Full Order Text
Final Order 4 · 10 Jul 2024 · CNR DLCT110005412024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Bail Application No. 90/24 CBI Vs. Dr. Parvatagouda (applicant Naresh Nagpal) RC No. 210/204A0009/CBI/AC-II, New Delhi U/s 7,9,10 of PC Act, 1988 & 120-B IPC 10.07.2024 Present: Sh. A.K. Tanwar, Ld. Sr. PP for CBI with IO/DySP G.S. Meena. Sh. Harsh Sethi, Sh.Raghav Luthra and Sh. Anant Nigam, Ld. counsels for applicant/accused Naresh Nagpal. An application seeking regular bail under Section 439 Cr.P.C filed on behalf of accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal, S/o Late Nand Lal Nagpal is pending disposal. Arguments were heard on 09.07.2024. Ld. Counsel for applicant/accused has argued that the instant application is the first bail application of the accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal. It is further argued that the arrest memo of the accused is defective as in the arrest memo the reason so given is that accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal is the proprietor of M/s Nagpal Techno Pvt. Ltd. The company has nothing to do with Naresh Nagpal. It is further argued that the company of Naresh Nagpal is Veena Cardio Systems. In the FIR M/s Nagpal Technologies Pvt. Ltd has been made as A-2 details and particulars of the company are available on the internet which is accessible to CBI and therefore since he accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal has been shown as owner of the company therefore, there is non Bail Application No. 90/2024 Page no. 1 of 8 -- 1 of 8 -- application of mind reflected from the arrest memo. It is further stated that in the reply to the bail application so filed on 02.07.2024 also at page No. 2 para No. iii accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal has been implicated as owner of Nagpal Technologies Pvt. Ltd. whereas Naresh Nagpal or his family member have nothing to do with this company. It is further argued on behalf of the accused /applicant that CBI has not conducted the investigation properly and accused/applicant is of 61 years of age and he has no criminal record as yet. It is further argued that CBI has not stated till date that accused/applicant is not cooperating with the investigating agency. It is further argued that accused/applicant is in JC and since 14.05.2024 he has not been interrogated even once. It is further stated that the voice sample of accused has been taken without any resistance. It is also stated that charge-sheet has been filed, therefore, there is no question of tampering with the evidence by accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal. It is also stated that when accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal was arrested he did not try to evade his arrest or flee away. Therefore, the flight risk is not correct and accused/applicant is ready and willing to abide by with any of the terms and conditions imposed by this Hon’ble court. It is further stated that accused/applicant is a permanent residence of Delhi and have two children (a girl and a boy) of marriageable age. Accused has no intention to avoid trial or escape justice of administrative system. It is Bail Application No. 90/2024 Page no. 2 of 8 -- 2 of 8 -- further argued that the role of accused/applicant is entirely different from the role/footing of co-accused persons as even as per CBI, no money was given by the applicant/accused in the bank account of other co-accused and there is no previous incident of alleged bribery. Hence, it is prayed that the application seeking bail of accused/applicant be allowed. Ld. Sr. PP for CBI, on the other hand had argued that the name of the firm of accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal as Nagpal Technologies Pvt. Ltd. has been mentioned in FIR on the basis of source information. But at the time of the trap proceedings it came to the knowledge of the trap laying officer from the disclosure of Naresh Nagal that he is the proprietor of Nagpal Health Care and Veena Cardio System. In this regard, a memorandum has been prepared on the same day of the trap. It is further argued that accused/applicant was caught red handed for giving bribe of Rs.2.48 Lakhs to Dr. Parvatagouda in the car parking of the doctor’s hostel, RML Hospital in the presence of independent witnesses for the purpose or as a motive to facilitate the equipment supply by M/s Veena Cardio Systems which were to be used by Dr. Parvatagouda as per allegations. Dr. Parvatagouda in conspiracy with accused/ applicant Naresh Nagpal implanted 59 stents from the period w.e.f. 01.01.2024 to 07.05.2024 procured from accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal’s Veena Cardio System. It is further stated that the value of such stents are about 19 Bail Application No. 90/2024 Page no. 3 of 8 -- 3 of 8 -- lakhs. It is further argued that besides that accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal also supplied consumable items of worth Rs.50 Lakhs within the period of 4 months i.e. w.e.f., January, 2024 to April, 2024. It is further stated that intercepted call containing the conversation between accused Naresh Nagpal and Dr.Parvatagouda are part of record which shows that accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal was in constant touch with Dr. Parvatagouda and used to discuss about the utilization of equipment in consideration of the bribe amount on different occasions. It is further argued that case is under investigation qua the other entities including M/s Nagpal Technologies Pvt. Ltd. if the bail is granted at this stage, there are changes that accused Naresh Nagpal may influence the witnesses for further investigation against other persons qua M/s Nagpal Technologies Pvt. Ltd. Since, the manner in which the offence of corruption is committed reflects that it is a grave offence and in view of para No. 15 the judgment passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, titled as Y.S.Jagan Mohan Readdy vs. CBI, Crl. Appeal No. 730/2013 (SLP Crl. No. 3404/2013) it is stated that economic offences have a separate category having serious impact on the society and this offence is to be treated differently from the ordinary offence. The judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Kalyank Chand Sarkar vs. Rajesh Ranjan @ Papu Yadav, AIR 2004 SC 1866 and Amarmani Tripathy’s case held that Bail Application No. 90/2024 Page no. 4 of 8 -- 4 of 8 -- longevity in jail itself is not a ground to grant bail to the accused. The applicant if released on bail at this stage, will in all probabilities influence the witnesses. It is further argued that the charge is yet to be framed, therefore, the application seeking bail should be dismissed. In his rebuttal, Ld. Counsel for accused/applicant submits that none of the accused is party to empanelment committee of the hospital which used to approve the product supplied by accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal. Until now CBI has not shown any link between Naresh Nagpal and M/s Nagpal Technology Pvt. Ltd. Arguments heard. Record perused. At the outset, it is mentioned that charge-sheet in present case against the accused persons is filed 05.07.2024 and investigation qua accused persons is concluded. As per the allegation accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal is stated to have connived with Dr. Parvatagouda (another co-accused) and had bribed him for a sum of Rs.2.48 Lakhs. It is further alleged and clarified in the charge- sheet that accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal is the owner/ proprietor of Nagpal Health Care and Veena Cardio System, who used to supply various equipment for conducting medical procedure for patients for which Dr.Parvatagouda used to demand and accept bribe from him. It is further reflected from the evidence filed along with the charge-sheet that medical equipments i.e. pacemaker etc., upto to the amount of Rs.19 Bail Application No. 90/2024 Page no. 5 of 8 -- 5 of 8 -- Lakhs have been exclusively supplied by the firm/company of accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal. It is further reflected from the record that there are various evidences supported documentary evidence that money has been transferred by various persons on behalf of accused/applicant or by himself to Dr. Parvatagouda, who is associated in seeking favour in supplying the medical equipments of their choice. Ld. Sr. PP for CBI has relied upon judgment of Y.S. Jagan Mohan Readdy (supra) that economic offences have a separate category having serious impact on the society and is to be treated differently from the ordinary offence, as well as relied upon another judgment Kalyan Chand Sarkar (Supra) that languishing in jail alone cannot be a ground to grant bail to the accused, however, the other directions given by Hon’ble Apex court in various judgments cannot be ignored. The directions laid down in judgments tilted as Anil Mahajan Vs. Commissioner of Customs and Anr, 84 (2000) DLT 854; Sanjay Chandra Vs. CBI, (2012) 1 SCC40 and Satender Kumar Antil Vs. CBI and Anr., Misc. App. No. 1849 of 2021 in SLP (Crl.) No. 5191 of 2021 are considered for reference here. At this stage, landmark judgment of Arnesh Kumar Vs. State, AIR 2014 SC 2756 is also referred here for reference that, the maximum punishment provided for offence alleged to have been committed by the applicant/accused Akarshan Gulati is 7 years. Thus, the guidelines laid down in Bail Application No. 90/2024 Page no. 6 of 8 -- 6 of 8 -- the case tilted as Arnesh Kumar’s (supra) case are equally applicable in the present case. It is a matter of record, as mentioned above, that this is the first bail application filed on behalf of accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal and CBI has not placed on record previous criminal conduct of the accused that he is habitual offender and is involved in various other criminal case of like nature. No report with regard to address of accused/application not being permanent or fake have been filed along with the reply of CBI. Keeping in mind the totality of circumstances, therefore, in the interest of justice, the application seeking regular bail is allowed. Accused/applicant Naresh Nagpal, S/o Late Nand Lal Nagpal is granted regular bail subject to furnishing of PB/SB of two sureties for a sum of Rs. 70,000/- each subject to the following terms and conditions: 1. That the applicant/accused shall cooperate in the investigation and shall join the investigation as and when called by the IO/investigating agency. 2. That the applicant/accused shall not intimidate the witnesses of the present case nor shall tamper with the evidence of the present case. 3. That the accused/applicant shall not leave the territory of Delhi/NCR without the permission of the court. Passport, if any, of the accused be deposited in the court. Bail Application No. 90/2024 Page no. 7 of 8 -- 7 of 8 -- 4. That the applicant/accused shall furnish his present and permanent address, mobile number, e-mail address to the IO. In case of any change in the address or mobile number or e-mail address, the applicant shall inform the IO forthwith and without any default. 5. That the applicant/accused shall abide by all the above said terms and conditions. Accordingly, the application stands disposed of. Copy of the order be given dasti, as per rules, as prayed for. (PRASHANT KUMAR) Special Judge (PC Act) (CBI)-07 Rouse Avenue Courts: New Delhi 10.07.2024 Bail Application No. 90/2024 Page no. 8 of 8 -- 8 of 8 --
