Full Order Text
Final Order 6 · 10 Jul 2025 · CNR DLCT030079342024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: M/s Rajkamal Enterprises vs. Aparajita CS SCJ No.: - 1993/2024 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Page 1 of 6 (Charan Salwan) Civil Judge-03, Central, Delhi IN THE COURT OF MS. CHARAN SALWAN, CIVIL JUDGE-03, DISTRICT CENTRAL, TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI CS SCJ No. :- 1993/2024 CNR No. :- DLCT03-007934-2024 In the matter of; M/s Rajkamal Enterprises Through its Authorised Signatory/ Representative Mr. Raj Kumar Gupta 2502/8, Beadon Pura, Karol Bagh, Delhi - 110005 Also, at:- 2188/62, G.F., Naiwalan, Gurudwara Road, Karol Bagh Delhi - 110005 ...Plaintiff Versus Aparajita 1, The Airconditioned Market, Shakespeare Sarani, Kolkata, West Bengal - 700071 …. Defendant Date of Institution of Suit: 19.10.2024 Date of Decision: 10.07.2025 Suit for Recovery of Rs. 2,63,306/-. Judgment (ex-parte) :- 1. Vide this judgment, I shall decide the suit for recovery of Rs. 2,63,306/- ( Rupees Two Lakhs Sixty Three Thousand Three Hundred and Six Only) instituted by M/s Rajkamal Enterprises through its authorized signatory Mr. Raj Kumar Gupta ( hereinafter -- 1 of 6 -- M/s Rajkamal Enterprises vs. Aparajita CS SCJ No.: - 1993/2024 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Page 2 of 6 (Charan Salwan) Civil Judge-03, Central, Delhi referred to as the plaintiff) against Aparajita, ( hereinafter referred to as the defendant). Brief Facts: 2(a) As per the averments made in the plaint, the brief facts are that the plaintiff is a reputed trader engaged in trading home furnishing goods such as blankets, quilts, bedsheets etc and has had business transactions with the defendant in the year 2021. It is averred that the defendant had placed orders with the plaintiff for goods which have been duly received and accepted by the defendant. It is averred that payment is still pending. (b) The details of the orders are as follows: S.No. Invoice No. Invoice Date Invoice Amount (in INR) Pending Invoice Amount (in INR) i. 5029 18 February 2021 72,655/- 72,655/- ii. 5073 09 March 2021 69,006/- 69,006/- iii. 5134 25 March 2021 1,07,470/- 1,07,470/- iv. 5150 01 April 2021 14,175/- 14,175/- (c) It is averred that an amount of Rs. 2,63,306/- is remaining outstanding against the defendant. It is averred that the plaintiff made multiple attempts to resolve the issue and to obtain the remaining dues. It is averred that the defendant has received delivery of the goods from the plaintiff. It is further averred that -- 2 of 6 -- M/s Rajkamal Enterprises vs. Aparajita CS SCJ No.: - 1993/2024 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Page 3 of 6 (Charan Salwan) Civil Judge-03, Central, Delhi the actions of the defendant have resulted into wrongful gains to the defendant and wrongful loss to the plaintiff. (d) It is averred that a legal notice was served upon the defendant on behalf of the plaintiff wherein the defendant was called upon to refund the amount due to the plaintiff alongwith interest @ 18 % per annum. Hence, the suit has been instituted by the plaintiff seeking the following reliefs: “ a. Pass a direction to the defendant to pay the amount of INR 2,63,306/- alongwith interest @ 18 % (to be calculated from the date of invoice till the date of complete payment) to the plaintiff; b. Direct the defendant to compensate the plaintiff for the cost of litigation; c. Pass any other decree as the Hon’ble Court deem fit” Service of the Defendant 3. The defendant was duly served with summons of the suit. However, Written Statement was not filed by the defendant and therefore, the defence of the defendant was struck off and the defendant was proceeded exparte vide order dated 07.01.2025. Plaintiff’s Evidence 4. To substantiate its case, the plaintiff examined himself as PW-1 and tendered his evidence by way of affidavit as Ex. -- 3 of 6 -- M/s Rajkamal Enterprises vs. Aparajita CS SCJ No.: - 1993/2024 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Page 4 of 6 (Charan Salwan) Civil Judge-03, Central, Delhi PW1/X, which bears his signatures at point A and B. He relied upon the following documents: - 1. Plaintiff partnership firm registration certificate. Ex. PW1/1 (OSR) 2. Authorization Letter of PW-1 Ex. PW1/2 3. Ledgers of plaintiff partnership firm. Ex. PW1/3 (Colly.) 4. Invoices of plaintiff partnership firm. Ex. PW1/4 (Colly.). 5. Copy of transportation receipts. Mark-PW1/A (Colly.). 6. Screenshots of GST Portal Ex. PW1/5 (colly) 7. GST Details of plaintiff as available on GST Portal Ex. PW1/6 8. GST Details of defendant as available on GST Portal Ex. PW1/7 9. Copy of legal notice Mark-PW1/B 10. Postal receipt of legal notice Ex. PW1/8 11. Postal tracking report Ex. PW1/9 12. Order dated 12.08.2024 Ex. PW1/10 13. Cancelled cheque of plaintiff firm Ex. PW1/11 14. Certificate under Section 63 of BSA, 2023 Ex. PW1/12 5. I have heard the ex-parte arguments on behalf of the plaintiff and have also perused the record carefully. Findings: 6. The suit of the plaintiff is within limitation after getting benefit of the directions of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Re:Cognizance for exention of limitiation. In support of his case, PW-1 tendered his evidence as per the pleadings. The plaintiff has relied upon Ex. PW1/1 which shows that the partnership firm is -- 4 of 6 -- M/s Rajkamal Enterprises vs. Aparajita CS SCJ No.: - 1993/2024 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Page 5 of 6 (Charan Salwan) Civil Judge-03, Central, Delhi registered. Ex. PW1/2, shows that Sh. Raj Kumar Gupta is authorized to appear in the matter. Ex. PW1/3 i.e. the ledger corroborates the version of the plaintiff that an amount of Rs. 2,63,306/- is outstanding against the defendant. Ex. PW1/4 i.e. the invoices, shows that there were commercial transactions between the plaintiff and the defendant. Mark PW1/A shows that the goods were delivered to the defendant. 7. All the averments made by the plaintiff stand duly proved by way of the afore-stated documents. Hence, the plaintiff has duly discharged his burden of proof under Section 104 of the Bharatiya Sakshay Adhiniyam, 2023. It was for the defendant to prove that there was no liability or amount due against them. It was for the defendant to dispute the contractual relationship with the plaintiff or to dispute the genuineness and correctness of the documents relied upon by the plaintiff. However, the defendant has failed to do so. Despite service of summons, the defendant did not appear and contest the matter and therefore, was proceeded exparte. Since the defendant was proceeded exparte and no evidence was led by the defendant, there is nothing on record which casts any doubt on the testimony of PW1. The testimony of the PW1 has gone unchallenged, uncontroverted, and unrebutted. Accordingly, the plaintiff has successfully proved its case on a scale of balance of probabilities. There is nothing on record which casts any doubt on the testimony of PW1. -- 5 of 6 -- M/s Rajkamal Enterprises vs. Aparajita CS SCJ No.: - 1993/2024 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Page 6 of 6 (Charan Salwan) Civil Judge-03, Central, Delhi Interest 8. The plaintiff has claimed interest at the rate of 18 % per annum on the decreetal amount. Considering the prevailing market conditions, it is not considered equitable to grant this high rate of interest. Accordingly, simple interest at the rate of 6% per annum is considered reasonable and equitable. Relief: 9. In view of the above discussion, the suit of the plaintiff is decreed and the following relief is being given to the plaintiff: - (a) A decree of Rs.2,63,306/- is being passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant, alongwith simple interest @ 6% p.a. from the date of filing of suit till date of realization of the decreetal amount. 10. No order as to Costs. 11. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. 12. File be consigned to the record room after necessary compliance. Pronounced in open court: (Charan Salwan) Dated: 10.07.2025 Civil Judge-03, Central, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi -- 6 of 6 --
