Full Order Text
Interim Order 7 · 15 Jan 2026 · CNR DLCT020268982025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: 49 CC No.1021-2025 SMT MAYA DEVI Vs. HEAD CONSTABLE PAWAN YADAV AND ORS /0 (Subzi Mandi) 15.01.2026 Present: Complainant with Ld. Proxy counsel. Matter is listed for orders on the application u/s 175(3) BNSS. Be passed over till 4.30 p.m. At 5.00 p.m. Present: None. Vide this order, I shall decide the application filed by the complainant u/S 175 (3) BNSS seeking issuance of direction to the SHO concerned to register FIR against the accused/alleged persons. Briefly stated, the complainant is a widow, senior citizen aged about 61 years, and claims to be a heart patient who has undergone cardiac surgery with stents implanted. It is stated that the complainant is the owner in possession of Third Floor, Right Side Portion with roof/terrace rights along with 1/4th share in stilt parking on the ground floor, forming part of built-up property bearing Nos. 8600–8601, Ward XII, Bhargarh, Roshanara Road, Subzi Mandi, Delhi, built on land measuring 55 sq. yards, having freehold rights along with electricity, water and sewer connections. Proposed accused no.1 is stated to be a Head Constable posted at Police Station Subzi Mandi. Proposed Accused Nos. 2 to 6 are described as builders/owners, and proposed accused No. 7 is described as an associate of accused Nos. 1 to 6. -- 1 of 5 -- The complainant resides with her family at Pahar Ganj, Delhi, and has locked the aforesaid third-floor property, which she claims to visit periodically. It is alleged that after selling the said third floor to the complainant, proposed accused Nos. 2 to 7 developed dishonest intentions and attempted to take illegal possession of the complainant’s property by committing criminal house trespass and by extending threats to kill the complainant and her family members. It is further alleged that proposed accused No.1, in conspiracy with proposed accused Nos. 2 to 7, instigated and abetted attempts of criminal trespass and threatened the complainant with false implication in criminal cases by misusing his official position, including threats of getting the complainant and her family sent to jail. It is further alleged that in the intervening night of 06.05.2025/07.05.2025, when the complainant and her family were out of Delhi, proposed accused Nos. 2, 3 and 4 broke open the locks of her third-floor premises and roof. Upon returning to Delhi, she allegedly found the locks broken and doors open. A complaint was lodged at Police Station Subzi Mandi, but no action was taken, and instead proposed accused No.1 allegedly threatened her. It is further alleged that on 10.05.2025, proposed accused Nos. 2 to 7 again attempted to trespass into the property, compelling the complainant to make a PCR call, but no action was taken by police. Further threats to kill the complainant and her family members are alleged, including threats extended on 23.05.2025 at the instigation of proposed accused No.1. It is also alleged that due to the acts of the proposed accused persons, an atmosphere of fear and stress was intentionally created, endangering the complainant’s health. Written complaints dated 02.06.2025 were sent to the SHO, P.S. Subzi Mandi and the concerned DCP, but no action was taken. The Action Taken Report has been filed by Inspector Manu Dev, stating that the complainant purchased a third-floor flat measuring 55 sq. yards with roof rights vide sale deed dated 12.12.2024 from owners namely Raghubir Kaur, Madhu and Anju. It is stated that four other flat owners of the same building submitted complaints against the present complainant alleging that as per their sale deeds, all residents have legal rights to use the roof/terrace for common amenities -- 2 of 5 -- such as cleaning water tanks, installation of TV antenna and lift, but the complainant has locked the entrance to the terrace, thereby obstructing installation of the lift and causing hardship to other residents. These complaints were marked to HC Pawan Kumar for enquiry. He issued a notice dated 30.05.2025 to the complainant’s son Ritesh Kumar to join enquiry, who stated that he was outstation and would join later. HC Pawan Kumar denied allegations of threats and stated that he contacted Ritesh Kumar only in connection with the enquiry of complaints received from other residents. During enquiry, the erstwhile owners Raghubir Kaur, Madhu Anand and Anju Sukhija have stated that the building was constructed by builder Micky Kukreja under an agreement, with eight flats constructed, and that all buyers were sold flats with provision for lift and they have further stated that the dispute pertains to installation of lift and use of common areas, and that the staircase leading to the roof is a common area legally usable by all residents. Further, broker Reeta @ Bhola and resident Rampraksh Yadav stated that the complainant has locked the staircase leading to the terrace, preventing installation of lift, and that they are not aware of any incident of lock breaking. Furthermore, regarding the alleged PCR call dated 10.05.2025, it is stated that DD No. 65A was recorded and enquiry by HC Pramod revealed a civil dispute relating to installation of lift and use of common passages, with no cognizable offence disclosed. The ATR concludes that the dispute is civil in nature concerning common amenities, terrace access and installation of lift, and that no cognizable offence is made out. During the course of arguments, the facts narrated above were reiterated by the counsel for the complainant which are not repeated herein for the sake of brevity. Submissions heard. Record perused. It is pertinent to note that the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in the case titled M/S. Skipper Beverages Pvt Ltd. vs State, 92 (2001) DLT 217 has held that: “10. Section 156(3) of the Code aims at curtailing and controlling the arbitrariness -- 3 of 5 -- on the part of the police authorities in the matter of registration of FIRs and taking up investigations, even in those cases where the same are warranted. The Section empower the Magistrate to issue directions in this regard but this provision should not be permitted to be misused by the complainants to get police cases registered even in those cases which are not very serious in nature and the Magistrate himself can hold enquiry under Chapter XV and proceed against the accused if required. Therefore, a Magistrate, must apply his mind before passing an order under Section 156(3) of the Code and must not pass these orders mechanically on the mere asking by the complainant. These powers ought to be exercised primarily in those cases where the allegations are quite serious or evidence is beyond the reach of complainant or custodial interrogation appears to be necessary for some recovery of article or discovery of fact.” The scope of powers under Section 175(3) BNSS (pari materia with Section 156(3) Cr.P.C.) is well-settled and direction for registration of FIR is not to be issued mechanically and is to be exercised judiciously, only where the allegations prima facie disclose commission of a cognizable offence and police investigation is necessary. It is pertinent to note that the true test to exercise discretion to order investigation by police under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C is not whether any cognizable offence is committed or not, but whether an investigation by police agency is required or not. In the present case, the admitted position emerging from the complaint as well as the ATR is that the complainant is a purchaser of a flat in a multi-storey building. Other residents claim rights over common areas, including terrace and staircase, for installation of lift and other amenities. It has been brought to the notice fo the court that multiple complaints have been made by residents against the complainant alleging obstruction of common facilities. As such, the dispute primarily revolves around access to terrace, use of common passages, and installation of lift. No independent material has surfaced to substantiate allegations of forcible house-trespass, breaking of locks, or criminal intimidation beyond bald assertions. Further, the alleged police inaction has been -- 4 of 5 -- explained in the ATR with reference to enquiries conducted and PCR record. The facts reveal a property-related dispute having civil overtones, rather than commission of cognizable criminal offences necessitating registration of FIR. Mere allegations against police officials or use of strong language cannot, by themselves, justify directions under Section 175(3) BNSS in the absence of prima facie disclosure of cognizable offences. In view of the aforesaid discussion, the application under Section 175(3) BNSS is accordingly dismissed. However, the complainant is not remediless and is at liberty to avail appropriate civil remedies as well as lead pre-summoning evidence in support of her allegations. Needless to say if the need for police investigation arises in future, recourse to provisions of Section 225 BNSS could be taken at the appropriate stage. Put up for PSE on 18.03.2026. (Preeti Rajoria) JMFC-07/Central District Delhi/15.01.2026 -- 5 of 5 --
