Full Order Text
Interim Order 6 · 18 Mar 2024 · CNR DLCT030030192023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS SCJ 1078/23 CNR No. DLCT030030192023 VINOD Vs. SIYA RAM 18.03.2024 Present : Sh. P. P. Tiwari, Ld. counsel for the plaintiffs. Sh. Balraj, Ld. counsel for the defendant No.1 alongwith defendant No.1. Arguments on the interim application heard. The plaintiffs have sought temporary injunction against defendant No.1 restraining him from creating third party interest in the half portion towards western side of the shop on the ground floor with roof rights area measuring 3'4” x 15'7” in the property bearing No. 1493-94, situated at Ward No. 14, Sarai Khalil Sadar Bazar, Delhi. The plaintiffs further pray that defendant No.1 be restrained from creating unnecessary interruption and hindrance in running business from their own share in the suit property i.e. half portion towards western side of shop on the ground floor with roof rights area measuring 3'4” x 15'7” in the property bearing No. 1493-94, situated at Ward No. 14, Sarai Khalil Sadar Bazar, Delhi during the pendency of the present suit. The case of the plaintiffs is that the plaintiffs are running their business in the name and style of M/s Sumit Plastic from shop No. 1493/94, Pand Mandi, Sadar Bazar, Delhi. That the plaintiffs and defendant Nos. 2 to 5 are legal heirs of late Sh. Daya Ram and defendant No. 1 is real uncle of the plaintiffs. That the defendant Nos. 2 to 5 are the proforma parties, who inherited property rights being the daughters of late Sh. Daya Ram against whom no relief has been claimed by the plaintiffs. CS SCJ 1078/23 VINOD Vs. SIYA RAM Page No.1 of 8 -- 1 of 8 -- That late Sh. Daya Ram was the owner of half portion towards western side of shop on the ground floor with its roof rights area ad-measuring 3'4"x 15'7" (4.82 Sq. mtrs), in property bearing No. 1493-94, situated at Ward No.14, Sarai Khalil Sadar Bazar, Delhi (hereinafter referred to as suit property) by virtue of registered sale deed dated 22.06.2005 and agreement to sell and purchase dated 30.11.2011 executed by the defendant No.1 in favour of the late Sh. Daya Ram. That defendant No. 1 is the owner of half portion of eastern side of shop by virtue of general power of attorney dated 21.04.1998 and agreement to sell dated 21.04.1998. That defendant No.1 is running his business from his half portion in the said shop in the name and style of M/s Manoj Plastic. That the plaintiffs and defendant Nos. 2 to 5, after the death of late Sh. Daya Ram on 12.12.2012, became the lawful owners of the portion of property owned by Sh. Daya Ram in equal share by way of law of inheritance. That the plaintiffs are using the entire suit property jointly along with defendant No.1, as there is no dividing wall in the suit property of their respective share. That the plaintiffs have been enjoying entire suit property jointly along with defendant No.1 and running their business in the name and style of M/s. Sumit Plastic. That however, the defendant No. 1 has now developed ill-will to grab the lawful 50% share of the plaintiffs in the suit property as there is no wall between their share and creating hindrance on daily basis in running the business smoothly. That the defendant No. I is trying and conspiring to grab the lawful shares of the plaintiffs by selling/transferring/alienating the suit property to third party. That defendant No. 1 has no right title to dispose of or alienate 50% share of the plaintiffs in the suit property in any manner CS SCJ 1078/23 VINOD Vs. SIYA RAM Page No.2 of 8 -- 2 of 8 -- whatsoever. That defendant No.1 started to spread the words in the market that he would create and prepare false documents for the purpose of creating third party interest in the suit property. That at the time of purchasing the suit property, the said shop was having a dividing wall, however, late Sh. Daya Ram and the defendant No.1, being the real brothers, have decided to merge the shop in order to make it large for smooth business and therefore, the dividing wall was removed and the shop was merged in one shop. That in the said shop one electricity connection was also installed in joint name of late Sh. Daya Ram and defendant No. 1. That since the defendant No.1 has now developed ill-eyes on the share of the plaintiffs and therefore, he has been creating hindrance and nuisance in running the business of the plaintiffs in their western side portion of the suit property. That the defendant No.1, in fact, malafidely and in order to harass the plaintiffs, has stopped paying the electricity charges since March, 2022. That though it was mutually decided by the father of the plaintiffs, and after his death by the plaintiffs and defendant No. 1 that the electricity charges would be paid turn wise. That since, the defendant No.1 did not pay electricity charges on his turn in March, 2022, as a result of which, the electricity department has cut the electricity supply on 22.03.2023. That the plaintiffs have been requesting the defendant No.1 to clear the outstanding dues of the electricity charges since March, 2022, however, when all the requests went in deaf ears and after having cut the electricity supply, the plaintiffs were constrained to clear the outstanding dues of electricity charges of Rs.7,270/-, which were paid on 11.05.2023. That even after paying electricity charges by the plaintiffs, the CS SCJ 1078/23 VINOD Vs. SIYA RAM Page No.3 of 8 -- 3 of 8 -- defendant No.1 is creating hindrance in running their business smoothly from their share in the suit property. That on 20.05.2023, the electricity supply was restored in the suit property only after making due payment by the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs, thereafter requested the defendant No.1 to at least share electricity charges proportionately, on this request of the plaintiffs, the defendant No. 1 not only annoyed but also became violent and rather slapped the plaintiff No.2 and shouted that he would throw the plaintiffs out of the suit property without even giving their 50% share in the suit property as he is having link with various local bad element. That the defendant No. 1, in fact, even went on to say to the extent that he would sale out entire suit property by creating and preparing false title documents and would create third party interest in the suit property and nobody can stop him. That defendant No.1 on many times has thrown the materials of the plaintiffs outside the suit property and the Municipal Authority, on being found the material of the plaintiffs on road, has challaned the plaintiffs for the same. That the plaintiffs have also requested the defendant No.1 on many times to erect the dividing wall in the suit property so that the plaintiffs and the defendant No. I could do their respective business smoothly in their respective portion without any hindrance or interference of each other, however, the defendant No I has not only flatly refused to erect the dividing wall but also threaten the plaintiffs not to give any share to in the suit property. That lastly on 03.05.2023, when the defendant No.1 came on the shop and without even informing the plaintiffs, has thrown out entire material of the plaintiffs and when the plaintiffs have confronted the same to the defendant No.1, the defendant No.1 has abused CS SCJ 1078/23 VINOD Vs. SIYA RAM Page No.4 of 8 -- 4 of 8 -- the plaintiffs and also threaten that he would not allow the plaintiffs to run their business from the said shop at any cost. That he further threatened to dispose of the suit property even without giving their lawful 50% share in the suit property. The plaintiffs have sought the followings reliefs: “(a) Pass a decree for permanent injunction against the defendant No.1 thereby restraining the defendant No.1, his associates, attorneys, beneficiary, legal heirs, representatives, agents, servants, etc. from creating third party interest by selling. transferring, alienating, disposing off, letting of qua half portion towards western side of Shop on the ground floor with its roof rights area admeasuring 3'4"x 15'7" (4.82 Sq. Mtrs), in property bearing No. 1493-94, situated at Ward No.14, Sarai Khalil Sadar Bazar, Delhi-110006 as shown in site plan; (b) Pass a decree for permanent injunction against the defendant thereby directing the defendant No. 1 to allow the plaintiffs to run their business without any hindrance or interruption with respect of half portion towards western side of Shop on the ground floor with its roof rights area admeasuring 3'4"x 15'7" (4.82 Sq. Mtrs), in property bearing No. 1493-94, situated at Ward No. 14, Sarai Khalil Sadar Bazar, Delhi-110006 as shown in site plan; (c) Pass a decree for mandatory injunction against the defendant No.1 thereby directing the defendant No. I to allow the plaintiffs to run their business smoothly from their portion i.e. western portion of the suit property and to prevent such breach of an obligation on the part of defendant No.1 and the defendant No.1 be further directed to allow the erection of dividing wall in the suit property bearing No. 1493-94, situated at Ward No. 14, Sarai Khalil Sadar Bazar, Delhi- 110006 as shown in dotted red in site plan of the said shop in order to avoid any disputes in future and enabling the plaintiffs to run their business without any hindrance or interruption; (d) Award costs of the suit in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants; and (e) Pass any other or further order(s) which this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant.” Defendant No.1 has filed written statement stating therein that the plaintiffs have not come with clean hands to this Court and has also concealed and suppressed material and true CS SCJ 1078/23 VINOD Vs. SIYA RAM Page No.5 of 8 -- 5 of 8 -- facts from this Court. That the suit of the plaintiffs’ is liable to be rejected under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure. That defendant No.1 is the absolute owner of the property bearing No. 1493-94, situated at Sadar Nala Road, Delhi, comprising of double storey construction having one shop on ground floor, one room on first floor with open roof rights on second floor, by virtue of agreement to sale of dated 21.041998, GPA, SPA, Will dated 22.04.1998, affidavit and receipt dated 23.04.1998. That defendant No.1 is the absolute owner of the half portion of the shop on ground floor with roof rights in area measuring 3'4"x15'7" part of the property No. 1493- 94, Sarai Khalil, Sadar Bazar, Delhi by virtue of sale deed of dated 22.06.2005. That the father of the plaintiffs namely late Sh. Daya Ram had taken the sign of the defendant No.1 fraudulently on agreement for sale and purchase dated 29.11.2011, GPA dated 01.12.2011, affidavit dated 30.11.2011 and receipt of dated 30.11.2011 of half undivided share in one shop on ground floor with its roof rights on area measuring 3'-4" x 15'.7" (4.82Sq.Mtrs) in property bearing No. 1493-94, Situated at ward No. 14, Sarai Khalil Sadar Bazar Delhi and no consideration has ever been received by the defendant No.1 and neither the father of the plaintiffs disclosed about these documents nor given any copy to the defendant No. 1 during his life time. That defendant No.1 came to know about the above said forged and fraudulent procured documents in the month of December 2020, when the plaintiffs trying to vacate the suit shop forcefully from the defendant No.1, and when defendant No.1 opposed him, then the plaintiffs told him about the above said forged and fraudulent documents. That in 12.01.2021, defendant No.1 had cancelled CS SCJ 1078/23 VINOD Vs. SIYA RAM Page No.6 of 8 -- 6 of 8 -- these forged documents and, the defendant No.1 has also given the intimation to the plaintiffs regarding the cancellation through legal notice dated 02.02.2021. That the plaintiffs have made up a false story in the present suit and the same has been filed with mala fide intentions to cause harassment to the defendant. That the plaintiffs have not filed correct site plan of the suit shop and measurement of suit shop is also incorrect. Arguments heard. Record perused. The plaintiffs have pleaded that his father was owner of half portion towards the Western side of shop situated in property No. 1493-94, Sarai Khalil, Sadar Bazar, Delhi by virtue of sale deed dated 22.06.2005. That defendant No.1 is the owner of half portion of Eastern side of shop situated in property No. 1493-94, Sarai Khalil, Sadar Bazar, Delhi. Perusal of the sale deed dated 22.06.2005 shows that the shop on the ground floor was purchased by father of the plaintiffs and defendant No.1 jointly. It is further stated in the plaint that the plaintiffs are using the entire property alongwith defendant No.1 as there is no wall in the suit property. No site plan is filed by the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs are seeking injunction without claiming the relief of partition since there are no pleadings to the effect that the partition had taken place between the father of the plaintiffs and defendant No.1. It is stated by the plaintiffs themselves that there is no dividing wall in the entire suit property though such wall was existing at the time when the suit property was purchased. The plaintiffs are seeking mandatory injunction for erection of a dividing wall without claiming any partition. The suit of the plaintiffs for simplicitor injunction is not maintainable. Moreover, defendant No.1 has claimed himself to be the sole CS SCJ 1078/23 VINOD Vs. SIYA RAM Page No.7 of 8 -- 7 of 8 -- owner of the entire suit property by virtue of documents i.e. GPA, SPA and Will dated 22.04.1998 and thus, a cloud is raised over the title of the plaintiffs and in view of the judgment of Anathula Sudhakar Vs. P. Buchi Reddy (Dead) by LRs & Ors., AIR 2008 SC 2033, where it was held that when a cloud is raised over the title of the plaintiff, simplicitor suit for injunction is not maintainable. Accordingly, no prima facie case is found in favour of the plaintiffs. Balance of convenience also does not lie in favour of the plaintiffs. Therefore, the application under order 39 Rule 1 & 2 CPC is dismissed. Nothing contained in this order shall tantamount to an expression on the merits of the case. Put up for arguments on maintainability on 27.05.2024. (Pranav Joshi) ASCJ (Central)/Delhi 18.03.2024 CS SCJ 1078/23 VINOD Vs. SIYA RAM Page No.8 of 8 -- 8 of 8 --
