Full Order Text
Order 9 · 31 Jul 2026 · CNR DLCT030077932025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS SCJ No. 2321/2025 Anand Padia & Anr. Vs. DCB Bank Pg. no.1/9 IN THE COURT OF SH. SUNIL KHATRI, CIVIL JUDGE-06, CENTRAL DISTRICT, TIS HAZARI COURTS: DELHI CS SCJ No. 2321/2025 CNR No. DLCT030077932025 ANAND PADIA & ANR. .....PLAINTIFFS VERSUS DCB BANK LIMITED .....DEFENDANT ORDER 1. Vide this order, I shall dispose of the application of the defendant bank filed U/S 8 r/w Section 5 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996. 2. The defendant bank has filed the aforesaid application submitting therein that plaintiffs and the defendant executed a DCB Business Loan Agreement dated 11.02.2023, duly signed and delivered by both Plaintiffs. The Loan Agreement governs the entire credit facility and - by virtue of Clause 29 of the Sanction Letter which expressly states that "the terms in the loan agreement shall supersede all previous related communications in respect of the credit facility/loan" - is the governing and controlling document superseding the Sanction Letter. The Loan Agreement contains Clause 11, which is a comprehensive arbitration agreement between the parties. The subject matter and substance of the present suit- concerning the -- 1 of 9 -- CS SCJ No. 2321/2025 Anand Padia & Anr. Vs. DCB Bank Pg. no.2/9 levy/recovery of prepayment charges and EMI deductions arising from the Loan Agreement is squarely covered within the scope and ambit of the arbitration agreement contained in Clause 11. The court is accordingly mandated to refer the parties to arbitration and has no discretion to refuse reference once a valid arbitration agreement is demonstrated. Hon'ble Supreme Court has consistently held that civil courts have no jurisdiction to entertain a suit where a valid arbitration agreement exists, and reference to arbitration is mandatory. The defendant has not yet submitted its first statement on the substance of the dispute in the present suit. The right to file a Written Statement was closed by order dated 04.05.2026 before any Written Statement could be filed. The present application for reference to arbitration is therefore being made at the earliest available opportunity and well within the mandate of Section 8(1) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act. The closing of the right to file a Written Statement by the Trial Court does not and cannot extinguish the Defendant's right to seek reference to arbitration, since the jurisdiction of this Court to entertain and try the suit is itself in question. 3. Reply to the aforesaid application was filed on behalf of the plaintiffs wherein plaintiffs submitted that the defendant has relied upon Clause 29 of the Sanction Letter dated 01.04.2023, however it has deliberately misquoted the same. Such clause did mean that a loan agreement would have to be executed in future, which was not done and therefore can by no stretch of imagination mean the alleged "Loan Agreement" which has a stamp dated 11.02.2023 is a valid agreement under the law -- 2 of 9 -- CS SCJ No. 2321/2025 Anand Padia & Anr. Vs. DCB Bank Pg. no.3/9 and it contains Clause 11, which is a comprehensive arbitration agreement between the parties. Such clause specifically uses the word "...may...", which makes it abundantly clear that there is not binding arbitration clause, even if it is assumed that the agreement had been validly executed, though not admitted. It is submitted that the Plaintiffs have placed on record only a copy of sanction letter and not the purported Loan Agreement, as no copy of purported Loan Agreement was ever in the Plaintiffs possession. The Defendant Bank never furnished a copy of the purported Loan Agreement to the Plaintiffs. It is further submitted that the Plaintiffs have filed all documents that were in their possession, custody and control. It is submitted that the Clause 11 of the purported Loan Agreement being relied upon by the Defendant clearly states that “ the dispute/difference may be referred to arbitration of a sole arbitration appointed by DCB Bank”. It is a settled principle of law that the use of the word "may" by the parties does not bring about an arbitration agreement, but it contemplate a future possibility which would encompass a choice or discretion available to the parties. It is further submitted that the right of the defendant to file WS was closed by the court after giving multiple opportunities to the defendant. Further, it is a settled principle of law that an application under Section 8 of the Act is not maintainable if filed beyond the period prescribed for filing the written statement and/or after closing of rights to file written statement. The service to Defendant on 08.01.2026 and 12.01.2026 is a matter of record. Further, the right to file WS by the Defendant was closed vide Order dated 04.05.2026 and till date, no WS or application for setting aside such order has been filed by the Defendant. -- 3 of 9 -- CS SCJ No. 2321/2025 Anand Padia & Anr. Vs. DCB Bank Pg. no.4/9 4. Ld. counsel for the defendant bank argued that there is a valid Arbitration Agreement between the parties in the form of Clause 11 of the Loan Agreement. In terms of the same, defendant bank and borrower has to resolve any dispute/ difference by referring the matter to the arbitration. The plaintiff has willfully suppressed the said Arbitration Agreement from the court by not filing the Loan Agreement on record. The defendant has not yet submitted its first statement on the substance of the dispute. Hence, it is mandatory under the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 to refer the present dispute to the arbitration. He relied upon the judgments titled as ‘Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. Pinkcity Midway Petroleums (2003) 6 SCC 503’ and ‘Agri Gold Exims Ltd. v. Sri Lakshmi Knits & Wovens & Ors. (2007) 3 SCC 686’ wherein Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that civil courts have no jurisdiction to entertain a suit where a valid arbitration agreement exists, and reference to arbitration is mandatory. 5. Per contra, Ld. counsel for the plaintiffs argued that Loan Agreement in which Clause 11 regarding the reference of the dispute to the arbitration has been mentioned was never executed/signed by any representative of the defendant bank. Therefore, it was not a concluded contract. Further, the reference to Arbitration as mentioned in the Clause 11 was not mandatory because it was specifically stated that “the dispute/ difference may be referred to Arbitration of a Sole Arbitrator appointed by DCB Bank” . He relies upon the judgment of ‘GTL Infrastructure Ltd. v. Vodafone India Ltd. (VIL)’ wherein Hon'ble High Court -- 4 of 9 -- CS SCJ No. 2321/2025 Anand Padia & Anr. Vs. DCB Bank Pg. no.5/9 of Delhi observed that word ‘may’ however conclusive on mandatory does not bring about an Arbitration Agreement, it merely contemplate a future possibility and gives a choice or discretion to the parties. Further, he argued that any reference to Sole Arbitrator unilaterally by a party has been help to the illegal/ invalid by the Hon’ble Apex Court. He also placed reliance upon the judgment of M/s Hitachi Payments Services Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. Sh. Shreyans Jain & Anr., 2025 SCC OnLine Del 1042 to contend that any application U/S 8 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act filed by the defendant after the defence of the defendant has been struck off due to non filing of WS within the statutory period is not maintainable. 6. I have heard the arguments on behalf of both the parties and perused the material available on record. 7. Section 8 of Arbitration & Conciliation Act provides as follows: “Section 8- Power to refer parties to arbitration where there is an arbitration agreement: “(1) A judicial authority, before which an action is brought in a matter which is the subject of an arbitration agreement shall, if a party to the arbitration agreement or any person claiming through or under him, so applies not later than the date of submitting his first statement on the substance of the dispute, then, notwithstanding any judgment, decree or order of the Supreme Court or any Court, refer the parties to arbitration unless it finds that prima facie no valid arbitration agreement exists. (2) The application referred to in sub-section (1) shall not be entertained unless it is accompanied by the original arbitration agreement or a duly certified copy thereof. -- 5 of 9 -- CS SCJ No. 2321/2025 Anand Padia & Anr. Vs. DCB Bank Pg. no.6/9 Provided that where the original arbitration agreement or a certified copy thereof is not available with the party applying for reference to arbitration under sub-section (1), and the said agreement or certified copy is retained by the other party to that agreement, then, the party so applying shall file such application along with a copy of the arbitration agreement and a petition praying the Court to call upon the other party to produce the original arbitration agreement or its duly certified copy before that Court. (3) Notwithstanding that an application has been made under sub-section (1) and that the issue is pending before the judicial authority, an arbitration may be commenced or continued and an arbitral award made.” 8. Further, Clause 11 of Loan Agreement is as follows: “5. That the Loan Agreement contains Clause 11, which is a comprehensive arbitration agreement between the parties. For the convenience of this Hon’ble Court, Clause 11 is reproduced hereunder in its entirety: Clause 11: ARBITRATION (a) If any dispute / difference arises between DCB Bank and the Borrower hereto during the subsistence of the Agreement or thereafter, in connection with any provision of the Agreement or regarding a question including but not limited to the questions whether the termination of the Agreement has been legitimate, DCB Bank and the Borrower shall first endeavour to settle such dispute / difference amicably. (b) In the case of failure by DCB Bank and the Borrower to resolve the dispute / difference in the manner set out above within 30 (thirty) days from the date when the dispute / difference arose, the dispute / difference may be referred to arbitration of a sole arbitrator to be appointed by DCB Bank. (c) The place of arbitration shall be the place (of applicable Jurisdiction / Courts) IN WITNESS WHEREOF the parties have executed this Agreement and any award whether interim or final, shall and shall be deemed for all purposes between DCB Bank and the Borrower to be made at such -- 6 of 9 -- CS SCJ No. 2321/2025 Anand Padia & Anr. Vs. DCB Bank Pg. no.7/9 place. The award including the interim award/s of the arbitrator shall be final and binding upon the parties concerned. (d) The arbitration proceedings shall be governed by the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, as amended from time to time. (e) The proceedings of arbitration shall be held in English language.” 9. In the present case, the summons were served upon the defendant bank on 08.01.2026. Vakalatnama and Board of Resolution were filed on its behalf on 05.02.2026. Thereafter, vide order dated 07.02.2026, last and final opportunity was granted to the defendant to file its WS. However, when the defendant failed to its WS despite multiple opportunities, its right to file WS was closed on 04.05.2026. In these facts, the case is squarely covered by the observations given in the case of M/s SPML Infra Vs. Trisquare Switchgears Pvt. Ltd., 2022 SCC OnLine Del 1914, which has been referred by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi, in the case of M/s Hitachi (Supra). The said observations are reproduced as follows: “ 8. In SPML Infra (supra), the Division Bench of this Court, considering the provisions of Section 8 of the Act, has held as under:- "18. It is clear from the scheme of the Act that once the proceedings before the court or judicial authority progress beyond the initial stage, it would no longer be permissible for a party to then turn around and seek recourse to arbitration. A mere delay in making an application under Section 8 of the A&C Act may not be fatal to a party's right; but once the proceedings have progressed beyond the stage of completion of pleadings, such an application would not lie. This is because at that stage, the parties are sufficiently invested in the said proceedings, and it would not be permissible for any party to turn around and apply under Section 8 of the A&C Act. -- 7 of 9 -- CS SCJ No. 2321/2025 Anand Padia & Anr. Vs. DCB Bank Pg. no.8/9 19. If a party's right to file a statement of defence is closed, the same would also result in its rights accruing in favour of the other party. Clearly, at this stage, it would not be permissible for a party to apply under Section 8 of the A&C Act even though he has not expressly evinced any intention to contest the proceedings. It is implicit in the expression "not later than submitting the first statement of substance of the dispute" that the application under Section 8 of the A&C Act can be made at the stage when it is open for a party to submit such a statement. It, obviously, follows that once such a stage is crossed, the right of the party to apply under Section 8(1) of the A&C Act would also stand closed. The scheme of Section 8 of the A&C Act does not contemplate unraveling concluded proceedings. Once the right of a party to file the written statement of defence is closed, the proceedings in a suit progress beyond the stage of completion of pleadings. It is not open for the defendant to now seek a reference to arbitration. Although Section 8 of the A&C Act (as in force prior to 23.10.2015) did not specify any time limit, it did indicate the stage of the proceedings at which a party could apply, that is, before filing of the first statement on the substance of the dispute. This clearly implies a stage at which such a statement could be filed and not thereafter. 20. If the contention advanced by the appellant is accepted, it would imply an application under Section 8 of the A&C Act can be allowed to be filed at any stage of the proceedings; even after the evidence is tendered and witnesses have been cross- examined or for that matter just before the matter is fixed for pronouncement of the decision. Clearly, this is not in conformity with the scheme of Section 8 of the A&C Act. xxxx xxxx xxxx……..xxxxxx…...xxxx…….xxxxxx 25. As stated above, a written statement would also fall within the sweep of expression "statement on the substance of the dispute" as used in Section 8(1) of the A&C Act. The introduction of the expression "the date of" in the context of the suit would necessarily have to be co-related with the time available or granted for filing of a written statement. The legislative intent of introducing the expression "the date of", when read with the contemporaneous amendments to Order VIII Rule 1 of the CPC by virtue of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, is quite -- 8 of 9 -- CS SCJ No. 2321/2025 Anand Padia & Anr. Vs. DCB Bank Pg. no.9/9 clear; it is to introduce the precise time frame within which an application under Section 8(1) of the A&C Act could be filed. 26. Resultantly, if a party fails to file an application under Section 8(1) of the A&C Act for referring the parties to arbitration within the time available or granted for filing the first statement on the substance of the dispute (which would include a written statement in the context of a suit), the party would forfeit its right to apply under Section 8(1) of the A&C Act." 10. In view of the aforesaid binding observations, in case a party fails to file an application U/S 8 (1) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act within the time available or granted for filing the WS, the party would forfeit its right to apply U/S 81 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act. 11. Admittedly, the present application has been filed by the defendant bank after about 03 months of closure of its right to file WS by the court. Hence, without going into the merit of contention raised by the plaintiffs regarding non-executon of loan agreement containing the arbitration clause by defendant bank or its representative; no mandatory reference to arbitration due to use of work ‘may’ and not ‘shall’; reference to sole arbitrator to be appointed by defendant bank being invalid etc., suffice it is to say that the defendant bank is guilty of latches and negligence and accordingly, present application is dismissed. Announced in the court on 31.07.2026. (Sunil Khatri) Civil Judge-06, Central District Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi -- 9 of 9 --
