Full Order Text
Order 3 · 17 Sept 2026 · CNR DLCT010122502026
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS DJ No. 684/2026 Mahesh Kumar & Anr. Vs. Purushotam Prashad & Ors. Page 1 of 9 IN THE COURT OF MS. SHEFALI BARNALA TANDON, DISTRICT JUDGE-04, CENTRAL DISTRICT, TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI CS DJ No. 684/2026 CNR No. DLCT01-012250-2026 Mahesh Kumar & Anr. … Plaintiff Versus Purushottam Prashad … Defendant 17.09.2026 ORDER 1. Vide this order, this Court shall dispose two applications under Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure (hereinafter referred to as “CPC”) filed by the plaintiffs separtely seeking in substance the temporary and ad-interim injunction restraining the defendants from selling, alienating, transferring, charging, encumbering or creating any third-party interest in the suit property and from raising any construction thereon, in any manner whatsoever, in respect of property bearing No. 5391, Gali No. 69/70, Karol Bagh, Regharpura, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the “Suit Property”). Brief facts 2. It has been the case of the plaintiffs that defendant Nos. 1 and 5, namely Sh. Nand Kishore and the father of the plaintiffs namely Sh.Ramesh Kumar, were the legal heirs/descendants and successors of Late Sh. Ghanshyam Dass, who was married to Smt. Mary Gomez and had four sons from the wedlock. The parents of the plaintiffs expired when the plaintiffs were young. It is pleaded that the grandparents of the plaintiffs, namely Late -- 1 of 9 -- CS DJ No. 684/2026 Mahesh Kumar & Anr. Vs. Purushotam Prashad & Ors. Page 2 of 9 Sh. Ghanshyam Dass and Smt. Mary Gomez, had acquired immovable properties during their lifetime. 3. It is further the case of the plaintiffs that Late Sh. Ghanshyam Dass died intestate on 27.09.1992 and his properties accordingly devolved upon his sons, including the father of the plaintiffs, and his widow Smt. Mary Gomez. After the demise of their parents, the plaintiffs continued to reside in the Suit Property and were brought up there by their grandmother and the defendants including Sh. Nand Kishore. 4. According to the plaintiffs, as they were minors when their parents expired, they reposed faith in their uncles and, upon their representations, signed various documents on the assurance that they would not be prejudiced and would ultimately be given their share in the properties left behind by their grandfather. It is alleged that it was decided that the Suit Property would be demolished and reconstructed and thereafter the plaintiffs would be given their respective shares. 5. The plaintiffs alleged that defendant Nos. 1 and others started demolishing the existing structure of the Suit Property and, when plaintiff No. 1 sought clarification regarding the proposed partition and their respective shares, no concrete answer was given. It is further alleged that plaintiff No. 1 subsequently learnt from the market that the defendants were intending to sell the under-construction floors to prospective purchasers and had approached property dealers for pre-booking of the floors. 6. The plaintiffs had earlier instituted a suit which was pending before the Court of Ld. District Judge-10. During the proceedings therein, -- 2 of 9 -- CS DJ No. 684/2026 Mahesh Kumar & Anr. Vs. Purushotam Prashad & Ors. Page 3 of 9 according to the plaintiffs, learned counsel for the defendants disclosed that Late Sh. Ghanshyam Dass had left behind a Will. The said suit was thereafter withdrawn and the present suit was instituted. 7. The plaintiffs state that they had no prior knowledge of any such Will and came to know about it for the first time on 03.07.2026. According to them, the Will is in English, whereas the testator was allegedly illiterate and was not conversant with the English language. It is also pleaded that the Will is undated and its contents raise serious doubts regarding its genuineness. The plaintiffs apprehend that the defendants, while proceeding with construction, may alienate the Suit Property or create third-party rights therein, thereby seriously prejudicing their rights and frustrating the subject matter of the present suit. Arguments addressed on behalf of the plaintiffs 8. Learned counsel for the plaintiffs submitted that the father of the plaintiffs and the defendants were sons of Late Sh. Ghanshyam Dass and that, after the untimely demise of the parents of the plaintiffs, they were brought up by the defendants in the Suit Property. It was submitted that the plaintiffs had always reposed faith in the defendants and had signed documents placed before them by the defendants. 9. Learned counsel further submitted that the defendants have demolished the old structure and are proceeding with construction without disclosing the manner in which the rights of the plaintiffs are proposed to be dealt with. It was argued that the plaintiffs have a genuine apprehension that the defendants may create third-party rights in the Suit Property, thereby -- 3 of 9 -- CS DJ No. 684/2026 Mahesh Kumar & Anr. Vs. Purushotam Prashad & Ors. Page 4 of 9 giving rise to further complications and multiplicity of proceedings, hence these applications. Arguments advanced on behalf of defendant No. 1 10. Defendant No. 1 has filed a detailed written statement containing preliminary objections, reply on merits and a separate reply to the injunction application. It has been specifically argued that the plaint does not disclose any cause of action against defendant No. 1 and is liable to be rejected under Order VII Rule 11(a) CPC. 11. It has been further argued that the plaintiffs are bound by their own solemn admission made before the statutory authority during mutation proceedings before the DDA, wherein, according to the defendants, the plaintiffs furnished a declaration/statement that they had no right, title or interest in the Suit Property and consented to mutation in favour of defendant Nos. 1 and 5. 12. It is further the case of defendant No. 1 that the Suit Property had already been partitioned by metes and bounds by virtue of registered Memorandums of Partition bearing Nos. 6455 and 6546, stated to have been executed inter-se between defendant No. 1 and defendant No. 5. The Assistant Collector, DDA, relying upon the said Memorandum of Partition and the appearance/declaration of the plaintiffs, is stated to have sanctioned Mutation Nos. 30244-30245 in favour of defendant Nos. 1 and 5 in equal shares. -- 4 of 9 -- CS DJ No. 684/2026 Mahesh Kumar & Anr. Vs. Purushotam Prashad & Ors. Page 5 of 9 13. It has also been argued on behalf of defendant No. 1 that the plaintiffs have suppressed material facts from this Court, including the alleged sale by the plaintiffs of property bearing No. 831, Block-D, Madipur, J.J. Colony, Delhi, which, according to the defendants, had been bequeathed to them out of love and affection by the father of defendant Nos. 1 and 5 and was also referred to in the Will dated 17.07.1922. Arguments advanced on behalf of defendant No. 2 to 4 14. Defendants No. 4 appeared in person for herself as well as defendants No. 2 and 3 submitted that they are only proforma party and do not have any connection with the suit property and hence, does not want to tender any arguments on the present application. Arguments advanced on behalf of defendant No. 5 15. Even, Ld. Counsel appearing on behalf of respondent No. 5 submitted that he has no objection, if the present application is allowed. Relevant Law 16. It is settled law that the power to grant temporary injunction is discretionary and the discretion has to be exercised judiciously. It is also well settled that before granting the injunctions, the following conditions are required to be satisfied: i. Prima facie the case is in favour of the plaintiff; ii. Balance of convenience lies in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant if the injunction is allowed; iii. Irreparable injury is likely to be caused to the plaintiff which cannot be compensated for in terms of money. -- 5 of 9 -- CS DJ No. 684/2026 Mahesh Kumar & Anr. Vs. Purushotam Prashad & Ors. Page 6 of 9 17. For proving all the aforesaid points, the burden is on the plaintiff. Mere proof of one of these conditions does not entitle the plaintiff to an order of temporary injunction. 18. It is trite that before granting of the temporary injunction, the Court has of necessity to satisfy itself that the failure to grant temporary injunction is likely to cause or inflict upon the plaintiff the loss or injury which cannot be compensated in terms of money and there is no other remedy available except the injunction and the plaintiff needs protection from the consequences of apprehended injury. Again there is no gainsaying that irreparable injury does not mean there must not be any physical possibility of repairing the injury, but it simple implies that the injury must be material one, namely one that cannot be subsequently compensated by of way of damages. If the loss, which is likely to be caused to the plaintiff in the case of failure to grant of injunction, can be compensated in terms of money, injunction as a matter of course should not be granted. While it's true that in most civil cases losses can be compensated monetarily, what matters is the proportionate amount needed to adequately compensate for the loss and injury. An injury is considered irreparable when there is no clear monetary standard for assessing damages. Court’s Observation 19. The rival claims of the parties raise disputed questions of fact and law, particularly with regard to the title and entitlement of the parties in respect of the Suit Property, the effect and validity of the Will relied upon by the defendants, the declarations allegedly made by the plaintiffs during the mutation proceedings and the documents executed between the parties. -- 6 of 9 -- CS DJ No. 684/2026 Mahesh Kumar & Anr. Vs. Purushotam Prashad & Ors. Page 7 of 9 These questions cannot appropriately be finally adjudicated at the interlocutory stage and would require appreciation of documentary as well as oral evidence. 20. At the same time, the Court is required to preserve the subject matter of the suit during the pendency of the proceedings. The plaintiffs have pleaded that construction/demolition activities are being carried out in the Suit Property and that there is an apprehension of creation of third-party rights therein. The defendants, on the other hand, assert their exclusive entitlement to the Suit Property. In such circumstances, permitting either side to alter the existing position or create third-party rights during the pendency of the suit may prejudice the rights of the opposite party and may also result in multiplicity of proceedings. 21. The relief sought at this stage is essentially preventive in nature. The Court is not required to finally determine the title of either party while deciding the present application. The material on record discloses a prima facie bona fide dispute requiring adjudication after the parties have led their evidence. It is, therefore, considered just and expedient that the Suit Property be preserved in its existing condition till the rights of the parties are finally determined. 22. The balance of convenience also lies in maintaining the existing position. If the Suit Property is permitted to be alienated, encumbered, demolished, substantially altered or third-party interests are created during the pendency of the suit, the same may complicate the adjudication of the suit and expose the parties to further litigation. On the contrary, maintenance -- 7 of 9 -- CS DJ No. 684/2026 Mahesh Kumar & Anr. Vs. Purushotam Prashad & Ors. Page 8 of 9 of status quo would merely preserve the subject matter of the suit and would cause no comparable prejudice to either party. 23. The requirement of irreparable injury is also satisfied to the limited extent that alteration of the nature and condition of the Suit Property or creation of third-party rights may lead to complications which cannot be adequately remedied merely by an award of damages. Preservation of the property in its existing condition is therefore necessary in the interests of justice. 24. In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the considered view that the plaintiffs have made out a case for grant of interim protection. However, since the rival claims of the parties are yet to be adjudicated finally, the appropriate interim protection would be to direct the parties to maintain status quo in respect of the Suit Property, rather than recording any final finding regarding the title or entitlement of either party. Conclusion 25. Accordingly, the application under Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2 read with Section 151 CPC is allowed. All the parties are directed to maintain status quo as existing as on the date of this order with respect to the Suit Property bearing No. 5391, Gali No. 69/70, Karol Bagh, Regharpura, New Delhi. Consequently, till further orders and no party shall sell, transfer, alienate, encumber or create any third-party interest in the Suit Property, nor shall any party carry out any construction, demolition or alteration therein so as to change its existing nature or physical status. -- 8 of 9 -- CS DJ No. 684/2026 Mahesh Kumar & Anr. Vs. Purushotam Prashad & Ors. Page 9 of 9 26. It is clarified that the direction to maintain status quo shall operate against all the parties to the suit and shall not be construed as conferring any right, title or interest upon either party. The existing possession, nature and physical condition of the Suit Property shall be preserved until further orders of this Court. 27. It is further clarified that the observations made herein are only prima facie in nature and have been recorded solely for the purpose of deciding the present interlocutory application. Nothing contained in this order shall be construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of the suit or the ultimate rights of the parties. 28. The application stands disposed of in the above terms. Announced in the open Court on 17.09.2026 (Shefali Barnala Tandon) District Judge-04, Central District, Tis Hazari Court, Delhi -- 9 of 9 --
