Full Order Text
Final Order 14 · 23 Mar 2026 · CNR DLCT030068182024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. AAKASH SHARMA: CIVIL JUDGE -02 (CENTRAL), TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI. CS SCJ No. 1783/2024 In the matter of :- SH. AKSHAT JAIN Proprietor of: M/s Jain Trading Company, Office At: - Ground Floor, 4/2, Godown No.4, Saur Urja Marg, Opposite-Cell, Jhandapur, Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh 201010. Mobile No. +91-8368686381 .... Plaintiff VERSUS SH. SNEH JAIN Proprietor of: M/s Indigo Solutions .… Defendant No.1 SH. ARIHANT JAIN (Authorized Person) Office At:5766/5, Ground Floor, Street No. 5, New Chandrawal, Jawahar Nagar, Kamla Nagar, Delhi-110007. Also At: Kh. No. 180, First Floor, Rajender Nagar Industrial Area, Ghaziabad, U.P. 201007 Mobile No. +91-9999822981 .… Defendant No.2 CS No. 1783/24 Akshat Jain Vs. Sneh Jain & Anr. Page 1 of /11 -- 1 of 11 -- Date of Institution: 09.09.2024 Date of reserving the judgment: 21.02.2026 Date of Judgment: 23.03.2026 JUDGMENT (Suit for recovery of amount Rs.10,384/- alongwith interest @24% per annum) 1. The brief facts of the present case are that plaintiff is having the business of trading of packaging material under the name and style of “M/s Jain Trading Company” at the above said address more particularly at Ground Floor, 4/2, Godown No.4, Saur Urja Marg, Opposite- Cel, Jhandapur, Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh-201010. 1.1 It is further submitted that the Defendant No. 1 namely Sh. Sneh Jain is also a trader of packaging material and had been working under the name & style of M/s Indigo Solutions having its Registered office at: 5766/5, Ground Floor, Street No. 5, New Chandrawal, Jawahar Nagar, Kamla Nagar, Delhi-110007, and working office at: Kh. No.180, First Floor, Rajender Nagar Industrial Area, Ghaziabad, U.P. 201007. Further, Defendant No. 2 namely Sh. Arihant Jain, is the authorized person/ authorized signatory for defendant no. 1. That the defendant used to place orders to the plaintiff for supply of goods on credit basis. That the defendant had placed orders with the plaintiff and in respect of the same, the plaintiff had supplied the goods, as per the orders, to the defendant vide following particulars:- CS No. 1783/24 Akshat Jain Vs. Sneh Jain & Anr. Page 2 of /11 -- 2 of 11 -- Sr. No. Invoice Number & Date Invoice Amount 1. 1852, dated 20.01.2024 Rs. 6,154/ 2. 1894, dated 25.01.2024 Rs. 2,320/- 3. 2017, dated 06.02.2024 Rs. 4,952/- 4. 2034, dated 08.02.2024 Rs. 1,053/ 5. 2227, dated 24.022024 Rs. 2,379/- 6. 118, dated 12.04.2024 Rs.8,013/- 7. 272, dated 02.05.2024 Rs.3,464/- 8. 280, dated 03.05.2024 Rs.8,662/- 9. 348, dated 10.05.2024 Rs.10,266/- That in lieu of the above-said order, the defendant had made payments in favour of plaintiff, on various intervals, the details of the same are as follows: Sr. No. Date Amount Mode 1. 23.01.2024 Rs.6,154/- Bank Transfer 2. 27.01.2024 Rs.2,320/- Bank Transfer 3. 14.02.2024 Rs.5,821/- Bank Transfer 4. 26.02.2024 Rs.2,563/- Bank Transfer 5. 15.04.2024 Rs.8,013/- Bank Transfer 6. 13.05.2024 Rs.8,662/- Bank Transfer 7. 05.06.2024 Rs.3,464/- Bank Transfer 1.2 It is further submitted that as per the ledger account of the defendant being maintained by the plaintiff total amounting of Rs. 10,384/ CS No. 1783/24 Akshat Jain Vs. Sneh Jain & Anr. Page 3 of /11 -- 3 of 11 -- is still due on the defendant. That in respect of the same, defendant had acknowledged the receipt of goods. That despite several intimations/ demands/ reminders and personal visits to the defendant and regular telephonic conversations regarding the debt amount, the defendant had paid no heed to it and kept on avoiding the payment on one pretext or another. That in respect of the above said due amount, plaintiff through his counsel also issued legal notice to the defendant vide dated 21.06.2024 having tracking No. ED653045314IN, ED653045186IN, ED653045305IN, and ED653045190IN dated 24.06.2024, respectively addressing to the defendant. That even after receipt of the Legal Notice, the defendants failed to make the payment to the plaintiff within the granted time. That thereafter, the defendants in discharge of their legally enforceable debts and liability to repay the above said amount to the plaintiff, the defendant no. 2 had issued part-payment cheque bearing no. 498757, amounting of Rs. 8,662/- drawn on State Bank of India, Shastri Nagar, Delhi Branch, dated 11.05.2024, in favour of the plaintiff proprietorship firm. That as per the defendant’s assurances and instructions, the plaintiff had presented the cheque bearing no. 498757, amounting of Rs. 8,662/- drawn on State Bank of India, Shastri Nagar, Delhi Branch, dated 11.05.2024, for encashment with his banker i.e. ICICI Bank, Delhi, but to the utter shock and surprise of the plaintiff, the above said cheque got dishonoured and returned unpaid with the remarks “Payment Stopped by Drawer” vide cheque returning memo dated 06.08.2024. 1.3 It is further submitted that upon the receipt of the information, CS No. 1783/24 Akshat Jain Vs. Sneh Jain & Anr. Page 4 of /11 -- 4 of 11 -- that the said cheque had been bounced, the plaintiff contacted to the defendant & informed about the fate and requested to make the payment in cash, to which the defendant started giving lame excuses and at last started avoiding taking calls of the plaintiff. That by this present suit, the Plaintiff is seeking recovery of its debts or liquidated demand in money payable by the defendant along with the interest. That the Cause of Action for filing the present suit arose in favour of plaintiff and against the defendant. That the Cause of Action first arose in favour of Plaintiff and against the defendant when the defendant approached the plaintiff for initiating business transaction on credit basis. It further arose when the defendant placed orders for the purchase of goods on credit on various intervals, more particularly on the dates as mentioned in the ledger account. It further arose when the plaintiff had supplied goods as per the demands of the defendant on credit basis, more particularly on the dates as mentioned in the ledger account. It further arose, when the defendant made part payment to the plaintiff on various intervals, more particularly as per the dates in ledger account. It further arose when the plaintiff issued legal demand notice to the defendant vide demand notice dated 21.06.2024, through his counsel. It further arose when the defendant no. 2 had issued the part-payment cheque in favour of the plaintiff proprietorship firm. It further arose when the defendant had stopped the payment from the said cheque. That as the payment has not been realized by the defendant to the plaintiff, thus the Cause of Action is still continuing and subsisting one as the defendant has failed to pay the outstanding amount till date. That this Court has jurisdiction to entertain this suit as the defendants are having their course of CS No. 1783/24 Akshat Jain Vs. Sneh Jain & Anr. Page 5 of /11 -- 5 of 11 -- business within the territorial jurisdiction to this Court and the plaintiff had also supplied the goods to the defendant at his address as mentioned above within the jurisdiction of this Court. Further, the Cause of Action arose within the territorial jurisdiction of this Hon’ble Court. Therefore, this Court has jurisdiction to entertain and to try the present suit. That the suit is valued for the purpose of court fee and jurisdiction for the relief of money of Rs. 10,384/- upon which ad-valorem court fee of Rs. 1,163/- has been affixed. The Plaintiff further undertakes to pay the further court fee in case, this Hon’ble Court directs the Plaintiff to do so. It is prayed that a decree for recovery of Rs. 10,384/- alongwith pendente-lite and future interest @24% per annum from the date of filiing of the present suit till realization be passed in favour of plaintiff and against the defendants. Cost of the suit is also prayed. DEFENDANT’S VERSION 2. The present ordinary suit was initially filed under Order XXXVII of C.P.C. and was converted into an ordinary suit vide order dated 16.11.2024. Summons for settlement of issues were issued to the defendants no. 1 and 2 received back served upon the defendants no.1 and 2 through electronic mode vide whatsapp on 23.06.2025 on both phone numbers as observed in the order dated 06.08.2025. Despite lapse of statutory period, the defendants no.1 and 2 not filed their written statement, hence, defence of the defendants no.1 and 2 was struck off and defendants no.1 and 2 were proceeded ex-parte vide order dated 23.09.2025. CS No. 1783/24 Akshat Jain Vs. Sneh Jain & Anr. Page 6 of /11 -- 6 of 11 -- PLAINTIFF’S EVIDENCE 3. In support of his case, the plaintiff got examined himself as PW-1 and tendered his evidence by way of affidavit Ex.PW1/A. PW-1 relied upon the following documents:- i) Ex.PW1/1(colly 3 pages) is GST Certificate of plaintiff. ii) Ex.PW1/2 is Copy of the Aadhar Card of the deponent. iii) Ex.PW1/3(colly 6 pages) is GST status of the defendant. iv) Ex.PW1/4 (colly 3 pages) is Ledger Account along with certificate of Section 65B of Indian Evidence Act. v) Ex.PW1/5 (colly 9 pages) are Invoices. vi) Ex.PW1/6 (colly 3 pages) is Legal Notice. vii) Ex.PW1/7 (colly 4 receipts)is postal receipts. viii) Ex.PW1/8 (colly 4 pages) are tracking reports along with certificate under Section 65B of Indian Evidence Act. ix) Ex.PW1/9 (colly 2 envelopes) are returned envelopes. x) Ex.PW1/10 is original cheque bearing no.498757 of Bank of Baroda. xi) Ex.PW1/11 is return memo. Defendants no.1 and 2 were already ex-parte vide order dated 23.09.2025. Sh. Sidhant Jain, son of the defendant no.1 was present through VC on 17.01.2026 during the evidence of PW-1 but defendant no.1 CS No. 1783/24 Akshat Jain Vs. Sneh Jain & Anr. Page 7 of /11 -- 7 of 11 -- and defendant no.2 did not take steps to conduct any cross-examination of PW-1. 4. Final arguments were heard on behalf of the parties on 21.02.2026. 5. The plaintiff has relied upon the following documents:- Ex.PW1/1(colly 3 pages) is GST Certificate of plaintiff; Ex.PW1/2 is Copy of the Aadhar Card of the deponent; Ex.PW1/3(colly 6 pages) is GST status of the defendant; Ex.PW1/4 (colly 3 pages) is Ledger Account along with certificate of Section 65B of Indian Evidence Act; Ex.PW1/5 (colly 9 pages) are Invoices; Ex.PW1/6 (colly 3 pages) is Legal Notice; Ex.PW1/7 (colly 4 receipts)is postal receipts; Ex.PW1/8 (colly 4 pages) are tracking reports along with certificate under Section 65B of Indian Evidence Act; Ex.PW1/9 (colly 2 envelopes) are returned envelopes; Ex.PW1/10 is original cheque bearing no.498757 of Bank of Baroda; and Ex.PW1/11 is return memo. 6. It was argued on behalf of the defendants that although defendants admitted receiving the goods from the plaintiff but the goods supplied by the plaintiff were of defective/inferior quality and that the defendants were not liable to pay for the supplied goods particularly qua invoice dated 10.05.2024 bearing no. 348 for sum Rs.10,266/-. That the defendant had duly made the payment for all other invoices except aforesaid as the defendant supplied inferior quality goods which were not CS No. 1783/24 Akshat Jain Vs. Sneh Jain & Anr. Page 8 of /11 -- 8 of 11 -- merchantable. That as the defendants apprised the plaintiff regarding the inferior quality and denied acceptance of the goods, the defendants were not liable to pay for the same having rejected the goods for their unmerchantable and inferior quality and that there were whatsapp chats between the defendants and the plaintiff in this regard wherein plaintiff admitted about fault in the products supplied qua invoice dated 10.05.2024 for sum Rs.10,266/-. 7. Section 42 of the Sale Of Goods Act, 1930 provides:- 42. Acceptance.— The buyer is deemed to have accepted the goods when he intimates to the seller that he has accepted them, or when the goods have been delivered to him and he does any act in relation to them which is inconsistent with the ownership of the seller, or when, after the lapse of a reasonable time, he retains the goods without intimating to the seller that he has rejected them. 8. The defendants have categorically admitted that the defendants received the goods for the invoice bearing no. 348 dated 10.05.2024 for sum Rs.10,266/- but took the defence that the same were of defective/inferior quality and were unmerchantable. It has to be taken note of the fact that the defendants have not examined any witness in their defence evidence to prove the defence that the goods were of inferior quality or that they had given due notice to the plaintiff regarding rejection of the goods worth Rs.10,266/- for their unmerchantable quality. The defendants have not brought on record the so called whatsapp chats wherein plaintiff acknowledged that the products supplied were of inferior CS No. 1783/24 Akshat Jain Vs. Sneh Jain & Anr. Page 9 of /11 -- 9 of 11 -- quality. The defendants neither filed any written statement, nor any documentary evidence nor conducted any defence evidence. Thus, the defence of the defendants that the goods supplied by the plaintiff were of unmerchantable and inferior quality and that the defendants gave notice of rejection of the goods by way of whatsapp to the plaintiff or the plaintiff acknowledged the same is liable to be rejected for lack of proof. Accordingly, the defendants are deemed to have accepted the goods as per Section 42 of the Sale of Goods Act, 1930 and the same remain unpaid goods. 9. The plaintiff has succeeded in proving the liability of the defendants for the invoice amount of Rs. 10,266/- as well as bank charges of Rs.118/- for dishonour of cheque, thus cumulatively for debit balance of Rs.10,384/- as reflected in the ledger statement Ex.PW1/4. However, the interest @24% per annum claimed by the plaintiff against the defendants is highly exorbitant. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, this Court is of the opinion that interest of justice will be served, if the plaintiff is awarded interest @ 10% per annum on the due amount of Rs. 10,384/- from the date of filing of the present suit i.e. 09.09.2024 till the date of decree alongwith future interest @6% per annum from the date of decree till the date of realization. 10. Relief. In view of the above discussion, the present suit is decreed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants. The plaintiff is entitled to CS No. 1783/24 Akshat Jain Vs. Sneh Jain & Anr. Page 10 of /11 -- 10 of 11 -- recover from the defendants jointly and severally, the due amount of Rs. 10,384/- with interest @10% per annum from the date of filing of the present suit i.e. 09.09.2024 till the date of decree alongwith future interest @6% per annum from the date of decree till the date of realization. Costs of the suit are also awarded to the plaintiff. Pleaders fee is also awarded to the plaintiff as per rules. Decree-sheet be prepared accordingly. File be consigned to Record Room as per rules. Announced in the open (Aakash Sharma) court today on 23.03.2026 Civil Judge -02 (Central), Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi. CS No. 1783/24 Akshat Jain Vs. Sneh Jain & Anr. Page 11 of /11 -- 11 of 11 --
