Full Order Text
Order 9 · 06 Oct 2025 · CNR DLCT030002792025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MS. DIVYA GUPTA, CIVIL JUDGE-08, CENTRAL DISTRICT, ROOM NO.283, TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI SUIT NO : 103/25 IN THE MATTER OF: - AMAR SHARMA ...PLAINTIFF VERSUS MAHENDER KUMAR ...DEFENDANT O R D E R 06.10.2025 1. Vide this order, I shall decide an application seeking leave to defend moved on behalf of defendant. 2. It is stated on behalf of applicant/defendant that the plaintiff has filed the present suit wherein the defendant had put his appearance and the plaintiff thereafter filed summons for judgment which were served through process server on 03.05.2025 upon the defendant. Hence, the defendant has filed the present application for leave to defend. CS No.103/25 Amar Sharma v. Mahender Kumar Page 1 of 9 -- 1 of 9 -- 3. It is submitted that the defendant had issued previous two blank security cheques bearing no.725456 and 725458 without date, month and year which were presented by the plaintiff without the permission of the defendant and the same were dishonored. The defendant informed the plaintiff about the dishonor of the said cheques and the defendant specifically stated that he had already paid the sum of Rs.1,02,000/- up to August, 2022 in installments of Rs.3000/- each to plaintiff. 4. That the plaintiff requested the defendant to make the balance payment of Rs.1,23,000/- and the defendant again issued two blank cheques without date, month and year as a security and promised the plaintiff to repay the same in installment of Rs.3000/- each per month. The plaintiff promised the defendant to return the said security cheque as and when the amount is cleared. 5. That thereafter the defendant had been regularly paying installment of Rs.3,000/- each per month, as per direction of plaintiff from September, 2022 up to March, 2023 i.e. Rs.21,000/- leaving behind the balance of Rs.1,02,000/- which the defendant is ready to pay. That the defendant has sent a sum of Rs.3,000/- through online in the month of 2022 which was CS No.103/25 Amar Sharma v. Mahender Kumar Page 2 of 9 -- 2 of 9 -- accepted by the plaintiff. 6. It is further contended that the plaintiff has misused the security cheques by presenting the same in his bank without the permission of the defendant. That the defendant has documentary proof regarding the above submission, so irreparable loss will be caused to the defendant without giving opportunity to the defendant. That there are many triable issued against the plaintiff and in favour of the defendant and these triable issued cannot be decided without leading any evidence. That the defendant is entitled for grant of leave to defend and contest the suit under the provisions of Order 37 Rule 3(5) CPC in the interest of justice, equity and fair trial. Hence, prayed that present application be allowed. 7. The plaintiff filed reply to the present application stating that the present application is beyond period of limitation of 10 days. That the present application is bad in law and no supporting affidavit has been filed along with the application. That the present application is not maintainable as the defendant has admitted the contents of the cheque in question and has not whispered a single word about the execution of the cheque and as such it will be deemed that the cheque in question is issued by the defendant under CS No.103/25 Amar Sharma v. Mahender Kumar Page 3 of 9 -- 3 of 9 -- debt of the amount as prayed for. That the application of the defendant is not maintainable as the signatures which defendant is alleging to be forged were put by the defendant himself at the time of taking of loan from the plaintiff and if there is any malafide in the plaintiff intention then the defendant after receiving the notice dated 11.07.2024 the defendant should have approached to the police authority for taking legal action. That the defendant has vaguely denied all the averments of the plaint without giving any specific reasons or suggestion about the averments of the plaint. Hence, prayed that present application be dismissed with heavy cost. 8. I have heard the arguments and perused the record. 9. Before delving into the merits of the present application it would be pertinent to refer to recent decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in IDBI Trusteeship Services Limited v. Hubtown Limited reported in (2017) 1 SCC 568, where the entire case law pertaining to summary judgments has been reviewed and it has been held at paragraph 17 as follows: “17. Accordingly, the principles stated in para 8 of Mechelec case [Mechelec Engineers & Manufacturers v. Basic Equipment Corpn., (1976) 4 SCC 687] will now stand superseded, given the CS No.103/25 Amar Sharma v. Mahender Kumar Page 4 of 9 -- 4 of 9 -- amendment of Order 37 Rule 3 and the binding decision of four Judges in Milkhiram case [Milkhiram (India) (P) Ltd. v. Chamanlal Bros., AIR 1965 SC 1698 : (1966) 68 Bom LR 36], as follows: 17.1. If the defendant satisfies the court that he has a substantial defence, that is, a defence that is likely to succeed, the plaintiff is not entitled to leave to sign judgment, and the defendant is entitled to unconditional leave to defend the suit. 17.2. If the defendant raises triable issues indicating that he has a fair or reasonable defence, although not a positively good defence, the plaintiff is not entitled to sign judgment, and the defendant is ordinarily entitled to unconditional leave to defend. 17.3. Even if the defendant raises triable issues, if a doubt is left with the trial Judge about the defendant's good faith, or the genuineness of the triable issues, the trial Judge may impose conditions both as to time or mode of trial, as well as payment into court or furnishing security. Care must be taken to see that the object of the provisions to assist expeditious disposal of commercial causes is not defeated. Care must also be taken to see that such triable issues are not shut out by unduly severe orders as to deposit or security. 17.4. If the defendant raises a defence which is plausible but improbable, the trial Judge may impose conditions as to time or mode of trial, as well as payment into court, or furnishing security. As such a defence CS No.103/25 Amar Sharma v. Mahender Kumar Page 5 of 9 -- 5 of 9 -- does not raise triable issues, conditions as to deposit or security or both can extend to the entire principal sum together with such interest as the court feels the justice of the case requires. 17.5. If the defendant has no substantial defence and/or raises no genuine triable issues, and the court finds such defence to be frivolous or vexatious, then leave to defend the suit shall be refused, and the plaintiff is entitled to judgment forthwith. 17.6. If any part of the amount claimed by the plaintiff is admitted by the defendant to be due from him, leave to defend the suit, (even if triable issues or a substantial defence is raised), shall not be granted unless the amount so admitted to be due is deposited by the defendant in court.” 10. In view of this aforesaid position of law, it is clear that if the facts disclosed by the defendant indicates that he has a substantial defence to raise or that the defence intended to be put up by the defendant is not frivolous or vexatious, leave to defend shall not be refused. 11. Reverting back to the merits of the instant application, the case of the plaintiff is that plaintiff advanced sum of Rs.2,25,000/- to defendant in cash in two installments, i.e. Rs.1,50,000/- on 31.10.2019 and Rs.75,000/- on 08.04.2019. That defendant issued two cheques bearing no.725458 for CS No.103/25 Amar Sharma v. Mahender Kumar Page 6 of 9 -- 6 of 9 -- Rs.1,50,000/- and 725456 for Rs.75,000/- in discharge of his liability. However, same were dishonored. Then parties entered into MOU/Settlement deed dated 06.10.2022 and defendant again issued two cheques, bearing no.060252 and 060253 both dated 16.03.2023. however, again cheques were returned dishonoured for reason “Funds Insufficient” vide memo dated 16.03.2023. Hence, the present suit for Rs.2,25,000/-. 12. In the present application defendant/applicant has nowhere denied the fact that sum of Rs.2,25,000/- was advanced by the plaintiff to him. Defendant has further admitted issuance of cheques however, defense set up by defendant is that cheques issued were security cheques. Further that defendant has already paid sum of Rs.1,02,000/- up to August 2022 on easy installment of Rs.3,000/- as per direction of plaintiff. That defendant has further paid sum of Rs.21,000/- up to March 2023 in installments of Rs.3,000/- per month and balance of Rs.1,02,000/- is outstanding. 13. Hence, clearly defendant has admitted his part liability of Rs.1,02,000/-. It is relevant to reproduce the relevant provision, i.e. Order 37 Rule 3 (5) of CPC which is as under: CS No.103/25 Amar Sharma v. Mahender Kumar Page 7 of 9 -- 7 of 9 -- “(5) The defendant may, at any time within ten days from service of such summons for judgment, by affidavit or otherwise disclosing such facts as may be deemed sufficient to entitle him to defend, apply on such summons for leave to defend such suit, and leave to defend may be granted to him unconditionally or upon such terms as may appear to the Court or Judge to be just: Provided that leave to defend shall not be refused unless the Court is satisfied that the facts disclosed by the defendant do not indicate that he has a substantial defence to raise or that the defence intended to be put up by the defendant is frivolous or vexatious: Provided further that, where a part of the amount claimed by the the plaintiff is admitted by the defendant to be due from him, leave to defend the suit shall not be granted unless the amount so admitted to be due is deposited by the defendant in Court.” 14. In my considered opinion, though the defendant has shown substantial defence and has raised genuine triable issue, however, as per the second proviso Order 37 Rule 3 (5) as discussed above, defendant is directed to deposit sum of Rs.1,02,000/- in the court within 30 days. 15. Accordingly, instant application is allowed and the defendant is granted conditional leave to defend qua the remaining amount. CS No.103/25 Amar Sharma v. Mahender Kumar Page 8 of 9 -- 8 of 9 -- 16. Let written statement be filed within four weeks with advance copy to other side, who may file replication thereto within two weeks thereafter. 17. Application disposed of accordingly. (This order contains 9 pages and each page has been signed by me) ANNOUNCED IN OPEN COURT (Divya Gupta) Today i.e. on 06.10.2025 Civil Judge-08 (Central) Tis Hazari Courts/Delhi CS No.103/25 Amar Sharma v. Mahender Kumar Page 9 of 9 -- 9 of 9 --
