Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 06 Oct 2023 · CNR DLET010119522023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: (1) Bail Matter No. 1459/2023 State Vs Vikas Choudhary FIR No. 424/2023 U/s 302/34 IPC P.S. Mandawali 06.10.2023 Present :- Sh. Sunil Dutt, Ld. Addl. P. P. for the State. Sh. Ajay Chaudhary, Ld. Counsel for applicant/accused Vikas Choudhary. Sh. Rajesh Kaushik, Ld. Counsel for the complainant. IO/Inspector Vijay Kumar is present. Ld. Counsel for the applicant/accused has filed the certified copy of the order dated 14.08.2023 passed in bail application No. 1230/2023 vide the which the previous application U/s 439 Cr.P.C. filed on behalf of the applicant/accused was dismissed as withdrawn. Same is taken on record. The IO has filed the previous conviction/involvement report of the accused/applicant, as per which there is no previous involvement of the applicant/accused. Remaining arguments on the bail application have been advanced by Ld. Counsel for the applicant/accused as well as Ld. Addl. P. P. for the State who is assisted by the IO and Ld. Counsel for the complainant. Ld. Counsel for complainant relied upon the judgment i.e. Ishwarji Nagaji Mali Vs. State of Gujarat & Anr II (2022) SLT 112 and Ld. defence counsel relied on the order passed by Hon’ble Delhi High Court in Yashwant Kumar Vs. State of NCT of Delhi, Bail Application No. 3209/2022 dated 05.12.2022 (Manu/DEOR/205700/2022). -- 1 of 6 -- (2) Put up for orders during the course of the day. (Anjani Mahajan) ASJ (FTSC) (RC), East/KKD Courts Delhi/06.10.2023 At 3.30 PM Present :- Sh. Sunil Dutt, Ld. Addl. P. P. for the State. None for applicant/accused Vikas Choudhary. None for the complainant. (1) This is stated to be the second application for grant of bail U/s 439 Cr.P.C. on behalf of the applicant/accused Vikas Choudhary. The first bail application was dismissed as withdrawn vide order dated 14.08.2023 passed in bail application no. 1230/2023. (2) Reply to the application was filed by the IO alongwith the previous involvement/conviction report of the accused. (3) The brief facts of the case as per the reply of the bail application as filed by the IO are that on 20.06.2023 a PCR call vide GD No. 60 A regarding stabbing of a lady under Railway Pullia, Mandawali, Delhi was received at PS Mandawali. Police officials reached the spot where they found on the left carriage way under the Railway Pullia a pink dupatta with blood stains, a ladies slipper and spectacles lying near the wall. It was revealed that the injured lady Mrs. Sudha Gupta had been sent to Metro Hospital by passersby and was unfit for statement. Her family members had shifted to her to Max Hospital, Patparganj where she was declared brought dead. On the basis of PCR call case U/s 302/34 IPC was registered. During the course of the investigation inter-alia, CCTV footage of large number of CCTV Cameras and -- 2 of 6 -- (3) CDRs of several numbres were analyzed and ultimately three accused persons were identified. All three persons were riding a silver colored bike to follow the deceased Sudha Gupta who was on a red colored scooty. On Kalyan Marg under Railway Pullia, they stopped her and killed her. On 21.06.2023, accused persons Monu Dedha @ Chacha, Sarthak Nagar @ Laddu and Puspender Yadav @ Aiiya were apprehended from Vatika Kunj Colony, Haryana and arrested as per law. They also disclosed about the involvement of the present applicant/accused Vikas Choudhary @ Lalla who waited for the aforesaid three accused persons at Mangalam Chowk, West Vinod Nagar, Delhi with his Santro Car as per plan. The accused persons Monu Dedha @ Chacha, Sarthak Nagar @ Laddu and Puspender Yadav @ Aiiya over- powered the deceased and started stabbing her with pockers till she was completely silent and they ran away from the spot on the bike and when they reached Manglam Chowk the accused Vikas Choudhary @ Lala was present and they left Delhi in the Santro car driven by the applicant/accused Vikas Choudhary who dropped them at village Baliyawas, Gurugram, Haryana and returned to Mandawali so as to keep a watch on the movement of the police. (4) It is averred in the present bail application that as per the version of police itself, the applicant/accused Vikas Choudhary @ Lalla was not at the scene of crime and the only allegation against him is that he had dropped the co-accused persons to the place where they went after commission of the offence. It is alleged that the applicant has no role to play and is a victim as he did not have any knowledge about what the other co-accused persons were planning and was merely an -- 3 of 6 -- (4) acquaintance of the accused persons sharing the same caste and community with one of the accused (stated during the course of arguments to be the accused Monu Dedha). It is contended in the present bail application that the co-accused persons had called the applicant/accused saying they had a fight in the family and asking him to drop them to some place where they could stay in the meanwhile and the applicant in good faith without knowledge of commission of any offence had dropped them to the place that they asked. Further, the applicant helped the police to nab the co- accused persons by taking the police where the co-accused persons were present. (5) Arguments along the lines of the averments made in the respective application and reply were advanced by Ld. Counsel for the applicant/accused and Ld. Addl. PP for the State who was assisted by the IO and Ld. Counsel for the complainant. (6) It was inter-alia argued by Ld. Counsel for the applicant/accused that the applicant/accused was not required for any custodial interrogation and the charge-sheet had already been filed in the present case on 19.09.2023. He argued that there was CCTV footage of outside the house of the applicant/accused to show that he left his house at 1.57 pm that day and if he had received the phone call from Monu Dedha at 1.13 pm in pursuance to alleged conspiracy then he would have immediately left the house maximum within 10 minutes as he would already have been prepared instead of leaving so late. In this regard Ld. Counsel for the applicant/accused showed alleged footage on his mobile phone stated to be of outside the house of the applicant/accused to show the applicant/accused leaving the house at 1.57 pm. -- 4 of 6 -- (5) (7) Ld. Addl. PP for the State argued that there were grave allegations against the applicant/accused who was having regular conversations with the main accused Monu Dedha and the applicant/accused was an active conspirator who knew exactly where to wait alongwith his car i.e. near the highway which was about 2.5 – 3 km away from the place of incident. The IO argued that the co-accused persons were having blood stains on their shirts and the shirts of the co-accused persons have been seized in this regard and also they had thrown the alleged murder weapons from the moving car and if the applicant/accused was so innocent than he would have informed the police and co-operated in the investigation but he chose not to do so. (8) Heard. Perused. (9) In the present case, the allegations against the applicant/accused are serious in nature wherein the offence U/s 302/34 IPC has been alleged. The Santro vehicle in question has been recovered at the instance of the applicant/accused. As per the reply of the IO, during the course of investigation, the CDR of the applicant/accused has been collected and analyzed which shows that he was in regular touch with the main conspirator Monu Dedha, there being 44 telephonic conversations between them from 02.06.2023 to 18.06.2023 and single calls only on 19 and 20 June 2023 when they purported executed the alleged conspiracy. The alleged incident occurred at about 2.15 pm and as per the CDR, at 2.22 pm the location of the applicant/accused was found at West Vinod Nagar, the alleged pick up point being Mangalam Chowk, West Vinod Nagar, Delhi and it could be argued that, as per the alleged pre planning and conspiracy, the applicant/accused reached the alleged pick up point within time, -- 5 of 6 -- (6) so the argument that the applicant/accused left his house at 1.57 pm is of no assistance to the applicant/accused at this stage. The applicant/accused did not choose to inform the police about the suspicious activity of the co-accused persons in throwing the alleged weapons from the car and having blood stains on their shirts. All of the aforesaid facts prima facie point to the alleged involvement of the applicant/accused in the conspiracy. The order of Hon’ble Delhi High Court in Yashwant Kumar Vs State of NCT of Delhi (supra) does not come to the assistance of the applicant/accused being distinguishable on the facts. (10) Moreover, as per the reply of the IO, in the postmortem report of the victim, the cause of death was given as shock due to multiple penetrating stab injuries to abdomen, chest and head and doctor described around 86 stab injuries. (11) Considering the grave nature of allegations against the applicant/accused, the nature of injuries sustained by the victim which resulted in her death reflecting the ruthless and brazen manner in which the alleged offence was committed in a public place, I do not deem it fit to grant bail to the applicant/accused Vikas Choudhary at this stage. (12) The present bail application of the applicant/accused Vikas Choudhary S/o Sh. Vinod Choudhary is accordingly dismissed. (13) Copy of this order be given dasti to Ld. counsel for the applicant/accused through the Bail Section as per rules. (14) Application be consigned to Record Room. (Anjani Mahajan) ASJ (FTSC) (RC), East/KKD Courts Delhi/06.10.2023 -- 6 of 6 --
