercial Court)-01
East District Karkardooma Courts, Delhi
CS (Comm) No. 378/2023
Punjab & Sind Bank Vs Amlesh Kumar Srivastava
Page no. 7 of 7
-- 7 of 7 --