Full Order Text
Final Order 16 · 28 Jul 2025 · CNR DLCT010168412024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SHRI SANJAY GARG-I, PRINCIPAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE (CENTRAL) TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI. GP no. 17/2024 CNR No. DLCT01-016841-2024 1. Mrs. Ritu Sehgal W/o Lt. Sh. Kapil Arora 2. Master Nevin Arora S/o Lt. Sh. Kapil Arora Through his natural guardian Both R/o S-146, First floor, Greater Kailash, Defence Colony, New Delhi-110048 ......PETITIONERS VERSUS 1. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) Through Secretary National Capital Territory of Delhi. 2. Hemant Arora S/o Lt. Sh. OmPrakash Arora 3. Neelam Arora W/o Lt. Sh. OmPrakash Arora Both R/o 9108/2, Multani Dhanda, Paharganj, Swami Ram, Tirth Nagar, S.O Central Delhi Delhi-110055 .......RESPONDENTS GP No. 17/2024 Ritu Sehgal & Anr. vs. State & Ors. Page 1 of 7 -- 1 of 7 -- Date of filing :22.10.2024 Date of arguments :28.07.2025 Date of Decision :28.07.2025 J U D G M E N T 1. Petitioner no.1 has filed the present petition under Section 8(2) of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act,1956 for grant of permission to sale/dispose share of petitioner no.2/minor child namely Master Nevin Arora, s/o Late Sh. Kapil Arora in favour of mother namely Ritu Sehgal being natural guardian. 2. Upon institution of the petition, notice was published in Statesman as well as Veer Arjun newspapers inviting objections, if any, from general public but no objection was received. Statements of Sh. Hemant Arora (respondent no.2)/brother in law and Ms. Neelam Arora (respondent no.3)/mother in law of petitioner recorded wherein they had given their no objection to the relief sought by petitioner no.1. On directions, the concerned SDM also filed valuation report pertaining to following properties - (i) Ward No. XIV, 507, 510A, 510B, 511, 514 and basement part of shop no.511 which also exists under the shop no. 512 and open terrace on the first floor (erstwhile shop no. 506), western portion admeasuring 37’0” X 10’4” of Sadar Bazaar, Delhi-06. (ii) Half of 9108, Multani Dhanda, Munde Wala Road, Paharganj, New Delhi. (iii) 9109, Ward no.XV, Multani Dhanda, Munde Wala Road, Paharganj, New Delhi, area measuring 7’ X 9’ X 11” out of 14’ X 9’ X 11” . The valuation report given by concerned SDM in respect of property GP No. 17/2024 Ritu Sehgal & Anr. vs. State & Ors. Page 2 of 7 -- 2 of 7 -- mentioned at (i) is Rs.1,61,06,667/-; the valuation report regarding property mentioned at (ii) is Rs. 16,33,014/- and the valuation report regarding property mentioned at (iii) is Rs.12,31,409/-. 3. Brief facts of the case is that petitioner no.1 is the mother and natural guardian of minor son namely Master Nevin Arora born on 15.07.2008. Sh. Kapil Arora, husband of petitioner no.1 and father of minor had expired on 30.05.2021 due to Covid-19 leaving behind the petitioners and his mother namely Smt. Neelam Arora as his only Class-I surviving legal heirs. The minor son is studying in private school and on his study approx. Rs.15,000/- is being spent per month apart from other day to day needs. It is stated that Petitioner no.1, after the death of her husband joined the job at Pratham Institute as a freelancer but she is not earning much and is presently unable to maintain herself and petitioner no.2 from the income she is getting. Petitioner no.1 with the help of her brother in law is looking after the upbringing of petitioner no.2. 3.1 It is stated that Sh. Om Prakash Arora, father-in-law of the petitioner had acquired 50% rights in the undivided property bearing no.XIV, 506-514, Sadar Bazar, Delhi-06 admeasuring 93 sq. yds. from his brother Sat Pal Arora by virtue of registered sale deed on 20.04.1985. Father-in-law of petitioner no.1 had expired on 05.03.2021 leaving behind Ms. Neelam Arora (wife), Kapil Arora and Hemant Arora (both sons) as his Class I legal heirs. It is stated that regarding property bearing no. XIV, 506- 514, Sadar Bazaar, Delhi-06, admeasuring 93 sq. yds., there was a dispute between the legal heirs of Late sh. Om Prakash Arora, S/p Sh. Hansraj and legal heirs of Sh. Sat Pal Arora, s/o Sh. Hansraj. The said dispute got amicably settled between the parties before Hon’ble High Court vide settlement agreement dated 26.07.2024. Vide said settlement agreement, the GP No. 17/2024 Ritu Sehgal & Anr. vs. State & Ors. Page 3 of 7 -- 3 of 7 -- property mentioned at para no.2(i) shall vest exclusively, permanently with the legal heirs of Late Sh. Om Prakash Arora. The share of the minor in the said property comes out to be 1/9th as the properties belongs to his grandfather. 3.2 It is stated that on 20.04.1985, Late Sh. Om Prakash Arora acquired rights in the property bearing no. half of 9108 and 9109, Ward no.XV, Multani Dhanda, Munde Wala Road, Paharganj, New Delhi admeasuring 36.33 sq. yds. by Hans Raj, Bimla Rani, Smt. Usha Rani, Smt. Parveen and Sh. Sat Pal Arora by virtue of registered relinquishment deed. The share of the minor in the said property comes out to be 1/9th as the property belonged to his grandfather. 3.3 It is stated that Sh. Om Prakash Arora sold the property bearing no.9109, Ward no.XV, Multani Dhanda, Munde Wala Road, Paharganj, New Delhi. Thereafter, Kapil Arora, husband of petitioner no.1 again purchased the said property from Subhash Chander, S/o Sh. Ram Prakash at a consideration price of Rs.50,000/-. Then, Sh. Kapil Arora sold one shop out of property bearing no.9109 i.e. 9109A, Ward no.XV, Multani Dhanda, Munde Wala Road, Paharganj, New Delhi to his brother Sh. Hemant Arora at a consideration price of Rs.40,000/-. The share of the minor in the said property comes out to be 1/3rd as the property belonged to his father. 3.4 It is stated that for the sake of bright future and welfare of Master Nevin Arora, petitioner no.1 has decided to sell/relinquish her entire rights in the said properties in favour of her brother-in-law Sh. Hemant Arora and the consideration amount that petitioner no.1 will receive from selling/relinquishing her share as well as the share of the minor, it will be used for the welfare of the minor. It is stated that the sole purpose for filing GP No. 17/2024 Ritu Sehgal & Anr. vs. State & Ors. Page 4 of 7 -- 4 of 7 -- the present petition is the welfare, education and better future of the minor/petitioner no.2. 4. In order to substantiate the contents of the petition, the petitioner no.1 has examined herself as PW-1. In her examination-in-chief she tendered her affidavit as Ex. PW1/A. She reiterated the contents of the petition and proved on record documents viz. Ex. PW 1/1 copy of Aadhr Card of petitioner no.1; Ex.PW1/2 copy of Aadhar Card of petitioner no.2; Ex.PW1/3 copy of death certificate of Sh. Om Prakash Arora; Ex.PW1/4 copy of death certificate of Sh. Kapil Arora; Ex.PW1/5 copy of surviving certificate of Sh. Om Prakash Arora; Ex.PW1/6 copy of surviving certificate of Sh. Kapil Aora; Ex.PW1/7 copy of Relinquishment Deed dated 20.04.1985; Ex.PW1/8 copy of sale deed dated 12.09.2000; Ex.PW1/9 copy of sale deed dated 06.01.2006; Ex.PW1/10 copy of order dated 29.05.2024 passed by Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in RFA No. 185/2019 and 117/2019; Ex.PW1/11 copy of order dated 05.08.2024 passed by Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in RFA no.185/2019 and 117/2019 alongwith Annexure-A i.e. Settlement Agreement dated 26.07.2024; Ex.PW1/12 is the copy of common decree sheet dated 05.08.2024 in RFA no.185/2019 and 117/2019 and Ex.PW1/13 certificate/affidavit u/s 63 of BSA 2023. Thereafter, petitioner no.1 closed her evidence. 4.1 Petitioner no.1 has also led additional evidence by way of additional affidavit which is Ex.PW1/A1. She also placed reliance on documents viz- Ex.PW1/14 copy of sale deed dated 03.10.1969 of properties bearing no.half of 9108 and 9109, Ward no.XV, Multani Dhanda, Munde Wala Road, Paharganj, New Delhi executed in favour of Smt. Kaushalya, W/o Sh. Hansraj and Ex.PW1/15 copy of English Translation of GP No. 17/2024 Ritu Sehgal & Anr. vs. State & Ors. Page 5 of 7 -- 5 of 7 -- sale deed dated 03.10.1969. Thereafter, petitioner no.1 closed her evidence. 5. Heard arguments of Sh.Sachin Aggarwal, Ld. Counsel for the petitioner. I have gone through the record. 6. Ld. Counsel for the petitioner has submitted that petitioner no.1 being the natural guardian of the minor Master Nevin Arora, is the best person to take care of his betterment and welfare. Petitioner no.1 has no interest adverse to that of the minor. Petitioner undertakes that she will deposit the sale proceeds in the the form of FDR or any other better investment through which petitioners can earn some amount for the welfare, education and better future of the minor. Hence, the petition may be allowed and permission may be granted to the petitioner to sell/dispose of shares of the minor in the aforesaid properties (as mentioned in para 2 of this order). 7. The relationship of the petitioner as mother of minor child Nevin Arora is established by her unchallenged pleadings and testimony, corroborated by the documents placed on record by way of evidence. The petitioner being mother and natural guardian of the minor child would be the best person to take care of his betterment and welfare. Moreover, the petitioner has no interest adverse to that of the minor. 8. In view of above described pleadings and evidence, I have no doubt that it would be in the welfare of the minor to allow petitioner no.1, being mother and natural guardian of the minor, to sell his share in the aforesaid properties (as mentioned in para 2 of this order). 9. Considering the above circumstances, the petition is allowed, thereby permitting petitioner no.1 Ritu Sehgal to sell 1/9th each share [in properties as mentioned at para 2(i) and (ii)] and 1/3rd share [in property as mentioned at para 2(iii)] of minor namely Master Nevin Arora, DOB GP No. 17/2024 Ritu Sehgal & Anr. vs. State & Ors. Page 6 of 7 -- 6 of 7 -- 15.07.2008 at the best available market price, with the condition that minimum amount of the total sale proceeds of the properties sought to be sold, shall not be less than the value mentioned in the respective valuation reports filed by the SDM concerned. Also with the condition that share of minor out of the sale proceeds shall be kept by way of fixed deposit receipt(s) with some bank on his name under the guardianship of petitioner no.1 till the minor Nevin Arora, attain age of majority. The interest accruing on the fixed deposit shall be credited to the savings account of petitioner no.1 who shall spend the same only for the welfare of minor. 10. Petitioner no.1 shall submit copy of the said fixed deposit receipt(s) within one week of receiving the sale consideration. Necessary certificate be issued to the petitioner no.1 subject to furnishing the requisite undertaking/bond with one surety. 11. This order is not conferring any rights/title over the property to any one. 12. File be consigned to record room. Announced in the open court on this 28th Day of July, 2025 (SANJAY GARG-I) Principal District & Sessions Judge Central District, Tis Hazari Courts Delhi (D) GP No. 17/2024 Ritu Sehgal & Anr. vs. State & Ors. Page 7 of 7 -- 7 of 7 --
