Full Order Text
Final Order 11 · 21 Apr 2026 · CNR DLCT030087822024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF DIVYA GUPTA ADDITIONAL RENT CONTROLLER-02 (CENTRAL), TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI RC ARC No.675/2024 In the matter of: - SWEETY MANGLANI W/o Sh. Rajeev Manglani, R/o B-19, Westend Colony, South-West Delhi, New Delhi-110021. ...PETITIONER VERSUS TARUN GULATI (Owner at Real’s by S.L. Gulati & Sons) S/o Late Surender Lal Gulati R/o Z-33-3, West Patel Nagar, New Delhi-110008. Also at: Private Shop No.2 and 10, Municipal No.10549 (5/54) Plot No.54, Block No.5, Western Extension Area, Karol Bagh, New Delhi – 110 005 ...RESPONDENT O R D E R 21.04.2026 1. The application under consideration is the one filed by the respondent/tenant u/s 25(B) of Delhi Rent Control Act ( in short “DRC Act”) seeking leave to contest against the eviction petition filed by the petitioner/landlord under Section 14(1)(e) with section 25(B) of DRC Act for seeking eviction of tenant/ respondent, in respect of private shops No.2 and 10, measuring 200 sq. ft. (approx.), Municipal No.10549 (5/54), Plot No.54, Block No.5, Western Extension Area, Karol Bagh, New Delhi-110005, as shown in red RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 1 of 41 -- 1 of 41 -- colour in site plan annexed with petition ( hereinafter referred as “tenanted premises”). THE PETITION: Succintly put, the facts of petition as alleged by petitioner are such, a. That on 19.07.1993, the petitioner purchased a Built-up property bearing Municipal No.10549 (5/54), Plot No.54, Block No.5, measuring 254.16 sq. yards (approx.), Khasra No. 1597/1147, situated at Western Extension Area, Karol Bagh, New Delhi 110005 ( hereinafter referred to as ‘said property’), from Mr. Arun Chawla S/o Late D.P. Chawla through a duly registered sale deed dated 19.07.1993. b. That at the time of buying the said property, the said property was completely under tenancy and occupation of the tenants including the Respondent herein and same are as follows: a. Sh. Daulat Ram Ahuja- Shop No.1 b. M/s Surendar Lal Ghulati- Shop No.2. c. Smt. Maya Manglani- Shop No.3. d. Sh. Ved Prakash Jaggi- Shop No.4. e. Sh. Amar Nath Chawla- Shop No.5. f. Sh. Tara Chandh Sindhi- Shop No.6. g. Sh. Ghanshyam Dass & Vasdev- Shop No.6A. h. Sh. Darai Lal- Shop No.7. RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 2 of 41 -- 2 of 41 -- i. Sh. Ghanshyam Dass & Jagdish- Shop No.8. j. M/s. Hari Chand Narang- Shop No.9. k. M/s. Surender Lal Ghulati & Sons- Shop No.10. l. Smt. Maya Manglani- Barsati Floor. c. That the tenanted premises/suit property was let out to the respondent herein at the rate of Rs.85/- and Rs.120/- per month for Shop No.2 and 10 respectively for commercial purpose. That after the purchase of the said property on 19.07.1993, the petitioner became the absolute owner and landlord of the said property and stepped into the shoes of the previous landlord and started receiving rent from the respondent. d. That the property tax and electricity bill for the entire said property is paid by the petitioner’s elder son namely, Mr. Sameer Manglani. e. That the Petitioner is a lady who is aged about 60 years old, having two sons namely, Mr. Sameer Manglani and Mr. Akshay Manglani. Both the sons are engaged in their respective businesses. That the petitioner in order to facilitate the respective professional endeavors of her sons, assisted and parted her properties among them and through a mutual oral family settlement, petitioner distributed her properties to her sons for development and expansion of their respective RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 3 of 41 -- 3 of 41 -- businesses. Accordingly, the elder son, Mr. Sameer Manglani received the said property, i.e. built-up 2 and ½ storied property bearing Municipal No.10549 (5/54), Plot No.54, Block No.5, measuring 254.16 sq yards (approx.), Khasra No.1597/1147, situated at Western Extension Area, Karol Bagh, New Delhi. Whereas the younger son, Mr. Akshay Manglani received the Property Bearing No.A-1 Mehrauli, Gurgaon Road, Sushant Lok Phase-1, Sector-28, Gurugram, Haryana 122002. f. That tenanted premises is required for bonafide need of petitioner’s elder son, Mr. Sameer Manglani who has been running women’s ethnic apparels business under the name and style of ‘M/s Meena Bazaar’. That as of now the said brand is present across 33 cities in India and it is renowned for its fashion, high-quality fabrics and intricate craftsmanship, particularly in handloom and embroidered products, which have attracted customers. That due to the high quality of the brand it has gained continuous massive popularity both in India and abroad. In view of the prevailing high competition/high popularity of e-commerce platforms and demand in the market, petitioner’s elder son, Sh. Sameer Manglani has been taking RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 4 of 41 -- 4 of 41 -- steps towards the growth and expansion of his business, however, he has been facing serious inconveniences, challenges and hardships in expanding his business particularly in Delhi (Karol Bagh) due to paucity of market space and proper showrooms/establishments. That due to non-availability of market/commercial space and proper showroom/establishments under one umbrella, he is constrained and forced to take different properties in different locations of Delhi on rent, despite having his own property. Further, he has been incurring unnecessary additional expenditure towards payment of high rent, maintenance, and other charges. It is submitted that this additional expense/expenditure incurred by him could have been used by him for growing his business. Moreover, due to the distance between one shop to another, he is incurring a high amount towards the cost of transportation and logistics as well. g. That Karol Bagh is known and famous as a highly prominent and important commercial marketplace when it comes to ethnic wear and merchandise business in Delhi. Since there are various competitive similar establishments already existing and operating in the said area, the petitioner’s elder son is unable to RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 5 of 41 -- 5 of 41 -- compete in the market on an equal footing, despite the petitioner having her own property right in the middle of the Karol Bagh market. It is also submitted that in this area, the petitioner’s son can get more clientele/business as the area is heavily populated and is promising for commercial activities. h. That the petitioner's elder son is undergoing mental agony operational hardship and challenges and the petitioner is apprehending that if the same continues then her elder son will further suffer. Moreover, due to COVID-19 pandemic, the business of the petitioner's elder son suffered hardships and challenges in his business and is now striving to grow and expand. i. The clientele built by the petitioner's elder son i.e. Sameer Manglani through his business is suffering due to non- availability of proper restrooms, display and shelving areas which includes mannequins to display outfits, wall racks and shelves for organizing clothes, central display units for showcasing new arrivals or special collections, spacious and comfortable trial rooms with mirrors, seating, and proper lighting. comfortable seating for customers convenience, RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 6 of 41 -- 6 of 41 -- customer service counters such as multiple billing counters and dedicated customer service desks for inquiries etc., storage areas having adequate storage space/ rooms to stock inventory and back-up supplies, and inadequate distance between different rented properties in different locations of Delhi. j. That Mr. Sameer Manglani is having the physical possession of the hall, on both the ground and the first floor, including the shops bearing shop number l, 3, and 7 which are under use and occupation by him for the business activities/ storage. However, the same is not sufficient and conducive for the business/showroom expansion. It would be convenient for him to expand his business by merging the tenanted premises with the existing premises, facilitating the creation of a proper showroom/corporate establishment to support the growth of his business and clientele. k. That the petitioner is simultaneously filing / in the process of filling other eviction petitions for other tenants who have been occupying the Entire said Property since last three decades on rent, for the purpose of making a proper showroom with all amenities as mentioned above. RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 7 of 41 -- 7 of 41 -- l. That petitioner does not have any other reasonably suitable alternative property in Delhi for running the said business. 2. For this need of the petitioner, eviction of respondent is prayed for. THE APPLICATION SEEKING LEAVE TO DEFEND: 3. Summons were served upon the respondent who filed leave to defend application with documents along with separate detailed affidavit mainly on the ground that the petitioner has alternate accommodations available and that the need projected by her is not Bonafide. The grounds raised by respondent, in brief, are as follows: a) That there is no landlord tenant relationship between the petitioner and the respondent. Respondent is not a proprietor of the firm namely ‘S.L. Gulati and Sons’. b) That petitioner has various properties available at her disposal and the instant case is only a case of additional accommodation. It is also come to the knowledge of the respondent that the petitioner has filed another Eviction Petition bearing No.642/2024 titled as "Sweety Manglani Vs Dalip Kumar" as well as another Eviction Petition bearing No.702 of 2024 titled as "Sweety Manglani Vs Sumit Chawla" which is pending RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 8 of 41 -- 8 of 41 -- adjudication before this Court and which shows that alleged requirement is only for additional accommodation. c) The petitioner in the entire petition has also not disclosed the alleged date of the oral family settlement/arrangement. d) The respondent is placing on record that screenshots of the website of the petitioner who is running a showroom under the name and style of “Meena Bazar”. Admittedly, the said brand of the petitioner has showrooms/ presence across all major cities in India. That the petitioner is a lady of means and financial status and has various commercial properties in her name. e) That the petitioner has not placed on record the existing space available to her. The petitioner has sufficient space in the entire said property and an approx. area of 1700 sq. ft. is available with the petitioner on the ground floor of the said Property. Similarly, on the first floor an area approx. 2500 sq. ft. is available with the petitioner. Further, an area of approx. 2500 sq ft. is available on the Second Floor and an area of approx. 2600 sq. ft. is available on the Third Floor with the petitioner. f) The respondent believes that as per the information available on the website as well as Google Search Engine, the petitioner has RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 9 of 41 -- 9 of 41 -- already partnered/collaborated with Unicommerce to strengthen its operation and presence across the country. In pursuance to the said understanding, the petitioner would be providing her stores/commercial properties to its partners and would be letting out the said spaces in lieu of very high rent. g) That site plan filed by petitioner is not correct as copy of site plan supplied is a photocopy of the blue print site plan and the same is not bearing any color or having any municipal numbers. Further there is no mention as to which portion is under the possession of the respondent. 4. Upon these grounds, the respondent prayed that there exist triable issues that would disentitle the petitioner from obtaining an eviction order in respect of tenanted premises. REPLY: 5. Reply to leave to defend application has been filed by the petitioner along with supporting affidavit wherein she has denied that the present petition is based on false and frivolous grounds and does not contain the ingredients of Section 14(1)(e) of DRC Act. The RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 10 of 41 -- 10 of 41 -- petitioner denies all the allegations and assertions made in leave to defend application and affidavit. 6. It is further submitted that tenancy was created in favor of respondent’s predecessor in interest and respondent himself. Respondent is the son and legal heir of Late Sh. Surender Lal Gulati, who was the original tenant in possession of tenanted premises. That respondent has not denied the tenancy in favour of “S.L. Gulati & Sons”. Respondent has not even filed any rent receipts to establish who is a tenant. 7. Further submitted that the petitioner is the lawful owner of built up 2½ storey building. That entire premise is comprising the ground, first, second and half portion above second floor and same are fully occupied and actively utilized for business operation of the petitioner’s son. That inadvertently the second and half portion, i.e. third floor which was under use and occupation of petitioner was not captured in the petition, but sale deed clearly discloses the possession of 2½ storey building with petitioner. Each available floor is under continuous commercial use and petitioner has been consistently using all the premises for her son’s commercial activities, stockpiling garments and related materials for business. RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 11 of 41 -- 11 of 41 -- Further that a temporary shed was erected on top to accommodate solar panel, AC exhaust units and a small cafeteria for employees. 8. That due to space constraint, son of petitioner Sh. Sameer Manglani is constrained and forced to take different properties in Delhi on rent despite having own property. Further he is forced to take office premises at Gurugram for his head office on rent. Petitioner has placed on record copy of lease deed and certain photographs. THE REJOINDER: 9. Rejoinder filed by the respondent to the reply of leave to defend application. ARGUMENTS: 10. I have heard learned counsel for both the parties and perused the records of the case very carefully. THE LAW: 11. The present petition for eviction is under clause (e) of proviso to sub-section (1) of section 14 of Act 59 of 1958 which after the RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 12 of 41 -- 12 of 41 -- judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in “Satyawati Sharma Versus Union of India”, on 16.04.2008 reads as under: - “14. (1) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in any other law or contract, no order or decree for the recovery of possession of any premises shall be made by any court or Controller in favour of the landlord against a tenant: Provided that the Controller may, on an application made to him in the prescribed manner, make an order for the recovery of possession of the premises on one or more of the following grounds only, namely: - * * * (e) that the premises are required bona fide by the landlord for occupation for himself or for any member of his family dependent on him, if he is the owner thereof, or for any person for whose benefit the premises are held and that the landlord or such person has no other reasonably suitable accommodation.” 12. In order to succeed in a petition for eviction filed under section 14 (1) (e) of the DRC Act, the petitioner must establish the following ingredients: - (i) That he is the owner of the tenanted shop and there exits relationship of landlord and tenant between him and the respondent. (ii) That tenanted shop is required bonafide by the petitioner for himself or for any member of his family dependent upon him. RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 13 of 41 -- 13 of 41 -- (iii) That the petitioner does not have any other alternate, reasonable and suitable accommodation. 13. The facts and circumstances of the present case are being analyzed hereunder keeping in view the principle of law as discussed above. I. Ownership of the petitioner over the tenanted premises as well as existence of landlord-tenant relationship between the petitioner and the respondent. 13.1. Before going into facts, it is important to discuss the law regarding concept of ‘ownership’ under the DRC Act which is different from the title suit under CPC. In case titled as Jiwan Lal Vs. Gurdial Kaur & Ors. 1995 RLR 162 a Bench of Hon'ble High Court of Delhi while dealing with the concept of ownership in a pending eviction petition under Section 14(1)(e) of the DRC Act had noted as follows: - "There is a tendency on the part of tenants to deny ownership in cases under Section 14(1) (e). To test the substance of such a plea on the part of the tenants the Courts have insisted that they should state who else is the owner of the premises if not the petitioner. In the present case it is not said as to who else is the owner. Further these cases under Section 14(1)(e) are not title cases involving disputes of title to the property. Ownership is not to be proved in absolute terms. The respondent does not claim the owner of the RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 14 of 41 -- 14 of 41 -- premises." 13.2. In Ramesh Chand vs. Uganti Devi, 157 (2009) DLT 450, this Court has specifically held that: - "It is settled preposition of law that in order to consider the concept of ownership under Delhi Rent Control Act, the Court has to see the title and right of the landlord qua the tenant. The only thing to be seen by the Court is that the landlord had been receiving rent for his own benefit and not for and on behalf of someone else. If the landlord was receiving rent for himself and not on behalf of someone else, he is to be considered as the owner, howsoever imperfect his title over the premises may be. The imperfectness of the title of the premises cannot stand in the way of an eviction petition under Section 14 (1) (e) of the D.R.C. Act, neither the tenant can be allowed to raise the plea of imperfect title or title not vesting in the landlord and that too when the tenant has been paying rent to the landlord. Section 116 of the Evidence Act creates estoppel against such tenant. A tenant can challenge the title of landlord only after vacating the premises and not when he is occupying the premises. In fact, such a tenant who denies the title of the landlord, qua the premises, to whom he is paying rent, acts dishonestly. I, therefore, find that there was no infirmity in the order of learned ARC in this respect". 13.3. Further, in the case titled as Smt. Shanti Sharma & Ors. Vs Smt. Ved Prabha & Ors 1987 AIR 2028, the Hon'ble Supreme Court RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 15 of 41 -- 15 of 41 -- observed: - “That the meaning of term 'owner' is vis a vis the tenant i.e. the owner should be something more than the tenant.” 14.It is also well settled that the petitioner should be something more than the tenant and the petitioner need not prove his ownership in absolute terms. It is sufficient for the petitioner to prove or to show that he is something more than a tenant. 13.4. Hence, it is well-settled that for the purpose of seeking eviction, the landlady/landlord was only required to show that he was enjoying rights in respect of the subject premises and held better title than the tenant. In fact, vesting of absolute ownership is not a pre-requisite for adjudication of an Eviction Petition under Section 14(1)(e) of the DRC Act. The landlord’s ownership is good against the world except the true owner. 13.5. Now reverting to facts of the instant petition, the case of petitioner in brief is that petitioner became the absolute owner of the said property, i.e. Built-up property bearing Municipal No.10549 (5/54), Plot No.54, Block No.5, measuring 254.16 sq. yards (approx.), Khasra No.1597/1147, situated at Western Extension Area, Karol Bagh, New Delhi 110005 (which includes tenanted premises) RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 16 of 41 -- 16 of 41 -- by virtue of registered sale deed dated 19.07.1993. That the tenanted premises was let out to the respondent at the rate of Rs. 85/- and Rs. 120/- per month for Shop No.2 and 10 respectively for commercial purpose. 13.6. It is argued on behalf of petitioner that after the purchase of the said property on 19.07.1993, the petitioner became the absolute owner and landlord of the said property and stepped into the shoes of the previous landlord and started receiving rent from the respondent. Further that the petitioner in order to facilitate the respective professional endeavors of her sons through a mutual oral family settlement, petitioner distributed her properties to her sons. Accordingly, the elder son, Mr. Sameer Manglani received the said property i.e., built-up 2 and ½ storied property bearing Municipal No.10549 (5/54), Plot No.54, Block No.5, measuring 254.16 sq yards (approx.), Khasra No.1597/1147, situated at Western Extension Area, Karol Bagh, New Delhi. Whereas the younger son, Mr. Akshay Manglani received the Property Bearing No. A-1 Mehrauli, Gurgaon Road, Sushant Lok Phase-1, Sector-28, Gurugram, Haryana 122002. Further that the property tax and electricity bill for the entire said property is paid by the petitioner’s elder son namely, Mr. Sameer RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 17 of 41 -- 17 of 41 -- Manglani. 13.7. Petitioner has relied upon a copy of registered sale deed dated 19.07.1993; copy of receipt dated 30.05.2024 for payment of property tax to MCD; copy of electricity bills, site plan of tenanted premises as well as entire said property along with photographs. 13.8. It is pertinent to note that in the leave to defend, respondent has nowhere disputed the ownership of petitioner over tenanted premises. Though respondent has denied landlord-tenant relationship with petitioner, however same is a vague and bald averment. The only objection taken by respondent is that tenancy was in favor of “ S.L. Gulati and sons” and that respondent is not a proprietor of the firm namely “S .L. Gulati and Sons”. In support of his contention respondent has filed license taken under section 417 of DMC Act 1957 which is in the name of Sh. Priyansh Gulati which was issued on 14.06.2023 and GST Registration certificate issued on 17.03.2023 in the name of Sh. Priyansh Gulati. 13.9. On the other hand, it is argued on behalf of petitioner that respondent is the son and legal heir of Late Sh. Surender Lal Gulati, who was the original tenant in possession of tenanted premises. That RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 18 of 41 -- 18 of 41 -- after death of Sh. Surender Lal Gulati, respondent has become tenant by operation of law. 13.10. Hence, the contention of petitioner is that respondent’s father was the original tenant in suit premises and that upon his demise, respondent being his legal heir, has acquired tenancy by operation of law. Same is evident from registered sale deed dated 19.07.1993 in favor of petitioner. 13.11. It is observed that both the above said documents relied upon by respondent, have trade name “ S L Gulati & Sons”. The respondent has failed to disclose his relationship, if any, with Sh. Priyansh Gulati. It is pertinent to note that respondent has nowhere denied the tenancy in favour of “ S.L. Gulati & Sons”. Admittedly, “ S L Gulati and Sons” is a proprietorship firm. It is a settled law that proprietorship does not have a separate entity from the proprietor. It is not in dispute that respondent is the son of Late Sh. Surender Lal Gulati. Respondent has not even filed any rent receipt to establish who is a tenant. Further it is trite that when original tenant dies, the legal heirs inherit the tenancy as joint tenants and occupation of one of the tenants is occupation of all the joint tenants. It is not necessary RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 19 of 41 -- 19 of 41 -- for landlord to implead all legal heirs of the deceased tenant, whether they are occupying the property or not. It is sufficient for the landlord to implead either of those persons who are occupying the property, as party. Reliance is placed upon case titled as Suresh Kumar Kohli Vs. Rakesh Jain (Civil Appeal No.3996 of 2018 decided on 19.04.2018). Hence, all the averments of respondent are baseless and unsubstantiated. 13.12. Here, I also find it pertinent to refer to the decision of the Hon'ble High Court passed in the case of Mohd. Naseer Vs. Mohd. Zaheer and Anr. RC Rev. No. 267/2016 dated 03.11.2016 is to be noted in which the following was held:- “19. ...Mere raising of baseless contentions against the landlord cannot be a ground for being granted leave to defend to the petitioners. It cannot be said that the petitioners have given facts or particulars which require to be established by way of evidence. The petitioners have merely made allegations for the sake of making allegation. There is no merit in the said plea of the petitioner. 20. The trial court has rightly concluded that the petitioners have failed to place on record any material to raise a suspicion that the respondents are having a vacant space on the ground floor of the suit property which can RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 20 of 41 -- 20 of 41 -- be used by them to open his workshop for industrial tools." 13.13. It is observed that the legal preposition is very well settled that once a tenant is always a tenant. That section 116 of Indian Evidence Act lays down as under: “116. Estoppel of tenant; and of licensee of person in possession.—No tenant of immovable property, or person claiming through such tenant, shall, during the continuance of the tenancy, be permitted to deny that the landlord of such tenant had, at the beginning of the tenancy, a title to such immovable property; and no person who came upon any immovable property by the licence of the person in possession thereof, shall be permitted to deny that such person had a title to such possession at the time when such license was given.” 13.14. Therefore, relationship of landlord and tenant between the petitioner and the respondent is not in question in any manner. Thus, there is no triable issue with respect to ownership of petitioner and landlord-tenant relationship between petitioner and respondent. II. Bonafide requirement of the petitioner: 13.15. The petitioner has stated in the petition that tenanted premises is required for bonafide need of petitioner’s elder son, Mr. Sameer RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 21 of 41 -- 21 of 41 -- Manglani who has been running women’s ethnic apparels business under the name and style of M/s Meena Bazaar. The case of the petitioner that in view of the prevailing high competition/high popularity of e-commerce platforms and demand in the market, Petitioner’s elder son, Sh. Sameer Manglani has been taking steps towards the growth and expansion of his business, however, he has been facing serious inconveniences, challenges and hardships in expanding his business particularly in Delhi (Karol Bagh) due to paucity of market space and proper showrooms/establishments. That due to non-availability of market/commercial space and proper showroom/establishments under one umbrella, he is constrained and forced to take different properties in different locations of Delhi on rent, despite having his own Property. Further, he has been incurring unnecessary additional expenditure towards payment of high rent, maintenance, and other charges. Moreover, due to the distance between one shop to another, he is incurring a high amount towards the cost of transportation and logistics as well. 13.16. On the other hand, it is argued on behalf of respondent that intention of petitioner is not bonafide as admittedly said brand of the petitioner has showrooms/ presence across all major cities in India. RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 22 of 41 -- 22 of 41 -- Further that the petitioner is a lady of means and financial status and has various commercial properties in her name. 13.17. It is observed that if a person is running an established business or if he is a settled and a big businessman, it cannot be assumed by the court that there cannot be any requirement of such person to start a new business. In the present case, petitioner has already disclosed that he has business spread all over India and son of petitioner wants to expand the same. The financial affluence of a person cannot be a determining factor to adjudicate that the requirement of the tenanted premises is bonafide or not. The term ‘bonafide’ has to be construed liberally and it cannot be interpreted in such a manner that the scope of the words ‘bonafide requirement’ is limited to the ‘bonafide need’. In this regard reference can be made to the judgement of Nisar Ahmad Vs. Agyapal Singh, MANU/DE/4291/2023, where in Hon’ble High Court of Delhi held that: “……. The court is of the view that the status of financial well- being of a landlord or his family members-wife and children, who are dependent upon him, is not the test of bonafide requirement. All that was to be seen was whether there was a suitable alternate accommodation available with the landlord, for him to use or for providing the same to his daughters. No such suitable alternate accommodation has been shown. The RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 23 of 41 -- 23 of 41 -- impugned judgement has misdirected itself in an inquiry about landlord’s, his wife’s and of the business of the husbands of the dependent daughters’ or their economic well- being or in concluding that simply because the daughters of the petitioner were married, “happy with their matrimonial life” and alternate accommodation was available with their respective husbands, therefore, there was no need for them to start their business or to ask their father to provide them an accommodation experience for business….” 13.18. It is contended by the respondent that as per the information available on the website as well as Google Search Engine, the petitioner has already partnered/collaborated with Unicommerce to strengthen its operation and presence across the country. In pursuance to the said understanding, the petitioner would be providing her Stores/ Commercial Properties to its Partners and would be letting out the said spaces in lieu of very high rent. Per contra same has been denied by petitioner. 13.19. It is observed that firstly same are bald averments. Secondly, said apprehension is already taken care of in the DRC Act itself by our legislative forefathers while enacting the laws who have already considered possibility of misuse in the hands of unscrupulous RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 24 of 41 -- 24 of 41 -- landlords and thereby inserted Section 19 of DRC Act which reads as follows: - "Where a landlord recovers possession of any premises and the premises are not occupied by the landlord or by the person for whose benefit the premises are held, within two months of obtaining such possession, or the premises having been so occupied are, at any time within three years from the date of obtaining possession, relet to any person than the evicted tenant without obtaining the permission of the Controller such tenant can be put back to the premises or can be paid such compensation as the Controller thinks fit." 13.20. Hence, if the requirement of landlord is not bonafide and if a landlord abuses the process of the court, obtains an order of eviction, subsequently lets out the property or sells the same, the tenant can always apply for restitution under section 19 of the DRC Act. 13.21. It is further argued on behalf of respondent that petitioner has filed similar petitions against other tenants as well and that petitioner has filed other eviction petition No.642/2024 and petition No.702/2024 and that present is a case of additional accommodation. However, it is observed that petitioner has already explained in detail the nature and purpose of requirement of the whole building/said property and petitioner has already submitted that the area which is RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 25 of 41 -- 25 of 41 -- in physical possession is not sufficient and has further categorically stated that the eviction petition has been filed against other tenants as well. The court is of the view that tenant/respondent cannot dictate the petitioner as to how and in what manner the petitioner has to build, construct and utilize the space available to her. Fact that the respondents are tenant in the tenanted premises for last 30 years itself does not create right in perpetuity in his favor. 13.22. The Ld. Counsel for petitioner has relied upon case titled Sandeep Kumar vs Nihal Chand 2025 SCC OnLine Del 6418 wherein the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi has made following observations: “27. In the present case, the tenant is actually urging the ground of 'additional' accommodation available with the landlord, which is different from 'alternative' accommodation available with the landlord. Merely because the landlord has/ possessed/ owned 'additional' accommodations other than the subject premises from which he is seeking eviction cannot be treated as the landlord having an alternative accommodation. It is to be borne in mind that the parameters for gauging the two are totally different and cannot always be taken to be overlapping with each other. By mixing them together, the tenant cannot make a case for denying the relief sought by the landlord under an eviction petition under Section 14(1)(e) of the DRC Act, particularly, since RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 26 of 41 -- 26 of 41 -- there is no bar under the DRC Act for the landlord to seek eviction of the tenant from the subject premises simply because he is the owner/ landlord of any other premises. . . 31. In any event, to hold that the tenant must be granted leave to defend as a thumb rule in all cases where the landlord has 'additional accommodation', wrongly treated as an 'alternative accommodation', would restrict the summary procedure envisaged under Section 25B of the DRC Act only to a landlord having only the premises wherefrom he is seeking eviction. This would be absurd as it would create an artificial distinction, contrary to the legislative intent underlying the introduction of the summary procedure. There is nothing of that sort provided either in Section 14(1) (e) or in Section 25B of the DRC Act. In the absence of any such limitation, no distinction can be read into the statute between the requirement of landlords who have no accommodation at all and one who, though have some accommodation albeit insufficient. As held by this Court in Naresh Kumar Jain v. S Shanmuga Sundaram36, any such interpretation would amount to arbitrary discrimination. 32. Lastly, reliance on Santosh Devi (supra) by learned counsel for the tenant is misplaced since it was passed under different set of facts and does not lay any principle of law required to be followed in all cases of RC.REV. No. 283 Of 2017 additional accommodation. In fact, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Madan Lal Gupta v. Ravinder Kumar37 has held as under: RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 27 of 41 -- 27 of 41 -- "2. However, the learned counsel for the petitioner sought to rely upon two decisions of this Court in Santosh Devi Soni v. Chand Kiran [(2001) 1 SCC at p. 255 : JT (2000) 3 SC 397] and Liaq Ahmed v. Habeeb-Ur- Rehman [(2000) 5 SCC 708 : JT (2000) 5 SC 611] . Neither of these two decisions set down any principle of law so as to call for interference by us. In these two cases on the facts arising in the case certain orders have been passed by this Court." 33. Moreover, this Court in line of precedents has held that grant/ allowing of an application for leave to defend is dependent upon the facts and circumstances involved in each case. Even if the landlord has additional accommodations, if it appears to the Court that accommodation available with the landlord is insufficient/ unsuitable/ out of place/ unbefitting/ not commensurate to the demand(s) of the landlord for his requirement pleaded, then leave to defend can be denied.” 13.23. It is further observed that the law is very well settled that the requirement of the landlord is to be presumed as genuine and, in this regard, reference can be also made to the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court titled as Abid-Ur-Islam Vs Indersen Dua dated 07.04.2022, wherein it was observed as follows: - “……...when a landlord asserts that he requires his building for his own occupation, the Rent Controller shall not proceed on the presumption that the requirement is not bonafide. When other conditions of the RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 28 of 41 -- 28 of 41 -- clause are satisfied and when the landlord shows a prima facie case, it is open to the Rent Controller to draw a presumption that requirement of the landlord is bonafide……”. 13.24. Further at this juncture, the law regarding the bonafide need has been made clear by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case titled as “Sarla Ahuja v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. reported as AIR 1999 Supreme Court 100”, whereby it was held that: “.... The crux of the ground envisaged in clause (e) of Section 14(1) of the Act is that the requirement of the landlord for occupation of the tenanted premises must be bona fide. When a landlord asserts that he requires his building for his own occupation the Rent Controller shall not proceed on the presumption that the requirement is not bona fide. When other conditions of the clause are satisfied and when the landlord shows a prima facie case it is open to the Rent Controller to draw a presumption that the requirement of the landlord is bona fide. It is often said by Courts that it is not for the tenant to dictate terms to the landlord as to how else he can adjust himself without getting possession of the tenanted premises. While deciding the question of bonafides of the requirement of the landlord it is quite unnecessary to make an endeavour as to how else the landlord could have adjusted himself....” RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 29 of 41 -- 29 of 41 -- 13.25. Now in view of this legal position and present facts and circumstances, it is observed that in the entire application for leave to defend the respondent has failed to specifically plead even a single word to deny the bonafide requirement of the petitioner as stated in the eviction petition and on the other hand petitioner has stated her bonafide need in a very detailed manner, therefore, the presumption of genuineness of requirement has to be drawn in favour of petitioner only. 13.26. Thus, respondent has failed to raise any triable issue qua the bonafide requirement of the petitioner. III. The petitioner does not have any other alternate, reasonable and suitable accommodation. 13.27. It is submitted on behalf of petitioner that petitioner does not have any other reasonably suitable alternative property in Delhi for bonafide need of her elder son. 13.28. Respondent has taken an objection that the petitioner has not placed on record the existing space available to her. That petitioner has sufficient space in the entire said property and an approx. area of 1700 sq. ft. is available with the petitioner on the ground floor of the RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 30 of 41 -- 30 of 41 -- said property. Similarly, on the first floor an area approx. 2500 sq. ft. is available with the petitioner. Further, an area of approx. 2500 sq ft. is available on the Second Floor and an area of approx. 2600 sq. ft. is available on the Third Floor with the petitioner. 13.29. Per contra in reply to leave to defend, petitioner has submitted that petitioner is the lawful owner of built up 2½ storey building. That entire premise is comprising the ground, first, second and half portion above second floor and same are fully occupied and actively utilized for business operation of the petitioner’s son. That inadvertently the second and half portion, i.e. third floor which was under use and occupation of petitioner was not captured in the petition, but sale deed clearly discloses the possession of 2½ storey building with petitioner. Each available floor is under continuous commercial use and petitioner has been consistently using all the premises for her son’s commercial activities, stockpiling garments and related materials for business. Further that a temporary shed was erected on top to accommodate solar panel, AC exhaust units and a small cafeteria for employees. 13.30. Perusal of record shows that in the petition itself petitioner has averred that Mr. Sameer Manglani is having the physical possession RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 31 of 41 -- 31 of 41 -- of the hall, on both the ground and the first floor, including the shops bearing shop No.l, 3, and 7 which are under use and occupation by him for the business activities/ storage. However, the same is not sufficient and conducive for the business/showroom expansion. Petitioner has already expressed her son’s need to expand his business by merging the tenanted premises with the existing premises, facilitating the creation of a proper showroom /corporate establishment to support the growth of his business and clientele. Respondent has failed to show that any portion of floors above said property are available with petitioner for alleged bonafide need. 13.31. Further it is pertinent to note requirement of petitioner is of shop at ground floor. The Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in the case of M/s A.K. Woolen Industries & Ors. Vs. Shri Narayan Gupta RC. Rev. No.495/2017 dated 31.10.2017 held that availability of upper floors above the tenanted premises on the ground floor cannot be said to be alternate suitable accommodation. In view of above discussion, even for the sake of arguments if it is assumed that above floors are available to the petitioner, the same cannot be considered to be as suitable as is the tenanted premises, which is on the ground floor for the business of the petitioner’s son. RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 32 of 41 -- 32 of 41 -- 13.32. In the case of Ravichandran and Ors. Vs Natrajan Nadar and Ors. (2004) 1 MLJ 458, the following was held: “Even assuming that other premises are available, then the choice is left to the landlord to decide as to which non- residential premises he should occupy, and the tenant cannot have any say in the matter. If the landlord is able to show the bonafide, then the tenant cannot dictate terms to the landlord that he should occupy some other building and not the one mentioned in the petition.” 13.33. At this juncture, it is also pertinent to mention that in case titled as “Balwant Singh @ Bant Singh & Anr. v. Sudarshan Kumar & Anr.” in case bearing Civil Appeal Nos. 231-232 of 2021 decided on 27.01.2021 the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed that: “It is not for the tenant to dictate how much space is adequate for the proposed business venture or to suggest that the available space with the landlord will be adequate. It has further been observed that the genuine need of the appellant to secure vacant possession of the premises for the proposed business is found to be established. The adequacy or otherwise of the space available with the landlord for the business in mind is not for the tenant to dictate” RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 33 of 41 -- 33 of 41 -- 13.34. It is further pertinent to note that petitioner in petition itself has already stated that the tenanted suit premises is situated in the Karol Bagh which is known and famous as a highly prominent and important commercial marketplace when it comes to ethnic wear and merchandise business in Delhi. Since there are various competitive, similar establishments already existing and operating in the said area, the petitioner’s elder son is unable to compete in the market on an equal footing, despite the petitioner having her own property right in the middle of the Karol Bagh market. It is also submitted that in this area, the petitioner’s son can get more clientele/business as the area is heavily populated and is promising for commercial activities. It is a settled law that suitability has to be seen from the convenience of landlord. 13.35. It is trite that tenant cannot dictate the landlord as to what is adequate and landlord is the best judge of his requirements. It is a settled law that mere availability of other alternate accommodation is itself not the decisive factor for denial of eviction proceedings by the landlord, more so, since there are various factors like the size, location, access, purpose, viability, safety concerns, football, and/or like, amongst others which have/ are to be taken into consideration RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 34 of 41 -- 34 of 41 -- while dealing with the aspect of availability of alternate suitable accommodation. Reliance is placed upon case titled as Shiv Sarup Gupta v Dr. Mahesh Chand Gupta [(1999) 6 SCC 222]. 13.36. In the case of Ravichandran and Ors. Vs Natrajan Nadar and Ors. (2004) 1 MLJ 458, the following was held: “Even assuming that other premises are available, then the choice is left to the landlord to decide as to which non- residential premises he should occupy, and the tenant cannot have any say in the matter. If the landlord is able to show the bonafide, then the tenant cannot dictate terms to the landlord that he should occupy some other building and not the one mentioned in the petition.” 13.37. The contention of respondent that petitioner has many other properties which she has not disclosed is vague and bald and does not hold any water. Further, in the eviction petition, the landlord need not disclose the alternate properties available to him if he is of the view that the alternate properties are unsuitable for him. The eviction petition is not a declaration or disclosure of all the immovable assets of the landlord and then and the exercise of sifting through the ones’ which are or could be deemed to be suitable as alternate accommodation. For any property to be considered RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 35 of 41 -- 35 of 41 -- alternately available, it has first to be available, i.e. in possession of the landlord and capable of being put to immediate use; thereafter only the issue of its suitability for the bona fide need arises. The landlord’s discretion and prerogative in this regard cannot be questioned, except insofar as it is not whimsical, ex facie or shockingly unreasonable. Reliance is placed upon Babu Lal vs Atul Kumar & Anr. CRP No.147 of 2012 passed by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi. 13.38. Even otherwise, it can be observed that it is not for the tenant to dictate to the landlord that how he should meet or fulfill his requirement. In this regard reference can be also made to the judgment of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi titled as Sudesh Kumar Soni & Ors. Vs. Prabha Khanna & Ors. [153 (2008) DLT 652] it was observed that: - “24. It is often said by courts that it is not for the tenant to dictate terms to the landlord as to how else he can adjust himself without getting possession of the tenanted premises. While deciding the question of bona fides of the requirement of the landlord it is quite unnecessary to make an endeavour as to how else the landlord could have adjusted himself. 25. Suitability has to be seen from the convenience of the landlord and his family members and on the basis of the RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 36 of 41 -- 36 of 41 -- circumstances including their profession, vocation, style of living, habits and background. Landlord is the best judge of his residential requirement”. 14. In Shiv Sarup Gupta Vs Dr. Mahesh Chand Gupta [AIR 1999 SC 2507], at pg-2512 in para 14 & 15, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that: - "14. The availability of an alternate accommodation with the landlord i.e. an accommodation other than the one in occupation of the tenant wherefrom he is sought to be evicted has a dual relevancy. Firstly, the availability of another accommodation, suitable and convenient in all respects as the suit accommodation, may have an adverse bearing on the finding as to bonafides of the landlord if he unreasonably refuses to occupy the available premises to satisfy his alleged need. Availability of such circumstance would enable the Court drawing an inference that the need of the landlord was not a felt need or the state of mind of the landlord was not honest, sincere, and natural. Secondly, another principal ingredient of Clause (e) of Sub-section (1) of Section 14 which speaks of non- availability of any other reasonably suitable residential accommodation to the landlord, would not be satisfied. Wherever another residential accommodation is shown to exist as available than the court has to ask the landlord why he is not occupying such other available accommodation to satisfy his need. The landlord may convince the court that the alternate residential accommodation though available is still of no consequence as the RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 37 of 41 -- 37 of 41 -- same is not reasonably suitable to satisfy the felt need which the landlord has succeeded in demonstrating objectively to exist. Needless to say that an alternate accommodation, to entail denial of the claim of the landlord, must be reasonably suitable, obviously in comparison with the suit accommodation wherefrom the landlord is seeking eviction. Convenience and safety of the landlord and his family members would be relevant fact Ors. While considering the totality of the circumstances, the court may keep in view the profession or vocation of the landlord and his family members, their style of living, their habits and the background wherefrom they come.” 14.1. In the case titled as Ragavendra Kumar Vs Firm Prem Machinery [AIR 2000 SC 534], it was observed as under: - “It is settled position of law that the landlord is best judge of his requirement for residential or business purpose and he has got complete freedom in the matter, (See: Prativa Devi (Smt.) v. T.K Krishnan, [1996] 5 SCC 353. In the case in hand the plaintiff- landlord wanted eviction of the tenant from the suit premises for starting his business as it was suitable and it cannot be faulted.” 14.2. In Praveen and Another vs Mulak Raj and Others (2023) SCC OnLine Del 7721, it has been held by the Hon’ble High Court that the Courts are not to sit in the armchair of the landlord and dictate as to how the available property of the landlord is to be best utilized by RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 38 of 41 -- 38 of 41 -- him. The landlord is the absolute owner of his property and is the best person to decide which property is to be utilized in what way. 14.3. In view of the settled legal position, it is not for the respondent to dictate to the petitioner that it should use some other accommodation for its business, even if it is indeed available with the petitioner. The tenanted premises belong to the petitioner and it is for the petitioner to see whether it is suitable for its requirement or not. It is the right of the petitioner to choose a property which is going to be more profitable and convenient for his business. If the tenanted premises is suitable as per his needs, the petitioner has every right to possess the said premises and the respondent cannot contend that the petitioner should manage his affairs otherwise. While deciding the question of bonafide requirement of the landlord, it is quite unnecessary to make an endeavour as to how else the landlord could have adjusted. In view of the above discussion, the allegation of the respondent that the petitioner has alternative suitable accommodations does not give rise to any triable issue. 14.4. Accordingly, I am duly satisfied that the petitioner needs the tenanted premises in question for purpose of setting up/expansion of business of her son, Sh. Sameer Manglani and I am further satisfied RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 39 of 41 -- 39 of 41 -- that the petitioner does not have any other alternate property available with her to fulfill the said requirement. 14.5. After analysis of the present factual situation in backdrop of the law discussed above, this Court is of the considered opinion that respondent has failed to raise any triable issue in respect of bonafide need of petitioner and alternate accommodation available with the petitioner. 14.6. Thus, this court is of the considered opinion that the need set up by the landlord/petitioner is genuine and bonafide and there is no alternate suitable accommodation available to her. CONCLUSION: 15. Hence, the present petition for eviction is allowed and an application for leave to defend stands disposed of accordingly as dismissed. The petitioner is held entitled to recover the possession of private shop No.2 and 10, measuring 200 sq. ft. (approx.), Municipal No.10549 (5/54), Plot No.54, Block No.5, Western Extension Area, Karol Bagh, New Delhi-110005, as shown in red color in the site plan annexed with petition. However, the petitioner would not be entitled to initiate execution proceedings for recovery of the possession of RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 40 of 41 -- 40 of 41 -- the tenanted premises before expiration of six months from today in view of provisions given in Section 14 (7) of the Act. 16. In the facts and circumstances of the case there shall be no order as to costs. 17. File be consigned to Record Room after due compliance. (This order contains 41 pages and each page has been signed by me) ANNOUNCED IN OPEN COURT (Divya Gupta) Today i.e. on 21.04.2026 ARC-02 (Central) Tis Hazari Courts/Delhi RC ARC No.675/2024 Sweety Manglani Vs. Tarun Gulati Pg 41 of 41 -- 41 of 41 --
