Full Order Text
Final Order 8 · 24 Jan 2025 · CNR DLCT010184462023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. ANIL KUMAR SISODIA: DISTRICT JUDGE (COMMERCIAL COURT-04), CENTRAL DISTRICT, TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI CS (COMM) NO. 28/2024 PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK Having its head office at Plot no.4, Sector-10, Dwarka, New Delhi-110075 Inter alia a Branch office at:- Subzi Mandi Branch, 8778-80, Roshanara Road, Subzi Mandi, Delhi-110007 Also at: Circle Sastra East Delhi, CSC, Mayur Vihar, Phase-2, New Delhi-110091 …........Plaintiff Versus MS. RANI GOYAL W/o Sh. Rajesh Goel Sole Proprietor of M/s. Mor Mukut Gar Tex, Having office at: E-16/1215, Gurudwara Gali, Tank Road, Market, Karol Bagh, Delhi-110005 And Also at: D-5/66, Ground floor, Block D, Pocket-V, CS (COMM) NO. 28/2024 PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK VS. MS. RANI GOYAL Page No. 1/8 -- 1 of 8 -- Rohini, Sector-15, North West, Delhi-110089 ………… Defendant Date of institution of suit: 04.01.2024 Date of reserving for order: 24.01.2025 Date of pronouncement: 24.01.2025 Ex-parte Judgment 1. Plaintiff has filed the commercial suit for recovery of Rs.11,32,524.76 (Rupees eleven lakhs thirty two thousand five hundred and twenty four and paisa seventy six only) along with interest against the defendant. 2. The case of the plaintiff as stated in the plaint is that plaintiff bank is a corporate body constituted under the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of undertakings) Act. The defendant is running a proprietorship firm in the name of M/s. Mor Mukut Gar Tex and engaged in the business of readymade garments. The defendant approached Oriental Bank of Commerce (which got amalgamated in the plaintiff bank w.e.f. 01.04.2020) in the year 2018 for financial assistance for smooth functioning of her business. The defendant requested the bank for grant of cash credit facility to the tune of Rs.10,00,000/-. The plaintiff bank sanctioned the Cash Credit Limit of Rs.10,00,000/- vide sanction letter dated 01.12.2018. The defendant executed the loaning and security documents in favour of the erstwhile Oriental Bank of Commerce i.e. Sole Proprietorship letter dated 01.12.2018, Agreement CS (COMM) NO. 28/2024 PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK VS. MS. RANI GOYAL Page No. 2/8 -- 2 of 8 -- of hypothecation of assets dated 01.12.2018 and Common Agreement dated 01.12.2018. The said facility disbursed under the said scheme to bear floating interest at MCLR (Marginal Cost of funds based Lending Rate) 1 year plus 2.25% p.a. with monthly rests, rising and falling from time to time as per the bank norms. It was further agreed between the parties that penal interest @ 2% per annum over and above the above mentioned rate of interest shall be charged on overdue portion. The said facility was running regularly till Covid-19. In the year 2021, the defendant again approached the plaintiff bank and requested to restructure her cash credit facility and to grant a COVID loan. The plaintiff bank has restructured the Cash Credit Facility to the tune of Rs.10,00,000/- in favour of the defendant. The plaintiff at the request of defendant sanctioned a fresh COVID 19 loan in the nature of Working Capital Term Loan under GECL of Rs.1,00,000/- vide sanction letter dated 24.06.2021 in favour of defendant. The said amount disbursed under the cash credit scheme, to bear floating interest @ 8.20% per annum with monthly resents. It was further agreed between the parties that penal interest @ 2% per annum over and above the above mentioned rate of interest shall be charged on overdue portion. It is stated that at the time of filing the present suit, the rate of interest is @ 10.90% per annum in cash credit facility account. It is stated that the amount disbursed under Working Capital Term Loan under GECL was to be repaid in 36 months including a moratorium period of 6 months in 30 installments. The defendant executed the loaning and security documents in favour of the CS (COMM) NO. 28/2024 PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK VS. MS. RANI GOYAL Page No. 3/8 -- 3 of 8 -- plaintiff bank i.e. Master Agreement dated 02.08.2021 and agreement for Working Capital Term Loan dated 02.08.2021. It is stated that despite reliefs granted by the plaintiff, defendant has failed to maintain financial discipline and failed to pay the interest as agreed. The defendant has not bothered to regularize the account despite of several written and oral request made by the plaintiff and has clearly violated the terms and conditions. The defendant has also not furnished financial data and stock statement as required periodically. 3. It is further averred that defendant has lastly paid Rs.20,000/- in cash on 03.02.2023. However, failed to deposit the requisite amount. It is stated that due to defaults on the part of the defendant, the loan account bearing no. 00144011000489 and 0014110RF00000013 were declared as NPA on 11.05.2023. It is stated that as per the statement of account, an amount of Rs.10,53,561.76 was due and outstanding against the defendant as on 11.05.2023. It is stated that besides the said amount of Rs.10,53,561.76, Rs. 78,963/- (Rs. 77,075/- in her CC loan account and Rs.1,888/- in her Working Capital Term Loan under GECL account) has also become due and recoverable from the defendant on account of interest and other charges from 12.05.2023 to 30.11.2023. Thus a total sum of Rs. 11,32,524.76 is due and recoverable from the defendant upto 30.11.2023. Finding no other alternative, the plaintiff bank has filed the present suit against the defendant. 4. Summons of the suit were issued to the defendant. Summons have CS (COMM) NO. 28/2024 PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK VS. MS. RANI GOYAL Page No. 4/8 -- 4 of 8 -- been delivered to the defendant on her mobile no.9540835000 through whatsapp on 25.07.2024 and on email ID mormukutgartex@gmail.com on 28.06.2024. Defendant was duly served with the summons through affixation on 25.06.2024. Summons have also been served on the defendant by way of publication in ‘Rashtriya Sahara’ on 03.07.2024. Despite service, none appeared on behalf of the defendant nor filed any WS. Hence the right of defendant to file WS stood forfeited and defendant was proceeded exparte vide order dated 17.12.2024. 5. To prove its case, plaintiff has examined PW-1 Sh. Abhishek Verma, who has filed his examination-in-chief by way of affidavit Ex.PW-1/A and has reiterated the facts stated in the plaint. The witness has proved the following documents:- Sr. No. Document Exhibit 1 Authority letter dated 19.12.2023(OSR) PW-1/1 2 Copy of GST Registration certificate of M/s. Mor Mukut Gar Tex Mark A 3 Copy of Aadhar card Mark B 4 Loan application PW-1/2 5 Sanction letter dated 01.12.2018 PW-1/3 6 Sole Proprietorship Letter dated 01.12.2018 PW-1/4 7 Agreement of hypothecation of Assets dated 01.12.2018 PW-1/5 8 Common Agreement dated 01.12.2018 PW-1/6 9 Sanction letter dated 24.06.2021 PW-1/7 10 Master Agreement dated 02.08.2021 PW-1/8 11 Agreement for working capital term loan dated 02.08.2021 PW-1/9 CS (COMM) NO. 28/2024 PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK VS. MS. RANI GOYAL Page No. 5/8 -- 5 of 8 -- 12 Recall notice dated 30.05.2023 Mark C 13 Mediation application form PW- 1/10 14 Non starter report PW- 1/11 Thereafter, ex parte evidence was closed by the plaintiff. 6. I have heard the arguments of Ld. counsel for the plaintiff and have perused the record carefully. 7. The testimony of PW-1 has remained unassailed and unrebutted as defendant has not contested the suit. The plaintiff has proved the authority letter in favour of Sh. Abhishek Verma as Ex.PW-1/1. The plaintiff has proved the loan application and sanction letter as Ex.PW-1/2 and PW-1/3. Plaintiff has also proved the sole proprietorship letter dated 01.12.2018 as Ex.PW-1/4. Plaintiff has also proved agreement of hypothecation of assets as Ex.PW-1/5 and common agreement as Ex.PW- 1/6. Sanction letter dated 24.06.2021 and Master agreement were also proved by the plaintiff as Ex.PW-1/7 and PW-1/8. Plaintiff has further proved the agreement for working capital term loan dated 02.08.2021 as Ex.PW-1/9. Plaintiff has also proved the recall notice dated 30.05.2023 as Mark C. 8. From the perusal of testimony of PW-1 and the documents proved on record, I am of the considered opinion that plaintiff has established its case against the defendant for recovery of Rs.11,32,525/-. The suit of the CS (COMM) NO. 28/2024 PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK VS. MS. RANI GOYAL Page No. 6/8 -- 6 of 8 -- plaintiff is within the period of limitation as the last payment was made by the defendant on 03.02.2023. The loan accounts were declared NPA on 30.05.2023. 9. The plaintiff has claimed pendente lite and future interest @ 10.90% per annum on the ground that the said rate was contractual rate of interest between the parties and the dispute between the parties is of commercial nature. 10. In Central Bank of India Vs Ravindra & Ors., (2002) 1 SCC 367, it was held that award of interest, pendente lite and post decree is discretionary with the courts as it is essentially governed by Section 34 of the CPC de-hors the contract. 11. Having regard to the lending rate of interest of the bank for the commercial transactions, this court is of the view that interest @ 9% per annum is reasonable and would serve the ends of restitutive justice. In the circumstances, plaintiff is held entitled to interest @ 9% per annum from the date of filing of the suit till its realization. 12. Accordingly, the suit of the plaintiff is decreed. A decree of Rs. 11,32,525/- is passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant. The plaintiff shall also be entitled to simple interest on the aforesaid amount @ 9% per annum from the date of filing of the suit till its realization. Plaintiff shall also be entitled to cost of the suit. CS (COMM) NO. 28/2024 PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK VS. MS. RANI GOYAL Page No. 7/8 -- 7 of 8 -- Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. File be consigned to record room after due compliance. Announced in the open Court (ANIL KUMAR SISODIA) Dated : 24.01.2025 District Judge (Commercial Court-04) Central District, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi CS (COMM) NO. 28/2024 PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK VS. MS. RANI GOYAL Page No. 8/8 -- 8 of 8 --
