Full Order Text
Final Order 21 · 18 Dec 2024 · CNR DLCT010131392023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MR. ANIL KUMAR SISODIA: DISTRICT JUDGE (COMMERCIAL COURT)-04, CENTRAL, TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI CS (COMM)1260/2023 SH. RAKESH BANSAL S/o Late Sh. Suraj Bhan Bansal G-88, Ashok Vihar, Phase-I, Delhi-110052 ...PLAINTIFF Versus SH. CANARA BANK Through its Manager, Property No. 4062-4063, First Floor, Naya Bazar, Delhi-110006 ...DEFENDANT Date of filing of the suit : 22.09.2023 Date of reserving judgment : 07.12.2024 Date of judgment : 18.12.2024 Judgment 1. This is a suit for permanent injunction, possession and for damages, mesne profits and pendente lite and future interest filed by plaintiff against defendant. 2. Briefly stated, facts of the case are that the plaintiff is owner and landlord of the first floor of the premises situated at property no. 4062-4063, First floor, Naya Bazar, area admeasuring 2,160/- sq. ft. (hereinafter referred to as “suit property”) to the extent of 11% undivided share in the suit CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 1 of 23 -- 1 of 23 -- property. It is further stated that the plaintiff is the owner to the extent of 69% share in the premises situated at ground floor of property no. 4062-4063, First floor, Naya Bazar, out of total area admeasuring 2160 sq. mtr by virtue of settlement which took place in CS (OS) No. 1556/2000 in case titled as Shri Subhash Chand & Ors. Vs Shri Jagdish Prasad Gupta & Ors., vide order dated 07.01.2005. 3. It is stated that defendant had approached the plaintiff for lease of the suit premises for running the aforesaid bank namely Canara Bank. The defendant was inducted as a tenant vide lease agreement dated 01.04.2013 at a monthly rent of Rs. 2,14,436/- and the defendant has been in possession of the suit premises wherein the plaintiff is owner to the extent of 11% undivided share. The total area of premises situated at first floor is 2,160 sq. ft out of which the defendant bank has been in occupation and possession of the premises as a tenant of a built up area admeasuring 1,860 sq. ft since the year 2013 by virtue of lease deed dated 01.04.2013 for which the monthly rent of Rs. 2,14,436/- has been tendered by the defendant. 4. It is further stated that the tenancy was for a period of 10 years commencing from 01.04.2013 to 31.03.2023. Defendant had assured to vacate the premises as and when required by plaintiff. Defendant is tendering the rent even after the determination of the lease deed dated 01.04.2013, thereby creating a month to month tenancy starting from the first day of CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 2 of 23 -- 2 of 23 -- each month of the English calender to the last day of the month. It is stated that after the expiry of lease deed in April, 2023 plaintiff asked the defendant to vacate the suit property but defendant continued to tender the rent and remained in exclusive possession of the tenanted premises. Plaintiff gave sufficient time of four months to the defendant to shift the bank to another property or location, however, defendant failed to adhere to the time lines and further requested for some more time to find out for an alternative location. Plaintiff through his counsel had served the defendant with a legal notice dated 31.07.2023 to vacate the suit property. However, defendant has not made an attempt to neither vacate the said property nor to reply to the legal notice. Finding no other alternative, the plaintiffs filed the present suit against the defendant. 5. The defendant was duly served with the summons of the suit. Defendant has contested the suit by filing the written statement. Defendant has raised preliminary objections that the the suit is misconceived and malafide. The plaintiff has not approached the court with clean hands and is not entitled to any relief. The plaintiff has no locus standi to file the present suit against the defendant as he is not the absolute owner of the lease property. Under the garb of the present suit, plaintiff wants to extort money from the defendant bank on the basis of false and baseless allegations. The present suit is also not maintainable and deserves to be dismissed for want to misjoinder and non-joinder of necessary parties to the present suit. It is stated that the suit CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 3 of 23 -- 3 of 23 -- property belongs to the plaintiff and his ten brothers and all the eleven joint owners of the suit property have made and executed the lease deed in favour of defendant bank. The lease has been commenced since the year 2013 for the period of 10 years and the same has been extended for the subsequent period since 2023 and other ten brothers of plaintiff have also agreed to extend the said lease for the subsequent period from 2023 but the plaintiff who is having 1/11th share in the said property, unnecessarily creating hindrance and obstruction with the view to extort money from the defendant bank. The defendant bank had invested huge amount for proper functioning of the bank business and defendant had never violated the terms and conditions of the lease at any point of time. On merits, the contents of the plaint have been denied. It is stated that the plaintiff is not the sole and absolute owner of the suit property as the suit property belongs to plaintiff and his ten brothers who are joint owners of the suit property. It is further stated that the other ten brothers of the plaintiff have agreed to extend the lease for the period subsequent to 2023 but only the plaintiff has been creating unnecessary hindrance and obstructions with a view to extort money. Plaintiff has no right to ask the defendant to vacate the suit property. The defendant has denied the service of legal notice upon the bank and in the alternative, it has been submitted that the said notice has no value in the eyes of law. It was denied that defendant bank is in illegal and unlawful possession of the suit property. Other contents of the plaint have been denied and a prayer has been made for CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 4 of 23 -- 4 of 23 -- dismissal of the suit. 6. Plaintiff filed replication denying the contents of WS and reiterated that the facts as stated in the plaint and has denied the facts contrary to it. 7. On the basis of pleadings of the parties, following issues were framed on 26.02.2024: - (i)Whether the suit of the plaintiff is bad for mis-joinder and non- joinder of necessary parties? OPD. (ii)Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the decree for possession, as prayed for? OPP. (iii) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for decree of permanent injunction, as prayed for? OPP. (iv) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for damages and mesne profits, if so, at what rate and for which period? OPP. (v) Relief. 8. The plaintiff examined himself as PW-1 and has tendered his affidavit as Ex PW1/A and proved the following documents: - Sr No Documents Exhibits 1 Sale deed dated 30.10.1992 alongwith Aadhar Card Ex.PW1/A and Ex.PW1/B 2 True copy of order dated 07.01.2005 alongwith application and site plan with share allotment of each Mark PW1/C (colly) CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 5 of 23 -- 5 of 23 -- respective owner 3 Legal notice dated 31.07.2023 and postal receipts and delivery proof Ex.PW1/D PW-1 was cross examined by the counsel for defendant. Thereafter, PE was closed. 9. Defendant examined Sh. Dinesh Joshi, Manager/Authorized officer of plaintiff as DW-1 who has tendered his affidavit as Ex PW-1/A. DW-1 was cross examined by counsel for plaintiff and thereafter, DE was closed. 10. I have heard Ld. Counsel for plaintiff and have perused the written submissions filed by Ld. Counsel for defendant. I have also perused the record carefully. 11. Issue wise findings on the basis of evidence and arguments are as under: - ISSUE No. 1: “Whether the suit of the plaintiff is bad for mis-joinder and non- joinder of necessary parties? OPD.” 12. The onus of proving this issue was placed on the defendant. In its WS defendant has taken a defence that plaintiff has no locus standi to file the present suit as he is not the sole and absolute owner of the suit property. It has further been stated that the suit of the plaintiff is liable to be dismissed for the misjoinder and non-joinder of other ten co-owners who have CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 6 of 23 -- 6 of 23 -- executed the lease deed in favour of the defendant bank. The plaintiff is only having 1/11th share in the suit property. In the absence of other co-owners being impleaded as co-plaintiffs or co-defendants, the suit filed by the plaintiff alone is not maintainable. 13. Per Contra, counsel for plaintiff has argued that the plaintiff is having 11% undivided share in the suit property along with the co-owners whereas defendant is a tenant in the suit property. It was argued that defendant cannot challenge the title of the plaintiff and cannot dictate as to how the plaintiff should manage his property. It was argued that the co-owner of an undivided property is owner of every portion of the said property. He further argued that it is not necessary that all the co-owners must join the eviction petition and even a single co-owner can file suit for eviction of a tenant in the property. The tenant cannot insist for the joining of all the co-owners in the eviction proceedings. Counsel for the plaintiff has also placed reliance on the following judgments in support of his arguments:- (i) Mohinder Prasad Jain Vs Manohar Lal Jain, AIR 2006 SC 1471; (ii)India Umbrella Manufacturing Company & Anr. Vs Bhagabandei Agrawalla (Dead) by LRs Savitri Agrawalla & Ors., (2004) 3 SCC 178; (iii)Yashpal Vs Chamanlal Sachdeva, 129 (2006) DLT 200; (iv)Sri Ram Pasricha Vs Jagannath & Ors., (1976) 4 SCC 184. 14. Perusal of the record shows that PW-1 has placed on record sale deed dated 30.10.1992 Ex. PW-1/A which shows that 11% undivided share in the suit property was purchased by the CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 7 of 23 -- 7 of 23 -- plaintiff from one Raj Kumar s/o Sh. Chandu Lal vide registered sale deed. Plaintiff has also filed certified copy of application u/O 23 Rule 3 CPC in suit no. 1556/2000 titled as Subhash Chand & ors. Vs Jagdish Prasad Gupta & Ors which also confirms that plaintiff is having 11% undivided share in the suit property by virtue of settlement and order of the court dated 07.01.2005. Further, perusal of testimony of DW-1 Dinesh Joshi shows that plaintiff is one of the landlords in the suit property. Defendant in its WS has also nowhere disputed this fact that plaintiff is owner of 11% undivided share in the suit property. 15. Law is well settled that a co-owner of an undivided property is the owner of every part of the property and his ownership is not confined to any particular portion of the property. It is also well settled principle of law that a co-owner can file a suit for eviction against the tenant and the tenant cannot resist the suit on the ground that he has not impleaded other co- owners in the ejectment proceedings. In Mohinder Prasad Jain Vs Manohar lal Jain (supra), Hon’ble Supreme Court relying upon the judgment of India Umbrella Manufacturing Company (supra) has held that one of the co-owner can file a suit for eviction of a tenant in the property generally owned by the co- owners. This principle is based on the doctrine of agency. One co-owner filing a suit for eviction against the tenant does so on his own behalf in his own right and as an agent of the other co- owners. The consent of other co-owners is assumed as taken unless it is shown that the other co-owners were not agreeable to CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 8 of 23 -- 8 of 23 -- the eject the tenant and the suit was filed inspite of their disagreement. Hon’ble High court of Delhi in the case of Yashpal Vs Chamanlal Sachdeva (supra) has also held that the tenant cannot insist on all the co-owners to join the eviction proceedings. It is not open to the tenant to insist that all co- owners be made a party to the petition, for this part is left to the co-owners themselves who may join the petition, if they wish to; support or oppose the tenant. 16. In the present suit, nothing has come on record that the other co-owners have opposed the filing of the suit by the plaintiff for ejectment of the defendant. Even though, defendant has claimed in WS that other ten co-owners have agreed to renew the lease for the subsequent period from 2023 but no documentary evidence to this effect has been placed on record, nor defendant has examined any of the co-owners to establish that they have agreed to renew the lease after 2023. In the absence of any such evidence on record, the consent of the other co-owners in favour of the plaintiff to file the suit is taken as assumed and plaintiff being a co-owner can file a suit for ejectment against the defendant who is a tenant in the suit property and there is no requirement of joining of other co- owners in the suit. 17. In view of the aforesaid discussion, I am of the considered opinion that the defendant has failed to discharge the onus cast CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 9 of 23 -- 9 of 23 -- on it. The issue is accordingly decided in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant. ISSUE NO. 2: “Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the decree for possession, as prayed for? OPP.” 18. The onus of proving this issue was placed on the plaintiff. The plaintiff has filed the present suit claiming that he is co- owner of 11% undivided share in the suit property. The defendant was let out the suit property for a period of ten years vide lease deed 01.04.2013 which expired on 31.03.2023. Even after the determination of the lease deed, defendant continued to pay the rent and assured to vacate the suit property as and when required by the plaintiff and thus, a month to month tenancy was created starting first day of each English Calender Month to last day of the month. It was further stated that the plaintiff served a legal notice dated 31.07.2023 on the defendant through his counsel but defendant did not vacate the suit property and has become unauthorized and illegal occupant w.e.f 01.09.2023. 19. Defendant bank in its WS has not disputed the fact that suit property was let out to the defendant on lease for a period of 10 years since 2013. However, defendant has taken a defence that the lease was extended by ten other co-owners for the subsequent period from 2023 but only the plaintiff is unnecessarily creating hue hindrance and obstructions with a view to extort money from the defendant bank. Defendant also denied the service of legal CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 10 of 23 -- 10 of 23 -- notice and stated that no notice was ever served on the defendant and even otherwise the notice has no value in the eyes of law as plaintiff had no right to demand possession. The defendant also denied that it is in unauthorized and illegal possession of the suit property. 20. Counsel for plaintiff has argued that defendant has not denied the fact that plaintiff is the co-owner of the suit property. It is also admitted by the defendant that defendant bank was inducted as a tenant for a period of ten years vide lease deed in the year 2013 and the said lease deed had expired on 31.03.2023 by efflux of time. He further argued that PW-1 Rakesh Bansal has proved on record the legal notice dated 31.07.2023 as Ex.PW-1/D along with original postal receipt and the tracking report of the postal department which shows that the legal notice was delivered to the defendant on 01.08.2023. He further argued that the plaintiff being a co-owner can file a suit for eviction of the tenant. Defendant has not been able to show that other co- owners are opposed to the eviction of the defendant or that they had agreed to renew the lease after 2023. Hence, the plaintiff is entitled for recovery of the possession of the suit property. 21. Defendant in its written arguments has opposed the suit of the plaintiff on the ground that plaintiff has no locus standi to file the present suit in the absence of other co-owners of the suit property. It was also submitted that the other co-owners had agreed to extend the lease for subsequent period from 2023. CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 11 of 23 -- 11 of 23 -- Defendant bank had invested huge amount for proper functioning of the banking business from the suit property as per the consent and permission of the plaintiff and other co-owners and defendant has never violated the terms and conditions of the lease deed. 22. In support of his case, plaintiff has examined himself as PW-1 and reiterated the facts stated in the plaint. He has also proved on record the sale deed dated 30.10.1992 as Ex.PW-1/A and copy of order dated 07.01.2005 as Mark PW-1/C to prove his undivided share in the suit property. He has also proved on record the legal notice dated 31.07.2023 along with original postal receipts and tracking report. In the cross examination, PW-1 has admitted that the suit property was let out to the defendant through registered lease deed which has expired on 31.03.2023. He has also deposed that there is no dispute between the co-owners. He further admitted that defendant used to deposit the rent in the bank account of the co-owners as per their shares. He further stated that defendant bank is still depositing the rent in the bank accounts of the co-owners after the expiry of lease but the lease deed has not been renewed. 23. On the other hand, defendant bank examined its Manager Dinesh Joshi as DW-1. In the cross examination, DW-1 admitted that the previous lease was upto 31.03.2023. He volunteered that the lease deed has been renewed upto 2028 but admitted that renewed lease deed has not been filed along with the WS or CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 12 of 23 -- 12 of 23 -- affidavit by way of evidence. He also admitted that plaintiff is one of the landlords and the bank used to pay rent to him. He also admitted that the rent has been paid to the plaintiff even after the issuance of legal notice by the plaintiff. He denied the suggestion that defendant bank has become unauthorized occupant after the termination of tenancy by the plaintiff. 24. From the pleadings and evidence of the parties, the following facts are established: - (i) Plaintiff is the co-owner and landlord of the defendant bank; (ii) Defendant was inducted as a tenant in the suit property by virtue of registered lease deed for a period of ten years which expired on 31.03.2023; (iii)The monthly rate of rent for the suit property was Rs. 2,14,436/- and therefore, the suit property is not governed by Delhi Rent Control Act; (iv)Legal notice dated 31.07.2023 terminating the tenancy of the defendant was served upon the defendant. 25. Chapter V of The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 deals with the provisions of leases of immovable property. Section 111 provides for determination of lease. Clause (a) of Section 111 states that a lease of immovable property determines by the efflux of the time limited thereby and Clause (h) of Section 111 provides that a lease of immovable property determines on expiration of a notice to determine the lease, or to quit or of intention to quit, the property lease, duly governed by one party CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 13 of 23 -- 13 of 23 -- to the other. In the present case, the tenancy of the defendant was determined after the expiry of the registered lease deed on 31.03.2023. Further, the tenancy was also determined by the service of legal notice dated 31.07.2023 Ex.PW-1/D by the plaintiff upon the defendant bank. 26. The defendant has submitted in the written arguments that it had been paying the rent to the plaintiff and other co-owners even after the termination of the lease deed and even after the issuance of legal notice by the plaintiff till March, 2024 in the bank account of the plaintiff and other co-owners. Although, defendant has taken a stand that other co-owners except the plaintiff have agreed to renew the tenancy but defendant bank has not proved this fact on record. Neither any renewed lease deed has been placed on record nor other co-owners have been examined by the defendant bank to establish that they had agreed to renew the lease of the suit property in favour of the plaintiff. 27. The law is well settled that mere payment of money described as 'rent' would not by itself suffice to create relationship of landlord-tenant. The parties must be ad-idem on the point of creation of fresh tenancy. For creation of a fresh transfer of interest, it is necessary that there must have been a fresh contract between the parties. Mere payment of money described as 'rent' may only prove permissive occupation not amounting to any right or title to possession. In Delhi Jal Board Vs. Surendra P. Malik, (2003) 104 DLT 151 it was held that CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 14 of 23 -- 14 of 23 -- mere acceptance of 'rent', after expiry of the tenancy cannot renew or create fresh tenancy. Further, Apex Court in Sheodhari Rai and Ors. Vs. Suraj Prasad Singh and Ors., AIR 1954 SC 758 held that mere payment of 'rent' as evidenced by 'rent receipts' would not necessarily establish relationship of landlord and tenant and further that such payment of money may only prove permissive occupation not amounting to any right or title to possession. 28. Hence, in the absence of any material on record, I am of the considered opinion that defendant has not been able to prove that other co-owners had agreed to renew the lease of the suit property in favour of the defendant. At the most, defendant is in permissive occupation of the suit property nor amounting to any right or title to possession. 29. Perusal of the record also shows that the suit property is situated at Naya Bazar, Delhi which is part of walled city and is covered under the Slum Areas Act. However, none of the parties had raised this issue before the court in their pleadings or during trial. Section 19 (i) (a) bars the institution of any suit or proceedings for obtaining any decree or order for the eviction of a tenant from any building or land in a slum area except with the previous permission in writing of the competent authority. Hence, in order to satisfy the judicial conscience and to make sure that jurisdiction of this court is not barred under Section 19 of Slum Areas (Improvement and Clearance Act), 1956 a notice CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 15 of 23 -- 15 of 23 -- was issued to the concerned authority seeking status report whether the suit property is covered under notified Slum area or not. 30. In response to the notice issued by the court, a status report dated 01.11.2024 was filed by the Delhi Urban Shelter and Improvement Board through its Deputy Director stating that as per the available record/list, in property section DUSIB, the aforesaid property does not exist in the list of transferred properties from MoR to erstwhile Slum & JJ Department (now DUSIB). It is also informed that no record exists to confirm that the said property is situated in a notified slum or not under Section 3 of the Slum Areas (Improvement and Clearance) Act, 1956. On 20.11.2024 proxy counsel for DUSIB also appeared and submitted that a copy of plaint is required to ascertain whether the property falls within the notified slum area or not. On the request of proxy counsel for DUSIB soft copy of plaint was supplied to the counsel for DUSIB. Another status report dated 27.11.2024 was filed by Deputy Director (Survey) on behalf of DUSIB stating that the suit property falls within the Slum Notified Area under Section 3 of Slum Areas (Improvement & Clearance) Act, 1956, vide Gazette Notification No. SRO 1252 dated 10.04.1957. 31. Copy of the status report were supplied to counsel for plaintiff and defendant and further arguments were heard on CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 16 of 23 -- 16 of 23 -- behalf of counsel for plaintiff whereas counsel for defendant adopted the previous arguments advanced by him. 32. Counsel for the plaintiff has argued that the two status report filed by the DUSIB are contradictory to each other and cannot be relied upon. He further argued that since defendant bank has not raised the defence that suit property is situated in slum area, the defence is said to have been waived by the defendant. He further argued that the defendant is a bank within the definition of Companies Act and not a person and therefore, protection under Section 19 of Slum Areas Act, cannot be given to the defendant. Ld. counsel for plaintiff also placed reliance on the following judgments in support of his arguments:- (i)Chiraguddin Vs Urmila Rani & Ors., 213 (2014) DLT 699 wherein Hon’ble High Court observed in para 11 that: ‘It is an extremely important aspect to note that ‘Slum Area’ is now only a mere nomenclature because really there are no slum and there is no slum area except that an area in the old Delhi, popularly known as walled city of Delhi, has been categorized a ‘slum area’ under the Slum Act although in fact and reality the entire walled city of Delhi/old Delhi is a totally built up area and therein exist sum of the most valuable immovable properties; both commercially and residential; in Delhi. Actually Slum Act was passed in the year 1956 as per the situation then prevailing but today in the year 2014 really there are no slum but only huge costly buildings both commercial and residential, though technically they continue to be labeled as a ‘slum area’. ” (ii) Dimple (P) Ltd. Vs Harish Kumar Aggarwal & Anr., 71 (1998) DLT 318 wherein Hon’ble High Court in para 35 of the CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 17 of 23 -- 17 of 23 -- judgment observed as under: “I am also tempted to cite the observations of a Single Judge of this Court as reported in Bismilla Jan v. Jain Tractors & Auto Spare, 1885 Rajdhani Law Reporter 477, (para 13)…….” The Slum Act was enacted for giving protection to poor individual tenants who have small means and cannot afford to get alternate accommodation outside the slum area or within the slum if evicted. If a couple of persons with substantial means float a company which goes into loss, even if they are evicted from the premises, they cannot create slums, particularly when the same persons own other concerns which also have offices at different places.” (iii) Virender Singh Vs State Bank of India, 185 (2011) DLT 407 (DB) wherein Hon’ble High Court in para 25 of the judgment observed as under: “The respondent State Bank of India is the largest bank having thousands of branches all over the country. The object of the Slum Act could never be to protect such giant juristic entities to claim protection under the Act. It continued to occupy the tenanted premises after tenancy was determined and its status was that of an unauthorized occupant and thus damages have to be paid.” 33. I have heard counsel for plaintiff and have carefully perused the judgments relied upon by him. A careful perusal of the aforesaid judgments show that they are of no help to the plaintiff in the case of Chiraguddin (supra) the issue involved was whether the right created under Section 19 of the Slum Areas Act, 1956 can be waived or not. Hon’ble High Court after considering the judgments of Albein Plywood Ltd. & Anr. Vs Janak Kapoor and Ors. 50 (1993) DLT 228; Mohd. Usman & CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 18 of 23 -- 18 of 23 -- Ors. Vs Mohd. Siddique and Anr, Civil (Appeal) No. 1906/1987 and Pooran Chand Vs Nathu @ Nathauli & Ors., SAO No. 60/1970 held that it is now well settled that the language of Section 19 completely bars initiation of eviction proceedings without obtaining necessary permission from the competent authority under the Slum Areas Act. Hence, the question of waiver of right by the petitioner does not arise at all as principle of estoppel will not apply against the statute. 34. Similarly, the judgment of Hon’ble Division Bench of Delhi High Court in Virender Singh Vs SBI (supra), after considering the provisions of Slum Areas Act held that the object of the Slum Act could never be to protect giant juristic entities like SBI. However, in the said case in para 22 it was observed that under Section 37 of the Slum Act, the jurisdiction of a civil court is barred only in so far as it relates to ejectment of an occupier and no more and the respondent bank was held liable for damages. Therefore, even this judgment does not come to the rescue of the plaintiff who has filed the present suit for ejectment of defendant without seeking permission of the competent authority under Section 19 of the Slum Areas Act. 35. Perusal of the judgment of Dimple (P) Ltd. Vs Harish Kumar Aggarwal (supra) also shows that even though it was held that petitioner in the said case was a company and the juristic person and was not entitled for protection under the Slum Areas CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 19 of 23 -- 19 of 23 -- Act, this judgment nowhere says that the provisions of Section 19 can be by-passed or waived. 36. Perusal of provisions of Section 19 of Slum Areas Act,1956 show that it has been given overriding effect on provisions of any other law. In case titled as “Harish Chander Malik Vs Vivek Kumar Gupta & Ors., 186(2012) DLT 697' Hon'ble High Court of Delhi considered scope of Section 19 of Slum Areas Act and held that Slums Act makes no distinction between premises fetching rent above Rs.3500/- and those fetching rent below Rs. 3500/-. Language of Section 19 of Slum Areas Act,1956 is plain in itself and has an overriding effect over any other law. 37. In view of the aforesaid discussion, I am of the considered opinion that in the absence of permission from the competent authority under Section 19 of Slum Areas (Improvement & Clearance) Act, 1956 no decree or order of eviction of the defendant from the suit property which is situated in Slum Area can be passed and the said permission is mandatory and a pre- requisite for initiating ejectment proceedings against the defendant. Accordingly, the issue is decided in favour of the defendant and against the plaintiff. ISSUE NO. 3: “Whether the plaintiff is entitled for decree of permanent injunction, as prayed for? OPP.” CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 20 of 23 -- 20 of 23 -- 38. The onus of proving this issue has been placed on the plaintiff. The plaintiff has prayed for a decree of permanent injunction for restraining the defendant from further entering into any lease deed of the suit property belonging to the plaintiff. Counsel for plaintiff has argued that the plaintiff is a co-owner of the suit property along with ten other co-owners. The plaintiff is having 11% undivided share in the suit property and defendant should be restrained from entering into any lease deed of the suit property. 39. The plaintiff has not led any evidence in respect of the aforesaid relief claimed by him. Even otherwise, plaintiff is only co-owner of 11% undivided share in the suit property. Restraining the defendant from entering into fresh lease deed in respect of the suit property with the other co-owners, will amount to denying the other co-owners (who are having majority share in the suit property) to enjoy the suit property freely as per their choice. Hence, I am not inclined to grant the relief of permanent injunction in favour of the plaintiff as it would not only infringe the rights of the other co-owners but would also be inequitable as it would amount to dictating terms to the other co-owners as to how they should use the suit property. The issue is accordingly decided in favour of the defendant and against the plaintiff. ISSUE NO. 4: “Whether the plaintiff is entitled for damages and mesne profits, if so, at what rate and for which period? OPP.” CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 21 of 23 -- 21 of 23 -- 40. The onus of proving this issue has been placed on the plaintiff. The plaintiff has claimed decree of damages/mesne profits @ Rs. 83 per sq. ft. w.e.f. 01.09.2023. 41. DW-1 Dinesh Joshi, Manager of the defendant bank has admitted that the defendant bank has been paying rent to the plaintiff @ Rs. 83 per sq. ft. and the rent has already been paid upto March, 2024. In view of the admission by DW-1 that defendant bank is already paying the rent to the plaintiff @ Rs. 83 per sq. ft., the issue is decided in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant. The defendant is directed to continue to pay the rent /damages to all the co-owners of the suit property including the plaintiff @ Rs. 83 per sq. ft. per month from April, 2024 on or before the 10th of each Calender Month till it remains in possession of the suit property. The issue is accordingly decided in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant. RELIEF: 42. In view of my findings on the issues hereinabove, suit of the plaintiff is partly decreed. The suit is dismissed qua the relief of possession and permanent injunction of the suit property i.e. first floor of the premises situated at property no. 4062-4063, First floor, Naya Bazar, area admeasuring 2,160/- sq. ft. The suit of the plaintiff is decreed for the relief of damages and mesne profits and the defendant is directed to pay the rent /damages to all the co-owners of the suit property including the plaintiff @ Rs. 83 per sq. ft. per month from April, 2024 on or CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 22 of 23 -- 22 of 23 -- before the 10th of each Calender Month till it remains in possession of the suit property. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. File be consigned to record room after due compliance. Announced in the open Court (ANIL KUMAR SISODIA) Dated : 18th December, 2024 District Judge (Commercial Court-04) Central District, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi CS (COMM) No. 1260/2023 Sh. Rakesh Bansal Vs Canara Bank Page No. 23 of 23 -- 23 of 23 --
