Full Order Text
Final Order 4 · 18 Dec 2023 · CNR DLCT010128042023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-05, CENTRAL DISTRICT, TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI CNR no. DLCT01-012804-2023 CA225/2023 Sudhir Sharma S/o Shri Dalel Sharma Presently Residing At Mata Tilla Road, Aradhay Sadan, Near Sankatmochan Hanuman Mandir, Tal Behet, Village Lalitpur, Uttar Pradesh-284125 …..Appellant Vs. Smt Savita Sharma W/o Shri Sudhir Sharma, D/o Sh. Kanhiya Lal Sharma, R/o House K-67, Gali No. 4, Delhi-110084 …...Respondent Date of institution :15.09.2023 Date of conclusion of arguments :18.11.2023 Date of order :18.12.2023 ORDER 1. Vide this order, I shall dispose off the present appeal u/s 29 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 against the orders dated 18.07.2023 passed by ld. MM-03(Mahila Court), Central District, THC, Delhi in complaint case no. 116/2021 titled as Savita Sharma Vs. Sudhir Sharma. The appellant before this court was the respondent no. 1 before the ld. Trial court and the respondent before this court was the complainant before the ld. Trial court. 2. The respondent/wife filed the complaint case u/s 12 of the DV Act and vide orders dated 18.07.2023, the ld. MM directed the appellant/ husband to pay the monthly maintenance of Rs. CA225/2023 Sudhir Sharma Vs. Smt Savita Sharma Page no. 1 of 6 -- 1 of 6 -- 20,000/- to the complainant for all ancillary purposes including medical expenses, food, clothing and residence/ rent from the date of filing of the petition before the ld. Trial court till the disposal thereof. 3. The facts in brief necessary for the disposal of the above said appeal are that the marriage in between the appellant/ husband and the respondent/ wife was solemnized on 18.04.2014. The respondent/ wife alleged that the appellant/ husband was earning Rs. 80,000/- per month and he was not having any other liabilities and therefore, it was prayed that the amount of Rs. 40,000/- per month be awarded as interim maintenance. 4. As per the income affidavit filed by the respondent/ wife before the ld. Trial court, she was a post graduate, residing in a rented accommodation at K-67, Gali no. 4, village Wazirabad, Delhi. The respondent further disclosed in her income affidavit that she had filed the petition u/s 125 of the Cr.P.C. before Family Courts, Saket, New Delhi and that her monthly expenses were Rs. 30,000/- per month. 5. In the income affidavit which was filed by the appellant/ husband, it was disclosed that he was MA, B. Ed(Mathematics) and he was working as a Primary Teacher with Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan. As per the own admission of the appellant, his monthly salary was Rs. 67,000/- per month. However, in his income affidavit, the appellant/ husband disclosed that his father aged about 65 years and his mother aged about 60 years were CA225/2023 Sudhir Sharma Vs. Smt Savita Sharma Page no. 2 of 6 -- 2 of 6 -- dependent upon him and that he had to incur a sum of Rs. 8,000/- per month on his mother and father. 6. Admittedly, the ld. Judge, Family court, Central District, THC, Delhi vide orders dated 10.02.2023, in the petition u/s 125 of the Cr.P.C. instituted by the respondent/ wife granted the interim maintenance of Rs. 13,000/- per month to the respondent/ wife by holding therein that the net income of the husband was Rs. 67,800/- per month and that he had to support his mother and father. 7. Subsequently, in the present petition u/s 12 of the DV Act, the ld. MM while disposing off the application u/s 23(2) DV Act granted the interim maintenance of Rs. 20,000/- per month to the respondent/ wife. 8. Now, the appellant has assailed the orders dated 18.07.2023 passed by the ld. MM on the ground that the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in Criminal Revision petition no. 633/2010, Cr. MA no. 15757/2010 titled as Renu Mittal Vs. Anil Mittal and Anr. has held that the jurisdiction under Domestic Violence Act is a parallel jurisdiction and if maintenance has been granted u/s 125 of the Cr.P.C., then, the Metropolitan Magistrate under DV Act is not supposed to adjudicate the matter of maintenance. It has been further stated that law does not warrant that two parallel courts should adjudicate same issue separately. 9. Relying upon the ratio of the above said judgment in the matter titled as Renu Mittal Vs. Anil Mittal and Anr., it has been argued that once the ld. Judge, Family Court, had already granted the CA225/2023 Sudhir Sharma Vs. Smt Savita Sharma Page no. 3 of 6 -- 3 of 6 -- maintenance @ Rs. 13,000/- per month, then, it was not open for the ld. Trial court to direct the maintenance @ Rs. 20,000/- per month under the provisions of the DV Act. It has been further argued that the respondent/ wife left the company of the appellant voluntarily. It has been further argued that the orders dated 18.07.2023 have been wrongly passed by the ld. Trial court. It has been prayed that the orders dated 18.07.2023 be set aside. 10. I have carefully gone through the entire material available on record and heard the rival submissions of both the ld. Counsels for the parties. 11. The first and foremost submission of the appellant is that the ld. Trial court failed to consider the ratio of the judgment passed in the matter titled as Renu Mittal Vs. Anil Mittal and Anr.. 12. It is true that the ld. MM in the orders dated 18.07.2023 has not stated anything about the above said judgment in the matter titled as Renu Mittal Vs. Anil Mittal and Anr. but I am of the opinion that the above said submission of the appellant does not hold much water and the answer to the above said submission has already been given by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the matter titled as Rajnesh Vs. Neha and Anr. A perusal of the above said judgment titled as Rajnesh Vs. Neha and Anr. Reveals that the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has dealt with the issue of overlapping jurisdiction and it has been directed that in a subsequent maintenance proceeding, the applicant shall disclose the subsequent maintenance proceeding and the court would take CA225/2023 Sudhir Sharma Vs. Smt Savita Sharma Page no. 4 of 6 -- 4 of 6 -- into consideration the maintenance already awarded in the previous proceeding. 13. However, admittedly, the salary of the appellant/ husband is Rs. 67,800/- per month as has been held by the ld. Judge, Family Court and by the ld. MM as well. The ld. Judge, Family court, in the orders dated 10.02.2023, has categorically held that the appellant/ husband has to support his father and mother who are dependent upon him and as such, has awarded the maintenance @ Rs. 13,000/- per month. The ld. MM in the orders dated 18.07.2023, to my mind, has not dealt with the above said aspect of the matter to the effect that the mother and father of the appellant/ husband are dependent upon him. As such, to my mind, after dividing the salary of the appellant/ husband in accordance with the ratio of the judgment Anurita Vohra Vs. Sandeep Vohra cited as 110 (2004) DLT 546, to my mind, the approach adopted by the ld. Judge, Family courts, appears to be more reasonable and balancing, in the given facts and circumstances. Accordingly, the orders dated 18.07.2023 passed by the ld. MM are modified to the effect that the appellant/ husband shall pay the interim maintenance @ Rs. 13,000/- per month to the respondent/ wife in terms of the orders dated 18.07.2023 passed by the ld. Trial court. The rest of the terms and conditions of the orders dated 18.07.2023 shall remain the same. Thus, the present appeal, stands partly allowed. CA225/2023 Sudhir Sharma Vs. Smt Savita Sharma Page no. 5 of 6 -- 5 of 6 -- 14. File of the present appeal be consigned to Record room, after necessary compliance. TCR be sent back to the ld. Trial court along with a copy of this order. Announced in the Open Court (Order contains 6 pages) (Raj Kumar) ASJ-05, Central District Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi 18.12.2023 CA225/2023 Sudhir Sharma Vs. Smt Savita Sharma Page no. 6 of 6 -- 6 of 6 --
