Full Order Text
Final Order 3 · 02 Dec 2024 · CNR DLCT030019572024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS SCJ 539/24 CNR no. DLCT030019572024 SARV DHARAM SANGH SANSTHA (REGD.) & ANR. Vs. MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI & Ors. 02.12.2024 File taken up today at oral request of the Ld. counsel for the plaintiff for preponement of the present case. Present : Sh. Arjun, Ld. counsel for the plaintiff. Sh. S.R. Dabi, ALO for defendant No.1/MCD. The present file has been taken out today at the request of Ld. counsel for the plaintiff as he has requested to prepone the present case and take up the case today itself. Heard. Allowed. Perusal of the record shows that notice u/s 91 of CPC has been issued to the defendants, however, plaintiff has failed to take steps for issuance of summons/notices to the defendants in terms of order dated 22.10.2024. He seeks an opportunity to file the PF at this belated stage. Ld. counsel for the plaintiff has been asked to advance his arguments on the maintainability of the present suit. Arguments heard. Record perused. Perusal of the record shows that the present suit has been filed under Section 91 CPC. It is stated in the plaint that plaintiff no.1 is the registered society having its office in Karol Bagh which is working for welfare of general public at large against the wrongful and illegal acts done by anyone. It is further stated that the plaintiff No.2 is a social worker. It came to the knowledge of the plaintiffs that illegal and unauthorized construction was being raised at property bearing Contd....2/- -- 1 of 4 -- CS SCJ 539/24 CNR no. DLCT030019572024 SARV DHARAM SANGH SANSTHA (REGD.) & ANR. Vs. MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI & Ors. -2- Plot No. 850-858, Joshi Road, Opposite Gali No.9, Karol Bagh, Delhi-110005 by defendant No.3 to 7 herein. It is further stated that defendant No.3 to 7 did not obtain any sanction from the departments and authorities concerned to raise the alleged unauthorized construction. Plaintiff filed an application under section 6 of RTI, 2005, however, no proper reply has been provided to him by the authorities concerned. Hence, the present suit seeking a decree of permanent injunction restraining defendant no.3 to 7 from raising illegal and unauthorized construction and for mandatory injunction seeking demolition of the construction already raised by defendant no.3 to 7 in property bearing Plot No. 850-858, Joshi Road, Opposite Gali No.9, Karol Bagh, Delhi-110005. Ld. counsel for the plaintiffs has argued that the present suit is maintainable and there is a valid cause of action in the present case. In Rajendra Motwani vs. MCD RSA No.243/17 dated 16.10.2017, Hon’ble Delhi High Court has categorically held that:- “8. The second reason for rejecting the argument urged on behalf of the appellants/plaintiffs is that an illegal construction in itself does not give any legal right to a neighbor. An illegal construction always no doubt gives locus standi to the local municipal authorities to seek removal of the illegal construction, but, a right of a neighbor only arises if the legal rights of light and air or any other legal right is affected by virtue of the illegal construction of the neighbor. Legal right to light and air is only in terms of Section 15 of the Easements Act, 1882 which requires a cause of action to be laid out and proved that right to light and air has been enjoyed for 20 years and only on completion of 20 years there is a right to acquisition by Contd....3/- -- 2 of 4 -- CS SCJ 539/24 CNR no. DLCT030019572024 SARV DHARAM SANGH SANSTHA (REGD.) & ANR. Vs. MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI & Ors. -3- prescription in the easementary rights. It is relevant to note that even after acquisition of easementary rights of prescription, yet, right to injunction for a neighbor is not absolute and is covered by Section 33 of the Easements Act which requires that disturbance to the easementary rights must actually cause substantial damage to a neighbor and the infraction materially diminishes the value of the dominant heritage with the fact that there is material interference in the physical comfort of the neighbor of living in his own house or prevents the neighbor from carrying on his accustomed business in the dominant heritage/his own house. All these are factual aspects and admittedly there is no cause of action which is laid out in the plaint in terms of Sections 15 and 33 of the Easements Act that right to easement of the appellants/plaintiffs has become absolute as it has been enjoyed for 20 years and that in fact after rights to easement are acquired by prescription there is also a substantial damage to the appellants/plaintiffs or there is material interference in the physical comfort of the appellants/plaintiffs or the appellants/plaintiffs being prevented from carrying on his accustomed business in their own dominant heritage/own property.” In view of the law laid down by Hon’ble Delhi High Court as discussed above, there is no averment whatsoever regarding any easementary rights being affected by the alleged illegal construction being raised by defendant no.3 to 7. At the same time, it is pertinent to mention that no cause of action has arisen in favour of the plaintiffs only on the ground of alleged unauthorized construction, to file the present suit before this Court. It is an admitted fact that plaintiffs are not the intimidate neighbours of defendant No. 3 to 7 and the property of defendant No.3 to 7 is situated at a distance of about 1.5 KM from the office of the plaintiff No.1. In view of the discussion above, this Court comes to a conclusion that there is no cause of action in favour of the plaintiffs as well as jurisdiction of this Court is barred in view of Contd....4/- -- 3 of 4 -- CS SCJ 539/24 CNR no. DLCT030019572024 SARV DHARAM SANGH SANSTHA (REGD.) & ANR. Vs. MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI & Ors. -4- the law discussed above and therefore, the present plaint is rejected in terms of Order 7 Rule 11 (a) & (d) CPC being devoid of cause of action and being barred by law. All pending applications are disposed of accordingly. File be consigned to Record Room after due compliance. Earlier date i.e. 20.12.2024 stands cancelled. (Rinku Jain) ASCJ-01 (Central)/Delhi 02.12.2024 -- 4 of 4 --
