Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 12

CNR DLCT13002229202128 Apr 2023
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 12 · 28 Apr 2023 · CNR DLCT130022292021

Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS
Pdf Text: LCA No. 491/21
LAKSHMAN
Vs.
North Delhi Municipal Corporation
28.04.2023
Present: Sh. Intjar Ali, AR for the Claimant.
Sh. Harinder, UDC/DEMS/KPZ of MCD.
The present petition has been filed by the claimant
claiming that he is employee of the management and
management has not cleared its dues pertaining to following
heads:
A. The dues regarding arrear of regularization
B. Arrear of non-metric
C. Arrear of MACP
D. Arrear of 7th CPC
MCD/Management has filed service record and
calculation sheet admitting the claimant to be its employee and
also admitting that the details of outstanding dues under various
heads: (a) Rs.21,269/- towards amount of Daily Wager
difference; (b) Rs.1,12,459/- towards arrear of non-metric; (c)
Rs.46,498/- towards arrear of MACP; (c) Rs.30,186/- towards
arrear of 7th CPC for total amount Rs.2,10,412/-. Copy given.
Statement of Sh. Intjar Ali, AR for the applicant has
been recorded, separately, whereby he has admitted the
correctness of calculation filed by the management and requested
that matter may be disposed off on the basis of calculation given
by the management.
Contd. 2/-
-- 1 of 4 --
-: 2 :-
Scope and ambit of Section 33-C(2) of I.D. Act
has been discussed in para 13 of judgment titled “Jeet Lal
Sharma Vs. Presiding Officer, Labour Court-IV & Anr.” 2000
IV AD (Del) wherein Hon’ble High Court of Delhi after
referring to a series of judgments of Hon’ble Apex Court titled
(i) “Punjab National Bank Vs. K. L. Kharbanda” reported in
1962 (1) LLJ 234; (ii) “Central Bank of India Vs. P.S.
Rajagoplan” reported in 1963 (2) LLJ 89; (iii) “Bombay Gas
Company Limited Vs. Gopal Bhiva” reported in 1963 (2) LLJ
608; (iv) “Chief Engineer Mining, East India Coal Company
Limited Vs. Rameshwar” reported in 1968 (1) Lab I.C.6 SC and
(v) “Municipal Corporation of Delhi Vs. Ganesh Razak”
reported in 1995 (1) SCC 335 has observed:
“13. When the claim is based on adjudication or
settlement it poses no difficulty. However there may
be cases where the workman would be held entitled
to receive the money as pre-existing right on the
basis of the agreement between the employer and
employee or as per established service conditions
which have culminated into right in favour of the
workman…...
It was also held by Hon’ble Apex Court that
application under section 33-C(2) would be maintainable and
jurisdiction of Labour Court will not be barred merely because
employer has denied the same in case the right to get a particular
benefit is included in the service conditions. Para 15 and 16
Contd. 3/-
-- 2 of 4 --
-: 3 :-
of judgment of Hon’ble High Court in Jeet Lal Sharma’s case
(supra) w.r.t jurisdiction of Labour Court are reproduced
below for reference:
“15. The point which is emphasized is that
entitlement to receive money i.e. pre-existing right
can be based on (1) adjudication (2) settlement (3)
service conditions. If the right to get a particular
benefit is there, the application u/s. 33-C(2) would
be maintainable and jurisdiction of Labour Court
will not be barred merely because employer has
denied the same.”
“16. What is the meaning of the expression
“entitlement to receive”. No doubt it is referable to
pre-existing right. However where the workman
claims a benefit flowing from a pre-existing and
approaches the Labour Court u/s. 33-C(2) for
computation of the right in term of money and the
employer disputes the existence of the right, the
Labour Court will have jurisdiction to determine the
question whether the right exists and if the existence
of right is established than to proceed to compute
the benefit flowing there from in terms of money or
on its decisions recovery proceedings can start
(New Taj Mahal Café Private Limited versus Labour
Court reported in 1970 (2) LLN 51 and East India
Coal Company Limited (supra). In deciding the
maintainability of the application u/s. 33-C(2) what
Contd. 4/-
-- 3 of 4 --
-: 4 :-
is to be looked at is the claim set up in the
applications and not what the other side contends
in its reply. The fact that the employer by his
plea raises some dispute does not mean that
jurisdiction of Labour Court to deal with the
question is taken away.”
Application under Section 33 C(2) of ID Act, 1947
is therefore allowed under Order 12 Rule 6 of CPC computing
arrears of service benefits Rs.2,10,412/- payable to the applicant
Sh. Laxman S/o Sh. Ramu. Under Section 33-C(4) of I.D. Act,
the copy of order be forwarded to appropriate Govt. for purpose
of recovery under sub-Section (1) of Section 33-C of I.D. Act.
File be consigned to record room.
(Ankit Singla)
Presiding Officer Labour Court- X
Rouse Avenue Courts
New Delhi: 28.04.2023
-- 4 of 4 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.