Full Order Text
Final Order 14 · 05 Dec 2025 · CNR DLET010041162024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. HEM SINGH, LD. DISTRICT JUDGE-01, EAST DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI Misc. DJ 303/24 In the matter of:- Lalit Kumar .........DH/ Non-Applicant Versus Madan Mohan Bhatia …....JD/ Applicant 05.12.2025 ORDER a) Vide this order I shall dispose of the application filed on behalf of applicants/JD (JD in CS No.492/18) under Order XXXVII Rule 4 CPC for setting aside the judgment/decree dated 12.12.2018. b) The plaintiff/DH/non applicant has filed reply to the present application denying all the assertions made therein and has prayed for dismissal of the said application. c) Arguments were heard on behalf of the parties. d) During the course of arguments, Ld. counsel for applicant/JD argued and submitted that the present case was filed by the plaintiff against the JD for recovery of Rs.7,82,925/- under order XXXVII CPC and the summons of the suit were never served upon the JD, therefore Misc DJ 303/24 Lalit Kumar VS. Madan Mohan Bhatia Page no. 1OF 9 -- 1 of 9 -- JD could not enter his appearance within the stipulated period of 10 days and therefore, the suit was decreed on 12.12.2018 against the JD. Ld. Counsel for applicant further submitted that the JD came to know about the filing of the said suit and execution on 18.07.2024 when he was arrested in pursuant of warrant of arrest issued in Execution Petition No. 308/2019. e) It is argued on behalf of Applicant/JD that summons of the suit were never served upon the JD. Ld. counsel for the applicant/ JD referred the report of process server wherein it is stated that on the day of visit of process server the premises of the JD that is situated at the top floor of property bearing no.13/139, Geeta Colony, Delhi-110031 was found locked. It is further argued by Ld. counsel for the applicant that from the report of the process server inference can be drawn in respect of absence of applicant/JD at his premises and further inference can be drawn that the speed post envelope were delivered to the resident of other floors of the said property, who are the relatives of the JD, however residing separately from JD and having no talking terms with the JD as a litigation of partition were pending between JD and other occupants of the property bearing no. 13/139, Geeta Colony, Delhi-110031. It is further argued that even from the tracking report of the speed post envelope it is not clarified by whom the said speed post was received. It is further argued that even in the memo of parties filed along-with the plaint the floor of the JD has not been mentioned by the DH. It is further argued that during the relevant period the JD was not present at home and he was hospitalized for his surgery of prostate. Misc DJ 303/24 Lalit Kumar VS. Madan Mohan Bhatia Page no. 2OF 9 -- 2 of 9 -- f) It is further argued that on the merits of the case JD is entitled for leave to defend as JD had never taken a loan of Rs.12,00,000/- from the DH and he had taken only a sum of Rs.4,00,000/- which was given by the DH to JD by way of cheques. No amount in cash ever paid by the DH to the JD. At the time of advancement of said amount of Rs.4,00,000/-, plaintiff had taken signature of the JD on blank promissory note and thereafter filled the figure of Rs.12,00,000/- in the said promissory note. It is further argued that the said amount of Rs.4,00,000/- has already been repaid by the JD to the DH with additional amount of Rs.1,50,000/- being interest. It is further argued that at the time of advancement of said loan DH had also took two blank cheques wherein he himself filled Rs.12,00,000/-. It is further argued that no written agreement was ever executed between the DH and JD in respect of said loan and therefore there is no signature of witnesses on the promissory note. It is further argued that the DH has nowhere disclose the source of Rs.8,00,000/- which was allegedly paid by him to the JD. g) On the other hand, Ld. Counsel for the non-applicant/DH argued that summons of the suit was duly served upon the correct address, which is mentioned in the election I D card of the applicant on 08.09.2018. It is argued that it is nowhere mentioned in the medical documents of the applicant that he was hospitalized on 08.09.2018. It is argued that from a perusal of the I D card of the applicant it would reveal that that no floor is mentioned therein, therefore, applicant cannot be allowed to take stand that the summons of the suit was received by other occupants of the building residing at the lower floors. It is argued Misc DJ 303/24 Lalit Kumar VS. Madan Mohan Bhatia Page no. 3OF 9 -- 3 of 9 -- that the applicant had knowledge of the decree on 31.07.2019, since on said date bailiff had approached the applicant for execution of warrants of attachment, however, applicant refused to pay decreetal amount. It is further argued that even notice to show cause for arrest was also refused by the applicant. h) It is further argued that the applicant has admitted his signatures on the promissory note therefore in view of section 20 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 and section 91 & 92 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, applicant cannot dispute the contents thereof. It is also argued that in discharge of his liability the applicant also issued a cheque in favour of the non-applicant/DH, which also confirms that the applicant has taken a loan of Rs.12,00,000/- from the non-applicant/DH. i) As there is delay in filing the instant application, the applicant has also filed application under section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 stating that the application came to know about the judgment & decree dated 12.12.2018 only on 18.07.2024 when he was arrested by the police pursuant to execution of warrant of arrest issued against him. No other reason except as mentioned above is mentioned in the delay application. j) As per Article 123 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act, the application seeking setting aside ex-parte decree is required to be moved within 30 days from "the date of decree or where the summons or notice was not duly served, when the applicant had knowledge of the decree". k) In the instant case the judgment and decree was passed on Misc DJ 303/24 Lalit Kumar VS. Madan Mohan Bhatia Page no. 4OF 9 -- 4 of 9 -- 12.12.2018, whereas the present application has been filed by the applicant/JD only on 27.07.2024. Ld. Counsel for the non-applicant/DH draw attention of this Court the report of bailiff dated 31.07.2019 filed in execution petition no. 308/2019. The contents of the said report are reproduced hereunder: Misc DJ 303/24 Lalit Kumar VS. Madan Mohan Bhatia Page no. 5OF 9 -- 5 of 9 -- l) A perusal of the aforesaid report reveals that JD came to know about the judgment & decree dated 12.12.2018 on 31.07.2019. m) Ld. Counsel for the DH also draw attention of this Court to the bailiff report dated 17.09.2019. The contents of the said report are reproduced hereunder: Misc DJ 303/24 Lalit Kumar VS. Madan Mohan Bhatia Page no. 6OF 9 -- 6 of 9 -- n) Ld. Counsel for the DH also draw attention of this Court to the process server’s report dated 28.02.2020. The contents of the said report are reproduced hereunder: Misc DJ 303/24 Lalit Kumar VS. Madan Mohan Bhatia Page no. 7OF 9 -- 7 of 9 -- o) A perusal of the aforesaid reports reveals that JD came to know about the judgment & decree dated 12.12.2018 on 31.07.2019, again on 17.09.2019 and thereafter on 28.02.2020 much prior to the alleged date of knowledge. p) Therefore, the instant application which has been filed almost after five years from the date of passing of decree as well as knowledge of judgment dated 12.12.2018 is hopelessly barred by limitation, hence deserves dismissal on this ground. q) So far as the service of summons of the suit concern, Ld. Counsel for the DH/non-applicant argued that as per the documents placed on record by the applicant, he has been residing at 13/139, Geeta Colony, Delhi 110031. It is the stand of the applicant that he is residing at the top floor of the aforesaid property and summons of the suit was served upon other occupants of the said property residing at lower floors of said property. Ld. Counsel for the DH has draw attention of this Court to para “7-h” of the instant application wherein the applicant has admitted the receiving of legal notice dated 25.11.2017. The said notice was sent at the aforesaid address of the applicant, therefore the contention of the applicant/JD that he was not served with the summons of the suit is not well found. Even from the report of the process server dated 14.09.2018 it can be inferred that the address mentioned in the suit is the address of the applicant, therefore, mere denial of the applicant is not sufficient to infer that summons of the suit were not delivered to the applicant at the said address. Hence the instant applicant deserves dismissal on this ground also. Misc DJ 303/24 Lalit Kumar VS. Madan Mohan Bhatia Page no. 8OF 9 -- 8 of 9 -- r) Therefore, in view of above discussion, this Court is of the view that the present application filed by the applicant/JD for setting aside decree dated 12.12.2018 do not inspire any confidence of the court and same is accordingly dismissed. Application stands disposed off. File be consigned to Record Room as per rules. Announced in the open court On 05.12.2025 (HEM SINGH) District Judge-01 (East) Karkardooma Courts, Delhi Misc DJ 303/24 Lalit Kumar VS. Madan Mohan Bhatia Page no. 9OF 9 -- 9 of 9 --
