Full Order Text
Order 9 · 10 Jul 2024 · CNR DLCT020105632023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Ct. Cases 742/2023 SHAUKAT ALI Vs. KAILASH RANI 10.07.2024 Proceedings are being conducted through hybrid mode. Ld. Presiding Officer was on short leave today. Present: Complainant in person. Sh. V.K. Mishra, Ld. Counsel for complainant. Today the present matter is listed for orders on application under Section 156 (3) of Cr.P.C. ATR was called and the same is on record. The case of the applicant in brief is that the complainant/applicant, formerly a tenant of the deceased Somnath, claims that post Somnath's demise, he continued rent payments to accused No. 1. On March 27, 2023, at approximately 11:00 AM, the accused persons allegedly expelled the complainant's belongings onto the street, threatened the complainant with false sexual offense charges, and unlawfully secured the premises with additional locks. Notably, the complainant alleges the accused misappropriated a briefcase containing Rs. 1,00,000 and valuable documents during this incident, purportedly in the presence of police officers. As per the ATR, the complainant did not provide any rent receipts to substantiate ongoing tenancy or payments. The complainant indicated the dispute pertains to a landlord-tenant relationship over rent, which he expressed a desire to settle independently. The allegations regarding the cash in the briefcase are deemed an afterthought by the inquiry officer. The ATR -- 1 of 6 -- concludes that the matter predominantly features elements of a civil dispute. Record perused. At this stage, it is apt to refer to the observations of the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in M/s. Skipper Beverages Pvt. Ltd. Vs. State 2001 IV AD (Delhi), it was held that: “It is true that Section 156(3) of the Code empowers to Magistrate to direct the police to register a case and intimate investigations but this power has to be exercised judiciously on proper grounds and not in a mechanical manner. In those cases where the allegations are not very serious and complaint himself is in possession of evidence to prove his allegations there should be no need to pass orders U/s. 156 (3) of the Code. This discretion ought to be exercised after proper application of mind and only in those cases where the Magistrate is of the view that the nature of the allegations is such that the complainant himself may not be in a position to collect and produce evidence before the court and interest of justice demand that the police should step in the help of the complaint. The court is supposed to order investigation keeping in mind the guidelines issued by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the case of Subh Karan Luharuka & anr Vs. State & anr 2010(3) JCC 1972, where it is laid down as under: “52A. For the guidance of Subordinate Courts, the procedure to be followed while dealing with an application U/s -- 2 of 6 -- 156 (3) of the Code is summarized as under: (i) Whenever a Magistrate is called upon to pass orders under Sec 156 (3) of the code, at the outset, the Magistrate should ensure that before coming to the Court, the complainant did approach the police officer in charge of the Police of Station having jurisdiction over the area for recording the information available with him disclosing the commission of a cognizable offence by the persons/persons arrayed as an accused in the complaint. It should also be examined as to what action was taken by the SHO, or even by the senior officer of the Police, when approached by the complainant under Section 154 (3) of the Code. (ii) The Magistrate should then form his own opinion whether the facts mentioned in the complaint disclose commission of cognizable offence by the accused persons arrayed in the complaint which can be tried in his jurisdiction. He should also satisfy himself about the need for investigation by the police in the matter. A preliminary enquiry as this is permissible even by an SHO and if no such enquiry has been done by the SHO, then it is all the more necessary for the Magistrate to consider all these factors. For that purpose, the Magistrate must apply his mind and such application of mind should be reflected in the Order passed by him. Upon a preliminary satisfaction, unless there are exceptional circumstances to be recorded in writing, a status report by the -- 3 of 6 -- police is to be called for before passing final orders. (iii) The Magistrate when approached with a complaint under Section 200 of the Code, should invariably proceed under Chapter XV by taking cognizance of the complaint, recording evidence and then deciding the question of issuance of process to the accused. In that case also, the Magistrate is fully entitled to postpone the process if it is felt that there is a necessity to call for a police report under Section 202 of the Code. (iv) Of course, it is open to the Magistrate to proceed under Chapter XII of the Code when an application under Section 156 (3) of the Code is also filed alongwith a complaint U/s 200 of the Code if the Magistrate decides not to take cognizance of the complaint. However, in that case, the Magistrate, before passing any order to proceed under Chapter XII, should not only satisfy himself about the pre requisites as aforesaid, but, additionally, he should also be satisfied that it is necessary to direct Police investigation in the matter for collection of evidence which is neither in the possession of the complainant nor can be produced by the witnesses on being summoned by the Court at the instance of the complainant, and the matter is such which calls for investigation by a State agency. The Magistrate must pass an order giving cogent reasons as to why he intends to proceed under Chapter XII instead of Chapter XV of the Code.” -- 4 of 6 -- According to the application, the applicant initially stated that the late Somnath was the landlord, and subsequently, proposed Accused No. 1 began collecting rent on behalf of Somnath’s legal heirs, thus assuming the role of landlord. However, the complainant has then revised his stance in the later part of his application claiming that accused persons are not the real landlords.. After a thorough review of the records and consideration of the arguments presented, the court is of prima facie opinion that the core of the dispute pertains fundamentally to a landlord-tenant relationship. Given the facts the present matter does not call for direction of registration of FIR followed by investigation by State Machinery against the respondents/proposed accused persons as: 1. The identity of alleged accused persons are ascertained. 2. No facts are needed to be unearthed as the same are well within the knowledge of the complainant. 3. Custodial interrogation of alleged accused persons are not necessary. 4. The evidence is well within the reach of complainant & no assistance of police is required to gather the same. 5. The facts of the case is not such that would warrant a detailed and complex investigation to be carried out by the State Agency. Hence, there is no need for investigation by the police u/s 156(3) Cr.P.C in this case. Application is hereby dismissed. -- 5 of 6 -- However, the cognizance of the offence is taken and complainant is at liberty to lead pre-summoning evidence. In case, assistance of police is required, resort can always be had to provision of Section 202 Cr.P.C. Put up for PSE on 04.12.2024. (Dr. Raj Kumar Singh) Judicial Magistrate First Class-05/Central Delhi/10.07.2024 -- 6 of 6 --
