Full Order Text
Final Order 5 · 04 Sept 2024 · CNR DLCT030062482023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF ADMINISTRATIVE CIVIL JUDGE- CUM- ADDITIONAL RENT CONTROLLER (CENTRAL) : DELHI PRESIDED OVER BY : MS. MEDHA ARYA Petition No. : Succ. Court/163/2023 CNR No.: DLCT03-006248-2023 In the matter of:- 1. Madan Lal Moondhra. S/o Late Sh. Shiv Das Moondhra & Late Smt. Gopa Devi Moondhra, R/o H. No. 3917, Shri Ganesh Building, Roshanpura, Nai Sarak, Delhi-110006. 2. Saroj Devi Dargar W/o Sh. Punam Chand Dargar D/o Late Sh. Shiv Das Moondhra & Late Smt. Gopa Devi Moondhra, R/o H. No. 148, Bagdi Mohalla, Bikaner, Rajasthan-334001. Through SPA Mr. Naveen Gupta R/o H. No. 2399, Hudson Lane, GTB Nagar, North West, Delhi-110009. ....Petitioners Versus 1. The State of NCT of Delhi Through Secretary Central Secretariat, Delhi-110001. 2. SRF Limited Through Managing Director, At Unitech Crest Building, Block-C, Green Wood City, Sector-45, Gurugram, SC/163/23 Madan Lal Moondhra & Anr. Vs. State and Ors. 1/7 -- 1 of 7 -- Haryana-122003. 3. Managing Director SRF Limited At Unitech Crest Building, Block-C, Green Wood City, Sector-45, Gurugram, Haryana-122003. .....Respondents Date of Institution : 02.11.2023 Date of order when reserved : N.A. Date of order when announced : 04.09.2024 J U D G M E N T : 1. Present succession petition has been filed by the petitioners under Section 372 of Indian Succession Act, 1925 (hereinafter referred to as the 'Act') in respect of debts and securities of deceased Late Smt. Gopa Devi Moondhra (hereinafter referred to as 'the deceased'). 2. It is averred that the deceased died intestate on 20.06.1987 at Delhi. It is stated that the deceased was the ordinary resident of H. No. 3917, Shri Ganesh Building, Roshanpura, Nai Sarak, Delhi-110006 which falls within the jurisdiction of this Court. It is further stated that deceased is survived by two legal heirs i.e. petitioners no.1 and 2, being her son and daughter respectively. 3. It is averred that deceased has left behind 270 shares of SRF Limited under the folio no. G-0001423. In the instant petition, petitioners have prayed for grant of succession SC/163/23 Madan Lal Moondhra & Anr. Vs. State and Ors. 2/7 -- 2 of 7 -- certificate in respect of aforesaid 270 shares of the deceased. 4. State has been impleaded as a respondent. 5. After filing of this petition, notice was given to the general public by way of publication in the newspaper “The Statesman” dated 10.06.2024, but none appeared from general public to oppose or contest the present petition. 6. During summary enquiry, 3 witnesses were examined. 7. Petitioner no.1 took the witness stand as PW-1. PW- 1 deposed that deceased who died intestate on 20.06.1987 at Delhi, was his mother. PW-1 further deposed that deceased has also left behind one daughter, who has been arrayed as petitioner no.2 in the present petition, and she has claimed her respective share in the debts and securities of the deceased. PW-1 also deposed that husband of the deceased namely Sh. Shiv Dass Mundhra predeceased the deceased on 13.08.1986. PW-1 further deposed that the deceased has left behind 270 shares of SRF Ltd. under the folio no. G0001423. PW-1 also deposed that the deceased was residing within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court. PW-1 relied upon the following documents in his testimony :- (i) Ex. PW-1/1 being the copy of death certificate of the deceased. (ii) Ex. PW-1/2 being the copy of death certificate of husband of the deceased. SC/163/23 Madan Lal Moondhra & Anr. Vs. State and Ors. 3/7 -- 3 of 7 -- (iii) Ex. PW-1/3 being the copies of share certificates of 270 share of SRF Ltd. lying in the name of the deceased. (iv) Ex. PW-1/4 being the copy of FIR lodged regarding the loss of original Share certificates of said 270 shares. (v) Ex. PW-1/5 (Colly.) being the communication received from SRF Ltd. with respect to the said 270 shares. (vi) Ex. PW-1/6 (OSR) being the copy of Aadhaar Card of petitioner no.1. He was not cross-examined despite opportunity. 8. Testimony of petitioner No. 2 has been recorded as PW-2. She testified that she wishes to claim her respective share in the debts and securities of her deceased mother. She was also not cross-examined despite opportunity. 9. RW-1 Mr. Pushpak Jain, Advocate of M/s. SRF Ltd, having office at 305, New Delhi House, 27, Barakhamba Road, New Delhi-110001, brought on record the certified record of 270 shares of SRF Ltd. under Folio No. G0001423 lying in the name of deceased, as per which the tentative market value of the said 270 shares is Rs.6,17,328/- as on 21.05.2024, Ex. RW-1/1. RW- 1 further deposed that the said 270 shares have been transferred to IEPF Authority. 10. The Court has heard submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioners and has perused the record. SC/163/23 Madan Lal Moondhra & Anr. Vs. State and Ors. 4/7 -- 4 of 7 -- 11. It is no longer res integra that succession petitions are to be decided summarily. Sec. 373 of the Indian Succession Act provides that a succession petition is to be decided in a summary manner and even if court cannot decide the right to the certificate without determining questions of law or fact which may seem to be too complicated and difficult for determination in a summary proceedings, the Court may nevertheless grant a certificate to a person if he appears to be the person having prima facie the best title thereto. Thus U/s. 373 of Indian Succession Act, only prima facie case is to be seen and other questions of law and fact which may be complicated are to be decided by a regular civil court. 12. In the case of Madhvi Amma Bhawani Amma and others Vs. Kunjikutty Pillai Meenakshi Pillai and others, Respondents. AIR 2000 Supreme Court 2301=2000 AIR SCW 2432 it was held as under :- “The enquiry in proceedings for grant of succession certificate is to be summary, and the Court, without determining questions of law or fact, which seem to it to be too intricate and difficult for determination, should grant the certificate to the person who appears to have prima facie the best title thereto. In such cases the Court has not to determine definitely and finally as to who has the best right to the estate. All that it is required to do is to hold a summary enquiry into the right to the certificate, with a view, on the one hand, to facilitate the collection of debts due to deceased and prevent their being timebarred, owing (for instance) to dispute between the heirs inter se as to their preferential right to succession, and, on the other hand, to afford protection to the debtors by appointing a representative of the deceased and authorising him to give a valid discharge for the debts. The grant of a certificate to a person does not give him an absolute right to the debts nor does it bar a regular suit for adjustment of the claims of the heir inter se”. SC/163/23 Madan Lal Moondhra & Anr. Vs. State and Ors. 5/7 -- 5 of 7 -- 13. Facts of the case shall be analyzed through the prism of legal position enunciated above. 14. As per uncontroverted testimony of PW-1, the deceased died intestate. As per Section 15 (1) (a) of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred as 'the HSA'), which provides that when a Hindu female dies intestate, her property shall devolve upon her husband and her children, including the children of her predeceased children. PW-1 has testified that husband of the deceased predeceased her. As such, upon the death of the deceased, her property notionally devolved upon her children, being petitioners no.1 and 2, equally and simultaneously. 15. As per death certificate of deceased Ex. PW-1/1, she used to reside at 3917, Roshan Pura, Nai Sarak, Delhi-110006, which falls within jurisdiction of this Court. 16. Succession certificate is sought qua 270 shares of SRF Ltd. under the folio no. G0001423. Total value of securities held by deceased is Rs.6,17,328/-. 17. Taking into consideration all the material on record, petitioners are seen to be entitled to the estate of the deceased equally and simultaneously. 18. In view of the evidence adduced on record which has remained unrebutted and uncontroverted, the Court is of the SC/163/23 Madan Lal Moondhra & Anr. Vs. State and Ors. 6/7 -- 6 of 7 -- considered opinion that there is prima-facie no impediment for grant of Succession Certificate in favour of the petitioners qua the debts and securities of deceased in terms of Ex. RW-1/1 having tentative market value of Rs.6,17,328/-. Succession Certificate granted accordingly. Succession certificate be drawn on deposit of requisite proportionate court fee of Rs.7,716.6/- each (Rounded off to Rs.7,717/-) in terms of Article 12 Schedule 1 of Court Fees Act, 1870, as applicable in Delhi and on furnishing an Indemnity Bond with one surety within 30 days from today. Petition is accordingly disposed of. File be consigned to record room after due compliance. Announced in the open (MEDHA ARYA) court on 04.09.2024. Administrative Civil Judge-cum- Additional Rent Controller (Central) Delhi. SC/163/23 Madan Lal Moondhra & Anr. Vs. State and Ors. 7/7 -- 7 of 7 --
