Full Order Text
Final Order 25 · 09 Mar 2026 · CNR DLCT010181992023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. RAKESH KUMAR SHARMA: DISTRICT JUDGE-8 (CENTRAL), EXTN. BLOCK, TIS HAZARI, DELHI Suit No. 1385/2023 Unique ID No.: DLCT01-018199-2023 In the matter of: Ms. Aruna Gupta W/o Sh. Bobby Gupta R/o 3540, Gali Hakim Baqa, Chawri Bazar, Delhi-110006 ….........Plaintiff VERSUS 1. M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co. (Partnership Firm through Urmila Goel, Partner) 4048A, Naya Bazar New Delhi 2. Urmila Goel, Partner, M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co W/o Sh. Parvesh Goel, R/o F-91, Ashok Vihar, Phase-I, New Delhi 3. Sushma Goel (W/o Late Rakesh Goel Partner, M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co) R/o C-2/8, Ashok Vihar, Phase-II, New Delhi Suit No. 1385/2023 Aruna Gupta vs. M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co & Ors. Page No. 7/7 -- 1 of 7 -- 4. Vineet Goel (S/o Late Rakesh Goel Partner, M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co) R/o C-2/8, Ashok Vihar, Phase-II, New Delhi 5. Shivani Goel (D/o Late Rakesh Goel Partner, M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co) R/o C-2/8, Ashok Vihar, Phase-II, New Delhi 6. Rita Goel (W/o Late Bhushan Kumar Goel, Partner, M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co) R/o C-3/19, Ashok Vihar, Phase-II, New Delhi 7. Varun Goel (S/o Late Bhushan Kumar Goel, Partner, M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co) R/o C-3/19, Ashok Vihar, Phase-II, New Delhi 8. Vidhi Goel (D/o Late Bhushan Kumar Goel, Partner, M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co) R/o C-3/19, Ashok Vihar, Phase-II, New Delhi 9. Harish Goel (S/o Late Bhushan Kumar Goel, Partner, M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co) R/o C-3/19, Ashok Vihar, Phase-II, New Delhi …….....Defendants Suit No. 1385/2023 Aruna Gupta vs. M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co & Ors. Page No. 7/7 -- 2 of 7 -- Date of institution : 22.12.2023 Date of Reserving judgment : 09.03.2026 Date of pronouncement : 09.03.2026 JUDGMENT 1. This is a suit for recovery of Rs.9,40,869/- (Rupees Nine Lakhs Forty Thousands Eight Hundred and Sixty Nine Only) with pendente-lite and future interest @ 15% per annum from the date of filing of the suit till realization with costs filed by the plaintiff against the defendants. 2. It is stated in the plaint that defendant no.1 is a partnership firm and its partners were Urmila Goel, Rakesh Goel and Bhushan Kumar Goel. Father of plaintiff Late Hari Kishore Singhal had good relations with the partners of defendant no.1 and had given personal loan to defendant no.1 firm long back on interest @ 15 % p.a. and defendant no.1 was making payment of interest @ 15% p.a. to the father of the plaintiff for last many years. As per the agreement, the interest amount used to be credited in the ledger account, amount, if any, used to be withdrawn was deducted and the entire amount at the end of the financial year used to become the principal amount on which the defendants used to pay interest @ 15% per annum. Father of the plaintiff Sh. Hari Kishore Singhal expired in the year 2013 leaving behind his wife Smt. Nirmala Devi and two sons namely Suit No. 1385/2023 Aruna Gupta vs. M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co & Ors. Page No. 7/7 -- 3 of 7 -- Rajeev and Raj Kishore and two daughters namely Aruna Gupta (plaintiff) and Anju Aggarwal, and the loan amount given by him was transferred to his wife Smt. Nirmala Devi by defendant no.1 with the consent of plaintiff and her other siblings and defendant no. 1 started paying interest amount to her by crediting the same in the ledger account. Smt. Nirmala Devi also expired in November, 2019 and after her death, a sum of Rs.25,67,576/- was lying to her credit towards the loan in books of accounts of defendant no.1 firm. The said amount was transferred separately by defendant no.1 in favour of all the four legal heirs of Smt. Nirmala Devi equally. In this manner, defendant no.1 transferred a sum of Rs.6,41,894/- (being 1/4th of said amount of loan payable to mother of plaintiff in the ledger account maintained by defendant no.1), in the name of plaintiff being the daughter of Smt. Nirmala Devi and handed over a signed ledger account to the plaintiff. Thus, the defendants admitted their liability towards the plaintiff. The ledger account sent by the defendants to the plaintiff showed a sum of Rs.6,41,894/- due as on 31.03.2021 towards loan advanced by the plaintiff with interest @ 15 % p.a. Hence, up to 31.10.2023 a sum of Rs.9,12,573/- has become due towards the principle and interest @ 15% p.a. After 31.03.2021, despite various demands of the plaintiff, the defendants avoided to repay the said amount on one pretext or other. The plaintiff served a legal notice dated 17.11.2023 upon the defendants but they failed to make the payment. Till filing of the suit, a sum of Rs.28,296/- has become due towards further interest. Thus, in all, a sum of Rs.9,40,869/- has become due against the defendants. All Suit No. 1385/2023 Aruna Gupta vs. M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co & Ors. Page No. 7/7 -- 4 of 7 -- the defendants, being partners of defendant no.1, are jointly and severally liable to make the payment of amount of Rs. 9,40,869/- with interest @ 15% p.a. to the plaintiff. Hence, the present suit. 3. All the defendants failed to appear before the Court and even to file their written statement despite service and were proceeded ex parte. 4. The plaintiff examined herself as PW-1 as the only witness in support of her case. 5. Ld. Counsel for plaintiff relied upon Order XXX Rule 1, 4 and 8(4) CPC to contend that the partners of a partnership firm may be sued in the name of firm and in case any of the partner dies even before the institution of the suit, the suit can still be filed against the firm without impleading the legal representatives of such deceased partner. 6. I have heard Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff and have gone through the record. 7. In her affidavit filed as examination-in-chief, the plaintiff fully supported her case as stated in the plaint and relied upon the following documents: Suit No. 1385/2023 Aruna Gupta vs. M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co & Ors. Page No. 7/7 -- 5 of 7 -- (a) Copy of ledge account of the mother of the plaintiff Smt. Nirmala Devi for the period from 01.04.2019 to 31.03.2021 as Ex. PW1/1. (b) Copy of the Form 15G issued by the defendants bearing the seal and signatures of the manager of defendant no. 1 firm as Ex. PW1/2. (c) Copy of death certificate of Sh. Hari Kishore Singhal as Ex. PW1/3. (d) Copy of death certificate of Smt. Nirmala Devi as Ex. PW1/4 (e) Copy of ledger account supplied by the defendants as Ex. PW1/5. (f) Statement of account of plaintiff as Ex. PW1/6 (g) Legal notice dated 17.11.2023 as Ex. PW1/7 (h) Postal receipts Ex. PW1/8 (colly) (i) Tracking reports obtained from official website of Indian Post as Ex.PW1/9 to Ex. PW1/12. 8. The testimony of the plaintiff goes unrebutted, unchallenged and uncontroverted, as there is no cross-examination of PW1 by any of the defendants. Hence, her testimony is deemed to be admitted by the defendants. Thus, all these documents stand proved on record. There is nothing on record to disbelieve the testimony of PW1, particularly when the same is supported by the documents placed and proved on record, more so when the defendants have not even filed their written statement. Suit No. 1385/2023 Aruna Gupta vs. M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co & Ors. Page No. 7/7 -- 6 of 7 -- 9. The suit is within the limitation. 10. The claim of interest @ 15 % p.a. is as per the documents Ex. PW1/1, Ex. PW1/5 (which bears the stamp of defendant no.1 firm) and Ex. PW1/6, and does not appear to be exhorbitant keeping in view that the loan amount was used by defendant no. 1 for commercial purposes. 11. In view of the above discussion, it is held that the plaintiff has successfully proved her case. Hence, the suit is allowed. A joint and several decree for Rs. 9,40,869/- with pendentalite and future interest @ 15% p.a. from the date of filing of the suit till realization with costs is hereby passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants. 12. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. 13. File be consigned to Record Room. Pronounced in the open court (RAKESH KUMAR SHARMA) on 9th March, 2026 District Judge-08 (Central), Extn. Block, Tis Hazari Courts New Delhi Suit No. 1385/2023 Aruna Gupta vs. M/s Nav Bharat Trading Co & Ors. Page No. 7/7 -- 7 of 7 --
