Full Order Text
Order 10 · 25 Aug 2026 · CNR DLET010036032026
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: SC 520/2026 with IA NO. 01/2026 STATE VS. SAMIR@GAZI FIR No. 64/2026 PS (Laxmi nagar) CNR No. DLET010036032026 25.08.2026 Pr.: Sh. S.K. Tripathi, Ld. Addl. PP for the State. Accused Samir @ Gazi has been produced from JC. Mohd. Tasleem, Ld. Counsel for accused. IO/SI Prashant Malik in person. Arguments heard on charge. It appears that some persons who were known to each other were at one place and during conversation amongst them one of those persons namely Samir @ Gazi started asking for protection money from Yash Verma and threatened in case he refused to give the money. When Yash Verma did not give the money, then Samir @ Gazi, Ankush and Saad took his bike. The case apparently was of robbery but in the statement of Yash Verma one sentence has appeared i.e. “Gazi Ne Apni Aunt Mein Lagi Pistol Mujhe Dikhai”. This statement apparently has prompted the police to also invoke Section 311 of BNS. Police investigated the matter and recovered the bike. The police also recovered a pistol from the house of Samir @ Gazi. Finally, the police file chargehseet on conclusion of the investigation and inducted Samir @ Gazi and Saad whereas Ankush was treated a CCL. The chargesheet has mentioned the offence u/s 309/311 of BNS and Section 25 of Arms Act. Section 311 BNS is triable by Sessions Court. Therefore, the Ld. Magistrate committed the case. Perusal of this provision shows that it comes into picture when the offender uses any deadly weapon. Subsequent recovery of any fire arm from house of any accused cannot -- 1 of 2 -- : 2 : justify the claim that the same was used during the robbery. The complainant does not claim that accused had taken out the fire arm and had then threatened him. The video footage relied on by the prosecution does not show availability of fire arm with accused Samir in any manner. In the video footage, the accused Samir appears to be wearing Paijama with long Kurta. It is hard to accept that he could have carried a pistol which was visible to the complainant. It seems that complainant has just given his version on assumption that Samir might be in possession of any pistol. This is however not sufficient to discard the CCTV footage which the IO has shown today on his mobile to the Ld. Opposite counsel, Ld. Addl. PP and to the Court. No doubt, at the stage of charge, minute appreciation is not required but at the same time, we cannot allow a trial on the basis of mere ipse-dixit of complainant. I am of the view that Section 311 BNS is not made out on the available material. All other offences mentioned in the chargesheet are triable by a Magisterial Court. Let the file be placed before the Ld. Principal District & Sessions Judge, East, KKD Courts, on 29.08.2026 so that the same can be marked to court of a Ld. Magistrate. So far as pending bail application is concerned, Ld. Counsel submits that the same may also be considered by the Ld. Magistrate as the main case is being transferred to the Ld. Magisterial Court. Since the bail application was filed in a pending case and now the case is being transferred, I consider that request of Ld. Counsel should be accepted and the Ld. Magistrate can consider the application u/s 480 of BNS. (Rakesh Kumar Singh) ASJ-02,East, KKD Courts, Delhi/25.08.2026 -- 2 of 2 --
