Full Order Text
Order 12 · 28 Mar 2026 · CNR DLCT020440402025
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: 51 CC No.1769-2025 veena khanna Vs. RAJINDER KUMAR CHAUHAN /0 (Subzi Mandi) 28.03.2026 Present: None for complainant. EO/SI Saurav Sharma in person. Clarifications have been sought from the EO regarding the legal opinion obtained by him during enquiry as also referred by him in interim reports filed earlier. EO has submitted that upon instructions from Senior officials, i.e. SHO concerned, legal opinion was not obtained. Vide this order, I shall decide the application filed by the complainant u/S 156 (3) CrPC seeking issuance of direction to the SHO concerned to register FIR against the accused/alleged persons. Briefly stated, it has been submitted by the complainant is a senior citizen residing at Malka Ganj, Delhi. It is alleged that accused no.1, namely Rajinder Kumar Chauhan, was earlier employed as a clerk in the company of the complainant’s son and was entrusted with various responsibilities including handling company documents, stamp, and pre-signed letterheads. Owing to alleged misconduct, he was terminated from service in July 2019. It is further alleged that after termination, accused no. 1 developed enmity against the complainant’s family and, in connivance with other accused persons, started harassing and threatening them with the intention to implicate them in false cases and to grab the complainant’s property. It has been further submitted that apprehending danger, the complainant lodged a written complaints dated 13.06.2023 (DD No. 28A) with SHO, P.S. Sabzi Mandi and on 16.06.2023 with the DCP concerned, but no action was taken. It has been specifically alleged that on 25.06.2023 at about 4:00 PM, accused persons including Rajinder Kumar Chauhan and one Naveen along with 4 to 5 associates forcibly entered the complainant’s house without permission, -- 1 of 4 -- recorded videos and took photographs despite objection, abused the complainant, threatened her with death, and attempted to enter her personal room. It is further alleged that the complainant was manhandled during the incident. It has been further submitted that the complainant somehow managed to save herself with the help of her staff. However, the accused persons allegedly extended threats before leaving. It has been also alleged that on the same day at about 12:00 midnight, the accused persons again came to the house, forcibly entered and threatened to kill the complainant and dispossess her from the property, thereby causing grave fear and insecurity. It has been lastly submitted by the complainant that she has lodged a detailed written complaint dated 26.06.2023 before the police, but no FIR was registered. Thereafter, further reminders dated 25.07.2025 and 30.07.2025 were also sent to SHO and DCP respectively, but no requisite police action is stated to have taken place. Action taken report was filed by Enquiry Officer, SI Saurav Sharma. As per the ATR, it is stated that the accused Rajinder Chauhan was previously employed with the complainant’s son and was terminated in 2019. It is stated in the action taken report that the accused has also filed a complaint against the complainant’s son. It is further stated that no PCR call was made at the time of the alleged incident and no immediate complaint was lodged by the complainant. On the basis of enquiry conducted, the Enquiry Officer has opined that no cognizable offence is made out. During the course of arguments, the facts narrated above were reiterated by the counsel for the complainant which are not repeated herein for the sake of brevity. Ld. Counsel for the complainant has submitted that accused Rajender Kumar has not provided any document/Registration Certificate qua his alleged Firm and that he has claimed ownership of the house of the complainant based on photographs. It has been further submitted that there have been a number of admissions on the part of the accused in his interrogation report. Ld. Counsel for the complainant has lastly submitted that contradictory conclusions have been -- 2 of 4 -- drawn by the Enquiry Officer as he has in his conclusive ATR stated that no cognizable offence is made out while in the interim ATR filed by him on 29.11.2025, he had stated that the allegations of the complainant prima facie disclose commission of cognizable offence. Submissions heard. Record perused, carefully. Upon perusal of the complaint with annexed documents, it can be summarised that the complainant has alleged serious incidents of criminal trespass into her residence, videography without consent, criminal intimidation with threats to life, use of criminal force and manhandling and attempt to dispossess her from property, dated 25.06.2023 and also including a second incident during midnight hours. Such allegations, on the face of it, disclose commission of cognizable offences. The contention of the Enquiry Officer that no PCR call was made or that no immediate complaint was lodged does not, by itself, negate the allegations, particularly when the complainant has placed on record written complaints dated 13.06.2023, 26.06.2023 and subsequent reminders. Further, another contention in the ATR that prior dispute or cross-complaints existed between parties cannot be a ground to refuse registration of FIR when allegations disclose cognizable offences. At this stage, this Court is not required to evaluate the truthfulness of the allegations or conduct a mini trial. The defence of the accused and conclusions drawn in the ATR are matters of investigation. Considering the nature of allegations, collection of evidence such as CCTV footage (if any), identification of accused persons, examination of witnesses including staff members, and verification of alleged incidents would require police investigation. Needless to state that the complainant is an elderly woman and the allegations involve repeated trespass and threats affecting her safety and property. Such matters require prompt and proper investigation by police machinery and also the fact that she is unable to collect the relevant evidence on her own. In view of the above discussion, this Court is of the considered opinion that the complaint discloses commission of cognizable offences and custodial as well as field investigation is required. The application under Section -- 3 of 4 -- 156(3) CrPC is therefore allowed. Accordingly, SHO, PS Subzi Mandi is directed to register FIR under relevant provisions on the basis of allegations set out in the complaint within 3 days and investigate the matter in accordance with law. A detailed report/chargesheet be filed before this Court after completion of investigation. Needless to say, in case, after free and fair investigation the SHO concerned comes to a conclusion that a false complaint has been filed or that additional offences are made out as stated in the complaint or alleged offences are not made out, suitable report be filed in that regard by him. Copy of the order be sent to the SHO concerned for compliance. Relist for filing of compliance report on 06.04.2026. (Preeti Rajoria) JMFC-07/Central District Delhi/28.03.2026 -- 4 of 4 --
