Full Order Text
Interim Order 14 · 29 Aug 2026 · CNR DLCT030055542025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS SCJ 1688/2025 Mahender Dayal Vs. Parmod & Anr. Pg. no.1/3 IN THE COURT OF SH. GAURAV DAHIYA, CIVIL JUDGE-06 CENTRAL DISTRICT TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI CS SCJ No. 1688/2025 Mahender Dayal ........Plaintiff Versus Pramod & Anrs. …..Defendants ORDER 1. Vide this order, application U/S 151 CPC for setting aside order dated 13.12.2025 filed on behalf of defendant no.1 and 2 shall be decided. 2. It is submitted in the aforesaid application that the defendants were served on 19.09.2025 with summons in a suit filed by the Plaintiff, and in good faith participated in mediation proceedings believing the matter to be a family dispute capable of amicable resolution, without realizing that their statutory 90 days period to file a Written Statement was running out. The mediation failed due to non-appearance of the plaintiff in person, and the Court subsequently closed the defendants' right to file their WS on 13.12.2025 without having given them a prior opportunity to do so. The matter proceeded for the plaintiff's evidence and the same was recorded and closed, and permission was granted for defendant evidence but their right was also closed on 11.06.2026 after the defendants could not appear on account of the death and mourning rituals of defendant no. 1’s grandfather. Throughout, the defendants remained unrepresented by proper legal counsel and acted under a mistaken belief that the dispute would be resolved -- 1 of 3 -- CS SCJ 1688/2025 Mahender Dayal Vs. Parmod & Anr. Pg. no.2/3 within the family. The present application, therefore, has been filed seeking recall of the order dated 13.12.2025 and an opportunity to file the Written Statement, on the ground that its earlier closure has caused grave prejudice to the Defendants' legal rights. 3. Plaintiff had filed the reply to the aforesaid application and submitted that the defendants have denied the plaintiff's contentions and submit that the present application (seeking recall of the order dated 13.12.2025 and permission to file the Written Statement) has been filed bona fide and in the interest of justice, not to harass the plaintiff. 4. Arguments on the application heard. Record perused. 5. As per record, the defendants were served on 19.09.2025 and appearance was filed on 06.11.2025 which was also the first date after service. The court had very categorically observed that the statutory period has already expired, however, liberty was granted to file written statement alongwith appropriate application seeking condonation. The matter was also referred to mediation on the same date. The matter could not be settled in mediation and notice was issued to both the parties for Pre-Lok Adalat sitting, however, no one appeared on behalf of defendants. Thereafter, matter was taken up on 13.12.2025 and since no one appeared on behalf of the defendants, their right to file written statement was closed. On subsequent dates, the matter was fixed for plaintiff’s evidence and the defendants were also advised to approach DLSA. Thereafter, defendants appeared in the court alongwith their counsel/ LAC on 12.03.2026 and even cross-examined the -- 2 of 3 -- CS SCJ 1688/2025 Mahender Dayal Vs. Parmod & Anr. Pg. no.3/3 plaintiff. 6. The record, as discussed above, would show that the defendants were negligent enough in not filing their written statement for more than six months and now intend to use the provision under section 151CPC for recall of the order. 7. It is to observe that the present application has been filed under Section 151 CPC. The said provision comes into effect during the pendency of proceedings before the court, and that too when there is no specific provision granting the relief sought by a party. In the case in hand, there are specific provisions in the CPC, which could have been invoked by the applicant for seeking the relief, and moreover the conduct of the applicant has not been such that the discretion of the court may be used in his favour. The application has not even been filed at the earliest possible opportunity and the court is of the view that if a party keeps sitting on his rights, then it would be prejudicial to the opposite party if the jurisdiction of the court is invoked in the interest of justice at the behest of the defaulting party. Thus, the present application is an abuse of the process of the court and a sheer wastage of precious judicial time. 8. In view of above, application U/S 151 CPC for setting aside/recalling of order dated 13.12.2025 filed on behalf of defendant no.1 and 2 stands dismissed. Pronounced in the open court on 29.08.2026. (Gaurav Dahiya) Civil Judge-06/Central Tis Hazari Courts/Delhi -- 3 of 3 --
