Full Order Text
Interim Order 10 · 10 Nov 2025 · CNR DLET010012172025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS (COMM) No. 75/25 Punjab National Bank Vs. Nisha Khandelwal & Ors. 10.11.2025 Present: Sh. Sunav Rastogi, Ld. Counsel for plaintiff. Sh. Shubham Singh Mahur and Shri Gaurav Singh, Ld. Counsel for defendants No. 1 to 3. Sh.Argha Roy, Ld. Counsel for defendant No. 4. Reply to applications for setting aside of ex-parte order and condonation of delay filed by the plaintiff. Copy supplied. Arguments heard. Ld. Counsel for defendants no. 1,2 & 3 has submitted that this case was listed for hearing on 15.09.2025 but the defendants could not appear owing to some family dispute, which was beyond their control. It is further argued that the defendants were not aware about court proceedings and were proceeded ex- parte. It is further argued that the defendants have good case on merits and would suffer irreparable loss, if opportunity to contest this case is not granted. It is further argued that there is some delay in filing of this application on account of some unavoidable personal reasons and delaying in filing application may be condoned and ex-parte order may be set aside. On the other hand, Ld. Counsel for plaintiff has opposed this application on the ground that no specific reason has been assigned for non-appearance of the defendants except a vague ground that the defendants could not appear due to some unavoidable personal reasons, whereas no such reason has been -- 1 of 4 -- -2- explained, due to vague reason is not a ground for condonation of delay or setting aside of ex-parte order and both applications are liable to be dismissed. I have heard the arguments and perused the record. No doubt the defendants have not disclosed any specific reason for non-appearance except stating that they could not appear due to some personal reasons, whereas Ld. Counsel for defendants has cited his personal ground for non-appearance, which is not mentioned in this application. However, present suit is a commercial suit and the defendants would suffer irreparable loss, if they are not allowed to contest this case. Accordingly, delay in moving application for setting aside of ex-parte order is hereby condoned and ex-parte order dated 15.09.2025 is hereby set aside. Ld. Counsel for defendants has submitted that WS filed by the defendants No. 1 to 3 may also be taken on record, which is strongly opposed by Ld. Counsel for plaintiff. Admittedly, WS in commercial suit must be filed within outer limit of 120 days and delay beyond this period cannot be condoned in any manner or any ground whatsoever. In this case, the defendants were duly served with summons 28.04.2025 and appeared through Counsel on 06.04.2025. The period to file WS was upto 24.08.2025, whereas the defendants were proceeded ex- parte on 15.09.2025, thereby meaning beyond the period of 120 days. In fact, application for setting aside of ex-parte order cannot extend period of limitation to file WS. -- 2 of 4 -- -3- Perusal of order sheet dated 15.09.2025 would show that it was recorded that the defendants had filed their WS, whereas they did not file any WS and rather have filed today. However, this written statement is also not according to provisions of Commercial Courts Act, as it is neither supported by any statement of truth, nor signed by the defendants on each and every page/s, nor supported by affidavit of admission/denial of documents. Accordingly, such WS filed on behalf of the defendants no. 1, 2 & 3 cannot be taken on record, hence rejected. The defense of the defendants is hereby struck off. Defendant No. 4 Suman Khandelwal was served way back on 24.04.2025 and outer limitation to file WS was by 24.08.2025, whereas she has filed WS on 21.08.2025, thereby meaning within a period of 120 days. Defendant no.4 has filed one application for condonation of delay in filing WS on the ground that her mother was seriously ill, due to she could not file WS. In support of this submission, the defendant has also filed medical prescription, as per which, her mother was expected to be admitted on 21.07.2025 and was to be discharged on 29.07.2025 for conservative treatment, whereas no other document has been placed on record to prove that she really got admitted to hospital. However, in view of nature of liability of the defendants viz a viz claim of the plaintiff, WS of defendant No. 4 accompanied with affidavit of admission/denial of documents is taken on record after condonation of delay in filing WS, subject to cost of Rs. 5,000/- to be paid to the plaintiff. -- 3 of 4 -- -4- Let replication if any and affidavit of admission-denial of documents be filed by the plaintiff within two weeks with advance copy to opposite party. Put up for completion of pleadings/admission-denial of documents/ issues on 03.12.2025. Both the parties shall appear on the next date of hearing for admission-denial of documents. (Devender Kumar) District Judge (Commercial Court)-01 East District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi /10.11.2025 -- 4 of 4 --
