Full Order Text
Order 8 · 03 Dec 2024 · CNR DLCT010159262023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: Misc DJ 729/2023 UOI vs. MCD & Anr. (Rashida Begum& Anr.) 03.12.2024 Present: None for UOI. Sh. Nipun Arora, Ld. Counsel for MCD/.I.P NO. 1. Ms. Dimple Dhamija, Ld. Counsel for I.P. NO.2 &3. At this stage, Ld. Counsel for IP no. 2&3 submits that the present claim pertains to the compensation as assessed by the LAC in respect of the superstructures of the properties which stood acquired vide main Award No. 12/LAC/N/12-13. It is further submitted by the Ld. Counsel that the compensation in respect of the super structures has been assessed vide a supplementary Award No. 12/LAC/C/17-18, which has been filed by the LAC in the case bearing No. LAC-19/21, titled as UOI vs. MCD & Others alongwith the details of the total compensation as well as the list of the properties in respect of which the compensation has been assessed. It has further been submitted that though a single Award has been passed in respect of the superstructures, but same being in respect of different properties, qua which the different claimants have been there and as such this Court vide its order dated 13.07.2023, directed that the different claims qua single property be segregated from the main case bearing no. LAC-19/21, titled as UOI vs. MCD & Others and be registered separately. It is further submitted that pursuant to the directions of this Court only, the present claim has been filed separately by the IP No. 2 & IP No. 3 in respect of property bearing no. 9070, Ist Floor, Rani Jhansi Road, Delhi, Page no.1 -- 1 of 3 -- which statedly is shown at Sl. No. 90 in the list of properties as filed by the LAC alongwith the supplementary award bearing no. 12/LAC/C/17-18. Ld. counsel for the MCD has also endorsed the said submissions in respect of supplementary Award bearing No12/LAC/C/17-18 which is the subject matter of the present claim petition having been filed in case bearing no. LAC-19/21, titled as UOI vs. MCD & Others. It is further submitted by the Ld. Counsel for the parties that the said case bearing no. LAC-19/21, titled as UOI vs. MCD & Others now only survives in respect of the claim of one Shafiq in respect of property bearing No. 9002, Rani Jhansi Road, Pul Bangash, Delhi, as claims qua the other properties stood separated from that case and subsequent to that new claims are being filed separately qua the superstructures of each property in respect of which compensation has been assessed by the supplementary award bearing no. 12/LAC/C/17-18. In view of the submissions of the Ld. Counsels for MCD and IP No. 2 & IP No. 3, this Court is of the considered opinion that for the proper adjudication of the present claim petition, the copy of the Supplementary Award no. 12/LAC/C/17-18 from the main case bearing no. LAC-19/21, titled as UOI vs. MCD & Others and also the copy of the order dt. 13.07.2023 is required to be seen by this Court. Accordingly, Ahlmad is directed to place the copies of the same and other relevant documents from the case no. LAC-19/2021 titled as UOI vs MCD & Others in the present case file by the next date of hearing. Page no.2 -- 2 of 3 -- At this stage, Ld. counsel for the IP No. 2 & IP No.3 submits that the IP No. 2 and IP No. 3 are the tenant and owner respectively in the property bearing no. 9070, Ist Floor, Rani Jhansi Road, Delhi and since there was no dispute among the IPs qua their status with respect to the suit property, the compensation qua the land in respect of the property in question has already been awarded in equal share to the IP No. 2 and IP No. 3 herein consequent upon the reference under Section 30-31 LA Act having been decided in their favour qua the Award No. 12/LAC/N/12-13 vide order of this court dated 22.12.2014. Ld. Counsel for IP No. 2 and IP No. 3 further submits that she has already filed the certified copy of the order dated 22.12.2014 and the memorandum filed alongwith the reference. She further contends that even in the said memorandum the compensation amount was shown to be awarded in equal shares of Rs.7,78,193.50/- each. Now to come up for further proceedings on 18.12.2024. (NEERAJ SHARMA) DJ-04, Central, THC, Delhi 03.12.2024. Page no.3 -- 3 of 3 --
