Full Order Text
Final Order 6 · 14 Oct 2025 · CNR DLCT030090842024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 1 of 20 IN THE COURT OF SH. RUPINDER SINGH DHIMAN, ARC-01, CENTRAL DISTRICT, TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI. RC ARC No. 696/24 1. Mohd. Salim S/o Late Mohd. Babudin 2. Mohd. Shuaib S/o Late Mohd. Babudin Both Residents of: 6251, Gali Jharsanyyan, Qasabpura, Sadar Bazar Delhi – 110006. .........Petitioner Versus Mursaleen S/o Sh. Mehboobilahi R/o 6251, Ground Floor, Gali Jharsanyyan, Qasabpura, Sadar Bazar Delhi – 110006 ........Respondent Date of Institution of the case 09.12.2024 Under Section 14(1)(e) r/w Section 25B, Delhi Rent Control Act. Date of reserving of Order 03.09.2025 Date of Order 14.10.2025 Decision Leave to defend application is dismissed and eviction order is passed Argued by: a) Sh. Akhtar Hussain, Ld Counsel for petitioner. b) Sh. M. Mohtram, Ld Counsel for respondent. -- 1 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 2 of 20 ORDER 1) This order shall dispose off an application for leave to defend filed by the respondent/tenant in an eviction petition under Section 14(1) (e) of the Delhi Rent Control Act ( hereinafter called as the DRC Act). The present eviction petition has been filed for seeking eviction of respondent from one room with damaged roof, two open rooms (i.e. rooms without roof), one kitchen, chowk / uncovered/open verandah, common toilet at ground floor (part of ground floor); one room and one kitchen at first floor and one chhappar covered with polythene at second floor of property bearing No. 6251, Gali Jharsanyyan, Qasabpura, Sadar Bazar, Delhi – 110006 (hereinafter referred to as tenanted premises) and more specifically shown in red colour in the site plan. PETITION 2) It is alleged by the petitioners that their grandfather namely, Mohd. Din was the owner of six properties bearing No. 7178 (New No. 6248); 7180 (New No. 6249) ; 7181 (New No. 6251); 8651 (New No. 6256) and 8782 (New No. 7526). It is stated that on his demise, he was survived by his wife, three sons and three daughters, including Usmani Begum who had migrated to Pakistan at the time of partition with her husband. It is stated that the custodian department held that she was entitled to 7/64th share of the above said properties. Thereafter, the competent officer vide its judgment dated 20.08.1957 held that Mohd. Din and his legal heirs except Usmani Begum were entitled to 57/64th share of the abovesaid properties and Usmani Begum’s share of 7/64th in the said properties was held to be evacuee property. Further, vide order dated 30.09.1957, the other legal heirs of Mohd. Din were permitted to purchase the said share. Accordingly, vide sale deed dated 11.10.1958, -- 2 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 3 of 20 the said 7/64th share of the said properties was purchased by the remaining legal heirs of Mohd. Din. Further, it is stated out of the said properties, in about November-December 1958, there was amicable verbal partition between the legal heirs of late Mohd. Din and property bearing No. 7187 (New No. 7656) was given to the legal heirs of Muglani Begum D/o Mohd. Din and remaining properties fell to the share of other legal heirs i.e. Babu Din (father of the petitioners), Zamani Begum and Rashidan. It is further stated that Zamani Begum relinquished her share in favour of Babu Din vide relinquishment deed dated 26.09.1996. It is further stated that Rashidan expired on 16.06.1985. It is stated that father of the petitioners disposed off property bearing No. 8782 (New No. 7526) in about 1998 and mother of the petitioners after the demise of their father disposed off property bearing No. 8651 (New No. 6256) in about 2009 to meet out family requirements. It is stated that property bearing No. 6248-49 (Old No. 7178,7180) is in the possession of old tenants of the petitioners. 3) It is stated that the present matter has been filed with respect to tenanted premises situated at property bearing No. 6251, Gali Jharsanyyan, Qasabpura, Sadar Bazar, Delhi - 110006 (hereinafter referred to as subject premises). It is stated that Rehmat Elahi and his brother Mehar Elahi (grandfather of the respondent) had been inducted as tenants by Late Mohd. Din in about 1947 at a monthly rent of Rs. 10/- only with respect to the tenanted premises in question . It is stated that subsequently Rehmat Elahi moved out of the tenanted premises but Mehar Elahi continued to live in the same with his family. It is stated that after the death of Mehar Elahi, his son Mehboob Elahi continued as a tenant in the premises. It is further stated that respondent is the son of said Mehbood Elahi and at present, the tenant in the said premises. It is -- 3 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 4 of 20 further stated that with the lapse of time, the tenanted premises became dilapidated and one room and roof of another room of the tenanted premises was demolished by MCD on 19.09.2024 qua which respondent had also raised objections vide letter dated 29.07.2024. It is also stated that the respondent had also filed a suit for permanent and mandatory injunction against the petitioners for carrying out repairs of the said portion but the same was withdrawn by the respondent vide order dated 04.09.2023. 4) It is stated that at present petitioner No.1 has one room, one store, open verandah, one kitchen, one bathroom and one toilet situated at second floor of the subject premises. It is further stated that petitioner No.2 has one room, one dallan/ covered verandah, one kitchen, one bathroom and one toilet at the first floor of the subject premises. However, it is stated that petitioners require at least four separate rooms for their sons (i.e. two sons of petitioner No. 1 and two sons of petitioner No.2); two study rooms, two drawing rooms, two guest rooms with required amenities of kitchen, bathroom, toilet and store room. Hence, it is prayed that petitioners have bonafide requirements of at least 10 more rooms for themselves and their dependent family members and no suitable alternative accommodation is available with them for the said purpose. Hence, it is prayed that an eviction order may be passed in favour of the petitioners and against the respondent. 5) Alongwith the eviction petition, petitioner has filed (a) Site Plan, (b) Death Certificate of Mohd. Din, (c) Death Certificate of Babu Din (d) Death Certificate of Nasra Begum, (e) Relinquishment Deed dt. 19.09.1996 (f) House Tax Demand notice dt. 31.07.1955, 26.09.1986, 03.10.1989, 13.11.1991, 09.08.1994 (g) House Tax Assessment related -- 4 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 5 of 20 documents dt. 27.11.1972, 01.04.1973, 28.03.1977, 01.04.1976 & 28.03.1977, (h) Mutation in MCD records in favour fo Sh. Babuddin dated 28.03.1978/ 31.03.1978 alongwith applications, affidavits and NOC dated 17.02.1978, 28.02.1978, 28.02.1978, 28.02.1978, 26.02.1975, 13.02.1975 (I) House Tax Payment receipts 31.03.1987, 03.02.2016, 26.06.2019, (j) Documents related to Electricity Connection dt. 09.03.1929, 22.06.1964, 29.05.1973, (k) Notices from Custodian Department dt. 28.04.1951, 02.09.1952 (l) All above are copies. Copy of order of court of complaint Officer, Delhi dt. 20.08.1957, (m) Sale Deed executed by competent officer, Delhi dt. 31.12.1957, (n) Copy of above sale deed registered on 11.10.1958, (o) Copy of Inspection Book of MCD for 1959-1960, (p) Copy of Inspection Book of MCD for 05.07.1968, (q) Copy of Inspection Book of MCD for 09.03.1972, (r) Copy fo letter written by respondent to MCD dt. 29.07.2024, (s) Copy of DD No. 300382 dt. 30.09.2024 of Rs. 65940/- in favour of MCD paid by petitioner No.1 on account of demolition charges and (t) Copy of receipt for the above amount of Rs. 65940/- issued by MCD, dated 30.09.2024. LEAVE TO DEFEND 6) Upon issuance of summons under the Third Schedule of the DRC Act, the respondent appeared and filed his leave to defend application within the prescribed time period. In the said application, respondent has sought leave to defend and raised various objections. Firstly, it is contended that the premises in question is in the adverse possession of the respondent since the lifetime of his grandfather Mehar Elahi. Hence, it is stated that there is no relationship of landlord tenant between the parties. Secondly, it is contended that there was no partition and entire property bearing No. 7187 and portion of subject premises consisting of three rooms, toilet, kitchen on the groundfloor and one room and one kitchen on the second floor are in exclusive possession of legal heirs of Muglani Begum D/o Mohd. Din W/o Rehmat Elahi as co- -- 5 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 6 of 20 owner of the property in question. It is further stated that Rehmat Elahi and his wife Muglani Begum never vacated or moved out from the aforesaid portion of subject premises at any point of time. It is stated that Mehboob Elahi (predecessor of the respondent) was in exclusive physical possession of portion of two rooms and a dallah and a kitchen at the first floor of the subject premises which has been demolished by the MCD at the instance of the petitioners and the plot of the same is therefore, in adverse possession of the respondent. It is stated that the name of Rehmat Elahi has been wrongly shown in the tenant in the Inspection Book of MCD. Thirdly, it is contended that the respondent is residing in the tenanted premises with Maqbool Elahi ( son of Rehmat Elahi) who is the co-owner of the tenanted premises alongwith the respondent. Fourthly, it is contended that alternative accommodation is available with the petitioner since they have already got vacant possession of portion consisting of one room with dallan, laterine, bathroom and kitchen on the first floor and one room on the second floor from tenant Ghyasuddin in the year 2024 which is lying vacant since then. Fifthly, it is contended that petitioners have also got vacant possession of one room with dallan on the first floor of the subject premises from tenant Kalloo. Sixthly, it is contended that payment of house tax is not proof of ownership and therefore, petitioners cannot claim the ownership on the basis of house tax receipts. Seventhly, it is contended that the petitioners have not taken NOC from the co-owners for filing the present petition and therefore, the petition is bad for non- joinder of necessary parties. Lastly, it is contended that the need is not bonafide and sole purpose of the eviction petition is to harass and pressurize the respondent to vacate the premises in question. -- 6 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 7 of 20 7) Alongwith leave to defend application, respondent filed (a) Photocopy of aadhar card of Maqbool Elahi, (b) Photocopy of aadhar card of Rehama w/o Maqbool Elahi, (c) Photocopy of Ration Card of Rehama W/o Maqbool Elahi (d) Photocopy of Ration card of Imam Elahi and (e) Photocopy of Death Certificate of Rehmat Elahi. REPLY TO LEAVE TO DEFEND APPLICATION 8) In reply to the leave to defend application supported with the accompanying affidavit, petitioner has denied the averments of the respondent and reiterated the bonafide requirement of the tenanted premises. Additionally, it is stated that the plea of adverse possession is not maintainable. It is also denied that there was no partition between the legal heirs of Muglani Begum or that they did not move out from the premises in question. Further, it is stated that Maqbool Elahi has already expired and his sister is residing at T-307, Fourth Floor, Ahata Kidara, Sadar Bazar, Delhi – 110006. It is also denied that petitioners had got any portion vacated from Gayasuddin in 2024 and allegations made in this regard are wrong and baseless. Further, it is stated that the present petition was filed on 03.12.2024 whereas damaged and dilapidated portion consisting of two rooms, open kitchen, open verandah, one latrine cum bath at first floor and one room and one kitchen at second floor was handed over by Saida Begum to the petitioners on 12.12.2024 in view of settlement in case bearing No. CS SCJ 2001/16. With respect to the room at first floor of tenant Kalloo, it is stated that the said room is reflected as room without roof in the site plan and the said room is inhabitable. Alongwith the reply, petitioners have filed copy of order dated 13.12.2024 in CS SCJ bearing No. 2001/16. -- 7 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 8 of 20 REJOINDER 9) Thereafter, in rejoinder, respondent has denied the assertions of the petitioners and reiterated his grounds of leave to defend application. Additionally, it is stated that petitioners deliberately concealed regarding the getting of possession from Saida. Further, it is stated that petitioners have not disclosed as to when one room with dallan was received from Kalloo. 10) Alongwith rejoinder, respondent has filed (a) Photocopy regarding sale deed dated 31.12.1957 (b) Six photographs of the property in question, (c) Photocopy of summons dt. 03.02.2025 of this Hon’ble Court, (d) Photocopy of two Ration card of Rezwana and (e) Electricity Bill and disconnection notice of Mehar Elahi. FINDINGS 11) Arguments were then advanced by respective counsels of both the parties on leave to defend application. At the outset, it is stated that there is no doubt regarding the case laws relied upon on behalf of both the parties where the Superior Courts have laid down the principles with respect to provisions of the DRC Act, 1958 in different factual scenarios. However, each case has its own distinguishing facts and circumstances and each matter has to be decided in its own factual background. It is trite to state that in a petition u/s 14(1)(e) of DRC Act in order to get an eviction order the petitioner/landlord is required to establish the following :- (i) That he/she is the owner/landlord of the property; (ii) That he/she requires the premises bonafide and iii) That he/she does not have any other alternative suitable accommodation for this purpose. -- 8 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 9 of 20 LANDLORD-TENANT RELATIONSHIP 12) As far as the landlord-tenant relationship is concerned, the respondent has disputed the same. It is contended that there is no landlord-tenant relationship between the parties and respondent is owner of the premises by being in continuous uninterrupted possession of the premises for the last many decades by way of adverse possession. However, it is not in dispute that his grandfather was inducted as a tenant in the premises. Once the respondent has admitted that his predecessor was a tenant under the predecessor of the petitioner, he, therefore, cannot deny the title of the successor of the erstwhile landlord. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Bansraj Laltaprasad Mishra v. Stanley Parker Jones (2006) 3 SCC 91 had held that: ".....13. The underlying policy of section 116 is that where a person has been brought into possession as a tenant by the landlord and if that tenant is permitted to question the title of the landlord at the time of the settlement, then that will give rise to extreme confusion in the matter of relationship of the landlord and tenant and so the equitable principle of estoppel has been incorporated by the legislature in the said section.” 13) Even otherwise, it is pertinent to note that petitioner has placed on record the inspection book whereby the name of the predecessor of the respondent has been shown as a tenant. The contention of the respondent that he has been falsely shown as a tenant, is devoid of merits. It is pertinent to note that in the leave to defend application, respondent himself has made averments about the status of Kalloo and Gyasuddin whose names too have been reflected as a tenant in the subject premises in the inspection book. Therefore, at one end, respondent himself is corroborating the particulars of the inspection book -- 9 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 10 of 20 by acknowledging the status of other parties as a tenant in the subject premises. But at the other end, he is challenging the authenticity of the government records which are more than 30 years old on the basis of a bald averment. It is no longer res integra that mere raising of baseless contentions against the landlord cannot be a ground for being granted leave to defend to the petitioners. Reliance in this regard is placed upon the decision of the Hon'ble High Court passed in the case of Mohd. Naseer Vs. Mohd. Zaheer and Anr. RC Rev. No. 267/2016 dated 03.11.2016. It is trite to state that respondent cannot approbate and reprobate at the same time. "Approbate and reprobate" is a legal principle, also known as the doctrine of election, meaning a party cannot simultaneously approve (approbate) and reject (reprobate) the same thing, transaction, or position, especially to gain an unfair advantage. Essentially, you cannot "blow hot and cold", as it is a fundamental rule of equity that prevents inconsistent claims or benefits from the same matter. Hence, a bald averment has been made in this regard and therefore the said contention is devoid of merits. 14) Further, it is settled law that the petitioner is not required to prove absolute ownership. In this regard it is necessary to mention the law laid down in the judgment titled as Rajender Kumar Sharma vs. Smt. Leela Wati reported as 155 (2008) DLT 383, the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi held that. ".....It is settled law that for the purpose of section 14 (1) (e) of Delhi Rent Control Act, a landlord is not supposed to prove absolute ownership as required under Transfer of Property Act. He is required to show only that he is more than a tenant. In this case, the landlady had placed on record the documents by which she became owner. The attornment given by the erstwhile landlord in her favour as well as an admission made by the tenant by filing -- 10 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 11 of 20 petition under section 27 of Delhi Rent Control Act acknowledgment the landlordship of landlady. Thus, the conclusion arrived at by the ARC regarding ownership and relationship of landlord and tenant were based on sound legal position and the cogent material before it....…” 15) Therefore, the objection on the ground that house tax receipts are not proof of ownership does not amount to any triable issue as imperfectness of title does not bar a petition u/s 14 (1) (e) of the DRC Act. Further, with respect to the contention of adverse possession, it is no longer res integra that a plea of adverse possession can be only taken against the true owner. Adverse possession is hostile possession by assertion of a hostile title in denial of the title of the true owner as held in M. Venkatesh v. BDA, (2015) 17 SCC 1 : (2017) 5 SCC (Civ) 387. Thus, on the one hand, the respondent has denied the petitioner to be the owner of the tenanted premises while on the other hand, he has taken resort to the plea of adverse possession. As stated before, the plea of adverse possession can only be taken against the true owner and hence the averments of the respondent are contradictory in nature. Moreover, the principle of once a tenant always a tenant comes into a play. The respondent cannot take the plea of adverse possession and claim ownership over the tenanted premises simply on the ground of being in possession of the tenanted premises for the past many years. 16) The principle is very clear that once a tenant always a tenant. Therefore, the tenant cannot dispute the title of his landlord or his successor-in-interest. Further, the law in this regard has been elaborately dealt with in the case of in Ramesh Chand vs. Uganti Devi reported as 157 (2009) DLT 450 the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi held: -- 11 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 12 of 20 ".......... The imperfectness of the title of the premises cannot stand in the way of an eviction petition under section 14 (1) (e) of the DRC Act, neither the tenant can be allowed to raise the plea of imperfect title or title not vesting in the landlord and that too when the tenant has been paying rent to the landlord. Section 116 of the Evidence Act creates estoppels against such a tenant. A tenant can challenge the title of landlord only after vacating the premises and not when he is occupying the premises. In fact, such a tenant who denies the title of the landlord, qua the premises, to whom he is paying rent acts dishonestly.........". 17) Next, it is contended that since the ground floor has been partly demolished, therefore, the premises in question do not fall within the domain of DRC Act. However, the said contention is also devoid of merits. It is trite to state that the tenancy cannot be split and bifurcated. Reliance in this regard is placed upon the case of S. S. Rikhy Vs. Hermes Travels and Cargo Pvt. Ltd, 2001 SCC Online Del 422 wherein it was held by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi that a landlord cannot split the unity and integrity of the tenancy and recover possession of only a part of the demised premises from the tenant. Thus, merely because part of the premises stands demolished, it does not mean that the tenanted premises are not in existence. Therefore, the said contention does not amount to any triable issue. 18) Further, it is contended that the petitioners have not taken NOC from the other co-owners for filing of the present petition and therefore, the petition is bad for non-joinder of necessary party. It is contended that there was no partition between the legal heirs of Muglani Begum and Babu Din. However, it is also well settled law that petition u/s 14 (1) (e) of DRC Act can be filed even by one of the co-owners -- 12 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 13 of 20 without impleading the other co-owners. In this regard, it is pertinent to refer to the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in M/s India Umbrella Manufacturing Company Vs. Bhaja Bandei Aggarwalla, 2004 (3) SCC 178 whereby it was held that even a co-owner can file an eviction petition against the tenant and all the co-owners are not required to be joined as a party. Similarly, it was held by Hon’ble Supreme Court in case titled as Dhannalal Vs. Kalawati Bai & Ors. (2002) 6 SCC 16 that even one of the co-owner can file a petition under Section 14 (1) (e) of DRC Act on the ground of bonafide necessity, against the tenants without impleading the other co-owners. Hence, the said contention is devoid of merits. 19) As far as the contention is concerned that respondent is residing in the tenanted premises with Maqbool Elahi, admittedly, Maqbool Elahi was son of Rehmat Elahi who had been inducted in the premises as a tenant with the grandfather of the respondent. Even otherwise, petitioner has categorically averred in the reply that the Maqbool Elahi has already demised and the said fact is not in dispute. Further, it is now well settled that on the death of the original tenant, subject to any provision to the contrary either negativing or limiting the succession, the tenancy rights devolve on the heirs of the deceased tenant. The incidence of the tenancy are the same as those enjoyed by the original tenant. It is a single tenancy which devolves on the heirs. There is no division of the premises or of the rent payable thereof. That is the position as between the landlord and the heirs of the deceased tenant. In other words, the heirs succeed to the tenancy as joint tenants. Reliance in this regard is placed upon H.C. Pandey vs. G.C. Paul (1989) 3 SCC 77 and Suresh Kumar Kohli vs Rakesh Jain & Anr, AIR 2018 SC 2708. -- 13 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 14 of 20 Therefore, any one of the joint tenant can represent the interest of all and no triable issue arises on account of said contention as well. 20) Accordingly, it can be stated that the petitioners are the owners/landlord of the tenanted premises and the respondent is the tenant in the said premises. Thus, the first ingredient of landlord-tenant relationship between the parties in the present case, stands established. BONAFIDE REQUIREMENT AND NON AVAILABILITY OF ALTERNATIVE ACCOMMODATION 21) Moving forward, in order to succeed in his petition, petitioners are required to establish their bonafide need. Petitioners have averred that the tenanted premises are required for the bonafide need of residential requirement of themselves and their dependent family members. However, it is contended on behalf of the respondent that the need is not bonafide and the sole purpose is to harass and pressurize the respondent to vacate the premises in question. But the Hon’ble Supreme court in Baldev Singh Bajwa vs Monish Saini (2005) 12 SCC 778 has held that whenever a landlord seeks eviction of the tenant for bonafide need, the controller shall presume the need as genuine and bonfide. Additionally, the burden to refute the said presumption squarely lies on the tenant and mere assertion on the part of tenant is insufficient. Hence, mere assertion of the respondent in this regard does not amount to any triable issue. Further, in this regard, the provision of Section 19 (2) of DRC Act is to be emphasized which protects a tenant in case the landlord recovers possession of any premises and the premises are not occupied by the landlord or by the person for whose benefit the premises are held within two months of obtaining such possession or having obtained the possession, the same are re-let to any other person within three years -- 14 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 15 of 20 from the date of obtaining the possession. Thus, the said contention is also devoid of merits. 22) Next, it is contended that petitioners have alternative accommodation in the form of vacant room which has been obtained from tenant Kalloo. However, petitioners have averred that the said room is in a dilapidated condition and has been reflected as room without roof in the site plan. No counter site plan has been filed by the respondent to challenge the same. In the case of V.S. Sachdeva Vs. M.L. Grover 1997 (2) RCR 302, it was held that if no site plan is filed by tenant, then the site plan filed by the landlord is deemed to be correct. Also, in the case of Rishal Singh Vs. Bohat Ram & Ors. 2014 (144) DRJ 633, the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi held that it is settled law that when the tenant contests the accuracy of the site plan filed by the landlord, he is required to file a copy of the site plan, he believes to be correct so as to guide the Court in finding the discrepancies in the site plan filed by the landlord. It was observed that without such site plan being filed, the mere contentions raised to this effect will be considered meritless. Thus, the aforesaid contention is devoid of merits. 23) Further, it is trite to state that the burden is upon the tenant to show that other alternative suitable accommodation is available with landlord and how the said premises were suitable for the pleaded requirement. Hence, no triable issue arises on account of said contention. Reference is made to the judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in the case of Lalta Prasad Gupta Vs. Sita Ram, 2017 SCC Online Del 13026, wherein it was held as under :- “18. Thus, if the tenant seeks leave to defend controverting the requirement pleaded by landlord on the ground of the -- 15 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 16 of 20 landlord, though at the time of requirement having alternate premises, having not used the same and instead having commercially exploited the same, the tenant must plead (a) the particulars of such premises; (b) the right/title of the landlord to the same; (c) that the said premises were vacant and available for use at the time of pleaded requirement of landlord; (d) how the said premises were suitable for the pleaded requirement; and (e) how the landlord has deprived himself thereof i.e. by sale or letting and support the said pleas with material on the basis whereof such pleas will be proved.” 24) As far as the contention is concerned that respondent is dependent upon the tenanted premises, it is a well settled principle of law that a Rent Controller has to see the bonafide requirement of the petitioner and not the comparative hardship of the respondent. Reliance in this regard is placed upon the Apex Court’s decision in Bega Begum and Ors. v. Abdul Ahad Khan and Ors (1979) AIR 272 that the inconvenience, loss and trouble resulting from denial of decree of eviction in favour of the landlord far outweigh the prejudice or the inconvenience which will be caused to the tenant. Therefore, no triable issue arises on the said contention. 25) Next, it is contended that the petitioners have already got vacant possession of portion consisting of one room with dallan, laterine, bathroom and kitchen on the first floor and one room on the second floor from tenant Ghyasuddin in the year 2024. However, nothing has been filed to corroborate the same with the leave to defend application. Moreover, no photographs or any counter site plan has been filed to show the purported alternative accommodation in the premises. It is pertinent to note that the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Abid-ul-Islam Vs. Inder Sain Dua, (2022) 6 SCC 30 has held for availing leave to defend a -- 16 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 17 of 20 mere assertion by the tenant is insufficient. Section 14 (1) (e) of the Act creates a presumption in favour of the landlord regarding bona fide need, which is rebuttable only with substantive material capable of raising a triable issue. It was further held that the burden of proof is on the tenant to demonstrate, with cogent evidence, that the landlord’s requirement is not genuine. The Court also reiterated the settled principle of law that leave to defend should not be granted on mere asking but when the pleas and contentions raise triable issues. Also, in case the petitioner fails to occupy the premises as has been claimed by him, the Delhi Rent Control Act also provides for recovery of possession by the respondent/tenant of the tenanted premises for his re-entry and occupation. 26) Next, it is contended that the petitioners have got vacant possession of portion consisting of two rooms, open kitchen, open verandah, one latrine cum bath at first floor and one room and one kitchen at second floor from Saida Begum and the said fact has been admitted by the petitioners in their reply to leave to defend application. However, petitioners have pleaded that they require four separate rooms for their sons (i.e. two sons of petitioner No. 1 and two sons of petitioner No.2); two study rooms, two drawing rooms, two guest rooms with required amenities of kitchen, bathroom, toilet and store room. Hence, it is prayed that petitioners have bonafide requirements of at least 10 more rooms for themselves. The Hon’ble Supreme Court and the Delhi High Court have repeatedly held that the Courts are not to sit in the armchair of the landlord and dictate as to how the available property of the landlord is to be best utilized by him. The landlord is the absolute owner of his property and is the best person to decide which property is to be utilized in what way. The respondent cannot dictate as to how the landlord is to utilize his property. The landlord possesses the prerogative -- 17 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 18 of 20 to determine their specific requirements, exercising full autonomy in this regard. Hence, it is not within the purview of the courts to impose directives on the landlord regarding the nature or quality of their chosen usage of the tenanted premises. Therefore, the courts refrain from prescribing any standard or guidelines for the landlord's choices (residential or commercial). Reliance is placed upon the decision of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in case of Praveen & Anr. Vs. Mulak Raj & Ors. RC Rev. 417/2016 in this regard. Furthermore, in the case titled as Ragavendra Kumar Vs. Firm Prem Machinery 2000 SC 534, it was observed as under:- "It is settled position of law that the landlord is best judge of his requirement for residential or business purpose and he has got complete freedom in the matter, (See: Prativa Devi (Smt.) v. T.K Krishnan, [1996] 5 SCC 353. In the case in hand the plaintiff- landlord wanted eviction of the tenant from the suit premises for starting his business as it was suitable and it cannot be faulted." 27) Therefore, merely because, during the pendency of the petition, petitioner obtained vacant possession of portion on the first floor and second floor of the subject premises from Saida, it does not mean his bonafide requirement stands extinguished. Moreover, bonafide need has to be seen at the time of filing of petition. Furthermore, the requirement of the petitioners is much more than the portion received from Saida. Furthermore, while deciding the question of bonafide requirement of the landlord, it is quite unnecessary to make an endeavor as to how else the landlord could have adjusted. in the case of Ravichandran and Ors. Vs Natrajan Nadar and Ors. (2004) 1 MLJ 458, it was held: -- 18 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 19 of 20 “Even assuming that other premises are available, then the choice is left to the landlord to decide as to which non-residential premises he should occupy, and the tenant cannot have any say in the matter. If the landlord is able to show the bonafide, then the tenant cannot dictate terms to the landlord that he should occupy some other building and not the one mentioned in the petition.”” 28) It is also pertinent to note that part portion of the tenanted premises lies upon the ground floor whereas the portion received from Saida is only on first floor and second floor. Reliance is also placed upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in Amit Khandelwal and Anr. vs. Hem Chand Aluria, RC. Rev. 380/2018 in which the Hon’ble Delhi High Court has held that a tenant cannot dictate to a landlord as to how the landlord is to use his premises and the ground floor would be much more convenient for residential purpose than upper floor. In the present case it is not in dispute that the petitioners are around 50 years of age and therefore portion on the ground floor would be much more convenient for their residential need than the portion on the upper floors. Also, it is trite to state that there is no requirement of the landlord to set out exactly what area is required in terms of giving the measurement. Reliance in this regard is placed upon the order of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in RC Rev. No. 224/2023 Sharad Jain Vs. Jayanti Jain Prasad dated 28.01.2025. 29) Hence, I find that the respondent has failed to raise any triable issue on the aspect of bonafide need and alternative accommodation as well. -- 19 of 20 -- RC ARC No. 696/2024. Mohd. Saleem & Anr. Vs. Mursaleen Page no. 20 of 20 RELIEF 30) Accordingly, in view of the aforesaid discussion and findings, I hold that the petitioners have been able to establish the essential ingredients of petition u/s 14 (1) (e) of DRC Act i.e. landlord-tenant relationship, bonafide necessity and absence of reasonably suitable accommodation. Thus, in view of the foregoing discussion, this court is of the view that no triable issue has been raised by the respondent in his leave to defend application. Accordingly, the leave to defend application is hereby dismissed and consequently, an eviction order u/s 14(1)(e) r/w Section 25B, DRCA is passed in favor of petitioners and against the respondent with respect to the tenanted premises i.e. one room with damaged roof, two open rooms (i.e. rooms without roof), one kitchen, chowk / uncovered/open verandah, common toilet at ground floor (part of ground floor); one room and one kitchen at first floor and one chhappar covered with polythene at second floor of property bearing No. 6251, Gali Jharsanyyan, Qasabpura, Sadar Bazar, Delhi – 110006 and more specifically shown in red color in the site plan. However, in light of Section 14(7) DRCA, the eviction order shall not be executable for a period of six months from today. No order as to costs. File be consigned to Record Room after due compliance. (Announced in the Open Court) (RUPINDER SINGH DHIMAN) ARC-01, Central District, THC Delhi/14.10.2025 -- 20 of 20 --
