Full Order Text
Interim Order 13 · 11 Jun 2026 · CNR DLCT030035642025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. AKSHAY PRAKASH CIVIL JUDGE-04, CENTRAL, TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI 11.06.2026 CS SCJ 1066/2025 IN THE MATER OF: Satish Jain …Plaintiff Versus BCTA and Ors. …Defendants O R D E R 1. By way of the present order, this Court shall decide the application filed by the plaintiff under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC seeking interim injunction restraining defendant no. 1, its agents, servants, employees, assignees or anybody acting on behalf of defendant no. 1 from trespassing into the passage shown in yellow colour in the site plan. 2. Briefly stated, the plaintiff has filed the present suit, inter alia, seeking a declaration to the effect that the passage shown in yellow colour in the site plan (hereinafter referred to as the “disputed passage”) forms part of property bearing no. 14 and further seeking a declaration that the plaintiff has the right to install and lock a gate on the said passage. 3. For the sake of clarity and to facilitate a proper appreciation of the controversy involved in the present matter, the site plan relied upon CS 1066/2025 Satish Jain Vs BCTA & Ors. Page of 1 11 -- 1 of 11 -- by the parties is reproduced below. 4. It is the case of the plaintiff that he is a co-owner of property bearing no. 14, Alipur road, Civil Lines, Delhi by virtue of a registered sale deed dated 07.01.1970. Defendant no. 1 is stated to be the occupant of properties bearing nos. 13, 15, 17, 19 and 21, whereas defendant no. 2 is stated to be a resident of property no. 14A, Alipur road, Civil Lines, New Delhi. It is further the case of the plaintiff that property no. 14A is a landlocked property and under the sale deed dated 07.01.1970, an easementary right of passage was created through property no. 14 for the benefit of property no. 14A. Accordingly, a passage was carved out in property no. 14 and the residents of property no. 14A were permitted to use the same. CS 1066/2025 Satish Jain Vs BCTA & Ors. Page of 2 11 -- 2 of 11 -- 5. It is further averred that after purchase of property no. 14, the plaintiff got the site plan approved and raised construction while preserving the easementary right in favour of property no. 14A. A gate was installed on the said passage (Point ‘A’ and ‘B’), one key whereof was retained by the plaintiff and another key was handed over to the occupants of property no. 14A. 6. According to the plaintiff, defendant no. 1 has a separate civil dispute with defendant no. 2. It is alleged that in the year 2008 defendant no. 1 removed a wooden gate existing between property no. 15 and property no. 14A (Point ‘C’ and ‘D’). Thereafter, students, workers and staff members of defendant no. 1's organisation started using the disputed passage, which according to the plaintiff was meant exclusively for the occupants of property no. 14A. 7. It is further stated that during the Covid-19 pandemic the gate installed on the disputed passage got rusted and disintegrated, resulting in unrestricted access through the passage. The plaintiff alleges that the increased usage of the passage by persons associated with defendant no. 1 led to the movement of anti-social elements and caused disturbance to the peaceful enjoyment of the plaintiff's property. 8. The plaintiff thereafter approached the SDM seeking police protection for reinstallation of the gate. The SDM, after hearing the parties, vide order dated 22.11.2023, directed police assistance for installation of the gate. The gate was accordingly reinstalled (Point ‘A’ and ‘B’) and a duplicate key thereof was supplied to the residents of property no. 14A. CS 1066/2025 Satish Jain Vs BCTA & Ors. Page of 3 11 -- 3 of 11 -- 9. Defendant no. 1 challenged the order of the SDM before the District Magistrate but subsequently withdrew the appeal with liberty to avail appropriate remedies before a civil court. Thereafter defendant no. 1 filed a writ petition before the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi seeking, inter alia, demarcation of property no. 14A. When no interim relief was granted in the said petition to defendant no. 1 then defendant no. 1 preferred a Letters Patent Appeal to the Division Bench wherein the Hon'ble Division Bench directed that the gate (at point ‘A’ and ‘B’) shall remain open from 7:00 AM till 7:00 PM. The said order was challenged by the plaintiff before the Hon'ble Supreme Court, however no interference was made by the Hon'ble Supreme Court on the ground that the order was merely interim in nature. Ultimately, the writ petition was disposed of by the Hon'ble High Court with liberty to the parties to approach the competent civil court and with a direction that the arrangement of keeping the gate open from 7:00 AM till 7:00 PM shall continue, subject to modification by the civil court. 10. The plaintiff has therefore approached this Court seeking interim protection. 11. Per contra, defendant no. 1 has opposed the application and has contended that the disputed passage is not part of property no. 14 but rather forms part of property no. 14A. It has further been argued that the passage has been continuously used by members of defendant no. 1's organisation for several years and therefore the plaintiff is not entitled to restrict access thereto. CS 1066/2025 Satish Jain Vs BCTA & Ors. Page of 4 11 -- 4 of 11 -- 12. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and carefully perused the record. 13. The first question which arises for consideration is whether the plaintiff has been able to prima facie establish that the disputed passage forms part of property no. 14. 14. In this regard, the registered sale deed dated 07.01.1970 assumes significance. A perusal of the said sale deed prima facie shows that while transferring property no. 14, an easementary right of passage was reserved in favour of property no. 14A. The sale deed specifically records that the owners and occupants of property no. 14A shall have a right of passage through the road commencing from the gate opening towards Alipur Road and running along the southern boundary wall. The document further specifically stipulates that no person other than the residents of bungalow no. 14A shall be entitled to use the said passage. 15. The language employed in the sale deed prima facie leaves little room for doubt that the disputed passage forms part of property no. 14 and that only the occupants of property no. 14A were intended to enjoy a limited easementary right over the same. 16. The aforesaid conclusion also finds support from the material placed on record by the plaintiff. The RTI replies obtained from MCD specifically state that the area commencing from the entrance of property no. 14 on Alipur Road and ending at property no. 14A is a private lane and not a public street. The plaintiff had further sought clarification regarding the strip of land running along the boundary wall of property no. 12 up to property no. 14A, to which MCD replied CS 1066/2025 Satish Jain Vs BCTA & Ors. Page of 5 11 -- 5 of 11 -- that the same forms part of private property. It is also pertinent to mention here that in the writ petition filed by the defendant no. 1 before the Hon'ble High Court, the plaintiff had moved an application seeking impleadment of the MCD so that the concerned authority could clarify the status of the disputed passage. In its reply to the said application, the MCD had categorically stated that there was no MCD land or public lane existing between property no. 12 and property no. 14. Thus the consistent stand of MCD has been that the disputed passage is not a public lane vested in the municipal authorities. 17. At this stage, therefore, the material on record prima facie establishes that the disputed passage is private property and not a public lane. 18. Once it is prima facie established that the disputed passage is private property, the next question is as to who all are entitled to use the same. The sale deed of 1970 very categorically states that only the residents of property no. 14A shall be entitled to use the said passage. Thus the question to determined is who all are the residents of property no. 14A. 19. The site plan of property no. 14A, which was filed by defendant no. 1, in litigation being CS(OS) No. 1418/2015 is also on record in the present case, perusal of the said site plan shows that the property no. 14A comprises of two dwelling units, one principal dwelling unit, one smaller dwelling unit and an open lawn area. The principal dwelling unit is admittedly occupied by defendant no. 2 while the smaller dwelling unit is occupied by a tenant. Defendant no. 1 claims that the said tenant is under his tenancy while defendant no. 2 CS 1066/2025 Satish Jain Vs BCTA & Ors. Page of 6 11 -- 6 of 11 -- claims him to be under his tenancy. In effect, the claim of defendant no. 1 to use the said passage is through his alleged tenant occupying a smaller dwelling unit situated in property no. 14A 20. In the opinion of this Court, the controversy regarding whether the said tenant is under the tenancy of defendant no. 1 or defendant no. 2 is not material for the purposes of the present application. The easement created under the sale deed is in favour of the “residents” and occupants of property no. 14A and not in favour of any landlord who is not in occupation thereof. 21. Consequently, even if it is assumed for the sake of argument that defendant no. 1 is the landlord of the smaller dwelling unit situated in property no. 14A, such status by itself would not confer upon defendant no. 1 a right to permit its students, employees, workers, visitors and other members of the public to use the disputed passage. The right of user created under the sale deed cannot be expanded beyond its express terms. 22. The contention of defendant no. 1 that the passage forms part of property no. 14A is also not supported by any title document. Mere assertions unsupported by documentary evidence cannot outweigh the registered sale deed relied upon by the plaintiff. 23. Defendant no. 1 has placed reliance upon the report of the Tehsildar dated 16.02.2010. However, a perusal of the said report shows that it merely states that defendant no. 1 is the recorded owner of Khasra no. 413 and the said khasra comprises of Property no. 14A to 19E and that as per the revenue record there exists no passage/rasta therein. Thus, the said report does not support the contention that CS 1066/2025 Satish Jain Vs BCTA & Ors. Page of 7 11 -- 7 of 11 -- the disputed passage forms part of a public way or belongs to defendant no. 1. The observation in the said report, regarding the existence of a passage on the spot, merely appears to refer to the physical passage presently existing through property no. 14. 24. It has further been argued that the plaintiff is merely a one-fourth co- owner and therefore cannot maintain the present proceedings. 25. The said contention is devoid of merit. It is a settled proposition of law that any co-owner is competent to maintain proceedings against a trespasser or a person having no lawful right over the property. Until partition by metes and bounds takes place, every co-owner is deemed to be in possession of every inch of the joint property. Therefore, non-joinder of other co-owners does not disentitle the plaintiff from seeking protection of the property against alleged unlawful user. 26. It has also been argued that the sale deed dated 07.01.1970 is not accompanied by a legible site plan and therefore the identity of the property cannot be ascertained. 27. This contention also does not merit acceptance. Though the site plans accompanying the sale deed may not be clearly legible, the boundaries described in the sale deed clearly identify the property. The document records Alipur Road on the east, property no. 16 on the north, other kothis on the west and properties nos. 12 and 14A on the south. Correlation of these boundaries with the site plan placed on record prima facie establishes the identity of the property and the location of the disputed passage. CS 1066/2025 Satish Jain Vs BCTA & Ors. Page of 8 11 -- 8 of 11 -- 28. Defendant no. 1 has further contended that according to the plaintiff himself after the removal of gate installed at point ‘C’ and ‘D’ somewhere in the year 2008, members of defendant no. 1’s organisation have been using the passage and have therefore acquired rights therein. 29. The said contention is equally untenable. Even assuming that the usage commenced in the year 2008 and continued uninterruptedly thereafter, the statutory period prescribed for acquisition of an easement by prescription has not elapsed. Therefore, no prima facie right by prescription can be said to have accrued in favour of defendant no. 1 or persons claiming through it. 30. The argument that the dispute has been pending for a long period is also of no consequence. Mere pendency of disputes cannot by itself defeat a claim for interim relief where the applicant is otherwise able to establish a prima facie case. 31. From the discussion aforesaid, this Court is satisfied that the plaintiff has been able to establish a strong prima facie case. The balance of convenience also lies in favour of plaintiff and irreparable loss is also likely to be caused to the plaintiff if unrestricted user of the private passage is permitted during the pendency of the suit. 32. Accordingly, the application under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC is allowed. 33. Defendant no. 1, its agents, servants, employees, representatives and all persons claiming through it are restrained from using the disputed passage shown in yellow CS 1066/2025 Satish Jain Vs BCTA & Ors. Page of 9 11 -- 9 of 11 -- colour in the site plan except in accordance with the terms of this order. The plaintiff shall be entitled to keep the gate installed on the disputed passage locked and to regulate access thereto in accordance with the rights flowing from the sale deed dated 07.01.1970. 34. Before concluding, it may be noted that on the last date of arguments, defendant no. 1 was granted liberty to file an affidavit indicating the timings of the educational institutions run by its organisation so that the interests of students using the disputed passage as a shortcut to access the metro station may also be considered while passing an appropriate interim arrangement. 35. In compliance thereof, defendant no. 1 has filed an affidavit disclosing the school timings. Having regard to the said affidavit and keeping in view the larger interest of school-going children who use the passage as a convenient route for reaching the metro station, this Court deems it appropriate to carve out a limited arrangement during the pendency of the suit. 36. Accordingly, notwithstanding the injunction granted hereinabove, the gate installed on the disputed passage shall remain open daily from 7:00 AM to 9:00 AM so as to facilitate students travelling to school and shall further remain open from 2:00 PM to 04:30 PM so as to facilitate students, teachers and other school staff returning after school hours, including students attending remedial classes extending up to 4:00 PM. CS 1066/2025 Satish Jain Vs BCTA & Ors. Page of 10 11 -- 10 of 11 -- 37. Save and except for the aforesaid timings, the plaintiff shall remain entitled to keep the gate closed and locked. 38. With these directions the present application stands disposed of. 39. Nothing contained in this order shall be construed as an expression on the final merits of the suit. (Akshay Prakash) Civil Judge-04, Central, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi 11.06.2026 CS 1066/2025 Satish Jain Vs BCTA & Ors. Page of 11 11 -- 11 of 11 --
