Full Order Text
Order 5 · 10 Dec 2024 · CNR DLCT030028552024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: 22RC ARC 222/24 Rakesh Kumar Gupta Vs. Abida Begum 10.12.2024 Present: Sh. Ajay Gupta, Counsel for the petitioner. Sh. Sachin Gautam, Counsel for the applicant. None for the respondent. 1. The present eviction petition has been filed u/s 14 (1) (e) of DRC Act. 2. Despite service of summons under the Third Schedule through publication on 03.08.2024, no leave to defend application was filed on behalf of the respondent. 3. However, an application under Section 25/37 of DRC Act was moved on behalf of the applicant Rais-ur-Rehman for impleadment. Reply to the said application is already on record. 4. Further, as per Ahlmad report, rejoinder to the said reply has also been tagged in the present file in compliance of the previous order. 5. Counsel for the applicant submits that he has already filed written arguments in support of the application. 6. Submissions heard. Record perused. 7. By way of the present application, applicant Rais-ur- Rehman has sought his impleadment in the present matter on the ground that the applicant is the owner of the tenanted premises in question and having independent title over the same. It is submitted that being the owner of the tenanted premises, applicant is a necessary and proper party. It is submitted that as per Section 25 of the DRC Act, the applicant being the owner and in occupation of the tenanted premises is having the right to be heard and raise objections. -- 1 of 3 -- Further, it is submitted that in view of the Section 37 of the DRC Act, the applicant must be given opporutnity to lead evidence in support of his submissions. 8. Per contra, Counsel for the petitioner /non-applicant has opposed the said application and argued that the applicant is not the necessary party. It is further submitted that the application is not maintainable since the applicant himself has stated that there is no landlord-tenant relationship and he is having independent title in the premises in question. 9. Perusal of record shows that the present petition is filed u/s 14 (1) (e) of the DRC Act r/w Section 25B of the DRC Act which is a complete code in itself. Furthermore, bare perusal of Section 25A of the DRC Act shows that the said chapter IIIA shall have overriding effect, notwithstanding anything contrary contained in the Act or any other law for the time being in force. Therefore, the reliance of the applicant on Section 25/37 DRC Act is misplaced. Chapter IIIA of the DRC Act is a complete code in itself. Here I also find it pertinent to refer to the decision of Prithipal Singh Vs. Satpal Singh (dead) through LR, (2010) 2SCC 15, where the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that Section 25 B is complete code in itself. Therefore, reliance on Section 25/37 DRC Act is of no assistance to the applicant. 10. Even otherwise, in the case of B.K. Khanna and Company Pvt. Ltd. Vs. K.C. Nahar; 1971 (2) ILR (Delhi) 366, the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi held that the jurisdiction of the controller is limited to a proceedings between a landlord and a tenant. It was further held that a person who is not a party -- 2 of 3 -- to such a relationship is not a necessary or a proper party to such proceedings and his title will have to be decided by a civil court in view of Section 50 (4) of the DRC Act. Even otherwise, petitioner is the dominus litis of his litigation and cannot be compelled to fight against the person against whom he does not wish to fight and against whom he does not claim any relief. 11. Hence, the applicant is not a necessary nor a proper party. Furthermore, perusal of proviso to Section 25 of DRC Act, itself shows that nothing in section 25 of DRC Act shall apply to any person who has an independent title to such premises. Therefore, even as per the submissions of the applicant himself, since he is claiming independent title to the tenanted premises, Section 25 of DRC Act does not come to his aid. 12. Accordingly, in view of the abovementioned decision of B.K. Khanna (supra), the applicant is not necessary party in the present matter and his claim of ownership/title can be decided by the Competent Civil Court only. 13. Hence, application u/s 25/37 DRC Act stands dismissed. 14. At this stage, counsel for petitioner prays that eviction order be passed since leave to defend the case has not been sought by the respondent. 15. Submissions heard. Record perused. 16. List for clarifications/orders on 13.12.2024. (Rupinder Singh Dhiman) ARC-01, Central District,THC 10.12.2024 -- 3 of 3 --
