Full Order Text
Final Order 17 · 12 May 2023 · CNR DLCT130008762021
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF GORAKH NATH PANDEY, ADDL. DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE, PRESIDING OFFICER : LABOUR COURT – IV, ROUSE AVENUE COURTS : NEW DELHI. LIR No.549/2021 CNR No.DLCT13-000876-2021 IN THE MATTER OF: Sh. Arjun Yadav, S/o late Sh. Ram Piyare Yadav, R/o WJ-60A, Naraina Gaon, Delhi. ….CLAIMANT/WORKMAN VERSUS M/s. Khebhar Service Station (Petrol Pump), Moti Bagh, near Desmukh Metro Station, New Delhi. Through Sh. Alind Kumar Garg. ….MANAGEMENT Date of institution of the case : 03.03.2021 Date of final arguments : 12.05.2023 Date of passing the Award : 12.05.2023 Decision : Dismissed. A W A R D 1. Vide this Award, I shall decide the Industrial Dispute which was referred by Joint Labour Commissioner, South West District on a complaint filed by the aforesaid claimant/workman against the Management, vide reference no. F.24(48)/Ref./2021/SWD/Lab./304-307 dated 21.02.2020, u/s Arjun Yadav v. Khebhar Service Station LIR No.549/2021 Page 1 of 12 -- 1 of 12 -- 10(1)(c) and 12 (5) of The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, wherein the following reference was to be answered :- “Whether the services of workman Sh. Arjun Yadav (Age-56), S/o Lt. Sh. Rampyare Yadav, Mobile No.8896945597 have been terminated illegally and/or unjustifiably by the management; if so, to what relief is he entitled and what directions are necessary in this respect?” 2. Notice of the reference was issued to the workman. Pursuant thereto, the workman appeared and filed his statement of claim against the management claiming that he was in the employment of the management since the year 2011 at the post of Driver and his last drawn salary was Rs.16,926/- per month; he worked honestly, efficiently, punctually and regularly and has never given any chance of complaint to his superior or any official of the management. It is further stated in the statement of claim that the management deprived the workman from legal facilities such as attendance register, wage slip, leave book, bonus, PF etc. However, the management only issued the ESI card to the workman. The workman demanded the above legal facilities from the management repeatedly and due to the said reason the management got annoyed and terminated his service illegally and unjustifiably on 28.12.2018 without paying his due salary for the period 01.05.2018 to 27.12.2018. Aggrieved from the illegal termination, the claimant issued demand notice dated 16.01.2019 to the management for his reinstatement and legal dues. The workman also filed the complaint against the management before the Labour Commissioner, Hari Nagar, Delhi. The workman also Arjun Yadav v. Khebhar Service Station LIR No.549/2021 Page 2 of 12 -- 2 of 12 -- filed his claim petition before the Conciliation Officer but no settlement could be arrived at between the parties due to adamant attitude of the management and hence the present reference. The workman claims to be unemployed from the date of his illegal termination. As claimed, the termination of service of the workman is illegal and unjustified as the management violated the provisions of I.D. Act. It is prayed that an award be passed in favour of workman and against management directing the management to reinstate him with consequential benefits including full back wages and continuity in service. 3. The notice of the statement of claim was issued to the management. The management made its appearance and filed written statement contended that there existed no relationship of employer-employee between the workman and the management. The present statement of claim is bad in the eyes of law and is liable to be dismissed. The management denied the other averments of the statement of claim and prayed to dismiss the claim petition. 4. From the pleadings of the parties, the following issues were framed on 03.09.2022: (1) Whether there existed a relationship of employer and employee between the workman and management? O.P.W (2) Whether the services of the workman were Arjun Yadav v. Khebhar Service Station LIR No.549/2021 Page 3 of 12 -- 3 of 12 -- terminated illegally and/or unjustifiably by the management and if so, to what consequential relief is the workman entitled for? O.P.W. (3) Relief. The case was, thereafter, fixed for evidence of workman. 5. In order to discharge the onus and prove the issues, the claimant had appeared as witness and filed his evidence by way of affidavit Ex.WW1/A wherein he had reiterated the contents of his statement of claim on solemn affirmation. Besides this, he had also placed on record the following documents :- (i) Ex.WW1/1: Statement of claim filed before the Conciliation Officer; (ii) Mark A and B: Copies of complaint made to Assistant Labour Commissioner by the workman against the management; (iii) Mark C: Reference order dated 21.02.2020. 6. The workman also summoned the witness from Deputy Labour Commissioner Office, South West District, DTC Colony, Pratap Nagar, Hari Nagar, New Delhi. Sh. Daulat Ram appeared from the said office with record. He had been examined as WW2 and deposed as under: “I am a summoned witness and brought the summoned record i.e. records of conciliation before Labour Commissioner vide Ex.WW2/1 (colly 4 pages). I have also brought the statement of claim filed before the Labour Commissioner, which is already exhibited as Ex.WW1/1. The demand notice dated Arjun Yadav v. Khebhar Service Station LIR No.549/2021 Page 4 of 12 -- 4 of 12 -- 10.03.2019 sent by the workman through union to the management is Ex.WW2/2”. The AR for the management cross-examined both the WW1 and WW2. Workman’s evidence was thereafter closed. 7. The management did not examine any witness in its evidence and management's evidence was closed vide order dated 21.04.2023. 8. I have heard the arguments addressed by the AR for the workman and the management. I have also gone through the materials lying on record. My issue-wise findings are as under:- Issue No.1: Whether there existed a relationship of employer and employee between the workman and management ?O.P.W 9. The onus to prove the relationship of employer employee between the management and the workman was on the workman/claimant. It is no longer resintegra that the burden of proving the employeremployee relationship primarily rests upon the person who asserts its existence. In a situation where a person asserts to be an employee of the management which the management denies, the duty primarily rests upon the person so asserting to give positive evidence in his favour and discharge his initial burden. Once such a person has given positive evidence in his favour, only then, the burden would shift on the management Arjun Yadav v. Khebhar Service Station LIR No.549/2021 Page 5 of 12 -- 5 of 12 -- to give evidence to counter such claims. This is because it is always easier to prove positive facts than a negative. 10. In the judgment titled Automobile Association Upper India v. P.O. Labour CourtII & Anr. , reported as 130 (2006) DLT 160, Hon'ble Delhi High Court has held that “engagement and appointment of the workman in service can be established either by direct evidence like existence and production of appointment letter or written agreement, or by circumstantial evidence of incidental or ancillary records, in nature of attendance register, salary register, leave records, deposit of PF contribution, ESI etc. or even by examination of coworker who may depose before the court that the workman was working with the management”. 11. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in “Workman of Nilgiri Coop. Mkt. Society Ltd. Vs State of Tamil Nadu”, reported as AIR 2004 SC 1639 held as under: “47. It is a well – settled principle of law that the person who is set up a plea of existence of relationship of employer and employee, the burden would be upon him. 48. In N.C. John Vs Secretary Thodupuha Taluk Shop and Commercial Establishment Workers' Union and others [1973 Lab. I.C. 398], the Kerala High Court held : “The burden of proof being on the workman Jai Prakash Vs M/s J.K. Sales Corporation 19.12.2019 Page No. 14 of 21 to establish the employer – employee relationship an adverse inference cannot be drawn against the employer that if he were to produce books of accounts they would have proved employeremployee relationship.” 50. The question whether the relationship between the parties is one of the employer and employee is a pure Arjun Yadav v. Khebhar Service Station LIR No.549/2021 Page 6 of 12 -- 6 of 12 -- question of the fact and ordinarily the High Court while exercising its power of judicial review shall not interfere therewith unless the findings is manifestly or obviously erroneous or perverse.” 12. In 'Kanpur Electricity Supply Co. Ltd. Vs Shamim Mirza', (2009/ 1 SCC 20, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held as under : “20. It is trite that the burden to prove that a claimant was in the employment of a particular management, primarily lies on the person who claims to be so but the degree of proof, so required, varies from case to case. It is neither feasible nor advisable to lay down an abstract rule to determine the employer – employee relationship. It is Jai Prakash Vs M/s J.K. Sales Corporation 19.12.2019 Page No. 15 of 21 essentially a question of fact to be determined by having regard to the cumulative effect of the entire material placed before the adjudicatory forum by the claimant and the management.” 13. Similarly, the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in case Babu Ram Vs Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Anr., 247 (2018) Delhi Law Times 596 was pleased to observe : “it is well settled principle of law that the person, who sets up a plea of existence of relationship of employer and employee, the burden would be upon him. In this regard, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Workmen of Nilgiri Coop. Mkt. Society Ltd. V. State of T.N. and Others, (2004) 3 SCC 514 has approved the judgment of Kerala and Calcutta High Court, where the plea of the workman that he was employee of the company was denied by the company and it was held that it was not for the company to prove that he was not an employee. Para 48 to 50 of the said judgment reads as under : Arjun Yadav v. Khebhar Service Station LIR No.549/2021 Page 7 of 12 -- 7 of 12 -- “In N.C. John v. Secy., Thodupuzha Taluk Shop and Commercial Establishment Workers' Union & Ors, (1973 Lab IC 398) the Kerala High Court held : The burden of proof being on the workmen to establish the employer employee relationship an adverse inference cannot bedrawn against the employer that if he were to produce books of accounts they would have proved employer employee relationship. In Swapan Das Gupta & Ors. v. The First Labour Court of W.B. (1976 Lab IC 202 (Cal)) it has been held : Where a person asserts that he was a workman of the company and it is denied by the company, it is for him to prove the fact. It is not for the company to prove that he was not an employee of the company but of some other person. The question whether the relationship between the parties is one of employer and employee is a pure question of fact and ordinarily the High Court while exercising its power of judicial review shall not interfere therewith unless the finding is manifestly or obviously erroneous or perverse." And observed: “The petitioner has placed on record his self supporting affidavit, demand notice and postal receipts in evidence which does not prove his relationship with the respondent as employee and employer. In these circumstances, I do not find that the impugned Award suffers from any illegality or perversity. There is no merit in the petition. The same is accordingly dismissed with no order as to costs.” 14. The question regarding onus and degree of proof for a claim of employment of a workman with the management was examined in the case of Bank of Baroda v. Ghemarabhai Harijibhai Rabari reported as 2005 (10) SCC 792. It was held Arjun Yadav v. Khebhar Service Station LIR No.549/2021 Page 8 of 12 -- 8 of 12 -- that onus of proof was on the claimant, namely the workman who claimed to have been employed by the management. It was also held that the degree of proof is vary from case to case and if the workman had established a prima facie case, it would be the responsibility of the management to rebut the same. In view of aforesaid law, it was for the claimant to prove that he was employee of the management. The statement of claim filed by the workman alongwith defence of management has been mentioned at the outset. The workman claimed that he was in the continuous service of the management w.e.f. 2011 at the post of Driver and his last drawn salary was Rs.16,926/ per month; his services were terminated on 28.12.2018. The management on the other hand denied any employer employee relationship between the parties. The workman examined himself as WW1 and relied upon the documents mentioned above. The workman was crossexamined and deposed as under: “I was employed with Indian Oil Company as a Driver. My tenure of employment was for 7 years from 2011 to 2018. I have studied till 5th class. Although, I was employed with Indian Oil Company but no card or document has been issued by them to me regarding employment. I am aware about the fact that cards and documents are required to be issued by the employer to an employee since the date of my employment. However, I did not raise any objection or lodge any complaint against the Indian Oil Company in regard to non issuance of legal facilities and documents of employment by the Indian Oil Company during the period 2011 to 2018. I have filed complaint in this regard for the first time after my termination of service by Indian Oil Company and never filed any such complaint prior to that. I have not filed on record any document to show that I ever worked with the Indian Oil Arjun Yadav v. Khebhar Service Station LIR No.549/2021 Page 9 of 12 -- 9 of 12 -- Company. It is wrong to suggest that I have filed the present complaint without any cause of action against the management or that I have filed the present complaint against a wrong party impleading it to be the management in the present petition. It is wrong to suggest that there is no employer employee relationship between me and the management herein or that I have not placed on record any document of employment in support of the present petition because I was never employed with the management herein or that I have filed a false and frivolous complaint before the Labour Commissioner, Hari Nagar, Delhi and/or that I have filed false claim before Conciliation Officer, Hari Nagar or that I am not entitled for any relief or that I am deposing falsely”. 15. I have gone through all the documents filed by the workman. The witness/workman has not filed any document regarding his appointment or payment of any salary as claimed by him against the management herein. The workman/witness has not produced any documentary proof regarding his employment with the management for the period as claimed in statement of claim. None of the documents relied by the workman are in respect of his employment or payment of salary by the management. No document was summoned or produced by the workman in respect of his employment with the management or payment of any salary. In fact, the workman did not take any steps to summon or prove any document regarding his employment, attendance or payment of wages. Merely oral and bald averments by the workman is not sufficient to prove that he was employed with the management as mentioned in the statement of claim. There is no admission by the management Arjun Yadav v. Khebhar Service Station LIR No.549/2021 Page 10 of 12 -- 10 of 12 -- and management has denied that the claimant/workman was its employee or paid any salary as claimed. 16. No doubt that claimant has examined himself as WW1 vide his affidavit Ex.WW1/A, wherein, he has claimed that he worked with the management for the said period and his services have been illegally terminated by the management on 28.12.2018. The claimant has failed to bring on record any cogent documentary evidence to prove that he worked in the management since 2011 till 28.12.2018. Neither the testimony of the claimant nor any of the documents relied / produced by him are sufficient to hold that the claimant had worked in the management as employee for the said period, as claimed by him in the statement of claim. Therefore, this court is of the considered opinion that the self serving affidavit Ex.WW1/A of claimant and the documents relied by him are not sufficient to conclude that claimant had worked in the management for the period as claimed by him. Issue No.1 is accordingly decided against the workman and in favour of management. ISSUES NO.2 & 3: (2) Whether the service of the workman were terminated illegally and/or unjustifiably by the management and if so, to what consequential relief is the workman entitled for? O.P.W. (3) Relief. Arjun Yadav v. Khebhar Service Station LIR No.549/2021 Page 11 of 12 -- 11 of 12 -- 17. The claimant has failed to prove on record that he worked in the management since 2011 till 28.12.2018. This court is of the considered opinion that self serving affidavit and the documents, relied upon by the claimant, do not inspire any confidence, so, the claimant is not entitled to get any relief. Issues no.2 & 3 are accordingly decided against the workman. The present statement of claim filed by the workman is accordingly dismissed. 18. Award is passed and reference is answered accordingly. 19. Signed copy of the award be sent to the Office of the Deputy Labour Commissioner, Government of NCT of Delhi of Distt./Area concerned for publication as per rules. 20. The award be also uploaded on server. 21. Judicial file be consigned to Record Room after compliance of necessary legal formalities. Announced in the open (Gorakh Nath Pandey) Court on 12.05.2023 Addl. District & Sessions Judge Presiding Officer Labour Court- IV Rouse Avenue District Courts. Arjun Yadav v. Khebhar Service Station LIR No.549/2021 Page 12 of 12 -- 12 of 12 --
