Full Order Text
Final Order 8 · 25 Apr 2026 · CNR DLET010051942025
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. HEM SINGH, DISTRICT JUDGE -01, EAST DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI GP No 8/25 CNR No. DLET010051942025 In the matter of: Smt. Nanni Devi W/o Late Sh. Puran Lal R/o H. No. 245/5, Gali No. 7, School Block, Mandawali, East Delhi-110092 .....Petitioner Versus 1. Branch Manager Indian Overseas Bank, Preet Vihar Branch, Delhi-110092 2. State (Govt. NCT of Delhi) Through Chief Secretary; Delhi Secretariat, New Delhi 3. District Magistrate (East District, Delhi), DC Office, East District, Shashtri Nagar, Delhi-110051 .....Respondents Date of Institution : 08.10.2025 Reserved for order on : 02.04.2026 Date of Decision : 25.04.2026 GP No. 8/25 Nanni Devi Pages 1 of 8 Vs. Indian Overseas Bank And Ors. -- 1 of 8 -- PETITION U/S 14 OF THE RIGHTS OF PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, 2016 JUDGMENT 1. FACTS: a) The present petition has been filed by Smt. Nanni Devi who is the mother and sole surviving caregiver of Ms. Sunita, an adult daughter aged approximately 37 years, suffering from 90% permanent intellectual disability as certified by the competent medical authority. b) It is averred in the petition that following the demise of her husband, Late Sh. Puran Lal, in 2024, the Petitioner has been solely responsible for the care, supervision, and maintenance of her daughter, who is entirely dependent on her for survival, medical treatment, and daily needs. c) It is stated that the Petitioner resides with her children, including Ms. Sunita and her youngest daughter Sonia, and personally attends to all caregiving responsibilities without external assistance. That Ms. Sunita has no movable or immovable property in her name, except for a savings bank account with Indian Overseas Bank, Preet Vihar, Delhi, and a pension account with Punjab National Bank, Mandawali, Delhi which are maintained for her welfare and future needs. That the Petitioner has been acting as the de facto guardian and has been withdrawing pension amounts for her daughter’s upkeep. d) It is further stated that after the death of Late Sh. Puran Lal, GP No. 8/25 Nanni Devi Pages 2 of 8 Vs. Indian Overseas Bank And Ors. -- 2 of 8 -- the Respondent no. 1/Bank (Indian Overseas Bank) has refused to allow the Petitioner to operate the account or withdraw funds, insisting on a formal guardianship order from a competent court. This has resulted in denial of access to essential funds required for the basic sustenance and medical care of Ms. Sunita. e) This Hon’ble Court has territorial jurisdiction, as both the Petitioner and the subject person reside in Mandawali, East District, Delhi, and the Respondents are located within the same jurisdiction. 2. PROCEEDINGS: a) The notice of the petition was issued to the respondents. The respondent no.1/State as well as general public was served by way of publication in the newspaper “The Statesmen” dated 11.01.2026. b) Despite publication in the newspaper and notice to general public at large, no one has came forward to make any objection in respect of the prayer made by the petitioner in the present petition. c) Respondent no. 2/State filed its report mentioning the details of legal heirs of Lt. Sh. Puran Lal. Respondent no. 1 despite service of notice, never appeared, hence, was proceeded ex-parte vide order dated 18.12.2025 3. ISSUES: Following issues were framed vide order dated 25.02.2026: (i) Whether the petitioner is entitled to be appointed as Guardian of subject person Sunita, as prayed for?OPP (ii) Relief. GP No. 8/25 Nanni Devi Pages 3 of 8 Vs. Indian Overseas Bank And Ors. -- 3 of 8 -- 4. EVIDENCE: a) Plaintiff stepped into witness box and examined herself as PW1. She tendered her evidence by way of affidavit Ex.PW1/A and has also placed reliance upon the following documents: Ex.PW1/1 (OSR)- Copy of Aadhar Card of petitioner. Ex.PW1/2 (OSR)- Copy of PAN Card of petitioner. Ex.PW1/3 (OSR)- Copy of death certificate of Lt. Puran Lal. Ex.PW1/4 (OSR)- Copy of Permanent Disability Certificate of Ms. Sunita. Ex.PW1/5 (OSR)- Copy of Unique Disability ID (UDID) Card of Ms. Sunita. Ex.PW1/6 (OSR)- Copy of savings bank passbook bearing A/c no. 130501000014330, Indian Overseas Bank, Preet Vihar Branch, Delhi. Ex.PW1/7 (OSR)- Copy of Pension Account Passbook bearing A/c no. 6023001700054970, Punjab National Bank. Ex.PW1/8 (OSR)- Copy of Aadhar Card of Ms. Sunita as residence proof. PW1 was not cross-examined as there is no contesting respondent. b) No other witness was examined by the petitioner. Thereafter, GP No. 8/25 Nanni Devi Pages 4 of 8 Vs. Indian Overseas Bank And Ors. -- 4 of 8 -- petitioner's evidence was closed vide her separate statement on 02.04.2026. c) Final arguments heard. Record perused. Considered. 5. FINDINGS: Issue no. 1: “Whether the petitioner is entitled to be appointed as Guardian of subject person Sunita, as prayed for?OPP” a) As per the case of the petitioner she is the mother of Smt. Sunita, the subject person, who is suffering from 90% permanent intellectual disability. The petitioner has placed on record the copy of Permanent Disability Certificate of the Ms. Sunita and exhibited the same as Ex.PW1/4 (OSR). A perusal of the same would show that the case of the subject person is severe intellectual impairment and her mental disability is 90%. Considering the nature and extent of mental disability of the subject person, this Court is satisfied that Ms. Sunita is not in a position to take her decisions independently. The father of the subject person has already expired and his death certificate is also on record. The family of the petitioner and subject person consists of petitioner and her four daughters and one son. It is not in dispute that the petitioner is the mother of subject person. b) As per Rule 7(6) of the Delhi Rights of Persons with Disabilities Rules, 2018 the Court shall consider a suitable person to be appointed as a limited guardian in the following preference of merit, namely:- (i) The parents or adult children of the person with disability; GP No. 8/25 Nanni Devi Pages 5 of 8 Vs. Indian Overseas Bank And Ors. -- 5 of 8 -- (ii) Immediate brother or sister; (ii) Other Blood relatives or care givers or prominent personality of the locality; and (iv) In case the family of the person with disability is not known, Superintendent of the Government Institution or In charge of the Registered organization under whose care the person with disability is residing, may be considered. c) In the case in hand the father of the subject person has already expired. The subject person is only survived by her mother (petitioner, herein) and her real sisters/brother. Therefore, in considered opinion of this court, the petitioner is the most suitable person to be appointed as limited guardian of the subject person. d) It is apposite to mention section 14 (1) of The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016. Section 14 of The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016: (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, on and from the date of commencement of this Act, where a district court or any designated authority, as notified by the State Government, finds that a person with disability, who had been provided adequate and appropriate support but is unable to take legally binding decisions, may be provided further support of a limited guardian to take legally binding decisions on his behalf in consultation with such person, in such manner, as may be prescribed by the State Government: Provided that the District Court or the designated authority, as the case may be, may grant total GP No. 8/25 Nanni Devi Pages 6 of 8 Vs. Indian Overseas Bank And Ors. -- 6 of 8 -- support to the person with disability requiring such support or where the limited guardianship is to be granted repeatedly, in which case, the decision regarding the support to be provided shall be reviewed by the Court or the designated authority, as the case may be, to determine the nature and manner of support to be provided. e) Section 14 of the Act provides for appointment of limited guardian to take legally binding decisions for person with disability. The object of Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 is to protect the interest and to provide due care to the persons with disability. In the present petition, the petitioner has proved that she is the mother of Ms. Sunita. It cannot be said that the petitioner is having any interest adverse to the interest of Ms. Sunita. The petitioner is the person who is currently taking care of Ms. Sunita. The petitioner has also deposed that Ms. Sunita is only having a savings bank account and a pension account in her name, and the respondent no. 1 i.e, Bank has refused to allow the petitioner to operate the said saving account and withdraw funds, therefore, an inference can be drawn that petitioner has moved the instant petition with sole intention to assume responsibility of her daughter and she is having no interest adverse to that of Ms. Sunita. Issue no. 2: “RELIEF” a) In view of aforesaid discussion, there is no impediment in allowing the present petition and issuing limited Guardianship Certificate in favour of petitioner to take legally binding decisions GP No. 8/25 Nanni Devi Pages 7 of 8 Vs. Indian Overseas Bank And Ors. -- 7 of 8 -- on behalf of Ms. Sunita. The petitioner is also permitted to operate saving bank account no. 130501000014330 in the Indian Overseas Bank, Preet Vihar Branch, Delhi. The certificate shall remain effective for a period of three years which can be further extended by the District Court as per rules. 6. Accordingly, limited Guardianship Certificate is ordered to be issued in favour of the petitioner in respect of Ms. Sunita and respondent no. 1 is hereby directed to permit the petitioner to operate the savings bank account of Ms. Sunita. Furthermore, petitioner is directed not to do any act which may be proved contrary to the interests of Ms. Sunita. Petitioner is also directed to file yearly statement of account in respect of amount withdrawn from the saving bank account and expenses incurred upon the subject person. Ordered accordingly. File be consigned to record room as per rules. Pronounced in the open Court Sh. Hem Singh on 25.04.2026 District Judge-01 East/KKD Courts/New Delhi GP No. 8/25 Nanni Devi Pages 8 of 8 Vs. Indian Overseas Bank And Ors. -- 8 of 8 --
